10 Things Fans Will Love (And Hate) About Mass Effect Andromeda

It is the blurst of times.

mass effect andromeda omni tool
Bioware

As you're probably already aware, Bioware's latest foray into the Mass Effect franchise - that took five years and over 40 million dollars to put together - has resulted in one of the most divisive games of the year, possibly of the generation. I'm not talking No Man's Sky-levels of out-and-out hate, more pointing and laughing at the state of the facial animations, feeling immense sorrow that this is what Mass Effect 'is' right now, then looking past that to find some immensely satisfying positives.

Because make no mistake, Mass Effect Andromeda is NOT the all-singing, all-dancing answer to our prayers. It is not an essential instalment in one of the richest sci-fi narrative tapestries in gaming history, and it is not going to please more than the most hardcore of fans in the process - in fact, those are the ones most at risk from flicking a middle finger and walking away entirely.

Behind the scenes, it's important to note that the team heading up Andromeda are a sub-division of Bioware. Formerly head of the multiplayer section of Mass Effect 3, this is the first time they've ever stepped up to bat for a full release.

The final product is ambitious, but it's also mired by a noticeable lack of polish; one that like Fallout and Bethesda's half-cocked approach to quality control, might endear it all the more, providing you're strapped in for such a bumpy ride.


10. Hate: How Limited The New Conversation System Is

Mass Effect Andromeda
Bioware

It was under the proviso that sticking with the original trilogy's Paragon and Renegade choices were too 'binary', that we now have a four-way emotion-based system; one predicated on being Emotional, Logical, Casual or Professional.

Thing is, 99% of the exchanges you have are still based in binary options. You're either forever casual or forever professional. Starlord or Captain Picard, no middle ground.

At rare key points in specific missions you'll be given all four options, but the issue with this more granular system is the big overarching plot points always charge ahead anyway. In giving us more 'emotional choice' in the moment, it removes the clearly distinguished repercussions of the former system, alongside the longterm ramifications of 'playing Paragon' or 'playing Renegade'.

This sort of thing could've worked a treat, but thanks to the conversation options you're given being so limiting, it really ruins that unique sense of intergalactic player agency necessary for Mass Effect to function best.


9. Love: Solving Interspecies Race Disputes

The Pathfinder Team - Mass Effect Andromeda
Bioware

Whilst the majority of your conversation options and Ryder's dialogue itself can feel very flat or bare-bones, the actual scenarios you're taking part in do have merit.

Carrying on from the original trilogy's positioning as Shepard (now Ryder) being a figure of galactic justice (the all-new 'Pathfinder' designation is pretty much SPECTRE status), you're free to meddle in everything from falsely-accused murder suspects to scanning artefacts for research projects, being interviewed for documentaries and anything in between.

Nailing down the tone and 'feel' of what makes Mass Effect so special comes from delving into this rich lore, empathising with a Krogan over how they're treated one minute, before realising their inherently violent tendencies might have caused friction in the first place. Whilst Andromeda strips down the sheer amount of races present - there are no Elcor or Hanar here - you can tell the writers have had a field day taking the racial staples we know so well, before mashing them together for what feels like an endless amount of side-quests and opportunities.


8. Hate: The New Planet-Scanning System

MASS EFFECT Andromeda planet scanning
Bioware

It was baffling they continued it in ME3, and it's a straight-up WTF jaw-dropper here.

Planet-scanning in past games was as simple as running a metal detector interface over a planet, tapping a button whenever spikes registered on your display, before reaping the rewards. In Andromeda, the basics of 'go to planet, scan, get stuff' are the same, but each and every planet, asteroid or ship are modelled in full 3D, and the game insists on you travelling between each component, one by one, complete with unskippable 'flying' animations.

For a system that comes with say, six planets, scanning them means enduring slow travelling cutscenes in between each, and even if you do indulge in this, you only get one material deposit per planet, because you're only allowed to scan one specific spot for one specific thing.

The whole thing feels like this weird space porn photo mode, being you can hit a button to drop the UI out and rotate around said planets and objects in 3D, letting the gorgeous lighting engine fill in some admittedly fantastic background detail.

That said, no one in their right mind could've thought this was a step up from what went before, and although I personally got on board with planet-scanning as a podcast-backed way to relax in ME2 and 3, Andromeda's 'innovation' will send you to sleep.


7. Love: Having Another Badass Krogan Squadmate

mass effect andromeda drack
Bioware

There are very few 'moments' in Andromeda on the level of choosing between Ashley and Kaiden, finding out the Archangel was Garrus or watching Mordin die in the process of curing the Genophage, but like any Bioware RPG, it's the non-human species that provide the most fun - particularly as in Mass Effect 3, we never had a Krogan pal to call our own.

Jaal is your new half-squid, half-cat warrior (a standout from the paltry three new races on offer), but alongside him is Drack; another mound-of-muscle Krogan who absolutely decimates all enemies in his way. Andromeda's script is fully aware of how much the fanbase adored Wrex and had a slightly tough time acclimatising to Grunt, now building Drack as a far older, somewhat wiser Krogan covered in the bones and skeletal remains of his enemies.

Drack is that archetypal immortal warrior that's 'seen everything', and from some vicious in-cutscene headbutts to one-liners and sprinting into hordes of enemies before sending them flying, he's been my constant teammate for the majority of the game.


6. Hate: The New Omni-Tool

mass effect omni
Bioware

One of the most beloved pieces of iconography from Mass Effect, subject of cosplays and essentially to the series what the Pip-Boys are to Fallout, how - in the blue hell - do you go from the shot on the left, to that on the right?

In motion, the new Omni-Tool almost looks like one giant texture that hasn't loaded properly, its forever-stuttering 'interface' being a mess of horizontal lines and sepia-tinged static.

Even thematically, this doesn't really hold up, as the Andromeda Initiative brought over their tech from the Milky Way i.e. where the events of the original trilogy were already in full swing. For Bioware to then frame a variety of dialogue scenes around looking at the Omni-Tool directly (way more than ever before) and then to miss including the necessary detail is just... weird.


5. Love: The GORGEOUS Landscapes & Environments

mass effect andromeda
Bioware

One thing Andromeda absolutely knocks it out the park on are the environments. Whilst the layout of these worlds never allows for the expansive draw distance of something like Breath of the Wild, there's a sense of detail and atmospheric density that provides a huge amount of variety to each and every landscape.

Contrasted against No Man's Sky - which derived beauty from the random computations of its forever-improvising algorithms - every world in Andromeda was hand-crafted, purpose-built and peppered with quests for you to find and complete.

You need to have an exploration bone in your body to want to do these things, but dive into anything from the frozen tundra of Heleus to the floating rock formations on Aya, and you'll come away with a phenomenal sense of place - one that begs you to spend hours uncovering each individual component.


4. Hate: The Archon & The Kett Being So Utterly Lame

Mass Effect Andromeda the archon
Bioware

There's no getting around it: From day one, the Kett looked a little... uninspired, and in-game they're just as one-dimensional.

Over the course of the story, you do get insight into how their leader, The Archon, operates, but when Bioware had the complete blank canvass of an entire new galaxy to play with, coming back with more humanoid rock-skinned warrior-men is beyond me.

Contrary to the majority of reviews complaining that you're forced into combat scenarios from the get-go, you can attempt to introduce yourself and later resort to blasting everything to cinders, but for all intents in purposes, this lot are a band of threadbare new-age Star Trek villains, a galaxy away in every respect from Saren or The Illusive Man.


3. Love: Being Back In This Mythology

Mass Effect Andromeda - Extraction
Bioware

The biggest plaster to layer over all these innumerable faults comes from Mass Effect as a mythology, and everything Bioware previously accomplished across those immaculate first three games (save for the disastrous final 20 minutes).

Returning to being slap-bang in the centre of another intergalactic mess of racial disputes, humanity being on the back foot and leading a merry crew all with their own motivations is what fans have reminisced about for years.

Andromeda fleshes each one of those strands out to a ludicrous degree, and whilst that results in an overwhelming amount of content with little throughline focus, it does mean that for fans especially, this veritable buffet of appetising dishes is one they'll want to gorge on for hours.


2. Hate: How Little Andromeda Progresses Anything

Mass effect andromeda
Bioware

On the contrary to this idea of indulgence in established franchise traits being satisfying, Mass Effect Andromeda offers quite literally nothing meaningful to the overall canon.

Whilst the first trilogy always had overarching plot lines in regards to everything from the Reapers to the Protheans, the Geth and Shepard's role as Space Jesus, Andromeda ditches that in favour of feeling like a giant sandbox of Mass Effect ephemera.

You can play with the action figures, read into all manner of conflicts and lose hours exploring planets, scanning and crafting weapons to your heart's content, but the purpose behind why Mass Effect Andromeda exists never changes: To make money off an established brand, because that name still means something.

This is a Halo 4 or a Gears of War 4, not an Uncharted 4. Take from that what you will.


1. Love: The Open-World Loop Of Combat, Exploration & Dialogue

mass effect andromeda
Bioware

All of which brings me onto this point: Mass Effect Andromeda can be fun, really fun - once everything clicks.

It takes some time to fully understand what the Andromeda Initiative are, what a 'Pathfinder' is and just what you're doing other than base exploration, but in a way, carving your own path through so much content and side-missions is the new Mass Effect experience.

Landing on a planet and darting between various mission strands can be a fantastic way to play, and it's here where all sorts of gameplay loops start to interweave.

mass effect andromeda
Bioware

You'll spy a Kett outpost down a ravine and launch down there in the Nomad to take them out with some blistering combinations of Biotic attacks. You'll explore underground ruins and terraform the surrounding landscape, build 'a new home for humanity' that rewards you with materials for more weapons and armour. You'll go on backstory-filling loyalty missions, take down alien dinosaurs with Asari swords, indulge in conversations about determinism, faith and space politics.

In short, you'll 'do a Mass Effect', but that core recommendation comes with one of the most bizarre and off-putting surface layers in recent memory.

Oh, and yes, the human facial animations are hilariously atrocious, but they won't get in the way of your overall enjoyment.

--

Are you picking up Andromeda, or have the mixed reviews truly put you off? Let us know in the comments!


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.