10 REAL Reasons Why These Video Games Failed
Overworking, under-planning, and good old fashioned hubris.
There are a lot of reasons as to why a game can fail. From not having enough money, to not having enough time, to the manager being a git, tons and tons of things can kill a project before it makes it to release.
But sometimes people focus way too much on one reason, that they lose sight of the actual big reason why something failed. Or maybe they would have noticed, if not for the publisher trying to save face by sweeping it under the rug.
Either way, the truth can only stay hidden for so long, so inevitably the gaming public unearths the true reason why their favorite hobby turned sour. These games failed for many reasons, but the true tale of their downfall took quite a bit to finally come to light.
10. Released Way Before It Was Finished - KOTOR 2
You'll find that a common issue with Obsidian studios' games is that they can be... unpolished. For one reason or another, they have a tendency to either release games before they're ready, or release them in a state where heavy patching is required afterward. And one of the most famous examples of Obsidian's lackluster time management is Knights of the Old Republic 2.
This one sits at the bottom of the list due to its reason being the simplest of all of them, it was just flat out not finished in time for release.
This resulted in a ton of bugs, some of them game breaking, the story not feeling finished, mostly due to the third issue, which is that entire swathes of the game are unfinished.
Now, the Star Wars fandom being what it is, naturally there are tons of free patches and mods for the game that more or less fix everything that can be fixed everything and even expand on unfinished elements. But they're a band aid on an injury that needs a cast.
9. EA Interfering At Every Turn - Ultima IX: Acension
It is no secret that EA is the worst company in the entire gaming industry, they've literally been given that award several times. If you don't hate EA already, Google them and you'll FIND a reason to hate them. For classic CRPG fans, that reason comes in the form of what they did to poor poor Origin Systems.
If you thought EA closing down studios that they set up to fail in the first place was a new thing, oh no, they've been doing it for literal decades, and Origin was one of their most famous victims. Once one of the founding fathers of computer gaming, Richard Garriot's Ultima series was reduced to a joke in the one-two punch of the unfinished Ultima VIII: Pagan, and the truly disastrous Ultima IX: Ascension.
And both failures have one thing in common. No prizes for guessing what it was.
EA interfered in the development of Ultima IX at pretty much every single turn, from cutting development time, to forcing them to use an engine Origin wasn't familiar with, to - of course - taking it out on Origin when the game came out, and of course, getting them absolutely eaten alive.
8. Trying To Compete With Overwatch - Battleborn
Overwatch conquered the world when it first came out, so - like with anyone foolish enough to drop a game the same weekend as a new Call Of Duty - anyone who tried to compete with Overwatch those first few years of its release was doomed to failure.
But that didn't stop 2K games from trying anyway with Battleborn.
Battleborn was fun in its own right, but to be frank, Blizzard at this time was still completely untouchable. Battleborn - like Lawbreakers and other character based arena shooters that came after it - simply didn't have a leg to stand on when it came to getting people into what many saw as a ripoff of a more successful product.
Which, you know, isn't a COMPLETELY inaccurate view of what Battleborn was. But considering how Blizzard has become a pariah of a company in less than 2 years, perhaps those who wrote off this game when it first released are rethinking their initial stance.
Speaking of which...
7. Blizzard Buying Their Own Hype - World Of Warcraft
Being the top dog of an entire genre of gaming can do funny things to a studio. It can, for example, make the studio heads think themselves untouchable, causing them to do some REALLY sketchy and despicable stuff because they're the heads of Blizzard and who's gonna stop them?
As you can imagine, this mindset can easily bleed over into the thing that put a studio there in the first place. Enter World Of Warcraft.
World Of Warcraft, if you ask any fan, has been on a downward spiral of quality for the past half decade. Now, you would think with genuine competition arising in recent years in the form of the completely revitalized Final Fantasy XIV Online, would get them to step up their game, but nope. See, one of the biggest things holding the game back practically since the start was a sense of entitlement on the part of the game's lead developers and the heads of Blizzard, most likely caused by years of pretenders being swept aside in the late 2000s.
This "they'll come crawling back" mindset, eerily reminiscent (for a number of reasons) of a bitter, rightly dumped, ex boyfriend, has done nothing but hold the game back as a whole. Which is why seemingly obvious quality of life improvements adopted by other big MMOs have yet to make it into WoW.
WoW is still around, sure, but if things don't turn around quickly, one must ask "how much longer"?
6. Severely Mismanaged Release - Destiny
The development of the original Destiny is a case study in how Murphy's Law can be a developer's worst nightmare. Basically everything went wrong while making this game, and at the worst possible time that it could have gone wrong. But even a game with this troubled a development could have salvaged itself if it got its release down pat.
Yeah it uh, didn't do that right either.
Destiny's launch was riddled with problems that took way longer to solve than it should have. One of the biggest albatrosses around the neck of the initial launch was the head scratching decision to more or less nix the entire story before the game launched. They would of course remedy this over the coming months, but an already controversial release was given an even higher uphill battle to fight because of this.
It's no wonder that Bungie made an entire sequel with the sole purpose of calling a do over. The fact that they even got to do that speaks to how much leeway the gaming public affords companies like Bungie.
5. Rushed Out Before Contract Expired - Tony Hawk Pro Skater 5
When you buy the rights to adapt an IP into a piece of media, you'll more often than not have to accept the caveat that - if you want to keep the IP - you have to, you know, USE it. Which, besides being the reason why Sony is so desperate to make Morbius a thing, is one of many reasons why Tony Hawk Pro Skater 5 was such a colossal trainwreck.
The Pro Skater franchise's heyday was already well behind it by this point, but what definitely didn't help matters was the fact that Activision rushed the game to release WAY before it was finished to make sure they can cash in on the game one last time before the contract officially expired.
This, naturally, led to Pro Skater 5 being a complete embarrassment when it hit store shelves - not helped by the fact that, on top of the rush job, development was handed to developer Robomodo, who are infamous among Pro Skater fans. So unfinished was the released game that Activision had to release patches and updates with file sizes that are normally reserved for anything made by Rockstar. And even then the game was still a fundamentally poor experience.
4. Crunch And Hubris - Cyberpunk 2077
Cyberpunk, after almost a decade of being teased by developer CD Projekt RED (your scribe, for example, was about 16 when he first heard about it) was finally released to near universal hatred. It's legitimately hilarious how vitriolic the response to this game was, especially because of how - yeah, it was completely warranted.
In the aftermath, journalists - desperate to learn why CD Projekt RED, once the golden boys of western RPGs, had failed so spectacularly - latched onto the intense crunch the studio forced the dev team to endure in order to meet its release schedule. The story goes the developers assumed they'd finish the game in 2022, so when a 2020 release date was announced, they couldn't believe how much work they'd have ahead of them.
And that was definitely part of the reason the game turned out to be such a mess, but like Blizzard earlier in the list, it goes deeper than that.
CD Projekt RED made The Witcher 3, one of the most beloved and acclaimed RPGs ever made. And because of that, the heads of development got it into their heads that they were the top dogs and no one could touch them. That kind of mindset is poisonous to any kind of art creation, let alone video games. Add the intense crunch of its dev team on top of that, and you get a toxic cocktail that led to one of the biggest embarrassments of any video game company in the industry's history.
3. Trying To Franchise - Dead Space 3
Some properties are built for expansion, and some aren't. That's just how art is. Sure you may get one really good sequel out of the latter category, but pushing beyond that is foolhardy.
Frankly, even if Dead Space 3 hadn't been littered with microtransactions and 2010s FPS nonsense, the game was practically doomed from the start because this idea is not meant to be franchised.
Dead Space and Dead Space 2 are wonderful games, and yeah, the lore is fascinating, but not enough for a long running game series, and certainly not enough for straight-to-DVD anime movies and comic books and everything else EA was trying to do with this franchise before they got bored with it and the studio that made it and promptly axed the whole thing.
Dead Space and Dead Space 2 were amazing games, but some properties are simply not built to be franchises.
2. Forced To Use An Incompatible Engine - Mass Effect: Andromeda
Bioware Edmonton is usually the one behind all of their games, but for the long awaited sequel to one of their two flagship franchises, EA outsourced development to Bioware's then new studio stationed out of Montreal. Not a problem in itself, but EA just couldn't leave well enough alone.
EA interfered with development at practically every step of the way. Most notably, like with Dragon Age: Inquisition, they forced the team to use the Frostbite engine, so that EA can avoid having to pay royalties for using a different engine.
Now, the Frostbite engine is a perfectly piece of kit in itself, but it's hardwired for FPS games. So while when used for first person shooter games like DICE's Battlefront 2, the engine soars, when applied to RPGs like Dragon Age: Inquisition and Mass Effect: Andromeda, it falls flat on its face.
Now, Bioware Edmonton had enough experience with Frostbite to figure out how to get Inquisition over the finish line intact. A luxury not afforded to Bioware Montreal, who had to figure out how to make this engine made strictly for first-person-shooters work on a third person shooter RPG while MAKING said third-person shooter RPG.
Is it any shock at all that this game turned out such a mess?
1. Rushed Out In Five Weeks Because No One Knew What They Were Doing - E.T. (Atari 2600)
The most infamous failure in video game history, the story of E.T for the Atari 2600 had to be at the top of this list.
EA, Blizzard, and all the rest may have their cardinal sins when it comes to how they manage the development of their games, but even they know better now than to make the mistakes Atari made when making E.T.
Game development at the time was the wild west: uncharted territory, where no one really knew what they were doing, and yet were pouring a sinful glut of video games into the market.
Atari demanded this game be made in just five weeks to be able to come out in time for Christmas. An unrealistic timeframe for even the simplest video game, but again, no one from bottom to top really knew that yet. Or if they did, they didn't listen to the guys sounding alarm bells. What resulted was a game that broke the camel's back of the game industry and crashed the whole thing.
ET failed because no one was being careful with this then experimental new medium. And when you're traveling uncharted territory, someone's gonna fall into a bottomless pit they didn't know was there. Almost makes the content of this game prophetic.