10 Things We Want To See From Yukes' Alternative WWE 2K Game
Fun beats photo-realistic...
Rejoice, dear long-suffering wrestling gamers, for news has broken that Yukes (the brains behind WWE's video game series for nigh-on 20 years) are working on an alternative to 2K's annual updates. This will be music to everyone's ears. Even if you happen to enjoy WWE 2K19 and are looking forward to what 2K20 brings, it's hardly a negative that we could get a totally different IP.
"Totally different".
That's exactly what Yukes' side project would have to be. There's no point in releasing a game anything like 2K's hodge podge of slow gameplay and attempted photo-realistic presentation. Any offshoot to the series must offer something unique that makes it worth purchasing to those who are sick of 2K19's increasing staleness.
There are loads of things we'd love to see in the new game, and they're all detailed here. This is a real chance for pro wrestling games to become great again; just like in real life with WWE, Yukes realise that a lack of competition breeds laziness, and it's something that's worrying them.
Here's how they can put things right...
10. No Commentary
The sub-heading doesn't lie, and neither does the pic attached to this entry. Spike Chunsoft's excellent Fire Pro Wrestling World has a rocking soundtrack playing over every match. It's admittedly a bit repetitive after a few hours, but it's way better than hearing Michael Cole, Corey Graves or Byron Saxton call Braun Strowman "she".
That happens too often in 2K's series.
Fire Pro doesn't have commentary, and it's a better game for it. Announcing, which has been a problem in wrestling video games since it was first tacked on to give the presentation a TV feel, is useless in WWE's titles. If Yukes are clever, they'll head to the audio section of their code sheets and delete it forever.
In Fire Pro, the jamming J-Rock beats and soaring power metal riffs combine to enhance the end portion of a match. That atmosphere is lost when Cole continually repeats the same line about Seth Rollins once turning on his Shield buddies.
9. A Totally New Graphics Engine
In her interview with VGC, Yukes' senior vice president and producer Hiromi Furuta admitted frustration that 2K are "still using old assets" for their WWE games. This is an annoyance shared by those who have been there from the very start. They're probably not the same, but those hair mechanics in 2K19 look almost identical to the ones used in the very first SmackDown on PS1.
Something has to change.
It's about time the developers built a new graphics engine from the ground up. The same could be said of the gameplay engine, because a lot of the animations are fundamentally the same as they have been for a generation or more. It's inexcusably lazy to repackage the same thing year on year and expect fans to be happy paying for it.
Yukes have finally grown tired of this repetition, and they're keen to develop a game that does the wrestling audience proud. If they're going to succeed, then we really need to kiss goodbye to Lego hair that passes through shoulders and dead eyes.
8. A Story Mode That Apes Real-Life WWE
WWE Universe, MyCareer and the Showcase Modes are all fine additions. No, really, they do have validity in 2K's series, and they are well-liked by some who play the games. There's one glaring omission though: fans don't have a proper story mode that mimics what they watch on WWE programming. It's a baffling oversight.
OK, so it is possible to recreate Kofi Kingston's unforeseen rise to the WWE Title in Universe, and MyCareer does offer interaction with a host of real stars, but, it's a hollow, inauthentic experience. Wouldn't it be better to have the developers put in a shift for you and ensure that stories play out like they did on Raw and SmackDown?
That used to be the way of it. Back in the days of SmackDown: Shut Your Mouth and even the PS1's Know Your Role, real-life feuds and angles that actually happened on TV were replicated in-game. It was a joy to play through these, and it's been bewildering to watch 2K ignore a product that is ripe for plunder.
WWE storylines are perfect for video games. Let's hope Yukes are paying attention.
7. WWE's Own 'Ultimate Team' Style Suite
This could be a toughie.
EA Sports have changed the way their FIFA series is consumed forever by focusing on the Ultimate Team mode for the past decade or so. Yes, this does come at a cost. Players who enjoy Career Mode and other offline features have been left behind for a while, but it's hard to refute the success of FUT as a focal point for EA.
They've made wads of cash with the mode, and Yukes could too if they can somehow marry what FIFA offers with the colourful world of pro wrestling. To do so, they could look towards the WWE Supercard game and its emphasis on stats. There's a whole world of possibilities here, and it'd be fun for fans to compete in matches, tournaments or gimmick bouts to unlock arenas, superstars and packs of new wrestlers.
This would replace the mind-numbing boredom of the VC points grind (or, dare we say it, the dreaded loot boxes), and it'd place less pressure on players to dump another one-off payment to unlock everything at once so they can actually enjoy the game. A sense of progression, socialisation and enjoyment is needed.
6. Live Updates
Pop in your copy of WWE 2K19 and it all feels a bit dated. Wrestlers will be wearing the wrong gear, some will have the wrong hairstyle and a fair few won't represent the person who bounds out onto the stage on Monday and Tuesday nights. This has been an ongoing problem for years now, and it's hard for 2K to manage.
Or, is it?
The lack of a live update system really hurts the lasting appeal of 2K's series. There's no attempt to keep up with what WWE are doing in real life by tweaking superstars and keeping them up-to-date, and that leaves the overall package feeling like yesterday's news pretty quickly.
Take FIFA or Madden for example. In both those games, EA constantly refresh stats and form tables for the teams involved so gamers can lose themselves in a world at least trying to mirror what they watch weekly. Yukes could do themselves a massive favour by promising weekly (or monthly) updates that add new moves, arenas, characters, ring attires and incentives to keep on playing their game.
5. Fun Backstage Roaming
Once you've played one 'Backstage Brawl' in WWE 2K19, you've played them all. A few short minutes is all it takes to experience almost everything the backstage hallways, locker rooms and offices have to offer. This is a rather gross misuse of the old "falls count anywhere in the building" phrase.
The general lack of interactivity with the world is frightening. Wrestlers clumsily bump into objects they're not supposed to use as weapons, and the ones that are animated feel clunky to pick up and play with. There's no immediate gratification like there was when RVD was Frog Splashing off the top of WWE New York or Eddie Guerrero was dropping elbows on Kurt Angle from a helicopter.
Backstage brawling, as fun a premise as it is, sucks when it becomes a glorified tech demo with severe limitations.
We want freedom from Yukes, even if it is all a bit silly. In fact, bring more of it if it's over-the-top. That's how a wrestling video game should be, and that's why the backstage areas in 2K19 fail to electrify us like the old ones used to.
4. Focus On Sim-Like Management Elements
If anyone has ever sat down to play Adam Ryland's underrated Extreme Warfare Revenge or Total Extreme Warfare/Wrestling series, then they'll get the gist of this entry. Anyone who hasn't should know that these games boil down to business strategy more than playing matches. You decide on everything, from who's feuding with who, how long that rivalry should last, what gimmicks the wrestlers have and what channel your shows are on.
Think Sim City or Theme Park, only with less graphics and more text.
The much-missed GM Mode would scratch an itch here, but so would combining the ability to play through cards with the control over how they come together. Sure, Universe has this same sort of ambience, but it's all very bland and lacks the real customisation Ryland's finest hours serve up.
We wouldn't be adverse to a Football Manager-like WWE experience at all. There's a certain thrill that comes from being the main decision-maker, and it wouldn't be hard for Yukes to package the new game as a management sim more than an in-ring button masher.
3. A Retro Masterpiece
Or, they could kick it old school and recapture that childlike wallop of arcade-like fun titles like the N64's No Mercy or the PS2's SmackDown: Here Comes The Pain had. Both those games, released just a few years apart on different systems, nailed what they were going for. Can the same really be said of 2K's recent work?
We doubt people will be talking about 2K19 with the same gusto as they do No Mercy or HCTP in 15-20 years.
Back then, AKI and THQ ignored the relentless pursuit of photo-realism 2K are on in favour of fun gameplay and an immersive WWE experience that plain rocked. Of course, neither company had the hardware capabilities to produce picture-perfect replicas of the roster, but they didn't need to. Fans could look past some rough models if the gameplay was fun enough.
It'd be something special if Yukes married No Mercy and Here Comes The Pain with the arcade goodness of WWE All Stars (released in 2011). That was a clear departure from the simulation style of the SmackDown vs. Raw series, and it was infinitely more playable than any WWE game since.
2. Focus On A Different Company?
Now isn't this a thought?
Hiromi Furuta didn't necessarily say that Yukes are working on another WWE game to complement 2K's product. Although her words did hint that this would be the case, she didn't outright say it. What if they're not? What if Yukes plan on producing a wrestling title that's based on another company, or want to base their game in a fictional wrestling universe?
AEW, ROH, New Japan and more are all companies that deserve video games (Fire Pro World was hardly an exhaustive NJPW title despite the licenses and limited number of New Japan wrestlers on the game's roster). It'd be incredible if Furuta was leading fans down one path because Yukes had something huge hidden behind the bushes on another.
If it's not a totally separate promotion from WWE (because, let's be honest, that might p*ss the organisation right off), then Yukes could develop an NXT game that plays faster than 2K's product. If so, then we're willing to waive the no commentary rule just to hear Mauro Ranallo say "Mamma Mia" when we kick out of finishers.
1. A Gap Between Releases
FIFA, Madden, WWE 2K and more all suffer from the non-stop annual release cycle. The window of development is painfully small, and that's why there are rarely significant changes between each game. This is a trap Yukes don't want to fall into, if only because it's not possible to produce radical improvements in such a short time.
We'd settle for a new wrestling game every three-four years.
If that sounds too long, then consider just how stale 2K's series has become in recent years. Games are released with almost-identical features, only boasting a few small minor additions to give the illusion of advancement. This formula was at its most paper-thin when 2K19 advertised 'Big Head' mode as some sort of top feature last year.
2K can still release WWE games yearly if they like (they are financially successful, after all), but it'd be great to see Yukes give their development team a decent amount of time to get things right before they shove the product out onto shelves/hard drives.
What else would you like to see from a WWE 2K alternative? Let us know down in the comments section below!