10 TERRIBLE Games That Got Great Reviews

Critics were ultra-generous to these trainwrecks.

final fantasy 16
Square Enix

The business of video game reviews sure is a funny one. It's often suggested that game reviews are inflated far beyond those of movie reviews, and that far too many outlets barely even use the bottom half of the 1-10 score scale.

And in fairness, players are hardly blameless themselves, many buying fully into the notion that any game rated below 8/10 isn't worth playing, and that reviews are intended to be anything other than the subjective assessment of a game's pros and cons.

But all the same, sometimes the gulf of opinion between critics and general players is vast enough that it becomes impossible to ignore - and absolutely merits assessment.

There's certainly no insinuation of nefarious doing on the part of reviewers here, but the fact that these 10 games didn't connect nearly as persuasively with gamers at large, and many found them straight-up awful, is quite fascinating.

The lesson here? As gamers, we're probably all better off not giving an aggregated score too much thought, but rather finding like-minded critics who reflect our own preferences and lending their opinions the most personal weight...

10. Forza Motorsport (2023)

Forza Motorsport
Turn 10

Last year's Forza Motorsport didn't rank among the series' better entries review-wise, but it still landed a totally commendable 84 on Metacritic, making one wonder quite what game critics actually played.

Even accepting that the mainline Forza games are a very different - some might say "boring" - experience to the more arcade-y Forza Horizon spin-offs, this dry-as-sawdust racer really tested the patience of all but the most die-hard racing sim fans.

From the stamina-obliteratingly dull single-player campaign to the lousy progression and garbage AI, it's a game held up only by its characteristically strong visuals and vehicular handling.

But that's just not enough, and with so little else going on under the hood, Forza Motorsport is a bafflingly soulless racer from a studio that's otherwise kept the mainline series so impressively consistent.

On top of this, the PC version continues to be plagued by brutal performance issues, ensuring that it now sits at a "Mostly Negative" rating on Steam.


9. Battlefield V

Battlefield V
Electronic Arts

Battlefield V certainly didn't review as well as the stronger entries into the franchise, but an 81 Metascore for the umpteenth instalment in an almost 20-year-old FPS franchise? That's totally fine, on paper at least.

And while there were certainly some bad actors out to ding the game solely for daring to feature women in its single-player campaign, Battlefield V felt like a staggering comedown from its predecessor Battlefield 1 all the same.

From the appallingly lacklustre amount of multiplayer content available on launch to the molasses-slow drip of game updates, ropey weapon progression system, and terrible balancing, Battlefield V didn't really offer much of a reason at all to stop playing the previous game.

While DICE did at least improve it in the years after launch, it's still a devastating example of a publisher forcing a game out the door before it was done cooking, and without enough content to justify the day-one asking price.


8. Hogwarts Legacy

Harry Potter Hogwarts Legacy
WB Games

Even with much debate about whether the mere act of playing the new Harry Potter game was ethical or not, Hogwarts Legacy still managed to land a very respectable 84 on Metacritic, with most reviewers praising it for doing firm justice to the license within a AAA open-world framework.

But after one spends a few hours exploring Hogwarts and the surrounding world, the allure begins to wear off and it becomes thunderously clear that Hogwarts Legacy is an almost laughably by-the-numbers Ubisoft open-world game with the Harry Potter license crudely pasted over it.

As recent AAA launches go it at least released in a serviceable, not-anger-inducing state - an apparently laudable achievement for a video game in 2023, because the bar is truly in Hell.

But from the groan-inducingly generic quests to the nothing-burger of a story, forgettable villain, and pointlessly level-gated main quest line, this feels like a thin sketch of a AAA game that could have been great with a few more years in the oven and a ton more ambition.

Instead, it's embarrassingly basic fare that's evidently content to just do the bare minimum each and every time. Wide as an ocean, deep as a puddle.

This didn't stop it selling 22 million copies in less than a year, though, so there's clearly no accounting for taste - or, at least, the indefatigable power of the Harry Potter license.


7. Final Fantasy XVI

Final Fantasy XVI
Square Enix

Why not kick things off with a sure-to-be-divisive choice, because Final Fantasy XVI's Metascore of 87 is nothing short of ridiculous.

Much as Naoki "Yoshi-P" Yoshida is rightly credited with fixing the sinking ship that was Final Fantasy XIV, he's just not particularly well-suited to spearhead a story-driven single-player Final Fantasy game, as proven by what's categorically the worst entry into the mainline series in many years.

Where to begin? From the soul-suckingly dull medieval aesthetic, defined by monotonous greys, browns, and earthy greens, to the tedious, endlessly expository dialogue, overabundance of joyless MMO-style fetch quests, and "mature" style brazenly cleaved from Game of Thrones, FFXVI smacks of a cynical attempt to broaden the series' appeal.

That's without even mentioning the dumbed-down real-time combat, spectacular-but-vapid Eikon battles, and overall lack of deep-dish RPG elements, ditched in favour of character action schlock.

For those who loved the three-peat of Final Fantasy VII, VIII, and IX back in the '90s, FFXVI doesn't even feel like it exists in the same franchise, and while change can so often be good, even necessary, in this case it feels like Final Fantasy has strayed too damn far from its roots.

At least Final Fantasy VII Rebirth will soon be here to (hopefully) wash the taste out of fans' mouths.


6. Halo 5: Guardians

Halo 5
343 Industries

With an 84 Metascore, Halo 5: Guardians appears to be a business-as-usual entry for the franchise - not the best, not the worst, but dead-in-the-middle, right?

You'd first need to ignore the game's atrociously miscalculated single-player campaign, which both trivialises the central marketing hook of the rivalry between Spartan Locke and Master Chief, and boasts the single worst recurring boss in the franchise - the Warden Eternal - who almost single-handedly makes replaying the game a non-starter.

That's without even getting into the sheer nonsense that is the actual story content of the campaign.

But Halo's multiplayer has always been its bread and butter, and while it's certainly the game's saving grace here, Halo 5 is still harangued by unnecessary changes made to the core gameplay and, worse still, the introduction of microtransactions. 

343 Industries' decision not to include local multiplayer functionality also sparked a significant and thoroughly justified backlash, cementing that Halo 5 took the series too far from its brilliant roots.


5. Spore

Spore Maxis
Maxis

If you ever experience a period of intense self-doubt, remember that Spore has an 84 Metascore.

Maxis' life-sim/god game was hugely hyped in the lead-up to its eventual 2008 release, with designer Will Wright promising that players would be able to control the development of a species from a single cell organism to a spacefaring civilisation with unprecedented granularity.

The reviews certainly seemed to indicate that, after numerous delays, Maxis had more-or-less pulled the damn thing off. Yet in the weeks and months that followed Spore's release, players gradually came to admit that they'd basically been duped.

Spore's five stages of advancement effectively function as independent mini-games in their own right, yet don't coalesce in an even remotely satisfying fashion.

The expected nuance and detail just isn't there, with the repetitive gameplay of each stage ensuring that Spore fails to maintain interest all the way to the end.

The Creature Creator is fun, at least, but the nuts and bolts of the game are a superficial far cry from the more advanced project Wright promised at the outset.


4. Deathloop

Deathloop PS5
Bethesda

Deathloop's Metascore of 88 seem to suggest it may be on-par with the finest works from Arkane Studios - especially the Dishonored games.

Yet as tantalising as its central premise is - of playing as an assassin caught in a time loop - Deathloop ultimately lacks the true freedom and exciting exploration of Arkane's better works.

From the overbearing amount of hand-holding - which might be an over-correction to complaints about Prey not giving the player enough help - to the disappointing linearity of the experience, poor AI, atrocious UI, and abrupt ending, it's a festival of head-scratching decisions.

In fact, the studio's Prey: Mooncrash expansion is basically a vastly superior proof-of-concept for Deathloop, which packaged the time loop idea into a more "commercial" framework when Prey flopped at retail.

For all of the bleating about Deathloop's innovative gameplay throughline, it's really just a shallow slog that wears out its already dubious welcome after a few hours.


3. Ni No Kuni II: Revenant Kingdom

Ni No Kuni II
Level-5

Ni no Kuni II: Revenant Kingdom - sequel to hit RPG Ni no Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch - landed an 84 Metascore, a mere point below its predecessor and suggesting that, if nothing else, it would be an impressively consistent follow-up.

For anyone who loved the original, there's absolutely no joy in experiencing what Revenant Kingdom turned out to be - basically a "direct-to-video" sequel with all the worst connotations that entails.

Beyond the game's admittedly spritely visuals, this is a bafflingly vapid experience which suggests returning developer Level-5 cut corners in order to save money at every turn.

Ditching the gorgeous animated cutscenes of its predecessor and massively scaling back the amount of voice-acted dialogue ensures that there's a major poverty of charm in this sequel from the outset.

Worse still, the plot is abject nonsense, protagonist Evan is childish to a fault, and eventually the game forces you to partake in a glut of dull "side content" - that is, snoozily unimaginative fetch quests - in order to continue the main story.

On top of all this, the skirmish mini-game is thoroughly naff and it's too easy to the point that there's genuinely little motivation to see it through to the end.

And yet, this thing got quite terrific reviews right out of the gate, no matter that fan opinion on it remains intensely divided to this very day.


2. Starfield

Starfield Game
Bethesda

Now that the dust has cleared and we're in a new calendar year, it's probably time for folks to admit that Starfield just wasn't very good - at least not where the pedigree of developer Bethesda is concerned.

It's telling that IGN received a ton of flak for giving Bethesda's space-faring RPG a "mere" 7/10 - a score which in hindsight can't help but feel rather generous.

Not quite as forgiving as the 83 Metascore, though, which would lead you to believe that Starfield may not quite hit the highs of the studio's best work, but it's still a damn fun time.

Yet in the months since Starfield's release, the Internet seems to have slowly accepted the idea that it's just not very good, as evidenced by it starting 2024 with "Mostly Negative" reviews on Steam.

Everything here feels like another studio trying to make a Bethesda game, except the storyline isn't interesting, the quests and characters lack charm and personality, exploring planets is boring, and the "unlock-a-power" mini-game might be the single laziest thing the studio has ever done.

For a publisher that's put out so many richly crafted games to deliver something so bland, even soulless, and for critics to largely trip over themselves to praise it, is absolutely head-scratching.


1. Gran Turismo 7

gran turismo 7
Polyphony Digital

Gran Turismo 7 is one of recent gaming's prime examples of critics and players experiencing something quite different.

Though it launched to an 87 Metascore, with critics praising the racing simulator as a major return to form for the hit franchise, developers Polyphony Digital quite sneakily waited until reviews were out before switching on the game's microtransactions.

As great as Gran Turismo 7 looks and handles, the laughably lackluster single-player campaign and especially the egregiously grindy progression - which aggressively nudges players to spend real cash on in-game currency - made it one of 2022's most depressingly cynical releases.

Hell, the situation was grim enough that players resorted to using a remote play hack which allowed them to auto-play circuit races and mine credits idly, prompting Polyphony to patch the game in order to make payouts even stingier.

The contempt for their own customers is shockingly thinly veiled here, enough that Gran Turismo 7's Metacritic user score sits at a devastating 2.7 after more than 11,000 votes.

For a game that should've been an absolute slam dunk for Polyphony and Sony - the first Gran Turismo game on PS5! - to feel like a craven cash grab was genuinely hurtful to the many millions who've supported the franchise for more than 25 years.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.