10 TERRIBLE Video Games (That Secretly Saved Franchises)
The night is darkest just before the dawn.
There's no denying that a bad video game can often be the kiss of death for a franchise - or in the case of Mass Effect, two hugely divisive releases in a row causing the series to be put "on ice."
Yet necessity is also the mother of invention, and so often all a major video game series needs is to be humbled and embarrassed by a terrible entry in order to fully reinvent itself.
Though each of these 10 games represent some of the worst that their respective series has ever had to offer, the fan outcry was vitriolic enough that the developers had no choice but to listen up, take note, and make sure the same mistakes weren't repeated next time.
As a result, these 10 hit video game IP were all restored to their former glory, but only after they were allowed to plumb the cleansing depths of awfulness first.
It's almost enough to make you wonder which other video game franchises could do with a little creative irrigation, to get the bland stodge out of their system and allow some passionate re-jigging to take place...
10. Tomb Raider: The Angel Of Darkness
Tomb Raider: The Angel of Darkness was the sixth mainline entry into the hit platformer franchise, and sought to effectively rejuvenate the series following Lara's fake-out "death" in The Last Revelation and consequent revival in Chronicles.
But many members of development team Core Design were tired of working on Tomb Raider by this point, to the extent that few key personnel from the earlier titles actually stuck around for The Angel of Darkness.
Elsewhere, poor management resulted in the game being scrapped at least once and the additional complexity of developing for PS2 hardware further hindered production, leading to an end product widely panned for being both glitch-riddled and blatantly unfinished.
Core Design reportedly submitted the game to Sony eight times before it was accepted, with staff later commenting that it needed around two more months of work to be satisfactorily completed.
The Angel of Darkness was not only blamed for killing the video game series' commercial prospects but also denting the box office performance of the Angelina Jolie-starring movie franchise, and led to Core Design head Jeremy Heath-Smith resigning in its wake.
All planned sequels were scrapped, and Eidos Interactive ultimately took the franchise away from Core and gave it to Crystal Dynamics, who released a string of critically acclaimed and commercially successful Tomb Raider games in the years that followed.
Most notably, they gave Lara Croft a gritty makeover with 2013's terrific reboot. Core Design burning out with The Angel of Darkness is ultimately the best thing that could've happened to the series, because it allowed a fresh, enthusiastic new pair of eyes to deliver a radical retooling.
9. Assassin's Creed Unity
Assassin's Creed Unity is widely accepted to be the worst entry into the core franchise, for despite its attempts to innovate the series, it was clearly released before it was done cooking.
Unity was so rife with bugs and glitches that Ubisoft offered players both an apology and compensation, while the company was also widely criticised for the game's lack of gender options in its co-op multiplayer mode (which they infamously dubbed "a lot of extra production work").
The intense backlash to Unity evidently gave Ubisoft a swift kick up the back side in a number of ways.
First and foremost, every subsequent Assassin's Creed game has released in a decidedly more polished state, while the series has also ditched the concrete annual production cycle, periodically waiting two years between some titles.
This not-so-coincidentally led to recent games Origins and Odyssey scoring some of the strongest reviews of the entire series.
And as a cherry on top, Odyssey also introduced full gender options, with the promise that this feature will remain in every future Assassin's Creed game.
As frustrating as Ubisoft can be as a company, they clearly took the near-universal disdain for Unity to heart, and the franchise has arguably never been better as a result.
8. Mortal Kombat: Special Forces
Almost every other game on this list is positively good compared to Mortal Kombat: Special Forces, a follow-up to Mortal Kombat 4 which landed exclusively on the PlayStation in 2000.
Special Forces was a bold - if misguided - attempt to diversify the series, by ditching the traditional beat 'em up style in favour of a third-person action romp with Jax being the single playable character.
You can probably imagine how this went down with fans.
Critics panned the game for its tedious gameplay, poor graphics, and excessive deviation from the core Mortal Kombat experience, cementing that the long-waning franchise had finally hit the bottom of the well.
Special Forces' critical and commercial failure prompted Midway Games to look long and hard at what fans wanted out of the series, which was clearly a back-to-basics approach, leading to the 2002 release of Mortal Kombat: Deadly Alliance.
Deadly Alliance was widely celebrated as the series' best game in around a decade, successfully updating the formula for a new generation.
Though there has certainly been experimentation with the Mortal Kombat formula in the years since, the series hasn't ever again lost sight of its roots, with NetherRealm Studios taking up terrific stewardship of the property in recent times.
Special Forces slamming into a brick wall as hard as it did made it clear to franchise creator Ed Boon that fans didn't want overpowering gimmicks or radical changes to the central gameplay.
7. Devil May Cry 2
Devil May Cry 2 is one of the most disappointing video game sequels of all time, with fans and critics alike complaining about its decidedly lowered difficulty compared to its predecessor, the "dumbed down" combat and boss fights, bland environments, and inexplicably stoic personality transplant given to Dante.
While DMC2 really stung fans at the time, it ultimately helped fully crystallise to Capcom exactly what they wanted from the franchise in its infancy.
This led to Devil May Cry 3 walking back every single bad thing about the previous game - particularly that low difficulty level - and in turn becoming arguably the fan favourite game of the franchise.
As much as some might decry 2013's DmC reboot, it nevertheless retained the fluid, balletic carnage and goofy tone of its better predecessors, even if just about everybody was pleased to see Devil May Cry 5 return to the original continuity.
6. Sonic Boom: Rise Of Lyric
To be a Sonic the Hedgehog fan is to be a glutton for punishment, because as iconic as the title character might be, the series' quality has been wildly all over the place, especially in the 3D titles which have defined the last 20-ish years of the IP's existence.
Sonic finally bottomed out critically, then, with the 2014 release of Wii U exclusive Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric and its DS companion piece Shattered Crystal, the former being especially vilified for its poor combat, boring puzzles, awful camera, and uninspired level design.
It even made 2006's Sonic the Hedgehog seem comparatively competent, resulting in straits so dire that Sega relented and let a group of fans and modders make the next official game in the series, Sonic Mania.
Sonic Mania ended up scoring the series' strongest reviews in almost 20 years and posted mighty commercial numbers to boot.
While a sequel has yet to materialise, it nevertheless reminded fans of what's possible when people with passion truly care about the end product.
5. Call Of Duty: Infinite Warfare
By the time Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare hit stores in 2016, it was undeniable that the enormously popular FPS franchise was going through both franchise fatigue and something of an identity crisis.
The two previous games, Advanced Warfare and Black Ops III, were divisively received by fans who felt that their more futuristic focus drifted too far away from the series' roots as a military shooter, and Infinite Warfare represented an insane apex of those complaints.
Despite its impressive visuals, Infinite Warfare's campaign committed the cardinal sin of being both ridiculous and dull, while the multiplayer was pilloried for its excessively twitchy pace and loot box mechanics, and Activision was harshly criticised for only making Modern Warfare Remastered available to those who purchased special editions of the game.
Underwhelming sales caused Activision to state that Infinite Warfare "didn't resonate with fans," and ultimately led to a far healthier diversification of the franchise across its development teams.
The very next game, Call of Duty: WWII, was a back-to-basics boots-on-the-ground affair, while Black Ops 4 was focused around its Battle Royale mode Blackout (admittedly at the expense of a campaign), and last year's Modern Warfare reboot offered up 64-player mayhem for the first time in the series.
Though not all new Call of Duty games will be for all players, it's simply refreshing that each new game has its own identity rather than simply being another also-ran futuristic shooter that's virtually indistinguishable from the previous one.
4. Dragon Age II
2009's Dragon Age: Origins was a massive critical and commercial success, not to mention a sure Game of the Year contender, only for Dragon Age II to receive a far less enthusiastic response from fans, who felt that the game had been hastily rushed out for a quick buck.
And indeed, EA gave BioWare only around 16 months to complete the game, requiring intense crunch periods and extensive re-use of assets from its predecessor.
Fans were ultimately frustrated at the game's new art style, simplified character options, excessive focus on combat, unsatisfying story, and generally smaller scope and scale compared to the original.
Dragon Age II was the clear product of a dev team struggling to meet an absurdly unrealistic deadline, and thankfully, BioWare were given almost four years to create the third game, Dragon Age: Inquisition.
The result was an impressive hybrid of everything people loved about the first game and what little actually did work from the second, massively upping the scale and clearly only bringing the game to market when it was actually ready.
As a triumph of adversity which combined everything BioWare learned on the two prior games, Inquisition was massively acclaimed by critics, even winning Game of the Year at the 2014 Game Awards.
3. Doom 3
To be clear, Doom 3 isn't actually a terrible game, but it is a terrible Doom game.
Doom 3 was released in 2004 as a quasi-reboot to the franchise, shifting away from the hardcore, fast-paced action fans of the series expected towards a slower, more survival horror-centric style and tone.
This was to the extent of even forcing players to choose between handling a flashlight or a weapon (until the BFG Edition fixed it). Naturally, many fans were left frustrated.
Though Doom 3's graphics were certainly impressive and the atmosphere was undeniable, it quickly fell into a repetitive rhythm and was, honestly, a chore to play through to the end.
Stripping away the series' sense of fun in favour of self-serious horror gameplay set in an endless array of blandly confined environments just wasn't what most fans wanted to see from a new Doom game.
Despite Doom 3 selling well enough that iD Software could've just rushed out a sequel within a year or two, they actually bothered to listen to the fan criticism, such that the original prototype for Doom 4 was scrapped after six years in various stages of production.
iD ultimately returned with 2016's Doom reboot, which returned the series to its face-melting roots and delivered arguably one of the franchise's strongest entries to date.
Better still, the recently released Doom Eternal was an ambitious step-up while never losing sight of what people loved about the earlier games.
Doom 3 arrived at a major point of uncertainty for the series, which had been on the skids for a while, and it ultimately served as a litmus test for the developer to realise what players really wanted out of the IP.
2. Resident Evil 6
Resident Evil 6 was the epitome of the series' increasing trend away from its survival horror origins, with the game unapologetically going full Michael Bay between its comically over-the-top set-pieces, excessive length, and inconsistent quality across its four character campaigns.
It couldn't have felt a further cry away from Resident Evil's suspenseful origins, switching out the original anguished intensity for empty, low-stakes action schlock that rarely raised the pulse.
Despite its commercial success, Capcom to their credit took heed of what their most loyal fans were saying. An action-centric 2013 prototype of Resident Evil 7 was ultimately scrapped in favour of what would be a radical soft reboot: a first-person survival horror game with VR support.
Resident Evil 7 eventually released to rave reviews, with the consensus being that the series had been restored to its former glory.
Though fans are still waiting for Resident Evil 8 to materialise, recent reports indicate it's going to follow in its predecessor's lead, and in the meantime we've had the well-received remakes of the second and third games in the series to feast on.
Simply, Resident Evil's acclaim hasn't ever been steadier or more consistent than it has been over the last few years, and we have RE6's over-eager, bombastic failure to thank for that. Sometimes things need to get worse before they can get better.
1. Final Fantasy XIII
Final Fantasy XIII is without question one of the most divisive games in the beloved RPG franchise.
Despite its undeniably splendid visuals, FFXIII was widely criticised by fans for its infuriatingly linear gameplay, effectively forcing the player down a corridor for a massive chunk of the game, while both the story and characters were bizarrely forgettable for the standards of the franchise.
The expected Final Fantasy charm just wasn't there, and the result was a superficially attractive yet ultimately shockingly soulless RPG, and one which soured many fans on the series for close to a decade.
Thankfully Final Fantasy XV, when it finally released in 2016, offered up solutions for many of those criticisms: it boasted a gorgeous open world, a memorable quartet of main characters overflowing with personality, and an intriguing, if messy, story.
FFXV certainly still had its issues - namely the infuriating Chapter 13 - but it was clearly a result of not only an extensively protracted development process, but Square Enix appreciating what fans hated about FFXIII.
With Final Fantasy VII Remake now racking up rave reviews and Final Fantasy XVI almost certainly in some stage of development, the franchise feels like it's gotten past its awkward generation-hopping growing pains and is back to greatness once again.