10 Problems Nobody Wants To Admit About The Xbox One

Oh, you can play while it's installing, right? WRONG.

You know what the Xbox One is the all-time greatest example of? Wasted potential. I, like probably many of you, am still wondering how Microsoft managed to almost single-handedly destroy its reputation in the console market within a matter of minutes on that fateful day in 2013. The near-catastrophic revelation that the eighth generation console would require an almost permanent connection to the internet along with the somehow-even-stupider decision to restrict the sale and use of pre-owned or second-hand games was a surefire way to put the thing six feet under before it even reached retail. Backlash forced the software giant to completely scrap those ideas in time as they let the public focus on what the Xbox One was doing right. As it turned out, there were quite a few positives; voice-based navigation, the ability to play games mid-install and the more recently, backwards compatibility, were all neat features worth getting excited about. Yet somehow, Microsoft even managed to inadvertently sabotage the popularity of those, too. With every great idea we catch wind of that's in the pipeline for the Xbox One, there's a drawback sure to follow. The Xbox One isn't even close to be being a bad console, but none of these are exactly helping its case, either...

10. Battery-Powered Controllers

Really, Microsoft? Come now, we're living in a wonderful technological age where most, if not all, of our electronic gadgets no longer require being frequently fed batteries to keep them alive: rechargeable devices are far less hassle to maintain, and more economic to boot. Now, let's get the obvious counter-argument out of the way first. Yes, there's a wide range of first and third-party 'charge kits' available to Xbox One owners that will do what the Wii U or PlayStation 4 gamepads already do straight out of the box, but why should we have to shell out additional cash for a feature that comes as standard with competing consoles? We shouldn't have to. It's as simple as that. Microsoft really has no excuse not to include the necessary recharge kit for its peripherals right out of the gate, but where's the money in that, eh? Skepticism aside, the whole problem would be far less pronounced if the Xbox One pad didn't guzzle up batteries like there's no tomorrow. A single, moderately-sized gaming session can easily be enough to eat up over a quarter of your battery life. Absurd.

9. The Dashboard Is Still Lagging

Despite the arrival of a vastly-improved Xbox One dashboard at the tail end of 2015 - dubbed the New Xbox One Experience - Microsoft's big black box is still suffering from several performance issues, chiefly, menu and interface latency. You all know what I'm talking about. Starting and closing games, snapping different apps together, opening party chat, browsing your friends list, all of these things (and more, might I add) are everyday features that we all - quite rightly - take for granted as features that should work seamlessly, considering the premium price of the console. More often that not though, you'll encounter unresponsive buttons, menus that can take upwards of 30 seconds to open or a total software crash, forcing you to go through the hassle of reopening the program. There aren't many things in life as frustrating as trying to join a group of friends for a quick round of team deathmatch, only to be left staring at a static screen, wondering if the console has registered you hammering on the 'Accept Invite' option. First world problems are real.

8. Sensitive To The Touch

If you own a pet or have one of those annoying 'kid' things, you'll know all-too-well the plight of inquisitive noses and grubby hands accidentally (or intentionally, some would swear) turning off your Xbox One mid-gaming session. Whether you're facing off against an end-of-level boss or on the killstreak of your life in your favourite shooter; your dog, cat or child cares not for the importance of such things, they just want to touch that glowing white light emitting from your console. In fact, the console's power button is so ridiculously sensitive that the act of an animal brushing past the faceplate can be enough to power off the thing, causing you to lose any progress you might have made. Pretty much the entire internet has been calling on Microsoft to introduce some sort of feature that enables users to disable the 'button' entirely, but we've had no such luck as yet. The problem's gotten so bad for some, that they've resorted to asking for tips on how to child-proof their console. Try keeping it elevated and away from the reach of kids. Oh, you have a cat too? God help you.

7. Auto Sign-Out Can Be Catastrophic

Here's a problem that many of you will be intimately aware of if you've ever signed in to Xbox Live with your Gamertag on multiple consoles. Microsoft is, and always has been, pro-social gaming, but their enthusiasm for cloud-based account migration and being able to use your account freely across any console can lead to some potentially disastrous accidents occurring. If, at any point, someone signs into your account while you're already logged in on your personal console, the system will literally bid you farewell and disconnect you from any multiplayer game you may be currently engrossed in. Yes, this has happened to me on several infuriating occasions. Sure, one could argue that I should get less careless friends that actually take the effort to look at which account they're signing in with, but some fail-safes on Microsoft's side wouldn't go amiss. As it is, simply clicking the sign-in button will instantly start the process, which is crazy. Secondary confirmation screens would be great, then I wouldn't have to scream in anguish after being disconnected from a Trials Of Osiris match in Destiny.

6. Backwards Compatibility Is Counter-Intuitive

I'll get this out there right now: backwards compatibility is great. It ensures all of those Xbox 360 games you spent hundreds - if not thousands - of hours on will live on beyond the console on which they originally appeared, and better yet, it's completely free. Unlike the PlayStation 3's awful reputation for multi-platform game performance, the opposite is true of the 360 and its position as king of the last console generation, and we're all happy it's a reality. However, some baffling design decisions are holding it back from being perfect. All 360 games you already own that are compatible with the service can be downloaded straight to your Xbox One, hassle free. The whole thing starts to take a turn for the worse though, when you want to download a last-gen title you don't already own straight to the X1. That just can't be done. Instead, you'll have to fire up your retired 360 to buy the desired software, just so it becomes accessible on the newer system, or use the Internet Explorer app to fumble around until you get through their online store that way. Microsoft says it's looking into offering a workaround for these current methods, so here's to hoping this becomes a thing of the past sooner rather than later.

5. Mid-Install Start Is Useless

"Don't worry guys, all your Xbox One games may need to be installed before you can play them, but with our new, mid-install 'Ready to Start!' feature, you'll be able to play as you download!" Great, huh? No, not really. Microsoft seemingly failed to mention (or just didn't test the feature extensively enough) that, while you can play your games before they've finished being fully installed, there's little point in doing so. Until that progress bar reaches 100%, the game you're 'playing' will basically be a menu screen, and if you're lucky, the first introductory stage that lasts little more than a handful of minutes. Nothing says immersion-breaking quite like a big, obnoxious pop-up that says "You need to wait until the game finishes installing to continue". Nice. It's not as if I wanted to leave the safety of the Torrens anyway; nobody told me there were Xenomorphs on that space station waiting to rip Ellen Ripley's face off.

4. Instant-On Mode Causes Problems

The concept of having a console that's essentially always active in the background - even if you weren't actively using it - sounded brilliant before we all actually went out and bought the Xbox One and discovered that, in actuality, the idea was terribly implemented. Whether it's due to poor infrastructure or because the console's internal RAM struggles to hold so much temporary information is unclear, but putting the Xbox One into instant-on mode brings with it a whole host of irritating latency and performance issues. It's nice to know you'll never have to deal with sitting on your couch like a lemon as you wait for game and system updates to install (as you would if you using energy saving mode), but when that comes at the expense of total system crashes and weird bugs that cause games to not even run properly, if at all, you have to wonder if it's really worth the hassle. Hell, head over to Reddit and you'll find a bunch of posts complaining that the progress bar for their latest download didn't even budge an inch after they left it on standby. You can fix all of these issues by doing a hard reset of the console, but that's hardly a long-term solution now, is it?

3. Update And Storage Space Woes

Microsoft's not the only console manufacturer that deserves to be called-out on this one, Sony's just as bad. In fact, so is Nintendo; the Wii U's native storage capability is laughably minute. When exactly, did it become an acceptable practice to ship consoles with a severely inadequate amount of storage? Sure, 10 years ago a 500GB hard drive would be more than you would ever need to store all of your game data, DLC and digital games on for potentially years, but this is 2016, and we can no longer run games straight off the disc without first having to install them to the console. When the likes of Halo 5: Guardians (as of writing this) requires a staggering 70GB of storage space for the base game, patches, DLC and updates, a measly half-terabyte just doesn't cut it. If every game required that much space, you'd only have enough room to have seven games installed at once. It's just dumb. All three current-gen consoles support the use of external storage devices, but, like the whole issue with the Xbox One gamepad, larger internal storage should have been part of the standard package to begin with. It's not as if the price would have been much different, either - the difference in cost between the two sizes is negligible.

2. There's An App For That

Where did it all go wrong? The Xbox 360 isn't considered to be the best console of the last generation just because of its superior engineering (post-Red Ring of Death, at least), performance and exclusives; one of the prime reasons it holds that crown is because it had, by far and away, the most accessible, clean and functional dashboard of its time. In the year leading up to the Xbox One's release though, it became apparent that Microsoft had suddenly taken a liking to all of this external app nonsense, and began hiding every single service behind hundreds of different tiles you had to navigate through like a blind man. Lo and behold, the preference for that type of content delivery exploded into the Xbox One dashboard we have today. Tucked away in its darkest recesses, I'm sure there's a treasure trove of software I'd love nothing more than to buy, and one day, I may actually be able to find it. Kinect goes a long way in remedying most problems by being able to search for something specific through speech, but that bloody thing has enough of its own problems...

1. Kinect Is (Almost) Dead Hardware

If it weren't for the fact that I rely on the Kinect's voice recognition software to navigate the clunky Xbox One dashboard on a day-to-day basis, I'd have boxed it up and stuck in on eBay a long, long time ago. Not that anyone would have bought it of course, that's how undesirable this plastic brick is for most gamers. It's funny, really. Six years ago, when the original Kinect was unveiled on-stage at E3, the whole internet exploded into a frenzy, declaring that Microsoft had just secured a deciding victory over its competitors with the most impressive piece of motion gaming technology ever. Sony responded with its more Wii-like version by releasing PlayStation Move and, back in the present day, it's now apparent that the whole thing was nothing more than a fad that only Nintendo ever managed to capitalise on. Despite Microsoft forcing Kinect 2.0 on us with the Xbox One, it quickly became apparent they had even less of an idea on how to put it to good use than consumers did, eventually backtracking on their stance of it being an integral part of their 'vision'. I can only imagine how much surplus stock of the standalone Kinect retailers have stacked up in their warehouses as I type these words. What a waste. Are there any huge issues with the Xbox One that really need to be aired out? Let us know in the comments!

In this post: 
XBox One
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Joe is a freelance games journalist who, while not spending every waking minute selling himself to websites around the world, spends his free time writing. Most of it makes no sense, but when it does, he treats each article as if it were his Magnum Opus - with varying results.