10 Terrible Levels That Haunt Otherwise Perfect Video Games

The shinier the surface, the more obvious the scratch.

assassin's creed desmond 3 III
Ubisoft

Sometimes, it's easy to forgive a developer for a bad game when the whole thing falls apart anyway. Maybe it was an idea that didn't translate well into the form of a game, or perhaps a meagre budget didn't match the team's lofty ambitions. Video games can, after all, be bad for so many different reasons.

However, it's much more difficult to look past a stage of a game that's so jarringly poor when viewed alongside the rest of a full product. It's really tough to accept when something is close to perfection, only to be ruined by one particularly awful mission, moment or level.

Sadly, even games that are considered to be true greats have suffered these moments of sheer frustration against an otherwise perfect execution. While we may not wish to acknowledge their existence, let's take a look back at where some games lost their near 100% score to an awful stage.

Here are ten terrible levels that haunt otherwise perfect games...

--

10. Sandtraps - Half-Life 2

Half Life 2 Sand Traps
Valve

While Half-Life 2 has left thousands of players desperately wishing for a third instalment to the immensely popular series, the game was never quite considered perfect. Certain players have different gripes, but the largest frustration definitely comes from one particular stage.

Sandtraps is the eighth level of Half-Life 2 and it is by far the worst. Despite an innocuous start, things quickly take a desperate turn when you suddenly find you have to navigate your way along large expanses of sand without falling on them. Doing so will alert hordes of antlions to attack and they'll keep coming until you're back off the sand again.

The path to success here is a combination of completing intricate jumps and constructing paths of debris with the Gravity Gun. It sounds simple enough, but this type of thing is virtually impossible to control in an FPS and thus mistakes will occur. When one antlion knocks you off your perch and subsequently summons an army of reinforcements you'll suddenly start to wonder why anyone really wants a Half-Life 3.


9. Tank Battles & Riddler Challenges - Batman: Arkham Knight

Riddler Race Arkham Knight
Rocksteady

When Batman: Arkham Asylum arrived it revolutionised super hero games. Then, when Arkham City followed as a sequel and did all the same things over again, that was perfectly fine. Arkham City was a great "If it ain't broke" example and in simply making the adventure bigger its developers did everything they could with it.

Recently, however, 'good enough' hasn't been deemed good enough. After the relative disappointment of Arkham Origins, Rocksteady had to step back in and re-right the ship. They attempted this by giving us a compelling new story centred around Scarecrow and the mysterious Arkham Knight, padding it out with all the great combat and gadgets of the first two.

Sadly, what they also did was add Batmobile sections to the mix and created a surprising failure. Batmobile stages consist of either infuriating races set by Riddler or pointless, plodding tank battles against Arkham Knight's drones. It's fun to blow these up for about thirty seconds, but the novelty wears off almost immediately. This turns out to be a huge shame, because the Batmobile is almost everywhere in this game.


8. Dream Sequence - Max Payne

Max payne blood trails
Remedy

Demonstrating that protagonist Max Payne was a tortured soul was apparently heavy on the agenda when the series began and has stayed the same every since. With the most recent Max Payne 3 this has been pretty well covered by the man's awful demeanour and mid-life crisis attire, but in the early days it wasn't as easy to do this successfully.

Payne's damaged psyche was represented in a few nightmare stages and players were forced to navigate their way through eerie dream sequences. The second of these was particularly bad, drawing virtually all tension out in favour of immensely frustrating level design.

Having players attempt to work their way through a blood trail maze and platforming section, veering even slightly from the line will see you fall to your death. Of course, this wouldn't be so bad if it weren't for the fact that the trail you have to follow was thicker than two pixels...

The fact that you can skip these on the iOS remake of the game does offer some suggestion that maybe mobile gaming really will take off one day!


7. Wrong Side Of The Tracks - GTA: San Andreas

GTA San Andreas CJ
Rockstar Games

"All we had to do, was follow the damn train, CJ!"

If you've never experienced this damning inditement first hand then it probably means one of two things; either you're a godlike Grand Theft Auto player who's never once failed a mission or, as is more likely, you've just never played GTA: San Andreas.

That said, if you're not in that group of four people, chances are you've had Big Smoke bark those words at you and walk off in disgust as you failed to kill the Vagos members staking out on top of a train. In that case you know how painfully annoying it is, not least because the mission itself is an absolute nightmare.

Keeping up with the train is made difficult thanks to San Andreas' pretty liberal approach to motorcycle handling, but on the occasions where you do manage it you can still fail anyway. Big Smoke shoots with all the accuracy of Arsenal reject Yaya Sanogo, meaning that you have to try to do that part as well. This is certainly a mission that Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas could have done without.


6. Escaping Taris - Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic

KOTOR Taris
LucasArts

Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic features one of the best stories every to be told in the Star Wars universe. In fact, if the filmmakers had actually released this instead of the prequel stories, the franchise probably never would have needed saving by J. J. Abrams.

More important still, however, is the fact that a movie version of KOTOR wouldn't have had to spend hour upon hour grinding its way through the depths of Taris. The city itself was interesting enough for a while, but after spending almost the entire first half of the game there this Coruscant-Lite became an utter bore.

Plenty of important stuff happens on Taris, of course, and much of the early running is dependent on the player's ability to navigate its seedy underworld. In reality this section absolutely did not need to be so long, and these opening stages could definitely have benefitted from being spread over two or three locations instead.

Seeing the planet's surface devastated by the Sith fleet as our hero escaped was as happy an ending as any in that game.


5. Desmond's Sections - Assassin's Creed II

AC Desmond.jpg
Ubisoft

The decision to split the story of the Assassin's Creed games between current and historic timelines has always been a contentious one. While many argue that the duality is great and that it adds much needed context to the events as a whole, many others suggest that video games negate the need for context by nature and that the existence of the Animus is superfluous.

But, whatever your stance on the narrative merits of the present day stories, there's no denying that they're painfully boring to play. Most obvious in Desmond's "adventures" with Assassin's Creed 2, the decision to have this part of the story bleed into the gameplay was simply baffling.

Despite attempting to give Desmond some of the impressive free-running abilities of his assassin ancestor, the sections where you actually control the man are awful. Consider the hideout, for example, where Desmond can climb and jump over boxes and stairwells for no other reason than to try to legitimise his existence.

But, with the whole thing taking place in such small and confined areas, none of the excitement from the main parts of the game translates into this at all.


4. The Ice Cave - Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

Uncharted 2 Ice Cave
Naughty Dog

In the 'Mountaineering' chapter of Uncharted 2: Among Thieves, players will have experience just why this game can never be considered truly perfect. Taking Drake's adventure into a desolate ice cave, the events take such a strange turn that you'll start to wonder whether you're still playing the same game.

The ice cave is passable enough, despite stretching the platforming sections of this already hardly believable adventure to its limits, but the fun really begins when it becomes clear something is watching you as you progress. Massacred animal corpses peak Nath's interest about what it may be, but he doesn't have to wait long to find out.

And, when he does, this globe-trotting adventure about an ambitious treasure hunter turns into a scarcely recognisable science fiction affair. Drake battles against a monster in the caves, one that is able to soak up piles of bullets at a time. This is okay, though, because suddenly you'll have access to infinite rounds for your firearm. Cheers, logic.

The fact that the bizarre creature looks like a mix between Star Wars' Wampa and the Predator speaks volumes of the storytelling at this point. This section undoes all of the great work that had gone into the game at that point.


3. The Fade - Dragon Age: Origins

Dragon Age Fade
Electronic Arts

Getting trapped in the Fade might sound like a pretty interesting challenge at first, but Dragon Age: Origins quickly manages to make it suck. Players get sent there by the Sloth Demon and are tasked with fighting their way through different domains in order to escape.

Putting aside the fact that the lazy appearance of this dreamworld is simply regular parts of the game with a sepia tone flushed through them, this part of the game is still terrible. You're forced to work your way through the different domains and acquire different skills to eventually face your captor and escape, but virtually every stage plays out exactly the same.

The mini bosses that await you in these areas are also just as uninspiring, and the sheer volume of time that has to be expended to complete this challenge is nowhere near worth the payoff. The Fade is filler content at its very best, which is so upsetting given how good the rest of this game is.


2. Cortana - Halo 3

Halo 3 Cortana
Bungie

Master Chief's quest to rescue the faithful Cortana in the penultimate stage of Halo 3 could have been a truly spectacular moment. In a series virtually devoid of genuine emotion, these two characters always provided enough of a spark to let us believe that there is something meaningful and human beneath it all.

Unfortunately the decision to set this epic quest in a Flood-infested High Charity doesn't quite have the same effect thanks to some dreadful design choices. Walking through the corridors and tunnels is so brown and gooey that it almost lets you imagine what it would be like to pilot a colonoscopy camera. It's literally as if you're sending Master Chief to wander through someone's bowels in search of something they inadvertently swallowed.

The fact that you ultimately have to turn back and head out the same ways does nothing to dispel the imagery: if Chief went in through the exit in the first place, what forces are going to expel him back out as he tries to escape?

I shudder at the thought...


1. The Hospital - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

metal gear solid v
Konami

Everyone knows that the Metal Gear Solid series has featured some pretty unusual stages over the years. Nothing in the franchise's history could ever have prepared players for the sheer, slap-you-in-the-face frustration of the opening mission in Metal Gear Solid V.

Having players slowly awake with grave injuries in a hospital bed, the game initially makes you think time will keep on passing until you can happily hop out of the bed and go about your mercenary business. Instead what you actually get is an extended set of sequences where you have to crawl and fall around as the game completely undermines every movement you try to make.

The intention was probably to get some gravity in the opening and to show just how dire the situation at the outset really is. Unfortunately this just doesn't translate into the finished piece at all and the result is an opening stage that threatened to derail the success of Metal Gear Solid V before it even had a chance to get going.

Let's hope Death Stranding doesn't have us crawling around a beach as a naked Norman Reedus for the first hour...

--

Which levels have been the thorn in the side of your favourite games? Vent your frustrations in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Gareth is 28 years old and lives in Cardiff. Interests include film, TV and an unhealthy amount of Spider-Man comics and Killers songs. Expect constant references to the latter two at all times. Follow on twitter @GJCartwright.