10 Terrible Video Games With Awesome Openings

At least Mafia 3's intro lived up to the hype.

Mafia 3
2K

Every gamer out there loves the feeling of pushing start on a new video game. A world of possibilities awaits us! This title could be so good it changes our lives or, conversely, might well be something we turn off after a couple of hours and never come back to.

You never really know until you find out for yourself.

Whether you go in with expectations or not, a game is sure to set them with it's opening cutscene. Great cinematics before or after the title-screen should lay before us an idea of what's to come.

The issue with promising beginnings is it makes for one hell of a plummet if things go wrong. If your average at best video game has an introduction that gets audiences hyped then there's going to be a lot of disappointment when they get into the real meat of the product. Nobody likes to feel short changed, which is why it's so frustrating when a game has an incredible start that it can't back up.

This list consists of games that had no right to go as hard as they did in their opening cutscene, knowing full well that the game they were delivering was not up to task.

10. The Order: 1886

The Order 1886
Sony

It was hard not to be interested in The Order 1886 in the lead up to release. Ready at Dawn, who were developing the game, had a solid track record of underrated spin-offs and ports.

Sony had trusted them to make a new exclusive franchise and it would be one of the earliest major new IPs on the PlayStation 4. Plus, it just looked really exciting.

The game opens with an extended and harrowing torture sequence all played out in first person as we watch ourselves get repeatedly dunked into dirty water by two angry British guards. It’s a dark way to kick things off and the visuals are stunning. Once players get moving, the graphics hold up and the setting of alternate timeline Werewolf-infested London is incredibly interesting.

It looks great and it's got a unique set-up: what’s not to love?

The Order 1886 met pretty middling review scores, only saved by the former positives. The gameplay was often described as boring, consisting of generic cover-based shooting and endless quick time events that never really got started before the game’s story abruptly ends at the 7 hour mark.

The game still has its fans, but it left a bitter taste in the mouth of many who were extremely excited for it. All that intrigue and such a strong beginning that was not the next generation jump that people were waiting for.


9. Castlevania: Lords Of Shadow 2

Castlevania Lords Of Shadow 2
Konami

After not doing all that much for a very long time with the IP, Konami finally rebooted the Castlevania series in 2010 with Lords of Shadow.

The big twist of this new reboot was that protagonist Gabriel Belmont was to become Dracula, and the player character had been the big bad of the Castlevania series all along. Whilst many fans prefer the original universe, Lords of Shadow at least had the brass to do something unique.

Its sequel definitely had similar things in mind. In the game’s stunningly good opening, we get a retelling of the events from the first game as well as a lot more. Familiar names are mentioned like Trevor and Simon Belmont, who carry on the lineage of their father Gabriel. In just this opening alone there are plenty of twists and turns, as Gabriel kills Trevor and resurrects him as Alucard.

It’s a huge lored-ump, but in a good way, widening the new reboot’s world in quick fashion and doing so very succinctly. A great voiceover over an animated storybook, it gives depth and history to this blossoming new Castlevania timeline.

Unfortunately, due to Lords of Shadow 2 being a bit of damp squib in visuals and gameplay, this cinematic as is good as it gets.


8. Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts

Banjo kazooie nuts and bolts
Rare

Animal duo Banjo and Kazooie were practically mascots for the 3D platforming genre all by themselves but when developers Rare were bought out by Microsoft they went worryingly quiet Then, 2008’s Nuts & Bolts happened.

The opening cutscene would be sure to reduce BK fans to tears as they got their first look at Spiral Mountain in glorious HD. The game quickly recaps the story so far, complete with your expected level of Rare humour, and then takes fans to Banjo and Kazooie’s abode. In the eight years since their last appearance they’ve grown old and fat and from here on out the title breaks the fourth-wall nonstop.

It’s some truly funny stuff, poking jabs at Rare’s own failures and the changes in the gaming industry. When it tasks the player with collecting a tonne of Jiggies but then cuts them off, bemoaning that players don’t “want that kind of thing” though? The goodwill starts to fade.

The game repeatedly tells us the original Banjo games are tired and outdated and it’s answer to that is to apparently turn the series into open-world kart driving blandness.

If their appearance in Smash Brothers amounts to nothing more than a fun cameo, at least we’ll have the opening few minutes of Nuts & Bolts before Banjo-Kazooie died forever.


7. Halo 5: Guardians

Halo 5: Guardians Master Chief Spartan Locke
Microsoft Studios

Halo 4 left things on a cliffhanger and fans were all hungry to see where the series was going next. As interesting as Master Chief John-117 was becoming as a character, more than just a hardened super-soldier, there was definitely room for new faces by the time Halo 5: Guardians came around.

Thus, the game kicks things off with its shiny new group Fireteam Osiris. The squad is made-up of characters from Halo books, a short film and Buck returning from Halo 3 ODST and it promised to bring the games closer to the extended universe.

The opening cinematic briefs the SPARTANs who, accompanied by an incredible piece of heart pounding music, drop into the action. Exceptional visuals guide us down to the surface as ships explode. Sliding down a snowy mountainside, our new team kick alien ass and don’t ask for names.

The mission that follows is probably one of the best of the game too, so that helps.

But Halo 5’s campaign story not only did very little with the extended universe, it did very little with anything. Master Chief was far too absent and the story meandered the entire way to its generic conclusion. This exciting start belays a campaign that feels safe, lifeless and extremely by the numbers.


6. Evil Dead: Hail To The King

Evil Dead: Hail To The King
THQ

Evil Dead is one of the most beloved B-movie horror series of all time so in a way it's surprising that hasn't had more video game adaptations. After its debut on the Commodore, the first proper video game experience from the franchise came rather late in the year 2000.

After eight years, Ash Williams would finally return in a canonical video game sequel. Hail to the King was set after the events of the third film and saw Ash return to the infamous cabin in the woods to face down his nightmares. Naturally, things go awry immediately.

The game’s opening cutscene is kitsch and very of it’s time, being a PlayStation and Dreamcast title, but it's wonderful to hear Bruce Campbell return to the role of Ash. He narrates the story so far which is interspersed with graphical recreations of iconic Evil Dead moments. The POV camera zooming through the woods effect is present and the sequence ends with Ash tooling back up with his trademark chainsaw and “groovy” catchphrase.

The cabin itself is great to be in in its own nostalgic way but as you move Ash around the game the whole thing falls to pieces. This clunky, slow, confusing and incredibly repetitive Resident Evil-like is horribly boring. The opening cutscene is the one true highlight, which is not really a great selling point.


5. Final Fantasy - Franchise

Final Fantasy X-2
Square Enix

Now, this one is a little bit of a cheat entry but hear it out. Think of the Final Fantasy game you dislike the most or indeed like the least.

Everybody’s got their tastes and even the less critically acclaimed entries have their diehard fans. The thing about Final Fantasy is, no matter how much you dislike an entry, you can’t deny that each game has stellar production value.

Final Fantasy VIII might be the most divisive of the PlayStation era, but it starts with an epic gunblade battle with Squall getting his face slashed open. Final Fantasy X is something adored and abhorred by different people, but the iconic flashforward opening of Tidus and company with its delicate piano main theme is undeniable. Even Final Fantasy X-2 with its crazy pop concert is at least entertaining in its own right.

Final Fantasy XIII might be corridors, tutorials and bad decisions for some, but the opening cinematic is a beautiful look at the game’s world.

Taking a side in the argument and dying on your Final Fantasy hill is something we all have to do as fans of the franchise. Whichever game you disdain the most though, we can at least all agree that Square-Enix have done a phenomenal job in the last twenty years of creating incredible opening sequences.


4. Musashi: Samurai Legend

Musashi Samurai Legend
Square-Enix

Out of all the games on this list, this one has the best chance of being the most unknown. Whilst its PS1 predecessor, Brave Fencer Musashi, was decently well received, it's this 2005 follow-up that fell totally flat on release.

A two-punch combo of Tetsuya Nomura character designs and Hiroyuki Imaishi as lead animator means that Samurai Legend has an absolutely excellent anime opening. Quite literally, this should be the opening credits to a high-spirited, action-packed television series rather than a game. Players get a brief look at the characters before they’re flying around being chased by robots with machine guns on motorbikes in a stunningly fast and high quality animation.

As Musashi faces-off in a rain-drenched black and white samurai showdown, gamers are sure to be ready to jump into whatever the hell this thing has to offer.

Unfortunately, when the gameplay begins Samurai Legend is slow, far too easy and aesthetically bland. A huge contrast to that opening you just watched that got your blood pumping.

Musashi: Samurai Legend is a weird one indeed as 2000s Square-Enix was a very creative and productive time for the company and it’s hard to not feel like this opening deserved a better game to go with it.


3. Anthem

anthem game
Bioware

A rather recent example of a game that had so much promise sadly underdelivering; BioWare’s track record with the likes of Mass Effect and Dragon Age meant that, whatever the case, Anthem was going to be a very high fidelity game.

Conceptually, the world of Anthem is wonderful: an alien planet full of unknown relics that trigger sudden terraforming, complete with massive storms that spawn monsters. Humans are now hundreds of years removed from enslavement from an alien race, and wear Javelin exosuits when they go into battle. Parts of this are teasingly touched on in the game’s intro, before players are set up for their first mission.

Anthem, from the off, feels like a no-expense spared experience with its great graphical presentation and cinematic swell. The opening cutscene introduces the setting, cast and tone as the player character is fired into a cataclysm, clashing with dragon-like monsters in the air before crashing to the ground.

Heck, even the compulsory tutorial doesn’t feel forced as the player’s exosuit needs a quick reboot after slamming into the planet’s surface.

Whilst Anthem starts strong, it got lambasted by critics and the general public for repetitive and shallow gameplay. For all of its graphical highs, it was stunted by long load-times and an empty world.


2. Mafia III

Mafia III
2K

2K Games’ Mafia series is a sorely underrated take on the criminal action-adventure genre where new titles only come along every so often. The first game in particular built on what had made Grand Theft Auto III great and made something truly special in and of itself.

Mafia III has the distinction of having one of the most interesting and unique openings to a game perhaps ever. Many people talk about cinematic but to give its set-up a sense of realism Mafia III goes full documentary.

We cut between a travel ad for New Bordeaux and the damages that its criminal underbelly have wrought. A retired priest and a former soldier give the audience their accounts on Lincoln Clay; his family, his upbringing and his service.

The facial capture and performance are immediately enrapturing. The writing builds up a wonderful air of mystique about the setting and the player character before the game even begins. It’s exceptionally clever.

Mafia III was praised for its direction, story-telling and voice acting but this promise was eaten alive by terrible performance and disappointing, boring gameplay. With a franchise with such a track record as this, and with an opening this imaginative, you cannot afford to waste it on tired gameplay mechanics.


1. Sonic The Hedgehog (2006)

Sonic 06
SEGA

Sonic’s early 3D output was at least a divisive affair. Some fans found lots to like about the two Adventure games and Sonic Heroes whilst others would say they were merely average. Sonic the Hedgehog 2006 changed everything.

For context, this was before the “Sonic cycle” of growing hype and utter disappointment, and early looks at the HD reboot for Sonic were extremely exciting.

Booting the game up greets players with the kind of cutscene that caused fans' hearts to swell. It felt like the new era of Sonic had begun. The graphical fidelity is so high and even today it all still looks incredible. The introduction of the bustling Venice-like city of Soleana, Princess’ Elise nightmarish vision and the coming of Eggman felt to fans like the Disney level leap that Sonic had been waiting for.

The blue blur’s arrival feels exciting and even now makes you want to sit up straight and play this wonderful game.

If only what followed it was anything like it. Instead, as is well documented, we have a notoriously glitchy game that nearly killed the franchise. The look of Sonic 2006 is fine but it doesn’t rise to the potential of that opening cutscene in no way, shape or form.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Mafia III
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite