
In 2010, in order to jump on the bandwagon of motion controls and compete with Nintendo, Microsoft released the Kinect for the Xbox 360. However, unlike its competition, the Kinect lacks any controller at all: using a motion sensing camera, the peripheral follows the players movements and inputs them into the system, allowing you to directly control and interact with the Xbox 360. The Kinect also acts as a means to broaden the appeal of video games, allowing those who find a standard controller to daunting a task to participate. The peripheral is by all means a success, selling over 10 million copies since its release. Yet despite the monetary success, as well as being a legitimately impressive piece of technology, the Kinect has had the same problem that other motion control systems have had: appealing to anyone other than the casual gamer. Anyone I know that owns a Kinect played with it for a couple weeks then soon forgot about it and moved on. It now sits and collects dust, only used for the occasional menu operation via voice. Now, two years later, nobody seems to be talking about it, no real games are released on a regular basis, and in general it sits in a vacuum alone and unattended. How could something as supposedly revolutionary as the Kinect be cared about so little? Well, thats what Im here for. Here are 10 reasons why nobody cares about the Kinect.
10. The Price

When it was first released, the price of the Kinect was $149.99. It has since gone down to around $100, which isnt too bad a price for such a device, but when you take into account the price of the games, you can see just how expensive investing in a Kinect actually can be. Despite most of the games not being full-fledged games, they still insist on marking them with the full $50-60 price tag. When you consider just how little youre actually getting, this is simply unacceptable. Unsurprisingly, it doesnt take long for these games prices to substantially go down, so one only has to wait a couple months to save some money. Even still, many of these games are so lacking in any substance that even at a reduced price they are not worth it. Basically, the Kinect is asking for a lot for very little.
9. The Space

In order to get the most out of your Kinect, it requires you to make a lot of space, so upon purchasing one, be prepared to start rearranging furniture. People I know who have the Kinect have to move their couch back every time they want to use it, which is actually a bit of a hassle. It may not seem it, but this can be quite an annoyance and can deter you from playing a Kinect game. Who wants to come home and chill with a game after a long day at work only to have to move the furniture? This becomes increasingly problematic when multiplayer is concerned. Dont make enough room, and youll inevitably smack your friend in the face while flailing your arms like a spaze. If youve already got a huge, expansive house, fine, but for the rest of us, this means making even more room than before. And for those who live in an apartment or small house, multiplayer is probably impossible. The Kinect was touted as a unifier; something to be experienced with friends and family, but it makes it very hard to do so for many people, so why bother?
8. Dance, Exercise, & Mini-Games

One of the most justifiable criticisms of the Kinect is its heavy emphasis on dance games, exercise games, and mini-game compilations. I have no problem with these types of games, as they are the most obvious means of showing off the tech in its early stages. They also work well in getting little kids or older people to play games, giving you games to play with them that lack the complication that turns them off. And dance and exercise games, while not something I am terribly interested in, have their place as well, allowing people to have some fun while they stay fit. These types of games are harmless time wasters, nothing more, hence why their heavy emphasis bothers me so much. These games have little value under the surface. They have no stories, no vision, and no point other than the previously mentioned. It just strikes me as odd that Microsoft would emphasize them and nothing else. I understand that they want to appeal to the casual as much as possible, but that appears to be the only demographic they seem to care about. If you enjoy playing video games for more than just competition or points, then the Kinect gives you little reason to bother. Video games have the ability to transport you to unique and amazing worlds, but the Kinect doesn't care about even trying to do that.
7. Cutesy Games
As part of the appeal to the casual gamer, Microsoft is also aiming the Kinect towards kids. Games like Kinect Sesame Street TV, Kinect Rush, and Kinectimals are all aimed solely at children. Again, this is not a problem, as children are just as much an important part of the gaming industry as anyone else, and the Kinect offers parents a simple and easy way for children to entertain themselves. They don't have to worry about objectionable content, and can even use it as a learning experience. However, just like with their heavy emphasis on dance and mini-games, Microsoft is also focusing a little too much on the children. When they demonstrated Sesame Street at the press conference during E3, most gamers laughed in confusion. Children and parents are certainly not the demographic to be watching E3, so it is baffling that they would think to even bother. Meanwhile, those who do pay attention to E3 sit there and wait for the pain to end and for Microsoft to start showing interesting titles. It is alienating, and feels like the outside is intruding on our passion. Again, kids deserve to have their own games, but not at the expense of the people who made the industry what it was. Expanding to the casual is completely understandable and acceptable, but they shouldn't loose focus on the core demographic. Hence why gamers have no interest in the Kinect.
6. No Core Games

Any gamer knows that in order to make an impression and convince us to buy a console, it must impress us with the software. This is why launch titles for new consoles are so important, and is one reason why Microsofts Xbox 360 was a substantial step ahead of Sonys Playstation 3; it had a stronger line up of games available at launch. Without the software, a console is useless, no matter the technology. This also holds true for additional peripheral devices such as the Kinect. It needs games to give us a reason to buy it, and at this point, it has nothing of substantial value. Yes, it does have a relatively large library of games, but most are nothing more than mini-game collections, dance games, and exercise games. These games have a valuable place within the Kinects library, but if it wants to attract gamers who want to play games that offer more than just dancing or exercising, it needs games that will attract their interests. Genres such as shooters, RPGs, and fighting games are all that would attract the more hardcore gamer, but so far are non-existent on the Kinect. As a result, the hardcore gamer, who makes up a substantial portion of the consumer base, has no interest in the Kinect. Why should they when it has nothing of value to offer?
5. Erratic Behavior

Im a Dragonball fan, so when the Kinect was released, I always joked how hilariously awesome a Dragonball game for it would be. This month, such a game was released in the form of the unsurprisingly titled Dragonball Z for Kinect. Upon its release, however, it was soon revealed that the game has its fair share of problems, of which the worst is its inability to register many of the moves. The system is completely erratic, as sometimes it registers moves, other times it doesnt. Whats the point of a Dragonball Kinect game if it doesnt even play right half of the time? This game highlights a big problem with the Kinect: the inconsistency of the devices ability to register moves of relative complexity. Some games, like many of the dance games, work remarkably well. Others, however, range from erratic to unplayable. Im not sure whether fault lies with the Kinect itself or the programming of the games, but when your games rely on the device operating perfectly, even the slightest hiccup in performance can be game breaking. It can be so bad that it puts you off from playing Kinect games at all.
4. No Controller
Oddly enough, the defining aspect of the Kinect is actually its Achilles Heel. Microsoft markets the Kinect on the idea that you are the controller, and because of this, it offers a more precise and simple gaming experience, but it turns out that this isnt actually the case. Anyone who has used the Kinect will tell you that, because of its ability to pick up even the smallest of movements with precision, players actually lack the precision that comes from a standard controller. Imagine trying to pull off a head shot using the Kinect. Your hands would be shaking ever so slightly, and so the reticule would be shaking as well. Oddly enough, the analog sticks of a controller are able to pull off such a simple task with great ease; its just about being accustomed to the controller. Of course, this scares away the casual gamer, hence the existence of motion controls and the Kinect. Gamers know that getting acquainted with controls is a process of learning and memorization. Each time we put in a new game, we go through this process. Kinect seeks to skip this process through streamlining via motion controls, but they ironically give us less control. Gamers instinctively know this, and thus have no reason to have interest in the Kinect. Controllers are just better.
3. Kinect Star Wars

I know I cant be the only one who immediately thought how awesome a Star Wars lightsaber game would be using the Kinect. As soon as the device was announced, such an idea was on the minds of many gamers. This shouldnt come as a surprise, as the device is practically tailor made for that type of game. Despite the many great Star Wars games released in the past, none of them have yet to capture the feeling of actually wielding a lightsaber like a true Jedi, but with the Kinect, this became a distinct possibility. We knew a Star Wars game would be announced at some point, it was only a matter of time. Sure enough, LucasArts announced Kinect Star Wars at E3 in 2011, and on April 3rd, 2012, it was released. If there ever was a game to properly actualize the potential of the Kinect, this was it. Instead of greatness, what we got is a collection of Star Wars mini-games. Yep, thats about it. Yes, there is a Jedi section, but it was a rail shooter with a lightsaber. No character, no story, no strategy, no challenge, just a casual game meant for kids, and any hopes of tapping into the Star Wars kid in all of us were dashed. That wasnt the worst part. Kinect Star Wars also gave us this: http://youtu.be/QaVrAw1-zrY Ummmwhat?! Honestly, Ive never been as disturbed as I am seeing Princess Leia dance to a Gwen Stefani knock off song. As if the Kinect wasnt drenched in dance games already, Lucas decided to sell out even more and give us this travesty. I can safely say that no one on this planet ever wanted a Star Wars dance game. No one. With Kinect Star Wars, any hope that the Kinect would register outside of the casual and reach the potential of motion controls were now gone. It gave those who already questioned its existence even more fuel, and turned those who had hope into cynics. Perhaps it was the limitations of the technology, or perhaps it was the developers lack of time or effort, but Kinect Star Wars, more than anything else, showed that the Kinect is nothing more than a glorified paper weight. Since its release, what little interest was left is now gone. Unfortunately nobody cares about the Kinect anymore, and for good reason.
2. Lost Potential

Kinect Star Wars is the perfect example of the lost potential so far with the Kinect, and the longer this goes on, the more apathetic gamers will be about it. The tech is there, as is the potential, but no one has even scratched the surface. It seems like developers and publishers realize this as well, as theyd rather play it safe and make another dance game or mini-game compilation than anything interesting or of substance. The worst aspect of this is that there really could be some great games made for the Kinect, assuming the tech is as good as they say it is. Think about the potential of a first-person adventure game or RPG, or a fighting game. Again, in order for these games to be good, the tech has to be responsive and the game design well implemented. The only reason this hasnt been the case is that it hasnt really been attempted. Maybe publishers are afraid that hardcore gamers wont respond regardless, so it isnt worth it, but this simply isnt true. Good games will attract gamers; its not that complicated. If no effort is made, the Kinect will continue to be ignored by a core consumer base. They are the consumers who will spend the money on games, not the casual players. Ignoring them is foolish, hence the lack of caring. Gives us the games, and we will come. Which brings me to the last point
1. Disappointing Games

Last year, Sega actually tried to do something cool with the Kinect with their game Rise of Nightmares. A survival horror game using the Kinect sounds undeniably awesome, and with this game there was hope that there would finally be a game worth buying the Kinect for. While the game ended up delivering on the visuals and atmosphere, what hindered it was, of course, the motion controls, which were often too imprecise or awkward. The game also proved to be too repetitive, forcing the player to hack and slash at foes with little else going on. The game is thought to be mediocre at best. What games like Rise of Nightmares, Kinect Star Wars, and Dragonball Z for Kinect have shown is that whenever developers have the chance to take advantage of the technology and try something different, they either refuse or fail spectacularly. From this, we can infer that the Kinect just isnt able to deliver legitimately good games. They either suck from lack of effort or the limitations of the technology. This is too bad, because as Ive mentioned before, the Kinect is itself an impressive piece of technology, it just doesnt seem like anyone has been able to tap into its true potential and deliver great games. Perhaps it can be chalked up to the fact that motion controlled video games are still in the early stages of development. Give it enough time, and the technology might surpass the limitations of a physical controller and usher in a new age of gaming. Or perhaps it will fade away in obscurity; another failed experiment within the video game industry. It is too early to tell, but at present, the Kinect has given us little reason to care. What do you think of the Kinect? Share your thoughts below...