10 Sequel-Proof Video Game Endings (That Got Sequels Anyway)

You thought that was the end? You fools!

Yakuza 6
Sega

A really good ending is defined by a few things, but one of the key factors is that a truly great ending doesn't have a follow-up. After all, it's an ending, the wrap-up of the entire narrative, the final ride off into the sunset. Adding more onto that would, by its very nature, ruin it - even if that new stuff is really good.

However, sometimes you get a new idea for a follow-up, or a project initially intended as a done-in-one is more successful than you anticipated, or even the story has turned into a money train that your bosses ain't gonna let stop unless they have a proverbial (and possibly literal) gun to their heads. Whatever the case, the end turns out to not be the end. This can prove embarrassing when you wrote an ending with the intent of never doing a sequel.

Some game endings are so brilliant, so final, that a sequel feels impossible to pull off. For better, and indeed for worse, these games ended on the most final note imaginable, and then just kinda kept going.

10. BioShock 2

bioshock 2
2K Games

There are many ways you can go about definitively ending a story. One of the most surefire ways is to utterly destroy the setting of the story. How much more perfect can you get, right? Can't have a story when the story has nowhere to happen. So when 2K Games demanded a sequel to BioShock, the devs decided that this would be the end, and went about it accordingly.

BioShock 2 feels needless at every step of the journey. Despite the gameplay being, in many ways, far superior to its more famous sibling, nothing about it screams that this is a sequel that needed to happen. This is probably why BioShock 2 ends with the city of Rapture being abandoned for good.

Sure, it's still technically down there, but the falls of Andrew Ryan, Frank Fontaine, and then Sofia Lamb leave the city with little to no infrastructure. The destruction of Hephaestus means very little of Rapture still has electricity, and pretty much every city official has been murdered. So yeah, safe to say Rapture ain't bouncing back. In fact, this entry is at the bottom because, technically, it didn't.

Oh sure, there was another sequel, but BioShock Infinite is more along the lines of a soft reboot, until over halfway through the game and into the DLC when it explicitly references Rapture.


9. Sly 3: Honor Among Thieves

Sly 3 Honor Among Thieves
Sucker Punch

Everything is brought full circle in Sly 3, including the ultimate act of "no, really, this is the end" for any narrative.

The Cooper Vault, the prize at the end of the third game, acts as the ultimate representation of the arrogance of the Cooper family, a line that began with noble intentions but fell to the egotism of its legacy. This giant vault is filled with the gold and jewels the Cooper family has stolen from other criminals over the years, and then hoarded away themselves. For whose benefit, asks Sly 3's finale, does the Cooper Vault exist? A bunch of dead guys we've never met? Is that really what all of this was for?

The story ends with Sly sharing the wealth with the people who actually helped him throughout his journey, and then leaving the criminal life behind via fake amnesia so he can spend his life with the woman he loves.

Sly 3 is this low on the list because Sucker Punch left it just open enough an ending so that another studio could take the series and run with it, but tied up all loose ends just in case that didn't end up happening.

Sanzaru Games would take them up on that with the release of Sly 4, and the less said about that trainwreck, the better...


8. Halo 3

Halo 3 Prophet of Truth Death
Bungie

Halo 3 wrapped up the story of Halo about as well as it could have. It's hard to get a more complete ending than "most of the main cast are dead and all the villains have been killed."

The Halo series was neatly wrapped up at the end of Halo 3, with Master Chief taking out the remaining leadership of the Covenant and then blasting the eldritch abomination known as the Flood to Hell, seemingly dying in the process. The Covenant War comes to a close with the humans and the Sangheili forming a truce; the only hint of stories to come being the Arbiter remaining unconvinced that John 117 is actually dead.

We would then get confirmation on that with the next Halo trilogy by 343 Studios. The new trilogy has proven... divisive, to say the least, especially the latest game, Halo Infinite, which goes all in on the infamous Live Service model. But the series still maintains a dedicated fanbase all these years later, speaking to the strength of those original games, and how well the ending of Halo 3 stuck in our collective memory.


7. Uncharted 4

Uncharted 4
Naughty Dog

This and one other entry do admittedly skirt the line between sequel and spinoff, but the way your writer personally sees it, that line isn't as set as people think. So long as the spinoff takes place after the game in question, and is considered canon, there's no reason it cannot be both.

Uncharted 4 was Naughty Dog closing the curtain on a franchise that had defined their creative direction long before even The Last of Us. Bringing an end to the story of Nathan Drake as he goes on one last adventure, the story even ends on a time skip, as Nathan and Elena's daughter discovers her parents' past to play us out. A genuinely perfect ending to a franchise that wasn't always the best when it came to heartfelt character writing.

And then The Lost Legacy came out.

Granted, this sequel doesn't ruin what came before, instead shifting focus to Chloe and former villain Nadine going on their own adventure. But it is funny that Naughty Dog just had to get one last, albeit much shorter, Uncharted game out of their system before moving on.


6. Jak 3

Jak 3
Naughty Dog

Well hello again, Naughty Dog.

The Jak trilogy holds a special place in the hearts of an entire generation of PlayStation nerds, your scribe very much included. However, calling it a "trilogy" is a bit of a white lie, because there were two sequels after Jak 3 wrapped everything up.

Jak 3 tied up almost every loose end, while leaving the occasional mystery or detail that doesn't make sense for another studio to run with. After that, in true PlayStation mascot fashion, they rounded out the franchise with a sick-ass kart racer, then a PSP spinoff after that, and then let the franchise fall by the wayside for another studio to pick up.

After Jak X, there were two more games. One is the underrated PSP gem, Daxter, which doesn't count, as it takes place during Jak 2. The other is Jak and Daxter: The Lost Frontier, the final nail in the coffin for the franchise. Once intended as a PSP game like Daxter, Lost Frontier was pushed out onto the PS2 at the end of its lifespan with all the pomp and circumstance of... well, of a developer who knew they'd made a turkey,

Lost Frontier just flat out didn't work, and was received accordingly, thus ending the Jak and Daxter franchise once and for all. Well, at least until someone lets Tom Holland out of their sight again.


5. Final Fantasy X

Ffx yuna and tidus
Square Enix

Because every entry in Final Fantasy is different each time, every story gets to end as definitively as they want. And FFX has one of the most complete endings in the franchise.

There's seemingly nowhere else to go after the end of Final Fantasy X. Spira's religion and government have irreparably collapsed, their god and devil figures are dead, and just to top things off, the main character very thoroughly dies to close us out. The premise that the story starts out with is not only upended, it is burnt to the ground, unable to ever go back.

Well, that was the case, but then FFX became one of the biggest things in the entire PlayStation 2 library, and one of the highest-selling RPGs of all time. So yeah, a sequel was ordered from on high.

Naturally, FFX-2 carries the only tone possible after an ending like that: "Now what?"

FFX-2's story is far from perfect, but following up an ending like X's is a herculean task, and it's a miracle X-2 wasn't just a complete disaster from minute one.


4. Red Dead Redemption

Red Dead Redemption
Rockstar

An ending so final, the sequel it got isn't even really a sequel.

Red Dead Redemption has one of the tightest, most well-told storylines in gaming history. You really didn't need a sequel, at least not one that continued following the Marston family, because everything that needed to be said for the story to work was said.

The tale of John Marston hunting his old running buddies on behalf of the US Government contained all the details needed for that story to be satisfying. Knowing more would've been nice, sure, but you didn't really need it. However, more details would indeed come eight years later with the release of Red Dead Redemption 2.

Red Dead Redemption told the story of a gang that had fallen apart years ago, while RDR 2 is about the long, agonizing process of that fallout. What could've been simply a playable wiki entry, just filling in gaps of info with no story to tie it together, turned into one of the most heartfelt storylines in gaming history.

Red Dead Redemption did not need a sequel, but thank god we got one anyway.


3. God Of War 2005

God Of War 2005
SCE Santa Monica

There's a reason there's only, like, one game on this list with a 2 at the end of it, because when it comes to wrapping everything up in a way where continuing on seems impossible, folks like to do that on either the third entry or the first one. Not hard to see why, as with new ideas, you have to take into account that it may not work and you may never get a sequel, so it's best to end your story accordingly.

SCE Santa Monica didn't think they'd get a sequel out of the original God of War. Even the folks who knew it would be a success, after all, could never imagine the heights of popularity the series would reach.

So at the end of the game, after getting his revenge on the god Ares, but being denied peace of mind by the gods of Olympus, Kratos throws himself off a cliff to end it all. Only to instead be rescued by Athena, who gifts him with the empty throne of the God of War. About as perfect an ending could be for this game, and if it all had been left here, then it would've been on a high note.

However, we all know that that isn't what happened. God of War turned into a bigger success than anyone could have expected, and Sony made sure to wring the IP for all its worth.


2. Yakuza

Yakuza PS2 Kiryu
Sega

Toshihiro Nagoshi genuinely did not think he would get to make another Yakuza game. Hell, he didn't even think he'd have a job after it came out, having told Sega that if this new idea he pitched that made them so nervous didn't work, they could fire him on the spot. As such, he made the original Yakuza as definitive as possible, including an ending that leaves little to no room for sequels.

The end of the original Yakuza doesn't just end, it salts the damn earth. All but four central characters are dead, all of the villains have been killed, the Tojo clan has been thrown into absolute chaos - with only a glint of hope that it can bounce back thanks to its new leadership - and Kazuma Kiryu leaves the Yakuza forever to raise his newly adopted daughter. Perfect ending to a flawed but brilliant game.

And then Yakuza sold like hotcakes across Japan, and Sega demanded another game by the next year.

Considering that set-up, it was a miracle that Yakuza 2 was not only great but a superior sequel to the original in pretty much every way. The Yakuza series is now one of Sega's mainline titles, in spite of Nagoshi's every attempt to end it back in 2005.


1. Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect 3 Shepard
BioWare

Like it or not, you cannot deny that BioWare left nothing behind when they brought Mass Effect to a close.

From the original game, we had been building up the eventual incursion by the Reapers, a race of godlike squid machines who make it their mission to "reboot" the universe every couple of millennia. They do this by laying tantalizing traces of advanced tech, like the eponymous mass effect generators and the Citadel, across the galaxy for people to discover and inevitably use. They then use the generators to enter the milky way and wipe out everything they find.

Mass Effect 3 was when the sword of Damocles was finally dropped right on top of Earth. In Shepard's quest to retake Earth and finally end the Reapers, every loose end in the series is tied up, culminating in the multiple-choice ending of the series all sharing the commonality of things being changed forever.

No matter how many companions and civilizations make it out of the battle for Earth alive, the ending of Mass Effect 3 seems about as complete and final as possible. To the point where, for the longest time, the only sequel we got, Mass Effect Andromeda, saw starting over completely as the only way forward.

But lo and behold, we are indeed getting a proper Mass Effect 4. Sometime. Eventually. Any day now, we're sure.


Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?