10 Shocking Ways Gamers Have Been Lied To
Often times in the desire to garner interest in a project, the people charged with the task will say things that are not true to the point that it makes the people behind the scenes commit a facepalm in unison. Oh why did he say that? Well, the extra million users who hit our website! This happens with varying frequency, but enough to be considered par for the course. While on its surface it might seem like a devious misdeed on the part of game developers, often times it speaks more to the idea that the right hand doesnt know what the left hand is doing. So, its important to remain objective when we consider these instances. The real issue is the term shocking, why are these particular examples of possibly deliberate dishonesty noteworthy? Well, lets look at our list of ten instances and decide. While we do have 10 examples, these will be broken up into smaller categories...
Massive Multiplayer Online Games (MMOs)
10. Free To Play
I could probably write an entirely different article about the obscene amount of BS involved in MMOs and how they treat their dedicated customers, but lets touch on a few of the more glaring issues. The idea of Free to Play on MMOs should definitely come with an asterisk, which would at the very least lead to the word kinda in fine print. Its a lie because the game that was intended for the players to play is often times nothing like the game that is free to play. As a free player the players ability to interact with the game on even the most basic level is highly restricted, even in areas where there is no identifiable price point (in game chat/trade options, basic character design options and post game content). Even drug dealers offer a better deal than MMO makers, who give players just enough to realize that they either should quit playing or cough up some bucks to enjoy the game as it was meant to be played. The communities themselves often embrace this practice and treat free players with contempt or ignore them and their cries for help entirely. Developers also limit free players access to message boards, because you know that the players opinion doesnt become valid until they prove their dedication, any other line of reasoning would force the Devs to admit that the free players experience is so limited that they arent able to really comment on the game or how it works. Subscribers cling to the idea that they are special because they are willing to pay indefinitely for a crappy game (yeah, MMOs typically suck) without realizing that the Free to Play model has an adverse effect on them, even more than the free players who are suffering no actual loss. All of the in-game features have a price point one way or another to justify the free to play experience, if the game was completely subscriber based, it would likely be cheaper in the long run. Shock Value: What other company can offer you such a deal and not be hauled into court or find themselves out of business? ESPN has a pay for insider information model that offers an extremely small and specific feature on top of the free information that makes up 98% of its service. While the service is different entirely, it points out the difference between a working business model and a cash grab designed to make as much money as possible until a better idea forces you out of business.
9. Multiplayer Environment
MMOs sell themselves as essentially an episode of .hack//Sign, where players are completely in character taking the fantasy world seriously (hold on while the average WoW player finishes their laughing fit), this is marginally not the case. Not just in the way the players choose to play the game, but in the way most MMOs are basically designed. Sure there is a basic area or zone that varies in size where players can congregate and then proceed to spam obscenities, racial epithets, and out of character game instructions and hacks, followed by the overwhelming amount of complaints about how bad the game sucks (told you). But youd have to look very hard to find anyone actively role playing in a role playing game. Also, character levels typically decide access throughout the game, so if a player and a buddy want to travel together they had better be on the exact same page or it will either result in an error message or instant death. This, were all playing the game together idea is immediately destroyed when it becomes clear that every single player is experiencing the game's story from their own singular perspective, and what another player does has no bearing on what they experience, none! Thats why everyone gets a chance to kill the Lich King, never mind the idea that even when the player is in a party, they are literally alone in a crowd, of sometimes evil, racist trolls who hate sunlight. Shock Value: False advertise much? There are many ways in which to market an MMO that actually depicts what the player will experience. How can they call it a RPG when RPers are typically relegated to an Unofficial RP Server (which means thats just where a bunch of them decided to set up shop) and are often times ridiculed by other players? After several conversations with RPers and regular players its clear that players generally feel that MMOs (including MMORPGs) arent designed to accommodate role playing. Try selling a car that doesnt accommodate driving.
8. The Living World But Not So Much
MMOs often boast these living and breathing worlds where anything and everything can happen, which is true in the sense that a monster can be dropped into the game by a dev at random. However, when considering how most MMOs work, the player has zero impact on the actual world. Going into an instance (see dungeon) places the player in an environment that is vacuum like in its scope, nothing that happens in the instance effects the world despite the results of the mission. For example, in the now shut down MMO City of Heroes, several instances started by going into an office building to complete a mission, which would end in the buildings destruction. However, upon escaping the towering inferno to the safety of the street, one would expect the building to be burning. Nothing. The world, that is supposed to be alive, only seems to grow when the devs step in and program a change. Aside from that the world is magically resistant to the awesome powers it contains, including the giant monster the devs spawned to wreck havoc, where havoc apparently means to be extremely careful not to actually break anything. Shock Value: This is another example of a pointless lie that by definition is just unnecessary. Promoting a game to do or even be one thing and then doing something else is an insult to the intelligence of just about everyone involved. Plus its an example of a company that literally cant control itself.
Sports Games
7. Accurate Simulation
There was a time when games like NBA Jam and Arch Rivals dominated the sports game genre. But gamers are a diverse group who fall into other demographics. Soon companies learned that legions of sports fans could also be attracted to games and the closer the games were to the real thing the better. So, its disheartening to come to the conclusion that the term simulation has been the most abused buzz word in the entire gaming industry (if you think The Sims is just like real life, you need to see a doctor). Just about every installment of Madden NFL has boasted that it was a true simulation since the early 90s, this has never been the case as no rendition of the game has ever managed to include enough aspects of the actual NFL experience in one game. Features come and go, with the only common trend being graphical improvement. Sure improved graphics give the game a more realistic look, but who cares when the game itself is nothing like what we know about the NFL? Shouldnt there be a threshold for when true simulation is achieved? Have we crossed it yet? If not, what the hell are you bragging about? Oh, youre telling us its a true simulation so that well buy the game. Then once youve got our money (because the moment I break the plastic seal the game loses its value faster than a new car being driven off the lot) you promise to deliver next year, or the next year, or the year after that. Shock Value: Boasting is still lying more often than not. The shock value of this lie is intrinsically tied to the next example. Suffice to say, whats wrong with saying that your game is a fun representation of our favorite sport, complete with real players and teams? Especially when things like driving and flight simulators have already existed to such a degree that they are used to train real pilots and drivers.
6. Were #1! (of 1)
Sports games have always been bereft of any abundance of actual competition. At any given time players were lucky if they had three options to choose from in any given sport. Then EA bought the exclusive rights to the NFL and the Players Association in general. That meant that they had cornered the market on football games that featured the real players and teams, something that had become a necessary component if a sports game had any hope of success. The timing of this move was extremely suspicious as 2K Games had thrown their hats into the ring and were steadily gaining ground on the undisputed (see unchallenged) grand champ of NFL games. Instead of improving their game to compete EA took the easy way out and simply bought their victory (something the Federal Trade Commission didnt seem overwhelmingly interested in waking the sleeping giant over) in a back room deal. This, of course, didnt stop EA from screaming to the rafters that their game was #1. Never mind the idea that real players and teams seem like a vital component to simulate the NFL, but hey. 2K actually released a game called All-Pro Football 2K8 that by all accounts was pretty awesome, featuring retired NFL legends who were no longer under the Collective Bargaining Agreement of the Players Association and NFL. However no one really cared, because it featured retired NFL Legends who were no longer under the CBA. But dont think that 2K is the victim in this, on the other side of things 2Ks NBA title had been engaging in the most one-sided video game battle in history, spending a better part of a decade wiping the floor with EAs NBA Live franchise, it wasnt even close. Compared to the 2K series, EA had let a team of exceptionally stupid, comatose monkeys develop their NBA franchise. EA threw in the towel in 2010, after NBA Live 10 induced projectile vomiting. However, for the next two years 2K would proudly place an official looking seal on the cover that they had the #1 Rated #1 Selling game that year, upon closer inspection the seal actually says 2K Sports Seal of Approval, seriously. While its awesome they approve of their own game, they fail to point out that they are #1 in a field of 1. Thats like telling your only child hes the favorite, compared to a fork, the dog, and dads favorite bowling ball. Shock Value: Did you miss the part where I mentioned that the Federal Trade Commission should take interest in this issue? A stink was raised, EA lost exclusive rights to the NCAA and AFL (Arena Football League, dont worry no one here in America cares about the AFL or Jon Bon Jovi, who does in fact care about the AFL) but retained its stranglehold on the only contract that mattered. Despite the NCAA being available to any developer, none have stepped up to make a game. Both companies lied to their fans in one form or another, resulting in hurting the people that support them.
Role Playing Games (RPGs)
5. Fable Is A Pack Of Lies
Peter Molyneux is a pathological liar, strong words but not mine. You know you have a bit of a reputation for not being completely honest when perfect strangers feel comfortable applying the term pathological to the general description. Molyneux turned empty boasting as a way to make money into an art form. The Fable series that he is most famous for came with so many hefty promises that by the third installment, the game wasnt complete without a few blatant lies about what the game would do. Were not talking about certain issues that the game neglected or didnt have time for; especially with the consideration that the games were equally famous for taking forever to be perfected (ol Pete apparently thinks perfect is equal to totally incomplete), no these are full on features that were supposed to revolutionize RPGs. The fact that most readers are still struggling to understand why Im calling Fable an RPG is all the proof I need of Lionhead Studios abject failure. All Fable redefined was the meaning of overstatement, the first game promised co-op play, a massive amount of quests to really explore the alignment system missing from video game RPGs (which ironically is still basically missing from Fable), amongst other wild features that probably would have made Fable the greatest game ever. Fable isnt the greatest game ever, just thought Id make that clear. At best Fable 1 was The Legend of Zelda with delusions of grandeur, and yes Im comparing a next gen 3D game to the original NES version (hint: Zelda was better, and I hated f#%kin Zelda). But the lies didnt stop there; if anything the amount and quality of the lies increased more than the quality of the games (feel like playing the same game 3 times over the course of years and paying for each new installment?) themselves. By the time Fable 3 came around it became clear that Molyneux apparently lived out of phase with reality entirely. He promised that the game would have a series of play based morphs. The player would morph based on class, behavior and weapon choice, none of which ever happened. Sure the weapons and character model morphed, but not in any way that the player could actually control or even influence outside of very basic settings (using a ranged fighter versus a melee fighter produced a difference, a magic user looked no different). Even after the promise of Co-Op play in the very first game, a system jump and two sequels later the Co-Op system was terrible and far behind anything other games were doing, not quite groundbreaking there are we? Molyneux receives all the credit for being full of s#!t because the lies continued upon leaving Fable and making a steaming pile of a game called Black & White, which may or may not have seen the light of day but definitely sucked one way or the other. The game had a similar promise of real ethical choices that effected the world, but totally didnt. Well, at least hes consistent. The best news is that he now works for Nintendo. (I hate Nintendo for abandoning me as a gamer, thought that needed clearing up) Shock Value: When someone does something despicable, and then turns a tremendous profit, this tends to encourage others to do the same until someone eventually ends up in jail. Since it doesnt look like game developers are facing a stint in pound me in the arse prison
4. When Do We Role Play?
One of the biggest, most enduring lies in video game history is defined by an entire genre. Role Playing Games either dont feature actual role play, or are a complete non-unique. If its the former then developers promised something that they mostly havent delivered, and if its the later then there is no such thing as an RPG in video game terms. Let me explain, RPGs were created as a transition from table top war strategy games utilizing miniatures to represent various units on the field. Gary Gygax really enjoyed these games, but thought it would be cool to employ a fantasy element and expand the level of interactivity between the player and what was happening on the field. Trading tanks and infantry for sorcerers and fighters lead to the creation of Dungeons & Dragons. What created the transition from strategy to role playing was the implementation of story and character creation. In the days of first edition, battle was still the primary draw and created characters were essentially an afterthought, quickly created and just as quickly slaughtered, tearing up a character sheet upon death was common place (wait a sec, thousands of D&D players under the age of 20 almost died). As time went by, character creation took on a life of its own and role playing came more and more prominent. Video game designers saw the value in table top gaming and began transitioning the game and its features to a video game setting, adopting the term RPG along with the concept. Unfortunately they completely left behind the actual role playing. For a while RPGs were turn based and utilized a stat system similar to table top games, but that isnt role play. Lets be honest, thats a game mechanic that truly alienates a tremendous amount of gamers who have no desire to watch a bunch of poorly drawn characters stand around and never actually interact. Even later games that got rid of turn based game play still offered nothing in the way of an actual role playing experience. A choice of possible phrases isnt bad, and Mass Effect's conversation system along with the Paragon/Renegade scale stands alone as the example of even bothering to try. But trying doesnt make one worthy of a title, doing does. The key component missing in video game RPGs is alignment. Through alignment consequences are conferred, and consequences add gravity to our decisions. In basic terms, if the player character (PC) is good aligned it weighs and factors into every choice they make and there are subsequent consequences to violating their alignment. This mechanic is what Fable hinted at and then never delivered; you cant have role play without alignment and the ability for the alignment to dominate the players decisions, not the other way around. Video game RPGs are built from top to bottom to at no point allow the player to actually role play. Shock Value: Consider this, video game developers and video game RPG fans will argue that the features and combat systems are what make their games RPGs, and on its surface its a fair assessment. Until you explain to them that nothing they just named is a necessary component to play a role playing game. You cant build a copy with nothing but non essential components and then tell me youre done, thats called lying. Everything in an RPG is interchangeable, with one exception, the ability to role play the character, how can you say you have this is a faithful recreation but be missing the only component necessary to define it as the recreation?
3. Decisions vs. Consequences
This is the last heading under the RPG section. It deals with another over hyped aspect of RPGs that make the developers guilty of false advertising. Think back to the end of the last decade. A game called Mass Effect by developer BioWare was starting to get a considerable buzz around the industry. One of the early short trailers featured the crew on its way to a mission when a panicked message bursts on their radio. The voice is shouting amidst chaos, begging for salvation from what could only be universal Amway salesmen. But the crew had a mission, and sad as it was, they ignored it. Wow! The expectations were set, tough choices and realistic results. So, how often does this dilemma present itself in the game? How about never? Not once in the entire experience is the player forced to choose one pressing emergency over the other. That Senator who is being held captive by insane biotics aboard a derelict ship, who only has hours to live tops? Oh, hell wait a few weeks while we go shopping for a rare blend of Brandy. There is, of course the obligatory point of (finish all your side quests) no return threshold where you cant go back and complete old quests. But the option to hold off saving the universe from destruction while the player gets their ducks in a row stands indefinitely! This idea that time stands still wherever the player isnt is an embarrassing trend that plagues most RPGs. To prove its a lie, look at the exceptions, Oblivion offered a far more realistic idea of the game world, where NPCs had schedules they followed requiring the player to time their visits to the town in order to be in the right place at the right time. The missions themselves still had a primarily infinite life expectancy but at least they were trying. The slap in the face was that the sequel Skyrim did away with the living world idea almost entirely, sending the game overall in the opposite direction back to static NPCs that were pretty much always in the same location, they even reduced the things the NPCs said, unless the player is supposed to believe that archers in Skyrim are all trained to shoot for the knee. The idea that the player has all the time in the world takes all the drama out of the game and the genre, a genre which boasts a more compelling story than the average action game. LIES!!!
Big Business
2. Our Personal Property - We Mean Your Playing Experience Is Important To Us!
DRM (Digital Rights Management) have become the fall guy for one of the more recent and blatant lies in the gaming industry. EA is back at the plate again, this time lying about their latest version of Sim City (no, Im not going to argue that Sim City isnt a true simulation) which launched in early March of this year. The launch proved to be one of the biggest debacles in recent history mostly due to server malfunction. A key component to the server issue was the always-on DRM that required players to be online in order to play the game, a game that is historically single player, and marginally still so. Players became angry that they couldnt play offline while EA got their act together. However, offline play would completely negate the effectiveness of their always-on DRM. EA could have simply came out and said that the DRM prevented piracy and therefore protected their product necessitating a server connection and to simply wait until they worked out the kinks. After all, launch day crashes and other complications werent anything new. However EA decided that lying would be easier, and released an official statement intimating that the game wasnt designed for offline play and that it would take an extensive effort at that point to make it so. Outsiders had no idea that this wasnt true, it seemed feasible. That was until a lone development staffer remembered he had a soul, and decided to call BS on the entire idea that the game would require such an effort to run offline, oops. This staffer, who was authenticated but remains anonymous, explained that the game's online component basically regulated typical online functions like messaging, trading and file sharing, but running the game itself wasnt an issue at all. The official statement made it seem like Skynet was literally keeping the entire game together. EA created a teachable moment to be certain, as their initial position made a great deal of sense. Downloadable games that play on PC offline are simply waiting to be pirated (see stolen, yeah call it what you want, you no pay, you steal). Put it this way, from where youre sitting you are about 20 minutes away from playing a full version of the original Star Craft complete with activation code for a whopping free 99. EA could have been honest, but by lying they allowed DRM to take the blame for the whole deal, which has now become a legal issue which in the end could make it harder for publishers to protect their work. Way to go EA. Shock Value It seems like the higher ups at EA think that the internet is a magical place full of demonic fire and muscular little people. How is it fair that these people make millions while proving that their formative years were an apparent waste?