10 Perfect Video Games With One Glaring Flaw
Even flawless diamonds have imperfections.
Talent, money, belief and ambition: even if all of these essential ingredients are present in abundance, chasing perfection is a fool's errand, especially when it involves the most volatile entertainment industry on the planet.
Yet, despite the long list of unforeseen anomalies, some visionaries will weather the inevitable storm to see their vision through to completion, even if it means making sacrifices along the way.
True perfection will never be possible, but if, in pursuit of that holy grail, developers continue to present gems like these, then we welcome the inevitable flaws, warts and all...
10. God Of War - Lack Of Unique Boss Encounters
When your past feats include crossing the names of an entire deific pantheon off your hit list, any future achievements are bound to pale by comparison. To be clear, the boss encounters present in this year's God of War reboot are fantastic - especially the tag-team brawl against Modi and Magni - the issue lies in Kratos' Nordic adventure failing to provide enough of them.
The Ghost of Sparta's encounters with Baldur, his aforementioned nephews, the dark elf Svartáljǫfurr and Valkyrie Queen Sigrun are all terrific feats of spectacle on Sony Santa Monica's part, but those highs are interrupted too often by repeated encounters with trolls and ogres, only with slight variations to stave off the feeling of repetition.
The reason for this is obvious, of course: Santa Monica has intentionally withheld the likes of Thor, Odin, Frigg and Sif for the inevitable sequels to come, but Nordic mythology isn't short on deities to put on the chopping block.
But a couple of additional, wholly unique encounters would have balanced the scales perfectly.
9. The Legend Of Zelda: Breath Of The Wild - Divine Duds
Finally, following the brilliant but structurally tired Skyward Sword in 2011, the Big N got to work on giving Link's by-the-numbers adventures the biggest shake-up since the series' inception.
Minus the notable citizens of Hyrule, Nintendo stripped out all of the series' trademarks - dungeons, linear narrative, a pseudo-open world - and replaced them with a new version of Hyrule, one with sprawling hills as far as the eye could see with little to no guidance for Link on his predetermined path to becoming legend.
Part of that reformulation involved the controversial replacement of traditional dungeons with shrines - bite-sized combat and mental challenges scattered throughout Hyrule - and the showstopping Divine Beasts.
The former were expertly realised; the latter not so much.
All four animal-shaped dynamic dungeons represent the same end-of-level challenge as traditional dungeons did in older Zelda games, but they're tragically let down, not just by their length (or lack thereof) but cut and paste boss fights. As a package, Breath of the Wild's Divine Beasts are a let down for what's otherwise nothing short of a masterpiece.
8. Mass Effect 3 - The Cop-Out Ending
Did Wrex live or die? Did you opt to help end the Genophage or suppress manufacture of the cure as penance for the Krogan race's past deeds? Does your intervention in the Geth/Quarian war lead to reconciliation between the two races or does one deserve to live over the other?
Despite Andromeda's dirtying of the series' reputation, the original Mass Effect trilogy remains a well-written space opera fraught with agonizing moral, ethical and existential dilemmas, which makes the final part of Shepard's quest to end the Reaper threat all the more demoralizing as it reaches its climax.
Having spent three games crafting your own personal narrative for Shepard with the promise that every choice would be accounted for by journey's end to form a tailored ending, it's not at all surprising that the three static, poorly-presented choices presented to Shepard at journey's end resulted in the universally derided ending that BioWare ultimately decided on.
Did the fan base expect too much or did BioWare bite off more than it could chew? Whatever the reality, Mass Effect 3's ending took into account all of the decisions players had made over hundreds of hours and fobbed them off with a generic, impersonal conclusion.
7. Overwatch - Distasteful In-Game Economy
'Cosmetic only' is not a valid defence for adopting the loot box monetisation model.
Ethically, obtaining items not affecting gameplay from randomized loot pools is infinitely more acceptable than, say, hiding unlocks and progression systems behind them as EA attempted with Star Wars Battlefront II, but at the end of the day, gambling is gambling.
With Belgium (and likely more to follow) having banned the sale of loot boxes in video games, Blizzard and its peers have been left with no option other than to remove the relevant monetisation systems from Overwatch and Heroes of the Storm, which begs the question: why not replace the system entirely?
Thus far, all of Overwatch's post-launch content, be it maps, modes or characters, have been free for all owners of the base game - selling cosmetics is how Blizzard recoups its development costs - but why not, instead of continuing to court controversy for the pinnacle of team-based shooters, just sell skins, sprays and voice lines directly?
It's the right and pro-consumer thing to do and would result in nothing but positive publicity for Blizzard, were it to go ahead with the change before anyone else.
6. Batman: Arkham Knight - The Batmobile
If Arkham Asylum represented the series' potential to be the ultimate Batman video game and Arkham City the realisation of that potential, what does that make the final part in Rocksteady's trilogy?
In two words: a misstep. One that's arguably through no fault of its own. After all, how else was it supposed to meet the expectations of what a sequel is meant to deliver? Expanding Batman's concrete playground and sprinkling in more members of his rogue's gallery, while welcome, would only offer more of the same.
No, the answer was the Batmobile, a feature that Rocksteady, up until Knight's release, had resisted the inclusion of for, in retrospect, good reason. On one hand, the Caped Crusader's signature mode of transport felt great to play around with, but on the other, Rocksteady's efforts to accommodate its inclusion as an integral feature rather than a gimmick was overzealous, to say the least.
Unlike the tireless enjoyment gained from beating thugs silly with Batman's fists, vehicular combat grew old, fast, and the handling of Batman's final showdown with the titular Arkham Knight in particular still leaves a tread mark-shaped stain of disappointment on the streets of Gotham.
5. Deus Ex: Human Revolution - Outsourced Content
Eidos Montréal's revival of Ion Storm's deliciously dystopic Deus Ex series in 2011 resulted in an early shoo-in for the inevitable (and fast-approaching) 'Greatest Games Of The 2010s' celebratory op-eds to come, but it'll never reach pole position due to one glaring, and avoidable, flaw.
With the majority of its manpower going toward making narrative and open-ended gameplay a priority and crunch time looming ever closer, Eidos found itself with no other option but to outsource its pre-planned boss battles to another developer, with the stipulation that they adhere to Human Revolution's existing framework. The only other option was to cut the encounters entirely.
Grip Entertainment was drafted in for the job, one it undoubtedly regretted accepting post-completion, given that their heavily scripted and non-conformist nature formed the only universally negatively received portion of Adam Jensen's story.
The takeaway from this debacle? Never, ever, outsource a key component of your game to an external source, especially not without first ensuring said contractor is aware of the vision you aim to achieve.
4. Halo - Length-Padding Levels
Bungie has long since flown the coop provided for it by Microsoft during the Xbox's formative years, forced to leave its beloved Halo in the talented hands of another, but the legacy it left behind is still felt by every gamer that's ever counted themselves a fan of the first-person shooter.
What Halo did, not just for the genre and the Xbox brand, but for all shooters that would follow in the wake of Master Chief's first footsteps, can't be overstated and it's a testament to Bungie's forward-thinking that 343 Industries' polished remaster, which left Combat Evolved's mechanics untouched, felt just as modern in 2011 as it did a decade prior.
What it also did, accidentally so, was shine a light on the oft-overlooked weak link in Halo's otherwise perfect chain of campaign levels - The Library. Even with 343's fresh coat of paint, Halo's dip in quality amounted to little more than a gauntlet of dark corridors populated by infinitely spawning Flood spores, momentarily reverting Halo's image as a progressive, non-linear shooter back to corridor shooter status.
3. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim - Asset Overuse
Now more far-reaching than the Bible, Bethesda's latest entry in its Elder Scrolls series continues to enjoy dominance of every video game platform known to man and it doesn't take a PhD to discern why. Sprawling dungeons, a massive open world, heaps of quests (and quest givers) and, of course, dragons - on the surface, Skyrim has a lot to offer, but in reality, it's a matter ripe for debate.
Conquering your first draugr tomb, slaying your first dragon, overhearing ambient NPC dialogue: Skyrim's series of firsts release doses of dopamine higher than Skyrim's mountaintops, but when those core activities repeat themselves ten, twenty, thirty times in a manner similar enough to trigger deja vu, fatigue sets in and the veil of immersion begins to dissolve before your very eyes.
Scouring the landscape for Daedric artefacts, spelunking into wholly unique environments, joining a country-spanning civil war or choosing to follow the path of lycanthropy, these are the unique moments that make Skyrim the gargantuan success that it is, not a by-the-numbers rematch with the same dragon you fought on day one, only with a different skin colour and more potent breath.
2. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves - Unimaginative Combat
The game that elevated Nate Drake's treasure hunting escapades from solid Sony exclusive to an integral cornerstone of the PlayStation family, Naughty Dog's bigger, better and more bombastic sequel raised the bar for what gamers should expect from the action-adventure, single-handedly making its contemporaries' storytelling, puzzle-solving and set-piece curation appear obsolete by comparison.
'Interactive movie' often carries a negative connotation in gaming circles, but in Uncharted 2's case, it was nothing but an adoring compliment, one accompanied with bewilderment that Naughty Dog had managed to blend cinematic quality with solid gameplay so seamlessly. Well, almost.
Despite its aforementioned reputation, Uncharted 2's combat scenarios struggled to garner any descriptor besides mediocre. The by-the-numbers engagements, devoid of any rhyme or rhythm besides 'kill all the guys trying to kill you' play out identically until the credits, the only variable being the terrain that Nate finds himself fighting in.
Had Naughty Dog envisaged its name-making sequel as an entirely pacifistic affair, Uncharted 2's quality would only have improved.
1. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain - Unfinished Business
Whatever it is that caused the schism between Konami and Hideo Kojima to grow so irreparably wide, we'll likely never know, but what's not up for debate is the detrimental effect its fallout had on the overall quality of Metal Gear Solid's fifth outing.
The first entry in Kojima's famed franchise to feature a fully-realised open world replete with open-ended gameplay, brilliantly-implemented micromanagement and progression systems in the form of Mother Base and an intriguing, if often incoherent, narrative, The Phantom Pain was the delivery on a tantalizing promise made with prequel Ground Zeroes, but its magnificence wasn't to last.
The sharp decline in quality arrives around the halfway point when the plot, having already concluded the Skull Face arc, reduces the game to a rinse and repeat jobbie where the player is forced to repeat several past missions in order to make the plot limp along to it's unsatisfying, obviously unfinished finale.
Konami never conceded to the suspicions that Phantom Pain shipped in an unfinished state, but the discovery of cut content in the form of unreleased episodes and a third chapter all but cement their accuracy.
A sad ending to potentially the last ever main line Metal Gear title.