10 Scariest Water Levels In Video Games
*plays Sonic drowning music*
Having a fear of water, especially deep water, open water, or water where you can’t see the bottom, is super common. As a result, it’s not surprising that plenty of game devs have decided to exploit that and design some truly terrifying water levels.
Whether there’s something else in there with you, the fear of drowning, or the fact that your movement is massively slowed, being under the surface might not be your idea of a fun time. These games absolutely nailed it on the water fear factor. And should probably be avoided if you’ve got Aquaphobia or Thalassophobia or Megalohydrothalassophobia.
That’s the fear of large things underwater and not a word I had to subject myself to reading out loud while writing this list but we got through it together.
In today’s list we’re covering everything from the water-dwelling monsters that scared you in high definition, to the traumatising water levels that made you pray for no more water levels when you encountered them as a kid.
10. Aqua Ring - Resident Evil HD
Kicking off the list on a pure survival horror foot, we’re talking Resident Evil for the GameCube, and I’m betting if you’ve played the game you know where I’m going with this.
Welcome to the Aqua Ring, keep your gun out of the water, do not stop moving, and I hope you aren’t afraid of sharks. You venture into the secret locale after uncovering it beneath the mansion’s guardhouse.
It’s flooded which isn’t great, there are huge ass sharks swimming around which is really not great, and they’re T-virus augmented which is the three for three we were not looking for. Initially, the arena is eerily quiet except for the splashing of waist high water but that’ll be broken pretty quickly by your own frantic cursing.
It’s hard to not feel a little like a Jill sandwich in this level as there’s very little space for you to move so the sharks inevitably make lunch meat out of you once or twice.
This is already bad enough, but don’t worry, there’s an even bigger shark you need to take care of before you can escape this nasty nightmare zone. At least there’s an absolutely horrifying orchestra crescendo that escalates to let you know you’re about to be fish food.
You do get to electrocute the big boy assuming you finish the level’s puzzle in time, just don’t let him take you out in one bite first.
9. The Hydrus - Shadow Of The Colossus
Shadow of the Colossus has plenty of incredible beasts and though it can be haunting, it’s certainly not a horror game. That’s not to say there isn’t a certain colossi that won’t absolutely freak you out if you’re not a fan of water.
Your encounter with the seventh colossi, Hydrus, doesn’t kick off until you sum up the courage to throw yourself into an enormous and seemingly bottomless body of water. The game has already made you keenly across the sensation of feeling very small within wide open areas and against gargantuan foes, but sticking you in the water where you’re far slower against a foe that’s pretty damn cosy there, is a whole other matter.
The eel-like Hydrus also comes complete with electrified protrusions on his back that will do you some nasty damage if you get too close.
In order to take this thing out you’ll have to chase it, climb aboard, and try not to drown as it drags you deep underwater and you’re forced to watch Wander struggle for breath and try to make it back to the surface. You also never have a concept of just how deep the water goes and occasionally you’ll lose your enormous target, but you know it’s in the water with you, which is significantly uncool.
Some of the colossi after this one are definitely more difficult, but at least you’ll be glad to have your feet on dry land.
8. Water Dam - Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1989)
If you only know one thing about Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles for NES it’s probably that the game is hard. Another entry on this list that is definitely not a horror game, but the Water Dam level will have you feeling like it is.
There’s a good chance I’m unlocking a stress memory here so bear with me through this one. The Water Dam level is absolutely notorious for being unbelievably difficult, made all the worse by a flashing time limit indication ticking down, your steadily depleting health, and a tonne of hazards. Not to mention a soundtrack that is easily going to boost your heart rate a few dozen beats a minute.
There’s nothing going bump in the night in this level but the trauma it caused thousands of kids in the 90s absolutely earns it a place on our list.
It takes a special type of game to exhibit this much mental torture via pixels but Konami weren’t messing around. So much so that one player wrote of the level, “I hope whoever designed this level is in hell.” There was absolutely no shame in passing the controller to your older sibling for this one.
7: The Vortex Queen - Ecco The Dolphin
Ecco The Dolphin seems to be a sweet 16 bit game where you get to play as a dolphin, and yet the nightmares the series has given kids everywhere would strongly suggest otherwise.
The entire Ecco franchise has scary bits. If getting chased by polygons underwater gives you the creeps you may want to stay away from Defender of the Future and its eel, shark, and crocodile encounters. We have to give the spooky cake to The Vortex Queen, though.
What person thought this was a chill-looking boss to bookend a dolphin-y adventure with, I cannot imagine. This thing is pure, toothy nightmare fuel that you find yourself wildly unprepared for. Not to mention the fight itself is far from a walk in the park.
Suffice it to say, plenty of parents who thought they were gifting their kids a cute dolphin game probably regretted their choices after this one.
6: Sewers Of The Imperial City - Star Wars: Shadows Of The Empire
Unlike the ocean, space doesn’t exactly go hand in hand with scary water levels but leave it to Star Wars to shove you in a creepy-ass sewer and traumatise kids for life. I guess it does have something in common with Ecco in that respect.
Star Wars: Shadows of the Empire came out for the Nintendo 64 in 1996. The third person shooter offered up some excellent levels replete with space opera action, and one that left any child that dared play it in the 90s with a lifelong fear of water.
You practically can’t see anything, you can barely move in the water, you need to not drown, and you’re being attacked by a massive diagona, the tentacle monster from the trash compactor in A New Hope.
If that sounds too breezy, later on you’ll drop down into a room full of water only to be surrounded by tentacles and ear-splitting screeching.
The arena is marked by some pretty damn small platforms you’ll be jumping between using your jetpack. Calculate wrong and you’re in the murky water facing off against the growling beast in the depths.
5: Labyrinth Zone - Sonic The Hedgehog (1991)
Sonic’s gotta go fast, but in the water Sonic is very, very slow. Coupled with what well might be the most horrifying death track in video games, Labyrinth Zone will absolutely fry your nerves.
What makes this particular water level so scary is the persistent fear of drowning. Sonic needs to make his way between sparsely located air pockets to survive and there’s very little margin for error as you move between them. Step a foot wrong and there’s a good chance you’ll be listening to this horribly unsettling underscore to our favourite blue hedgehog meeting a watery grave.
On top of that, the water keeps rising, so you have no choice but to go as fast as your little waterlogged sneakers will take you.
The dread you get from the constant stress of where your next breath is going to come from coupled with the nature of the timed mission is just awful. No big toothy monsters required.
4: 40 Fathoms - Tomb Raider II
Not that big toothy monsters don’t absolutely have their place. If you want to be worried about running out of air and concerned about getting gnawed to bits by a shark, Tomb Raider II has just the level for you.
We’re getting into a lot of old school low-poly scares in this list, but sometimes the classics are classic for a reason, and you can’t understate the games that established lifelong water level trauma. In the seventh level of Tomb Raider II, Lara enters the wreck of the Maria Doria. And, yeah, there are sharks aplenty before you even get in there. Perhaps the most horrifying thing about these bad boys is how wide their jaws open when they’re all set to bite themselves off a piece of Lara’s ample polygonal chest.
You’re in a hugely unfamiliar place, running out of air, listening to a pounding heartbeat, and praying you’re swimming the right way.
There’s a chilling silence to the entire level and the amount of tension is enough to make you stop playing, really, despite Lara’s fetching wetsuit.
3. Jolly Roger Bay - Super Mario 64
This one’s for your childhood, as Super Mario 64’s underwater beastie Unagi absolutely terrified kids who came across it. Particularly those who weren’t used to being jump-scared in 3D.
Approach what appears to be a 2D face in a wall and boom you’ve got a toothy eel coming right at your little plumber pal. Would this scare the crap out of you now?
Well, probably not. But in the context of the time and the age most people encountered it, this was not what you would have been expecting to encounter in a kid’s game. On top of that, the only way to get in his hidey hole is to lure him out and potentially get chomped on. Any contact with the eel and Mario jumps back, reeling.
Seeing Mario’s gurgling as he suffocates and drowns while grabbing at his face, then watching his corpse begin to drift to the surface is also completely traumatizing.
2. Mermaid - Inside
I really loved Inside, but when I saw this chick I said “Nope, this sucks” and almost had to put the game down. Playdead’s puzzle platformer is supposed to be bleak but this chick is next level freaky.
You encounter the long-haired creature (Siren or Mermaid, if you prefer) a few different times in the game. Each progressively more unnerving and threatening than the last. Her appearance is very pale, she wears no clothing, and has long black hair.
Your young protagonist is completely vulnerable the entire game, and you’ll often be outrunning this girl (or rather, out-swimming her), trying not to get grabbed, or hastily manoeuvring yourself to shine a light on her to stop her relentless pursuit of you.
The mermaid is insanely fast and you are crazy slow, adding to the absolute terror of being stuck in the water with her.
During your final encounter with her she actually does get a hold of you and drags you down into the depths. And that’s pretty much exactly as uncool as it sounds.
1. Every Kaernk Level - Amnesia: The Dark Descent
Yeah, you probably saw this one coming. I’m almost definitely butchering the pronunciation of the word Kaernk but if you’ve played Amnesia I’m betting he’s butchered you at least once so let’s say he had it coming.
Otherwise known as the invisible water monster, this guy is discernible only from its growling, and fierce splashing footsteps. Proving you don’t need to see something scary to get a chill up your spine, the flooded cellar levels where you’re running away from an invisible growling beast lunging at you are arguably the most unplayably frightening in all of Amnesia.
And that’s saying something in a game infamous for its ability to shove you into the shoes of a vulnerable protagonist clinging onto his sanity in a literal house of horrors. Well, castle of horrors, but you get it.
Its guttural snarls are absolutely terrifying and there is something so entirely fear-inducing about hearing splashing footsteps grow closer behind you as you rush to jump on a nearby crate in the world’s scariest game of ‘the floor is made of lava’.