10 Saddest Soulsborne Bosses

Prepare to cry.

dark souls gwyn lord of cinder
FromSoftware

FromSoftware have garnered quite the reputation over the past few years. Beginning with Demon Souls, (which is soon to get a remaster) each title afterwards has only increased in popularity and mainstream interest, due to their trademark style of firm but fair gameplay.

And with Elden Ring (Probably? Hopefully?) around the corner, it doesn't look like FromSoft has any intentions of abandoning their signature formula.

What makes this formula so great, besides the feeling of triumph after finally beating that one area on the 373rd attempt, is the skilful way the Soulsborne games manage to blend fear with sorrow.

The bosses are big, and scary, and well designed, but you could say that about Cuphead. For it to truly be a SoulsBorne boss, it needs a backstory so glum it'd make even the bleakest Tim Burton film look like Fall Guys by comparison.

From forgotten kings to lonely dogs, FromSoft loves to swipe at the heartstrings as they swipe at your health bar. So get those tissues ready and that stamina metre recharged, as we dive into the saddest denizens of Dark Souls and beyond.

Because the best bosses in SoulsBorne are the ones you feel sorry for. Even if you still end up smashing their faces in.

10. Headless Ape

Headless Ape Sekiro
FromSoftware

The first Guardian Ape fight is one of the hardest that Sekiro has to offer, and the game tricks you into a crushing second phase fight right after you think you've finally beaten it.

So players can be forgiven for hating Donkey Kong's evil sadist of a cousin by the time they finally put it down.

It's only afterwards, when FromSoft gives you the first little lore tidbit, that you begin to feel the slightest bit guilty.

Because the Guardian Ape wasn't there flinging poo and eating centipedes for the good of its own health. Sadly, the Ape can't die. It's being controlled against its will by the centipede inside it, and can only get more pathetic from here.

In contrast to the first fight, the Headless Ape fight takes place in a hole in the ground, where you find it banging its head (well, neck) against the wall in brainless frustration. Instead of being another challenging and terrifying encounter, killing it just feels like you're putting the thing out of its misery.

And unless Sekiro has the Mortal Blade, death is only temporary, leading to a humiliating and endless display that would alarm more than one animal rights groups.

From a once proud titan of the Ashina to a headless centipede puppet, this Giant Ape has it worse than King Kong.


9. Lothric, The Younger Prince And Lorian, The Elder Prince

Dark souls 3
FromSoftware

Dark Souls 3's premise is centered around taking down the Lords of Cinder: Titans and Gods who linked the flame in ages past, after facing more trials and tribulations than you ever did in trying to beat the Nameless King on your own for once.

So it's fair to say these guys have a bit of a reputation, and most of them live up to it.

Then, we meet the Twin Princes. Two teenagers, one bedbound, the other mute and hiding in a corner. Not exactly an astounding first impression.

The fight itself is over pretty quickly as well, a few well timed dodges here, a few big hits there, and suddenly there's a cutscene.

Turns out, the Princes don't want to link the fire. They've seen how futile it is, and want no part of it. They're even willing to give their own lives to defend each other, with Lothric giving up part of his health to resurrect Lorian, in a touching display of affection.

So just how many times are you willing to kill two teenage boys, one who gave up the use of his legs to save his brother, just so you can light a little bonfire?

What's that Nietzsche quote? About fighting so many monsters you become one? Yeah. Seems relevant here.


8. Genichiro, Way Of Tomoe

Sekiro Genichiro
FromSoftware

Before Sekiro was even released, we knew Genichiro was going to be bad news. As the man who cuts off your arm in single combat, as well as defending and running an entire region, there's no better set up for a powerful and unrepentant antagonist.

So when we encounter him again at the end of the game, it's hard not to feel a little bit sorry at seeing how far the mighty have fallen.

Because he uses the same moveset as all his previous fights, final form Genichiro is laughably easy. As someone who was once Sekrio's biggest threat, it's kind of heartbreaking to see how frail he's become to save Ashina.

You almost don't want to fight him. And when you beat him, (in what is likely record time) you just want to give him a hug.

What's that Genichiro? Yeah, it is sad how much you've lost. No, you're not any closer to winning. Why don't you just put the sword down now, ok? Wait, what's that coming out of your neck? No, Genichiro, mate, don't do this to yourself, it's not worth the effort.

Even his resurrected spiritual Grandad practically spits on his grave. Poor, poor guy.


7. Gehrman, The First Hunter

gehrman the first hunter bloodborne
From Software

Beating up a wheelchair bound old man just isn't right to begin with. Even if he does have a scythe that's three times bigger than your hopes of beating the game.

The saddest part about the Gehrman fight is that there's really no malice to it. Your goal is to save the first hunter from the horrible, endless dream, and his goal is to do the same for you. He's just trying to stop you from trapping yourself in the depressing fate that he's had to put up with for centuries.

If that's not enough, the atmosphere and music for this fight is nothing short of oppressively melancholy. Instead of the epic horror choir that's present for most of the other fights, Gehrman's theme is a quiet, somber violin, played against the backdrop of a peaceful cemetery that's littered with the gravestones of the old hunter's past students.

In fact, this is one of the only fights in the Soulsborne series where the winner is actually the loser, and it really says something about Gehrman's character that the happiest ending is the one where you choose to be executed by him.

Clearly spending an eternity with a creepy, talking sex doll wasn't all it cracked up to be.


6. Yhorm The Giant

DARK SOULS 3 Yhorm
FromSoftware

Like the Guardian Ape in Sekiro, Yhorm looks big and mean, but actually has a lot going on under the surface. He's like a swan. A really sad, really pitiful swan.

Yhorm, like most of the old Lords of Cinder, didn't want to link the flame in his world. And who would? By all accounts it's hard, hot and painful. Yet Yhorm did it anyway, to save his people from destruction.

Sounds kind of heartwarming, right? Well, this is a FromSoft game, so the answer is no. Turns out, Yhorm's people hated him, on account of him being a big, scary giant. He only ever had one friend, and this loneliness eventually drove him mad, which is why he isn't in a talking mood when you meet him.

Even sadder, that one friend is Siegward, who can help you in the fight against Yhorm. So instead of a noble knight taking down the evil giant, what you're actually doing is helping one best friend kill another, because he can't bear to watch him suffer any longer.

Oh, and by the way, Yhorm's original boss title was "Yhorm the Lonely Ruler." Just in case the point hadn't been hammered home quite hard enough.


5. King Vendrick

Dark souls 2 vendrick
FromSoftware

From the very tutorial of Dark Souls 2, King Vendrick's name is mentioned. In fact, throughout most of the game, the man's hinted to be the final boss, much like Gwyn was in the original.

So when we finally meet Vendrick, about three quarters of the way through Dark Souls 2, as a shambling, shuffling zombie dragging himself around a prison cell, you could be forgiven for not even recognising the ruler from all the stories you've been told.

The forgotten King is so sad and pathetic, in fact, that he's not even compulsory. The player can completely ignore him, as if the man who kickstarted the entire storyline just isn't worth the time of day.

If you do choose to attack him, the fight isn't that impressive. He has a few damaging attacks, but no visually amazing displays or uber powerful one shot hits. The fight's theme is muted and pitiful, much like the King himself, and it's unlikely he'll take more than one try to defeat.

He's not worth the effort, honestly. It could even be said that defeating him is a "Hollow" victory. Get it? Hollow? Okay, let's move on.


4. Laurence, The First Vicar

Bloodborne Laurence
From Software

Even before turning into a giant, flaming werewolf, Laurence was not exactly the happiest of people. And then he turned into a GIANT FLAMING WEREWOLF.

While this bossfight is spectacularly hard, and one of the greatest challenges that Bloodborne has to offer, you wouldn't know that from the way this boss conducts himself.

Even at full health, Laurence is very obviously in great pain, moving and swaying like a drunken minister at the pulpit, as the flames take over his massive, hairy body.

Usually, in FromSoft bossfights, the succeeding phases of each boss show it getting stronger, and tougher, as each stage of the fight increases in difficulty. Not so for Laurence, who begins each new phase by disintegrating more and more.

This culminates in the final phase, in which you're only fighting the upper torso of Laurence, the rest of him having been burnt to cinders.

Watching him drag himself around on his one remaining arm, as he screams with violent incoherence, sort of makes you want to forgive for the last 20 times he one-shotted you with that stupid AoE attack. Sort of.

What it definitely does, is make you wish you never woke this poor guy up in the first place.


3. Gwyn, Lord Of Cinder

dark souls gwyn lord of cinder
FromSoftware

If entering the Kiln of the First Flame - a barren, ashy wasteland filled with lost ghosts - wasn't enough of an indication that Gwyn maaaaaay let himself go a wee bit, then watching him shamble forwards as you parry him into oblivion will definitely disabuse any remaining delusions of grandeur.

Even from Dark Soul's first and only major cutscene, Gwyn is presented as a mythical figure, hurling lightning bolts like Zeus and taking down Dragons like he's in Game of Thrones.

So you'd be forgiven in thinking that King Gwyn, Lord of absolutely everything would be a grand and radiant final boss fight.

What you get is a half dead, decrepit old geezer who, let's be honest, isn't really that tough.

After learning how much Gwyn sacrificed, how much he gave up to continue his age, and ultimately, how badly he failed, this fight is nothing short of Shakespearean in how tragic it is.

Combine that with the now iconic and understated piano theme, and you've got one of the most depressing fights in Dark Souls history. Most other franchises would celebrate players conquering the final boss. FromSoft all but accuses you of regicide.

Still, gotta get that sweet, sweet, morally dubious ending.


2. Maiden Astraea

Demons Souls
FromSoftware

The Maiden Astraea bossfight is as unimpressive as her name is unpronounceable.

Having said that, it's also one of the biggest gut punches in the entire franchise.

This is partly due to the fact that you're just straight up killing an unarmed woman. She doesn't transform into a huge demon, she doesn't hurl any stupidly powerful spells that somehow clip through solid walls, she just... sits there. Christ, this was meant to be Soulsborne, not GTA.

And then, just to really cement yourself in the annals of sinful douchebaggery, you end up stealing her soul as well.

While Demon's Souls is all about collecting the souls of, well, demons, Maiden Astraea is far from evil, after accepting the soul of a demon only to help the sick and dying. Y'know, standard nun stuff.

Exactly how and why having a demon's soul helps the sick and dying in any way is a little bit of a mystery, but ah well.

And if massacring this poor woman's innocent bodyguard and extracting the soul from her corpse isn't bad enough, we'll all get to go through it again in the remaster. Hurrah!


1. Great Wolf Sif

Dark Souls Sif
Bandai Namco Entertainment

This is a boss fight where you slaughter a lonely dog that refuses to leave the grave of its master. That's really all that needs saying about this one.

The idea of killing dogs is something that doesn't exactly sit well with most people to begin with, but in this case, it's an honourable, sword wielding dog that belongs to one of the most popular characters in the franchise. It's therefore understandable that some players get a little bit upset at this part.

It's also probably the only fight in the franchise that you don't mind dying to.

What? He killed me again? Good job buddy! Oh, Who's a good boy?

Eventually though, the inevitable must occur, and in the immortal words of Watchmen's crazy vigilante: "Dogs get put down." And so it is with this fight.

Every hit feels like a personal ticket straight to hell, and is THE definition of "this is going to hurt me more than it's going to hurt you." And just to twist the knife in that little bit more, Sif's final phase is that he limps. He LIMPS.

Hope that ring of Artorias is worth it, you dick.


Watch Next


The IMPOSSIBLE Dark Souls Quiz: How Far Will You Get?

Dark Souls Boss
FromSoftware

1. Easy: In The First Dark Souls Game What Is The Name Of The First Boss?

In this post: 
Dark Souls
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Currently attempting to convert the desire to play video games into the desire to work.