10 Scrapped Video Game Boss Battles That Would've Been Incredible
The planned Doc Ock fight was WAY better.
"For of all sad words of tongue or pen, the saddest are these: 'It might have been!"
The above statement comes from Maud Madder, a 19th century poem by John Greenleaf Whittier. I mention it because:
a) It's a fitting sentiment for the subject of this article, and
b) It's a rare chance to get some practical use out of an English Literature degree.
This list will take a look at some of the best boss battle that gamers never got to experience. As well as fights that were cancelled outright, this list will also include climactic clashes whose best ideas never made it to the finished product.
After all, who wouldn't want to fight a horse that turns into a castle? Or fight an iconic comic book bad guy across the entirety of New York?
So let's pass through the fog door of history and take a look at what might have been.
10. The Hydra - Half-Life 2
To start things off, we have one of gaming's most infamous disappearing acts - Half-Life 2's Hydra.
The Hydra made a memorable appearance during Half-Life 2's showcase at E3 2002, impaling a hapless goon and dragging him to the watery depths before the player's eyes. Evoking memories of the original Half-Life's legendary Blast Pit Tentacle (now there's a band name if ever we've heard one), gamers everywhere were anticipating a similarly tense encounter against this aqeuous adversary.
Unfortunately, it was not to be. Valve soon realised that while the Hydra was great to look at, it was a monumental pain in the rear-end to actually fight. As detailed in Half-Life 2: Raising the Bar, the Hydra was a massive let-down once the player got down to actually fighting it. The book described the boss as an unsatisfying blob monster whose tentacles killed players before they even realised what was happening, and the decision was made to cut it from the game.
A Hydra that was as satisfying to fight as it was incredible to look at would have been amazing, but Half-Life 2 turned out fairly well regardless.
(Fun fact: Half-Life 2 will be old enough to drink this year. We'll let that sink in before moving on to the next entry...)
9. Undead King Jar-Eel - Dark Souls
Ah, Dark Souls. The game that spawned a genre and ensured any game with even the slightest level of difficulty would be labeled "the Dark Souls of platformers/shooters/horticulture maintenance simulators".
Dark Souls earned its notoriety through its meticulously malevolent dungeons (looking at you, Sen's Fortress) and some bastard-hard boss fights. The likes of Manus, Sif and Ornstein & Smough have battered many a gamer in the decade since Dark Souls' release, but if all had gone to plan there would have had one more adamantine roadblock to bar players' progress - Undead King Jar-Eel.
Given Dark Souls' infamously opaque nature, it's fitting that Jar-Eel himself is shrouded in mystery. There's enough of his code left in the game files to mod him back into the game, but beyond that it's anyone's guess how he would have fit into Dark Souls - both in story and practical terms.
One thing's for sure though - given how difficult Kings tend to be in Soulsborne games (Old King Allant, the Nameless King, the absolutely sodding Burnt Ivory King) there's every chance that Jar-Eel would have been another royal pain in the rear had he survived the editing process.
8. Great One Beast - Bloodborne
From one Soulsborne to another, we arrive at the game that provided the latter half of the portmanteau - Bloodborne, a razor-sharp nightmare of a game that lurches from Hammer Horror thrills to Lovecraftian menace at the drop of a tentacle.
No other enemy type illustrated Bloodbornes all-encompassing approach to horror better than its Beasts - werewolf-esque enemies that had gone through enough body horror to make David Cronenberg blanch.
From the permanently aflame Watchdog to the skinned & mutilated Blood-starved Beast, each was as tragic as it was monstrous, and putting them down felt more like an act of mercy than vengeance. (Although it was hard not to feel vengeful when you were being repeatedly slaughtered by them).
Each Beast battle felt like a highlight in a game already full of them, and we could have had one more had the Great One Beast made the cut. Given that Bloodborne already has more than a dozen Beasts to slay, you can see why the developers felt one more would be overkill.
Then again, you can never have to much of a good thing, and we'd have much rather faced down the Great One Beast than banged our heads against the spell-spamming Micolash.
(To anyone who now shudders at the words "A Call Beyond", I feel your pain).
7. Centaur & King Xemnas - Kingdom Hearts II
Kingdom Hearts II's climactic battle against Xemnas was already epic in its own right, but according to the official concept art it could have been even more jaw-dropping.
Apparently at one stage, the plan was for Xemnas to transform into what was essentially a living castle, adorned with a multi-storey crown on its head, and then metamorph into a ludicrously large mecha centaur.
To which all I can say is "Woah!"
As well done as the actual fight against Xemnas was, these concepts are so staggeringly ambitious that I can't help wishing Square Enix had pulled them off.
From the very first battle against Darkside in the opening minutes of Kingdom Hearts I, the franchise has had its share of colossal bosses. Hell, the recent Kingdom Hearts IV trailer centred around Sora taking on yet another skyscraper-sized monster. But if Square Enix had managed to bring Centaur & King Xemnas to digital life, it's safe to say they would have dwarfed the competition.
6. The Harpy Boss - God Of War (2005)
The very first God of War was a milestone in the PS2's lifecycle - a ferocious, hyper-violent action-adventure that breathed new life into the console and started another flagship franchise for the Playstation.
But it wasn't perfect. One of the game's most common criticisms was that, after kicking off with a spectacular battle against a Hydra (not the Half-Life 2 one), there was an almost complete lack of boss fights until the final clash against Ares.
Had things gone to plan, though, there would have been at least one more boss fight in the game, and it sounds like it would have been a doozy.
Skip to the four-minute mark in the above video and you'll hear GoW creator David Jaffe talking about the game's abandoned Harpy boss fight. A puzzle-boss fight that would have involved Kratos using the Harpy's slaughtered young as bait, the fight would have taken place over a large arena and provided more evidence that you were not playing as the hero in this story.
Given how well GoW's trifecta of boss fights (Hydra, Minotaur, Ares) were executed, it's safe to say that the Harpy would have provided one more memory for PS2 gamers to savour. (Not that they're lacking in that regard).
5. Meta Kraid - Metroid Prime
As great as Metroid Dread was, one of the best things about it was seeing Kraid finally returning to the Metroid franchise after a twenty-seven year absence. (No, appearing in the background of a Smash Bros stage doesn't count).
However, if things had gone to plan during Metroid Prime's development we could have fought everyone's favourite morbidly obese reptile all the way back in 2003.
Originally planned as a boss fight for the GameCube classic, Kraid was cut due to time constraints. Jack Mathews, Metroid Prime's tech leader, would reveal that Kraid made it to the prototype stage but the planned fight was unfeasibly large for the time limit the developers were working under.
The battle would have involved multiple stages, moving platforms, and finding a way to remove the retro sci-fi helmet adorning Kraid's skull to reveal his weak spot for massive damage. (Oof, showing our age with that reference...)
Given that Kraid's partner in crime Meta-Ridley got not one but two epic boss fights in the Metroid Prime series, it's a shame it took so long for Nintendo to bring the fan-favourite dino-beast back to our screens. But as anyone who's played Metroid: Dread will tell you, it was worth the wait.
4. Gojira - Fallout: New Vegas
Three things I learned when researching this article:
#1: Gojira are a French heavy metal band who've been rocking since 1996.
#2 : Gojira is the Japanese pronunciation of the original, 1954 Godzilla movie.
#3: Gojira was an absurdly overpowered mutant gecko from Fallout New Vegas who never made it to the final release.
As the above video shows, Gojira is somewhat unique from the other entrants in this list in that it was never intended to be in the game at all. It was created by animator Seth McCaughey for his own amusement, who enjoyed watching his creation lay waste to New Vegas' hapless NPCs.
It's a shame that no-one on the development team ran with the concept. A kitschy, Godzilla-spoofing questline would have fit right in with Fallout's "50's sci-fi gone amok" theme, and would have provided a great end-game challenge for completionists.
3. Mecha - Alice: Madness Returns
Normally, when a developer removes content from a game you can't really tell anything is missing. You could play all of Half-Life 2 and never realize the Hydra was meant to be a significant part of the game, and Kingdom Hearts II's Xemnas still felt like a complete boss battle even without transforming into a giant horse.
That's not the case here. Here, the editing department's trimming scissors left some embarassingly ragged edges on display.
Alice: Madness Returns' Mecha was so obviously meant to be a proper boss. It arrives at the climax of the first world, is piloted by two of the game's primary antagonists, and is standing in the middle of an arena ready and raring to go.
Then a giant teapot falls from the sky and kills it dead.
Game desginer Amercian McGee would later admit that the perennial game development bugbear of time constraints prevented Mecha being a proper boss battle. This is particularly infuriating, as Madness Returns was torn apart by reviewers at the time for its excessive length and repetitive level design.
It was a classic case of a developer putting effort in all the wrong places, and it was boss fight lovers who suffered for the game's lack of direction.
2. Doctor Octopus - Marvel's Spider-Man
Much like Spider-Man himself, developers Insomniac faced a difficult choice at the end of their journey. (If you've played the game you'll know what we're talking about).
In 2021 Ted Price, Insomniac's CEO, said that the fight against Doctor Octopus was meant to be a cinematically spectacular, knock-down brawl that would have covered all of New York City.
And while that certainly sounds better than what we ended up getting (a weirdly forgettable final brawl that paled in comparison to the spectacular opening fight against the Kingpin), Insomniac had a good reason for restraining their ambitions - crunch.
Ted Price stated that for the fight had gone ahead as planned, Insomniac would have had to force their developers to endure a hellish crunch session. They definitely made the right call in choosing a watered-down boss fight over their employees wellbeing, but we can't help but wonder about how stunning that original fight could have been.
With that being said, here's our advice to Insomniac for the upcoming sequel: Spend more time on the boss fights, and absolutely no time on making tedious stealth sections. That way, everyone wins.
1. Illusive Man - Mass Effect 3
Mass Effect 3's ending has long gone down in history as one of the most frustratingly anti-climactic in all of gaming, and one common complaint is the lack of a final boss battle. (Indeed, the final enemy you face is a bog-standard Marauder with a shield gauge, leading to the ME fandom jokingly declaring "Marauder Shields" as the final boss of the Mass Effect universe).
What's frustrating is they were so close to a fan-pleasing battle, but no-one on the development team realised it.
A little background - Mass Effect 2 had a terrific villain in Harbinger, a baritone-voiced Reaper (ME's primary antagonists) who could take over his minions at will by uttering the instantly memetic line "I am assuming direct control". So when concept art of the Illusive Man - Mass Effect's shadowy human villain - being controlled by a Reaper appeared, we were left wondering...
Why did nobody think to have Harbinger "assume direct control" over the Illusive Man?
Instead, the Illusive Man is taken down in a battle of words, putting a gun to his own head when the protagonist makes him realise the futility of his actions. And while that was fitting in its way, you can't tell us the fans wouldn't have rejoiced had the Illusive Man got back up while Harbinger declared "I am assuming direct control" one last time.
Oh well. In the words of John Greenleaf Whittier, "It might have been!"