10 Reasons Bloodborne Is Better Than Dark Souls III

It may be the best Dark Souls, but it can't beat Bloodborne.

Bloodborne Fiery Beast
FromSoftware

Lock your doors, turn off your phones and prepare to die over and over again, because Dark Souls III is finally here.

The long-awaited - and possibly final - Dark Souls game is already earning acclaim from fans and critics for its improved combat, stunning graphics and absurd difficulty level that players just can't get enough of. Gamers everywhere are still working their way through the title's nightmarish journey, and word is out that Dark Souls III improves upon its predecessor in nearly every way.

That's great, but the game that Dark Souls III is really going to be compared to is Bloodborne. Developer FromSoftware's brilliant spin-off of the Dark Souls franchise blew away just about everyone when it hit the PS4 in 2015, and in many ways set a new standard for the Dark Souls franchise despite being a spin-off. It's a standard that even Dark Souls III falls short of.

As brilliant as Dark Souls III is, it just can't match the greatness of Bloodborne in these ten critical ways.


10. The Incredible Chalice Dungeons

Bloodborne Ebrietas
Bloodborne Wikia

While there€™s an argument to be made that Dark Souls III€™s main story is just as long as Bloodborne€™s, the chalice dungeons of Bloodborne add hours upon hours of additional gameplay that Dark Souls III cannot match.

Chalice dungeons are optional areas within Bloodborne€™s main hub world. They essentially turn the game into a roguelike experience by offering randomly generated dungeons that get increasingly more challenging as you play.

You can easily get just as many hours of play out of this optional mode as you can from the main game. Even better, it puts just enough of a twist on the experience to feel like an entirely separate game built within Bloodborne€™s engine.


9. Less Cumbersome Inventory

bloodborne old hunters DLC
FromSoftware

As I made my way towards the end of Dark Souls III, I couldn€™t help but be struck by how many items were in my inventory. Even after selling off excess stock as I acquired it, my menu was still plagued with items that I never intended to use.

Bloodborne didn€™t have this problem. Not only did it remove many of the more superfluous weapon and character buff items that Dark Souls features, but it also had a host of clever ways to help manage your items automatically. The most notable of these would be the invaluable way that the game would automatically filter away excess health items and given them to you when you respawn.

You should never really have an abundance of resources in these games, and Bloodborne makes sure that you do not.


8. Back-stabs Aren't Nearly As Cheap

Bloodborne Backstab
FromSoftware

In Dark Souls, back-stabs are as devastating as they are easy to perform. You simply circle around an enemy until they present their vulnerable backside and press the attack button.

Things are a little more complicated in Bloodborne. While back-stabs are still possible, actually performing one requires much more finesse. By turning back-stabs into a multi-step process, Bloodborne replaces one of the cheapest aspects of Dark Souls with one that provides a genuine sense of accomplishment, as well as a powerful attack.

Anyone that loses a Dark Souls III PvP match thanks to the relative ease of the back-stab maneuver will instantly wish the game had taken a page out of Bloodborne's playbook.


7. Guns Are More Interesting Than Shields

Bloodborne Gun
FromSoftware

Along with back-stabs, one of the more consistently cheesy ways to find victory in Dark Souls is to throw up the biggest shield you can find and tank damage whenever possible. Invest enough skill points into this ability and you€™ll become nearly unstoppable.

For the most part, Bloodborne replaces shields with guns. However, rather than treat guns as the uber-powerful pieces of destruction most games present them as, here guns are more of a deterrent. They are used to stagger your foes and set yourself up for a powerful attack, as opposed to killing them outright.

It€™s an incredibly unique way to treat firearms in a game and adds a layer of skill to the combat that the shields of Dark Souls III cannot equal.


6. The Health Restoration System Is Perfect

Bloodborne the old hunters
From Software

For the most part, restoring your health in Dark Souls III involves using an estus flask with limited charges. While there€™s nothing wrong with the system, it€™s a little hard to go back to after experiencing what Bloodborne had to offer.

In Bloodborne, it€™s possible to restore your character's health by striking an enemy immediately after taking damage. While you can€™t rely on this method as your lone source of recovery due to the risk involved, it does a tremendous job of advocating risk-taking in combat in order to reap reward.

This mechanic is an absolutely inspired way to introduced health gains into these games without compromising the challenge, and Dark Souls III suffers from its absence


5. Better Boss Design

Bloodborne game
FromSoftware

This one is tough to admit as I actually do love the bosses in Dark Souls III, but ultimately they do not top the brilliance of Bloodborne€™s biggest encounters.

The biggest advantage that Bloodborne has here is an emphasis on variety over quantity. While Dark Souls III doesn€™t go overboard with bosses the way that Dark Souls II did, it is still a little too fond of inserting boss fights that seem to exist out of an obligation to have a boss fight. Meanwhile, bosses in Bloodborne all feel like they play a substantial role in the events that are occurring.

The variety carries over into the fights themselves as well. Many of Bloodborne€™s bosses have some unique mechanic that separates them from the pack while Dark Souls III occasionally treads too much old ground.


4. Unique Weapons

Bloodborne Weapons
FromSoftware

With relatively few exceptions, the weapons in Dark Souls III are fairly uninspiring from a design standpoint. There€™s quite a few of them €“ and they€™re certainly effective €“ but they rarely go beyond the standard collection of axes, swords, and bows.

Bloodborne, however, more than makes up for its relatively small arsenal by making sure that each and every one of its weapons has genuine personality. Whether it€™s a katana with a sheath that turns it into a greatsword or a spear that doubles as a rifle, Bloodborne€™s weaponry is filled with creative dealers of death with differences that are far more than cosmetic.

Exploring the various weapons of Bloodborne and their abilities is a genuine treat, whereas comparing the Dark Souls III weapons usually involves seeing which one hits harder and rolling with it.


3. Faster Combat

Bloodborne Combat
FromSoftware

Once upon a time, Dark Souls was praised for its methodical combat that emphasized strategy in a way that few other games that put a sword or blunt object in your hands ever do. It€™s still one of the best out there.

But Bloodborne sets a new standard. It requires no less strategy and skill than Dark Souls, but it is able to execute those qualities at a much faster pace. Here you must be able to constantly think on the fly, as moments of consideration are few and far between.

While some may deem this to be a simple difference in styles, Bloodborne manages to retain many of the best elements of Dark Soul€™s combat, while turning the speed up to 11.


2. A More Interesting World

bloodborne game
From Software

All due respect to Dark Souls III€™s take on dark fantasy, but it is fairly similar to many dark fantasy titles that we€™ve seen in the past. Within you will find few major deviations from the dragons, skeletons, and castles we associate with the genre.

Bloodborne, however, is a child of far fresher inspiration. Its gothic world borrows a few pages from the works of HP Lovecraft and Hammer horror films but has a dreamlike quality that is entirely its own. There is a malevolent - yet undeniably beautiful €“ character to the visual design of Bloodborne that encourages you to explore every inch of it despite the danger.

It€™s no coincidence that many of the best visuals in Dark Souls III are lifted from Bloodborne.


1. Feels Like A Proper Follow-Up To Dark Souls

gehrman the first hunter bloodborne
From Software

If you loved the first Dark Souls and are looking for more, then you are going to love Dark Souls III. It does an excellent job of carrying on and evolving the things that made that game great.

What Bloodborne does is arguably more impressive however. It examines the things that made Dark Souls unique but doesn€™t rely on the exact formula of the original game as closely as Dark Souls III does. As a result, it feels more like a proper sequel as opposed to an impressive expansion.

Bloodborne and Dark Souls may technically be separate franchises, but the way that Bloodborne resists treading old ground while providing fans with many of the elements that made them fall in love with Dark Souls in the first place is truly impressive.


Contributor
Contributor

An entertainment enthusiast living in Brooklyn, trying to make his way by slinging words at blank pages.