10 Popular Video Game Debates That Need To Die

Y'know what sells me on a game? When characters have good teeth.

horizon forbidden west
Guerrilla Games

Video games eh? What a lovely, open-minded, welcoming community that deals with differences of opinion in a safe, constructive and supportive manner.

LOL.

Yeah, turns out the 21st century's defining hobby inspires a lot of the 21st century's other defining hobbies: Bitching, moaning and most of all, arguing.

It can be about anything, from the minutiae of League of Legends lore and whether Smash Bros is an E-Sport, to if VR gaming will ever take off and which games are worth pre-ordering, along with everything in between.

Now, if any industry is worth this level of scrutiny, it's gaming. God knows there's more than enough shady practises to go around and a consumer base this switched on and opinionated could be an asset to it.

The problem is a number of the most well-worn video game arguments have more or less been ended already. And yet on they go, droning, stumbling and thrashing like a zombie with added "well actually".

Well, call me Jill Valentine, because I'm about to mow these arguments down. Not with a weapon, but with a top ten list. And I always double tap.

10. Are Video Games Art

Journey Game
ThatGameCompany

This is an argument that has been thrown around since the very birth of the medium. And I do mean the very beginning!

The first video games weren't just Pong and Space Invaders - text-based role playing games were asking serious questions of their players way back in the late seventies.

Today, mainstream, multi-million dollar franchises like Mass Effect ask its players to think about what constitutes humanity. Bioshock builds entire worlds to examine extreme libertarianism and extreme communitarianism. Untitled Goose Game lets you be a horrible goose.

And people question the artistic validity of the medium?!

Seriously though, at their best, video games offer an artistic experience like no other: The ability to examine yourself through choice.

When playing Dishonoured, is your first instinct to kill your enemies or sneak past? In Fallout, who do you ally with and who do you oppose? What does Harry Du Bois become in your hands, in Disco Elysium?

If that doesn't make gaming an art form to you, perhaps you should think about what *does* constitute an art form.


9. The Console Wars

PS5 Xbox Series X
Sony/Microsoft

Bit of a retro one here, but since there are still corners of the internet prolapsing over a woman playing Doctor Who, it makes sense there are still sentient beings slugging it out via keyboard on which pile of chips and processors farted out by multi-billion dollar corporations (or not, in the case of the PS5) is superior to the other.

Of course, you're going to get the same basic arguments about speed, power and platform-exclusive titles, but of all the entries on this list, this might actually be the one closest to going away.

Hardcore gamers are always going to get all the consoles on the market. Beyond that, we're now we're at a point where your average laptop can struggle through AAA titles from a few years ago, so Steam fills in gaps that a more casual fan might have problems with not too long ago.

Yes, trying to get gamers away from each other's throats for any reason is a recipe for disappointment, but this debate is (slowly) fading. Only to be replaced by a billion others, but baby steps!


8. [Insert Genre Here] Is Too Popular!

Call Of Duty 4 Modern Warfare Remastered
Activision

First Person Shooters. Mascot Platformers. Single Player Adventure Games. Sports Titles. You name it, there are chuds online throwing a tantrum about people liking a thing. And y'know what? Sometimes you can see where they're coming from.

Take films as a parallel example. It can be a little disheartening to look at your local multiplex and see nothing but superheroes and franchises dominating the box office.

That, is what we call "step one".

Turns out, films don't begin and end with your local Vue. Independent cinemas and online streaming services like Mubi provide exciting alternatives to whatever Marvel is churning out this week.

Gaming, in turn, doesn't begin and end with the latest AAA extravaganza or live service addiction machine. The more you look, the more interesting, unique and boundary-pushing experiences you'll find. Whether that's deep within your console networks, Steam or itch.io.

Just this week, I played a put-upon reporter in Headliner: Novinews, deciding which news stories my channel broadcasts and watching the societal impact of them in real time. Before that, I was captivated by Inscryption's mix of deck building mechanics, escape room mysteries and folk-horror chills.

It's never been easier to create video games, and it's never been easier to find them. So find them!


7. Are E-Sports Real Sports?

E-Sports League of Legends Tournament
https://www.flickr.com/photos/bagogames/22364914234

It's somewhat overdone to point out that the line between nerds and sports fans is a slim one indeed. In recent years however, the comparison has become more apt than ever.

In 2017, the League of Legends World Championship Final outdrew that year's UEFA Champions League Final, and yet still there's something of a stigma to the world of E-Sports.

On the surface, you can see it. E-sports can seem to miss "the point" of gaming, being principally about watching the game being played at a high level. For most, the appeal of the medium is the personal journey of overcoming a challenge or experiencing a story.

However, the truth is, whichever way you look at it, it's valid. Do you watch sports for the athletic excellence and dedication of the athletes? Competitors in both worlds have absolutely put their 10,000 hours in.

Do you watch it for the pageantry and storytelling? There's just as much soap opera in both of them, so long as you look for it.

Different strokes for different folks of course, but what you can't deny is that there's a colossal audience for it. And as any fan of chess-boxing will tell you, if people will watch it, it's a sport!


6. Is Mobile Gaming Real Gaming?

Candy Crush Saga
King

From whether sports are real sports to whether games are real games, and as much as I want to get on a high horse and shout "it's in the damn name, NERD" then barrel off into the sunset like a listicle Lone Ranger, I have to dismount that high horse (his name's Trevor) and admit there actually is a discussion to be had here.

Mobile gaming is, broadly speaking, a market of cheap, addictive attention grabbers trying to swindle a few bucks out of you. That much is undeniable. You've seen your mum on Candy Crush. Hell, we've *all* seen your mum on Candy Crush.

Even games that aren't glorified apps, the likes of PUBG Mobile and Pokemon Go. They may be"free" technically but exist on a lifeblood of microtransactions that can make them as expensive as any game. More so, if you're not careful.

However, this is nothing new. Hell, cheap, addictive attention-grabbers that swindled kids out of their parents' coin were almost the entire gaming industry in the heyday of the arcade. Video games as a whole needed time to become accepted as more than just a con, is it too much to ask for some patience from its mobile counterpart?

Knowing gamers, almost certainly yes.


5. Game Critics, Good Or Bad?

gaming critics
Access Games

"8.8 out of ten?!?! Do you even play games?!?!?"

The life of a critic is rarely fun. You scrape by from a rapidly decreasing number of people paying for your take on things, then the remorseless, multitudinous vermin of the internet decide that you haven't fellated their favourite thing hard enough.

They descend like locusts from on high, wishing death upon you for not validating the love, time and money they've wasted on whatever corporate branding scheme they've fallen for like the witless marks they are.

Why yes, I was a critic for years, what gave it away?

Seriously though, there is a discussion to be had about reducing the quality of a piece of art to a number. There is a discussion to be had about critiquing games you've played half of. These are discussions to be had with the industry as a whole, the writers are just doing a job. A really, really hard one, with non-existent job security.

Just as change within any industry comes from pressure to those at the top, the change in the gaming press will have to come from the same. Bullying writers will solve nothing.


4. "Real Games" Are DIFFICULT

Bloodborne You Died
From Software

Sit quietly a moment and you may hear it on the wind. The siren song of those with a love of gaming in their heart. Legends tell if you look in a mirror and ask how to defeat Theseus and Asterius on Extreme Measures mode in Hades, you too will hear the words...

"GIT GUD."

These are, of course, super helpful words that have solved all manner of problems. Especially those caused by accessibility issues or not having the time to sink hundreds of hours into Dark Souls/Bloodborne/Sekiro/delete as applicable.

But according to some, that's what makes them "real games" and asking for an easier ride on "real games" is akin to asking for stabilizers for the Tour De France. The challenge is the point. And that may be true... for those specific titles.

The wonderful truth is that video games have become a medium bigger than one definition. Just as fiction is diverse and broad enough that both Ulysses and The Devil Wears Prada can be brilliant in their own ways, gaming is the same!

Just because you can breeze through Life Is Strange or Portal in an afternoon doesn't cheapen those experiences or make them lesser. Just different, and that's ok!


3. Video Games Are Too Violent!

doom eternal
iD Software

And you thought the console wars entry was a throwback!

Difficult as it is to believe, there are still people claiming that violent video games are warping the minds of our precious bambinos. Turning them into frothing lunatics chained to their consoles, laughing maniacally as they mow down wave after wave of baddies.

The fact there are still people thinking this is proof that these debates can't be won with logic and reasoning. The best case scenario is these people Just Don't Get It, and never will. The worst case scenario is these people are *choosing* not to get it.

They've made their minds up, and no matter how many times you talk them through Animal Crossing, or Beat Saber, or Gran Turismo or sodding Tetris, they've decided that video games are one thing and one thing only. Listening to anyone else will only ruin it for them.

Don't bother mentioning that mainstream media from movies to novels to the actual news is as violent if not more so than what can be created digitally either. As I said, to some, these are arguments that cannot be won, so it's best not to lose sleep over it.


2. Graphics Vs Gameplay

Tomb Raider Lara Croft
Core Design

It's always a trip to look at gaming magazines from the late 90's and early 2000's, where they'll have a picture of Lara Croft in all her polygonal glory with a caption like "that's not a photo, fellas!" or something equally embarrassing.

I won't lie, there is a thrill that comes with seeing genuine leaps forward in graphical ability. The Unreal Engine 5 demos have been gobsmacking. But those are few and far between and companies still feel the need to crow about their technical capabilities. Sending out endless "remasters" or re-releases of games that were fine the first time around.

Todd Howard, I'm looking in your general direction.

But what draws us to gaming is more than just power and technical ability. Games like Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines, System Shock 2 and Final Fantasy 7 look dated but are still worth playing decades after the original release, due to creative gameplay and design.

Even a title like Chrono Trigger, in all its 16 bit glory, can have unforgettable art on a fraction of the power of the latest Call Of Duty. The soul of a game is what makes it special, not the power.


1. Video Games Are For Men

horizon zero dawn
Sony

Remember earlier, when we were talking about debates that are so rooted in a ridiculous assumption that it's almost impossible to "win" them? Yeah. That.

Art is for everyone. Games are for everyone. People trying to make an industry more inclusive and more welcoming to others is a good thing. Alienating others with the same passions, ostracising people who are trying to support the medium you love will only damage it further.

This is not to say that the gaming industry does not deserve criticism, quite the opposite. From EA's lootboxes, Rockstar's crunch, to the rampant and widespread employee abuse seen throughout the industry, the problems are there.

The last place to take out our frustrations with it though, is on the people who share our love of this medium. If there's one thing to take away from this list, it's that getting angry with people on your level, the players, is a waste of energy.

The games industry is vast and ever changing. But these debates won't go away if we keep having them among each other. Save our ire for those in positions of power, then we can start moving forward.

Any industry can always get better, if you demand it from the right people.


Watch Next


Contributor

Will Howard hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.