10 Powerful Video Game Bosses That Became Weak Playable Characters
Why aren't they as powerful as they seemed when you fought them?
When approaching a boss battle in a video game, players tend to have certain expectations. These fights might not all be comparable in terms of difficulty (a Super Mario title isn’t going to feature a spirit-crushing boss of Dark Souls-esque unbeatability), but they’re going to be a cut above the standard foes you’ll find in any given game.
Bosses are gatekeepers, after all. They’ll stand sentinel at the end of a level, or they’ll guard a new ability or weapon. Sometimes, they will even pop up as optional superbosses, more formidable foes than any the main campaign can muster (think the notorious Emerald Weapon and Ruby Weapon of Final Fantasy 7).
It’s always a bit of a thrill when one of these formidable foes later joins the player’s party, or is otherwise unlocked as a playable character. The trouble is, though, boss battles are often about spectacle, drama and challenge, which means that certain villains could break a game outright if they had all the same absurd attacks and powers they do in said battles.
A bit of a nerf is often in order, though sometimes these characters are weak enough to be outright disappointing. Here are some examples.
10. Adder - Advance Wars 2
Adder is a
Black Hole Army CO who appears in Advance Wars 2: Black Hole Rising. In the
first sequel to Nintendo’s beloved Game Boy Advance turn-based strategy title
(the long-running Famicom Wars in Japan), the Black Hole Army returns to wreck
havoc on Wars World. Adder serves as an officer in this invading force, charged
with the attack on Yellow Comet.
Encounters with Adders are marked by his rudeness, his arrogance, his lack of respect for anybody but those who outrank him. Like many antagonists, he is quick to disregard his opponents and will belittle them at every turn, but the battles against him are challenging more as a result of the scenarios and the nature of the game (it’s certainly a difficult one) than because of any special abilities he possesses. Indeed, when he’s unlocked, he may prove to be very disappointing.
Adder’s CO Power is Sideslip, and his Super CO Power is Sidewinder. They’re very quick to charge, at just two stars and a further three stars respectively, but they also only grant +1 movement (Sideslip) and +2 movement (Sidewinder) to all Adder’s units. Without any attack or defense bonus (though a 10% boost to both stats was added to these powers in Advance Wars: Dual Strike), this has very limited use, and with his completely standard units, Adder will often be overlooked for a CO more specialized for the task at hand.
9. Eternatus - Pokémon Sword And Shield
Pokémon
Sword and Shield’s climactic battle against Eternamax Eternatus is perhaps the
most cinematic in series history. The music swells, both Zacian and Zamazenta
team up with the player, and Eternatus breaks the rules of the game’s mechanics
themselves.
It’s a hard-fought match against a towering beast as imposing as it is a little ridiculous, a souped-up take on Max Raid battles that exists only for this one encounter and can’t be recreated. When the beast with its absurdly bloated stats is defeated, the protagonist gets a chance to catch Eternatus itself. Sadly, that’s all they get: no Eternamaxing capabilities included, no refunds.
Eternatus certainly isn’t a bad Pokémon, boasting excellent base stats in HP, Special Attack and Speed. It also has the brilliant exclusive move Dynamax Cannon, which deals double damage to Dynamax/Gigantamax foes. The issue is, it’s a gargantuan step down from its now-inaccessible Eternamax form –which exchanged those offenses for ludicrous defenses—in sheer intimidation factor, and when permitted in standard play, other Uber Pokémon (including Zacian itself) will often be prioritized in teams.
8. Edea - Final Fantasy 8
Final Fantasy 8 is characterised by its unique twists on the franchise formula. Its plot, too, takes many unconventional twists and turns. Earlier in the game, it appears that Sorceress Edea is shaping up to be the main antagonist, as she assassinates President Vinzer Deling and begins to exert her influence on the world. Later, it transpires that Edea is the kindly ‘Matron,’ who cared for the party members as children in her orphanage. The true villain of the piece is Ultimecia, an even more formidable sorceress from the future who seeks to end time itself.
After these revelations, Edea joins the party for a brief period, as they escort her to the futuristic city of Esthar (there, the eccentric Dr Odine believes he can free her from Ultimecia’s influence). As the dramatic conclusion to the first battle against her demonstrated, Edea was a formidable foe indeed as a boss, but the playable Edea doesn’t really have anything to distinguish herself from the rest of the party at all.
Though her Guardian Force compatibility is good and her Limit Break, Ice Strike, powerful, she’s available only temporarily and can’t equip any weapons. It’s scarcely worth switching another player’s junctioned magic to her.
7. King K. Rool - Super Smash Bros. Ultimate
King K. Rool certainly isn’t weak in the conventional sense in Super Smash Bros. Ultimate. That boxing glove really, really smarts. The sad fact is, though, the hype surrounding him seemed to fade rather quickly.
The addition of Donkey Kong’s nemesis to the roster was a huge moment in Super Smash Bros. history, yes, and there’s no denying that the king of the Kremling crew makes for a unique fighter. With his armoured belly, his crown and cannon projectiles and his impressive propeller-aided recovery, there isn’t a heavyweight fighter in the series like him.
Earlier in the game’s lifespan, there were widespread complaints that these traits may make King K. Rool overpowered. Those notorious down-smash and down-throw shenanigans were the scourge of online play.
Despite his assets, though, the reptilian royalty can be exploited for his slow nature and huge hitbox like any other heavy character. The smaller, more combo-orientated characters that tend to dominate tier lists can be a nightmare for him to handle. As such, he’s a real rarity on the tournament scene and his popularity has fallen.
6. Shadow Mewtwo - Pokkén Tournament
As with King
K. Rool in Super Smash Bros. Ultimate, Pokkén Tournament’s Shadow Mewtwo is not
a character lacking in raw power. Indeed, it has tremendous combo and damage
potential. After a couple of encounters with it in the game’s single-player mode,
you'll know exactly how fearsome the boss battles against it can be.
Through progress in the Ferrum League, both Mewtwo and Shadow Mewtwo join the playable roster. This version of the latter is significantly toned down in comparison to the one from said boss battles, boasting all the same strengths along with some heavy drawbacks.
Shadow Mewtwo is a fighter with huge damage potential, offset by very limited HP that must be carefully managed (it both drains its own HP and can recover it with certain moves). A very technical fighter that requires a skilled player’s touch. For these reasons, Shadow Mewtwo can seem very weak indeed in the wrong hands, disappointing those left in awe by their encounters with it.
5. Bowser - Super Mario RPG: Legend Of The Seven Stars
Super Mario
RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars is not only an iconic adventure that paved the
way for the great Mario RPGs that followed. It also marks a rare and notable
example of these two archenemies joining forces.
Naturally, Bowser fights for the side of good largely for his own personal gain (he’s out to reclaim his sword-skewered castle). As a party member, he utilizes mostly melee attacks with his claws and Chomps. Great damage-dealing potential, but his special moves (such as Terrorize, an attack with a Big Boo) tend to prevent him from hitting the elemental weakness that other team members excel against.
This is compounded by the limited equipment available to him, unfortunately meaning that he’ll sometimes be outclassed by others in the party.
4. Shiva - Streets Of Rage 3
Long-time fans
of the classic Streets of Rage series will know that Shiva is quite the enigma.
He’s introduced in the second game in the series, a powerful and agile foe who
serves as one of Mr. X’s elite goons. He’s fought just as the game draws to a
close, a boss encounter barring the way to his master.
He returns in Streets of Rage 3, where he instead serves as the game’s first boss battle. In both iterations, he’s a tough foe, sporting leaping attacks and flurries that are difficult to deal with within the confines of the games’ rather limited movement. When he’s beaten at the end of stage one, he can be unlocked for play by simply holding a button until the next level begins.
Fans were surely thrilled to learn this, but the first playable Shiva in the games left rather a lot to be desired. He did not have the arsenal of special moves that make him so much fun to play in Streets of Rage 4, and simply served as a powerful, speedy, yet very ‘vanilla’ character. His inability to use weapons (a trait carried over to the next game and perhaps a reference to his honorable nature) arguably made him a much weaker pick than the other cast members.
3. Dracula - Castlevania Judgment
Of course, nobody
really comes out of Castlevania Judgment looking very good. This 2008 Wii
exclusive took the series in a bizarre direction, a spin-off one-on-one
fighting game replete with metal-esque takes on classic series music and some
unapologetically edgy character models for beloved characters.
While it wasn’t well received at all by most, fighting games are fighting games, and those who played flocked towards the most effective cast members. A playable Dracula, surely an enticing prospect for many Castlevania fans, sadly fell a bit flat.
Unlike the rest of the fighters in the game, Dracula can’t be knocked down. He also has a moveset that incorporates those classic fireballs of his and other iconic moves. The crafty Count has his boons, but his constant teleportation shenanigans and meager story mode --which is themed around rematches against characters who have defeated him before-- make this take on Dracula rather weak (his damage potential notwithstanding). It’s a shame that the big bad of so many Castlevania titles just didn’t stand out more in his first playable appearance.
2. Nitros Oxide - Crash Team Racing
Crash Team Racing's plot is hardly gripping stuff: Nitros Oxide, a being from the planet Gasmoxia, has challenged the fastest drivers on Crash’s world to a race, promising to transform the planet into one huge parking lot if he wins.
Needless to say, Oxide does not play fair. His races (he is taken on twice) take place on his own track, the long and winding Oxide Station. He rockets away before the countdown is finished, getting a head start, drops copious amounts of items to scupper the player, and initially only span out briefly when hit by even Juiced-Up weapons (though this isn’t the case in remaster Crash Team Racing: Nitro-Fueled).
He seems like an impossible speedster, but when he’s unlocked in Nitro-Fueled (he isn’t legitimately available in the original), players realize this isn’t the case. His Driving Style is Acceleration, making him functionally identical to the others that share this style. This is academic now that Racing Styles can be customized, but Nitros Oxide’s artificial difficulty is very common in racing games.
1. Yuffie Kisaragi (As Mystery Ninja): Final Fantasy 7: Where Did All Those Neat Abilities Go?
As Final Fantasy 7 veterans will know, Yuffie is an optional party member who can be recruited very early. From the moment the player leaves the Mythril Mine, she has a chance to spawn in forests around the world map. When she does, it is as Mystery Ninja: not strictly a boss battle, but a sneaky and tricky foe nonetheless.
She boasts a range of interesting moves, several with elemental properties, and her stats scale with those of Cloud and co (because she can appear at different stages during the game). This battle’s aftermath makes it even more challenging: mewcomers often have to repeat it several times, as the multiple-choice conversation that follows can result in Yuffie immediately walking away and not joining the party.
When she does, her base stats are very lackluster. Solid enough all around, but she excels only in Luck and Dexterity. As a party member, she’s very reliant on assets like Conformer’s ability to Morph for full damage and the Limit Break Doom Of The Living to warrant a teamslot. It’s a shame she lacks the unique abilities she employed as Mystery Ninja.