10 Recent Video Games That Totally Divided Players

Nobody can agree on these recent releases.

Hellblade II
Ninja Theory

Much as publishers don't want to admit it, even the most popular video games aren't made for everyone, and generally speaking, trying to make a game that pleases everybody is a shortcut to delivering a game that swiftly satisfies nobody.

And then there are those anticipated games that just end up splitting players firmly down the middle, driving a huge wedge between its audience and generating a spirited discourse to say the very least.

And over the past year-or-so, no video games have proven more divisive than this bunch, with public opinion ranging from pure masterpiece status to hot garbage, and of course, everything else in-between.

These games had no clear consensus among the player-base, their gameplay and story decisions making them some of the most interesting - or, perhaps, frustrating - titles to discuss over the last 12 months.

Again, no game can please everyone, yet these titles sparked an unexpectedly contentious dialogue among fans, none of whom could agree on just how good or bad said game actually was.

And so, as we all still struggle to reconcile our feelings on these games, let's look back to what both sides of each argument are thinking...

10. Final Fantasy XVI

Final Fantasy XVI
Square Enix

Final Fantasy XVI just might be the most polarising entry into the legendary RPG franchise, and that's really saying something.

FFXVI has been lauded as a wild shake-up of the series, with its more self-serious, Game of Thrones-inspired narrative and undeniably controversial decision to ditch the franchise's traditional turn-based combat.

And here's something just about everyone will agree on - Masayoshi Soken's musical score is absolutely gorgeous, even if you hate most everything else about this game.

And there certainly are haters, indeed. For many who love the series' traditional formula, this was just too far a departure, deeming the combat casualised to the point of tedium, with an overly serious story and characters, and a dull earthy colour palette, while the much-hyped Eikon battles too often felt like empty, on-rails spectacle.

Square Enix themselves have admitted that they wanted Final Fantasy XVI to open the series up to a wider audience, and whether they succeeded or not - and more importantly, whether that's a good thing - has firmly split the existing fanbase down the middle.


9. Dead Island 2

Dead Island 2
Dambuster Studios

Given that Dead Island 2 spent almost a decade in protracted, hellish development - where it burned through three different dev teams - even the series' biggest fans would've been foolish to expect greatness from it.

And yet, there was a profound sentiment of surprise when the game finally hit stores last year, that with so much anti-hype in front of it, Dead Island 2 was actually... pretty good?

Though it hardly reinvented the wheel, there was something to be said for the game's shiny, ultra-gory, no-nonsense zombie-slaying action, while contained within a refreshingly modest semi-open world.

But it's also fair to say that expectations were so bleak pre-release that basic competence bought the end result a lot of goodwill, even if to some players, this is an aggressively simplistic experience that struggles to maintain interest across its roughly 15-hour story.

In the very least, most will agree that it's far from the disaster that seemed to be on the cards a few years back.


8. The Crew Motorfest

The Crew: Motorfest
Ubisoft

Despite scoring just consistently "OK" reviews with critics, The Crew franchise has garnered itself quite the passionate fanbase over the years, and for many of them, threequel The Crew Motorfest was the series' strongest entry yet.

From its gorgeous Hawaiian setting to its much-improved car handling and shameless pilfering from the Forza Horizon series, the third time seemed to be the charm for a lot of players.

But on the other hand, it's a game that did little to dissuade those already skeptical about The Crew as an IP, cribbing from the open-world racing formula perfected by Forza in a manner so blatant that, unless you only own a PlayStation 4 or 5, there was little reason to bother with this instead of just sticking with Forza Horizon 5.

Yet even those indifferent to the series mostly accepted The Crew Motorfest to be an improvement over its uneven predecessors, even if it didn't persuade everyone that there's a place in the racing sphere for yet another franchise like this.


7. Alone In The Dark

Alone in the Dark
THQ Nordic

There probably weren't many folk genuinely expecting great things from the new Alone in the Dark reimagining, but with Hollywood stars Jodie Comer and David Harbour involved, there presumably had to be something interesting, right?

And that really depends who you ask. Despite scoring wildly mixed reviews from critics, this game has some extremely passionate defenders, who see it as a loving homage to the series' sunnier past, right down to its emphasis on puzzle-driven gameplay, making this arguably the second-best entry into the entire franchise.

But let's be clear - given the utter tawdry state of Alone in the Dark as a series, the bar is in hell. 

And for even some long-time fans, this new entry didn't quite cut it, with the janky gameplay - namely the wretched combat - too often undercutting the spirited attempts to muster a thick atmosphere.

Given that it flopped commercially, it likely won't see a sequel regardless of what you thought of it.


6. Starfield

Starfield
Bethesda

Starfield was unquestionably one of 2023's most anticipated video games, and boy was the discourse surrounding its release something alright.

Though reviews were largely positive, they weren't quite as glowing as many were expecting for Bethesda's long-gestating open-world sci-fi RPG. And things only ramped up from there once general players got their hands on it.

There were absolutely those players who fell in love with Starfield's richly immersive world, but for everyone wowed by it, there was someone left crestfallen by how... fine it was.

For many, Starfield simply failed to match the scale of its lofty ambitions, from the forgettable story and characters to the repetitive gameplay, unimaginative quest design, and shockingly lackluster space exploration. It had all the ingredients for greatness, but ultimately failed to distinguish itself in a crowded genre.

Almost a year removed from its release, player response has become no less divided, resulting in what's by far the most fiercely debated AAA Bethesda release to date.


5. Diablo IV

Diablo IV
Blizzard

Diablo IV released to generally rave reviews from critics, and the early player sentiment was pretty damn positive for the most part too, with a lot of love for its combat and atmosphere in particular.

But that all changed in the weeks and especially the months following release, as players reached the endgame content which many of them found disappointingly piecemeal. 

Couple this with controversial changes made to gameplay systems by Blizzard post-release, and the tide of public opinion quickly turned against it.

Basically, many players remain skeptical that Blizzard are going to deliver on the game's live service promises, and given what's been offered up over its first year on the market, that's certainly a valid stance.

But to the same token, if you just want to get in, experience the main story, get out, and move onto another game, Diablo IV's core experience has a lot of fun to behold.


4. The Expanse: A Telltale Series

Telltale's The Expanse
Telltale Games

The Expanse: A Telltale Series marked the first new episodic project from Telltale Games in many years, and so expectations were high that this promising prequel to the incredible Amazon sci-fi series would deliver the goods.

On one hand, there's been a lot of appreciation for Telltale's love letter to The Expanse, from all the visual detail of its world to its fleshing-out of Drummer's backstory, and of course, the outstanding central performance from Cara Gee in the lead role.

But on the other, gameplay-wise this has been embraced less-warmly, given the reliance on dull mission objectives and puddle-deep puzzles, all while the entire five-episode series can be easily beaten in under four hours.

For everyone who found it to be a welcome addition to the Expanse canon, there was someone left totally unimpressed by what was basically Just Another Telltale Game, packed with gameplay so unambitious as to incite genuine boredom.


3. Avatar: Frontiers Of Pandora

Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora
Ubisoft

How well you'll vibe with Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora will largely depend on your fondness for the Ubisoft open-world formula - namely, whether you find it comfortingly familiar or snooze-inducingly generic.

But what few will dispute is the game's visual accomplishments, dropping players into James Cameron's one-of-a-kind world and keenly exploiting the eye-popping flora and fauna that reside within.

Yet beyond its superficial pleasures, Frontiers of Pandora caught plenty of flak for being an almost comically by-the-numbers open-world action game from Ubisoft. 

There's nothing in the gameplay you haven't seen elsewhere, and when tethered to a so-so story and characters, it ensured that many struggled to plow through its 20-hour campaign, even with such lush visuals to soak in.

Again, it's all down to your tolerance for formulaic gameplay, but given that Ubisoft has printed billions of dollars with this framework, it clearly is enjoyed by a great many players.


2. Senua's Saga: Hellblade II

Hellblade II
Ninja Theory

Though Hellblade II was broadly well-received by critics, the player response has been decidedly more polarised. 

While many embraced it as a gorgeously cinematic and refreshingly short action-adventure sequel, there were just as many left utterly underwhelmed by it.

For everyone bowled over by its cutting-edge visuals, enigmatic story, and Melina Juergens' sublime performance as Senua, there were those unmoved by gameplay perceived as lackluster - especially the dumbed-down puzzle segments and repetitive combat engagements.

After roughly five years of development, many fans of the original Hellblade were left expecting much, much more than a visually stunning but fundamentally shallow five-hour experience.

But again, on the other side, a lot of players also found its modest length and refusal to overcomplicate itself a pleasant surprise in an industry that too often makes sequels bloated affairs bogged down with needlessly complex gameplay systems.

It's a game that's sure to inspire debate for the rest of the year and beyond, from those who consider it Game of the Year-caliber to others who deem it a colossal letdown.


1. Indika

Indika 2024
Odd Meter

And finally we have Indika - a fascinatingly bizarre third-person story-driven game in which players control the titular nun as she navigates a bleak existence in 19th century Russia.

One of the oddest games released this year so far - or in any year, really - Indika is a tough beast to quantify, lurching from walking simulator to puzzle game and back again while daring players to invest in its deeply surreal crisis-of-faith story.

Indeed, you've never played anything quite like Indika - a game which clearly relishes making fun of the medium's biggest tropes, even as it forces players to partake in intentionally tedious busy-work mini-games in-between the strangely alluring narrative.

For some, it's a peculiar meditation on faith wrapped inside a self-aware commentary on the state of modern gaming, while to others, Indika is a low-budget-to-a-fault indie that pads out its already brief play-time out with head-smackingly tedious puzzles.

What just about everyone can agree on, at least, is that it's one of the most singular gaming experiences out there.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.