10 Perfect Stories Told In Video Games
Will anything ever top Red Dead Redemption 2?
Video game storytelling isn’t just at a point where it's on par with other mediums, it’s so good and the medium is so uniquely interactive, I’d argue there are plenty of video game narratives that best those coming out of film, television and books.
Actually I would say I know that for a fact because getting this list down to just ten games was an absolute nightmare so I apologise ahead of time for inevitably missing out on some of your favourites but I’m trusting you to get them in that comment section for me.
While I fret about whether I should have subbed in games with phenomenal stories like Uncharted 4, Final Fantasy 7, God Of War, NieR: Automata or Telltale’s The Walking Dead instead of the ones I chose I’ll just take a second to point out this list includes ten incredible stories that can be found in games, but it’s very far from an exhaustive list.
--
10. Firewatch
Video games like Mass Effect have proven time and again that they can take galaxy-wide stakes and deliver an unbelievable story, but stories don’t have to be life and death to be perfect and Firewatch is a perfect example.
Developed by Campo Santo, a studio made up of ex-Telltale writers and phenomenal artist Olly Moss, Firewatch tells the story of a fire lookout called Henry who spends a period of time in the Shoshone National Forest. The adventure and exploration-oriented gameplay in an immersive setting largely revolves around a mystery you encounter in the forest and your ongoing conversations and relationship with your supervisor Delilah over walkie-talkie. The beauty of this game is in its simplicity and extraordinary writing.
The choices you’re called on to make throughout the game naturally increase your empathy for Henry and connection to his emotional state and relationships.
The game also has an intro that’s on par with the movie Up and The Last of Us in terms of its ability to make you cry right out of the gate. The gameplay might not be for everybody but the earnest and heartfelt story is worth experiencing for even the most devout anti-walking simulator players.
Firewatch is a masterclass in nuanced writing that is able to take the mundane and make it special, and even when you come away from the game perhaps without the epic conclusion you’d expected, there’s still so much satisfaction in the journey.
9. The Last Of Us
Since we’ve brought it up, there’s no way we’re getting through a video about wonderful stories told in video games without mentioning The Last of Us and I think if I tried you guys would quite rightly tear me apart in the comments.
From the very first moment The Last of Us grabs you. Its world, its characters, its unique apocalypse and how those within it have adapted is such an engrossing concept and every little piece of it works.
The emotions of the characters you embody and encounter are so authentically presented and delivered. The phenomenal performances, the story that winds through a fairly long period in time in a brutal game world but never overstays its welcome, and the characterisation of its heroes is almost without comparison. These elements succeeding the way they do ensures that you feel Joel’s desperation, his growing affection for Ellie, and every twinge of fear that death is just around the corner.
Culminating in one of the most impactful endings in video games that is as delightfully divisive as it is earned, The Last of Us is just narratively flawless end to end.
8. Soma
Switching out one brutal post-apocalypse for another, that’s about where the similarities stop between The Last of Us and Soma, the 2015 survival horror adventure from the developers behind Amnesia: The Dark Descent. If you didn’t already pick this up playing Amnesia, Frictional Games really know how to tell a story, and to say that they tried some narratively and thematically challenging things with Soma would be an understatement.
In short, a major extinction event wiped out the inhabitants of Earth in 2104 and what remains is the crew of PATHOS-II who were working in an underwater research facility.
You explore the events that followed, learning what became of humans trying to grapple with their predicament, and figure out why you’ve awoken in this facility after nearly dying in a car accident in 2015. In a Delilah-like twist, you’ll spend a lot of time talking with Catherine, a brain scan of a PATHOS-II worker housed inside a robot. To say much more would be to spoil the narrative but suffice it to say, it really goes places. The story deals with themes like the human condition, artificial intelligence, what makes us who we are, and the muddy intersection between technology and humanity. It’s not as scary as Amnesia in its moment-to-moment gameplay, though there are monsters here and there, but it doesn’t need to be as the implications of the narrative come chocked with enough psychological horror for a good handful of sleepless nights.
Frictional absolutely nails the landing on this one, too, so if it’s a story you missed out on I’d really recommend you check it out. And if you’re a big scaredy cat you can play it in safe mode so the monsters can’t kill you so no excuses.
7. The Longest Journey
While there are games like The Last of Us that I couldn’t get away with not including, I’ve tried to throw you some curveballs in this list that you might not have played because AAA studios haven’t cornered the market on perfect stories.
For this entry we’re heading back to 1999 when Funcom released the fantasy point-and-click adventure game, and my favourite game of all time, The Longest Journey.
A true high fantasy narrative with a firm grasp on telling the realistic story of an 18-year-old living in a future metropolis, while incorporating the parallel world of magic that exists in tandem and the sociopolitical chaos unfolding across both worlds, there’s a lot going on here. But whether the story is focussed on protagonist April’s relationship with her best friend or her fraught family life, or switching gears to helping various magical races reunite or trying to reinstate a magical ancient guardian into his realm to restore the balance of the twin worlds, the writing is sublime.
Beyond that, the game boasts a suite of enigmatic and fascinating characters bolstered by brilliant performances and each of them feel unique and palpably realised adding weight to the narrative. This is back when adventure games didn’t let you make choices beyond proving you could solve puzzles and perhaps making one call as to whether you want to spend the night out with a douchey guy or with your mates. The Longest Journey has a meticulously designed story to tell you and wants you to experience it as intended.
The Longest Journey is just that, a fantastic and unforgettable hero's journey that is just an absolute joy to watch unfold.
6. Silent Hill 2
Diving back into the horror genre, we simply can’t ignore one of the best stories ever told in Team Silent’s 2001 epic Silent Hill 2. James Sunderland has received a curious letter from his late wife which takes him to the sinister town of Silent Hill.
The game has a huge amount of symbolism that reflects James’ deep-seated insecurities, fears, and beliefs.
There’s an impressive amount of subtlety in the storytelling that elevates psychological horror beyond the simple presence of monsters in front of you. The monsters are actually a representation of James’ disturbed psyche and your journey toward learning that and realising who he really is is fascinating. Another cool area in which Silent Hill 2 is extra special is that you can get different endings depending on how you played. For example, if you spent a lot of time with low health the game interprets that as James being suicidal.
Silent Hill 2 deeply embeds you in the disturbing story that it has to tell in that way only a video game can and it's a story that is impeccably told.
5. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
I wrote a list last week rounding out ten games that are indisputable masterpieces and I didn’t put The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt on it and while ten was really not enough for that list I’m not going to make the same mistake again and leave it out here. One of the clues that The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt’s story is really something special is that you don’t even need to have played the previous games in the series to fall in love with it.
It helps, for sure, but the game has won plenty of fans just on its own merits.
Another game that presents absolute high fantasy heaven, The Witcher 3 excels at worldbuilding from its unique locations that each have their own social and political tribulations to its cast of colourful characters. Everyone has their favourites and the story is riddled with highs and lows.
Expect to be laughing, crying, and everything in between no matter how your version of events unfolds.
Geralt is every bit the strong stalwart hero and every encounter from the life-or-death main campaign to the side quests fleshes out his character, his companions, and the fascinating world around you. End to end, and including the DLCs, you’re hard-pressed finding writing this good from many other places in video games.
4. Persona 5 Royal
This one has to kick off with the traditional Personal 5: Royal caveat which is that I’m really sorry I’m telling you the best version of a game is the new one that came out when you probably already spent 100 or so hours in its vanilla version.
Now, there’s nothing inherently wrong with Persona 5, it’s also a fantastic game, but when we’re talking about perfect video game narratives we can’t leave out the impact that Royal’s new storyline has on making this one flawless. This is largely due to newcomers Kasumi Yoshizawa and Takuto Maruki who collectively introduce what I would argue as one of the most well written antagonists and fascinating high stakes fantasy stories in any medium. I really don’t want to spoil any of the twists and turns that lie ahead for you here, so I’ll just say the narrative progression, mature themes, and relationships are handled so expertly.
The sheer length and scope of this game also ensures the characters are fully realised letting you understand their beliefs, motivations, and intentions.
The unfolding narrative and its implications is deeply affecting and while it’s a story that’s been explored before elsewhere, Persona does so with its trademark charm and unwavering earnestness that tugs at your heartstrings every step of the way.
3. Red Dead Redemption 2
I take personal offence when people tell me that Red Dead Redemption 2 is too hard to get into because my only reply is “Alright, well, you’re missing out on one of the greatest stories ever told, but you do you.”
As with the case in almost all of the games I’ve mentioned, much of Red Dead 2’s strength lies in its incredibly realised characters, especially Arthur Morgan who might be my favourite fictional character to ever exist. Another theme present here that I’ve mentioned earlier in this list is that the story, writing, and characterisation succeeds due to its subtlety.
Arthur is relatively reserved, he doesn’t want to be mixed up in the drama of the rest of the Van der Linde gang and almost everything in the story just happens to or around him and he’s forced to deal with it. The fact that Red Dead Redemption is already a masterclass in video game writing and we just added gorgeous graphics and a new fantastic character means Rockstar were set up for success and they continued to prove themselves.
There’s a deep pathos and empathy you feel for Arthur throughout his journey and experiences meaning you’re unlikely to forget Red Dead 2’s story any time soon.
The open world is available as your playground but returning regularly to the linear story at the heart of the branching sub missions and activities is essential to carrying you toward the story’s grand conclusion. The story is riddled with tension as allegiances evolve and crumble, plans fall apart, and Arthur discovers there are some things that can’t be resolved with a gun or any amount of money.
Your deep connection with Arthur is what winds you into every plot point and NPC interaction. You’ll be cheering at every win and have your heart aching at every loss and it’s just fantastic.
2. Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic
A story so cleverly told and compelling from end to end that it’s still up there with the biggest buzz in video game storytelling circles almost 20 years after its release, Knights of the Old Republic is something truly special.
From its wildly memorable characters to its perfect pacing, playing through KOTOR and seeing the story at its heart unfold is an absolute delight.
While BioShock is equally remembered for its epic twist, KOTOR is so much more than an unexpected 180 in the plot. Your journey from scrappy nobody to a lightsaber-wielding hero and beyond is extremely satisfying, as is building up relationships with your confidants. Characters like Bastilla and HK-47 will go down in history as some of the most creative and memorable ever realised in the medium and the writing is consistently spot on.
Whether you’re light-side or dark-side, there’s a really cool story to play through here, and it's this narrative combined with the game’s mechanics that make this one of the best RPGs out there.
1. What Remains Of Edith Finch
Giant Sparrow’s 2017 adventure What Remains of Edith Finch is a little bizarre and frequently takes hard left turns but in the best possible way. The game tells the story of a family that meets various misfortunes and you’ll play through a series of their experiences to learn more about them and what happened to them. The gameplay style and mechanics shift frequently throughout but it's all in service of the overall narrative which comes together seamlessly with interesting themes that ruminate on family and death.
It’s a little hard to talk about this one without spoiling it because you’ll knock over the whole thing in less than 3 hours, but it’s absolutely worth delving into.
Like many non-AAA games, What Remains Of Edith Finch has that indie charm in that it is precisely what it intends to be, nothing more and nothing less. Luckily that just happens to be a really fascinating story told in a way that only a video game could get right with some stunning sequences you won’t be able to get out of your head.
I will warn you that this game is a bit of a giant bummer but if that doesn’t turn you off then the amazing story is really worth seeing for yourself.