10 Things You Didn't Know About Batman: Arkham City
Can you believe we were robbed of a bat shark repellent gadget?
Not to make you feel old, but it won't be long before Batman: Arkham City turns ten. Rocksteady's sequel dropped just before Halloween in 2011 to rapturous acclaim, with many critics and fans calling it not only the best Batman game ever made, but perhaps the greatest superhero game in general.
For good reason as well.
With more confidence and resources than ever, Rocksteady built upon the foundation set by Asylum by doubling down on the elements that worked well, and taking just as many creative risks as they did the first time around.
What that resulted in was a distinctively different sequel - so different debate rages to this day over whether City or Asylum had the ultimate Dark Knight formula perfected - but one which was undeniably bursting with passion, content, and, of course, secrets.
As we know with the first game though, plenty can change from conception to release, and not everything the devs had planned went smoothly...
10. Catwoman's Voice Actor Didn't Know Her Part Until The Day
The world of acting is a pretty mysterious business. With the people behind certain projects doing their best to keep their productions shrouded in secrecy, that often means giving actors the bare minimum amount of information.
Apparently, that ethos extended to Arkham City, where some performers didn't even know which roles they'd been hired for until the day they started work.
The story goes that, allegedly, voice of Catwoman, Grey Delisle, didn't know she was actually Catwoman until entering the recording studio. At the time, someone else had been cast in the role but was replaced at the last minute.
Fortunately, Grey Delisle completely knocked it out the park regardless.
9. Deadshot Threatens Bruce Wayne In The Processing Center
One of the long-running side missions in Arkham City concerns Deadshot, a supervillain running around the city and sniping other inmates, leaving a trail of dead bodies for Batman to find and follow. It's one of the game's more memorable optional encounters, relying on Batman's detective work to track the killer down.
However, it's even more satisfying to complete it and take him out with this detail in mind.
The opening to Arkham City actually has you controlling Bruce Wayne outside of the costume, being escorted through the prison and hounded by inmates. While most of these nondescript goons fade into the background, there is one in particular that tells Bruce Wayne he's on his list. It turns out this is actually Deadshot out of costume.
As a result, when you finally defeat him hours later, the victory feels even more personal.
8. There Are Surprising Connections To Lost
Unsurprisingly, there's a whole bunch of Easter eggs and pop-culture references tucked away in Arkham City that could easily take up its own list. Hell, one of these list entries even originally concerned Luke Skywalker's lightsaber potentially showing up in the Deadshot side quest, but that turned out to simply be the villain's sniper scope at a weird angle. Still, the fact that so many people though it was legit proves just how packed this series is with secrets like it to find.
However, one TV show that pops up more than others in City's references is Lost. Now, this isn't just a target picked at random, but actually stems from the fact that the game's writer, the always excellent Paul Dini, also served as a story editor on the series. I know, there's a surprising trivia fact for you in and of itself.
As a result, everything from a series of repeated numbers that would ring alarm bells for any fans of Lost to goons outright discussing how they didn't 'get' the ending of the show (don't worry guys, I don't think you're alone with that,) can be found in game.
Though he's since retired from Twitter, one of Lost's co-creators, Damon Lindelof, even jokingly responded at the time, tweeting: "Crud. Now I've gone and pissed off the Joker (touche, ARKHAM CITY)".
7. Kevin Conroy And Mark Hamill Finally Recorded Their Lines Together
Though it was incredible to get the old band back together and have Kevin Conroy and Mark Hamill reprise their roles as Batman and Joker for Arkham Asylum, apparently it wasn't all that great of an experience for the actors themselves.
Allegedly, having to record their lines separately in their own individual studio slots made for a process that wasn't totally enjoyable, especially when the pair were used to recording with each other on Batman: The Animated Series.
Fortunately this was remedied for the sequel, and this time around the two were able to bounce off each other in an actual recording studio for their sessions. This was a much more enjoyable experience, and arguably elicited an even better performance from the two actors, especially Hamill who absolutely revelled in this new, sick and twisted version of the Clown Prince of Crime.
6. Rocksteady Knew Robin Would Be Divisive
Outside of comics (and sometimes even in them), the idea of Batman always coming with a Robin has divided creatives and fans alike. Perhaps partly down to The Dark Knight's solo movies (as well as the lingering memories of the Batman and Robin movie), the superhero has mostly been portrayed as someone who works alone, and audiences have come to find the likes of Robin a hard sell.
This, of course, is something Rocksteady knew before including the character in this game. Speaking in an interview with The Guardian, Sefton Hill conceded that not only did the team realise that the sidekick would be met with resistance from some fans, but that some inside their own team may not be totally thrilled with the character's inclusion.
The director confessed how much he personally loved the hero, but acknowledged others may need more convincing, saying:
"It's actually incredible how divisive a character he is, but I think done well and done right, he's got the potential to be an awesome character."
That could explain why he only shows up for a cameo and in the challenge rooms for the sequel, as the studio analysed whether the audience would accept a bigger bat family.
5. Nightwing's Lines Were Cut
As mentioned in the previous entry, adding other members of the Bat family into Arkham City was always going to be divisive.
With Catwoman being playable and Robin as a cameo, Rocksteady were already pushing the boat out a little bit and testing the waters with an audience that might have scoffed at anything other than a solo Batman experience.
Consequently, the team may have worried that adding Nightwing into the story as well would be one step too far. Though he showed up as DLC, it's been speculated that originally he may have played a bigger role, considering voice actor Quinton Flynn (perhaps most famous for voicing Raiden in Metal Gear Solid) was credited with Nightwing's performance, despite the character not having any lines in the final game.
Of course, he played a heavy role in Arkham Knight, so maybe the plan was to give him a similar introduction as Robin in this game. Likewise, maybe they didn't like Quinton Flynn's performance, as the character is played by someone else in Knight, or maybe they simply used some of Flynn's stock grunts for the DLC.
4. Jason Todd's Death Was Teased In The Challenge Maps
On the same theme, with Batman: Arkham City introducing the wider bat-family and Dick Grayson and Tim Drake accounted for, it left fans wondering: where did Jason Todd fit into this universe?
Eventually, they'd get their answer (and probably be extremely annoyed by it) in Arkham Knight, which cast Todd as the primary, titular antagonist. The game extensively focused on flashbacks of his demise at the hands of the Joker, leading to his eventual villain turn and vendetta against Batman.
While comic fans might have pieced this together anyway, it was also hinted at in the DLC challenge rooms for Arkham City. While playing as Robin, Joker will remark: "Wait, didn't I kill you already? No? Well, there's always time." In a less concrete reference during Asylum as well, Joker comments that Batman is in need of a new sidekick, potentially because he recently murdered one of them.
Whether Jason Todd's major role in the story was always planned is anyone's guess, but it's clear that Rocksteady wanted players to know he was part of this world.
3. The Game Director Has A Six Foot Poster Of Batman And Catwoman In His Home
It's not uncommon for people who work on big projects like Arkham City to take some mementos home with them to remember the experience by. Even better, when you're the creative lead and director, you can usually count on first picks of anything on offer, an advantage Rocksteady's Sefton Hill took full advantage of once production wrapped.
As mentioned in his AMA on Reddit, the director commemorated the game shipping by taking home a framed thank you poster written by Mark Hamill himself, as well as putting up a six-foot image of Catwoman and Batman in one of his hallways at home.
Apparently his house is full of Batman memorabilia of this kind as well. Talk about taking your work home with you.
2. Batman Carrying The Joker's Dead Body Was The Story Starting Point
With a lot of stories, writers actually begin with an ending and then work backwards to fill out how the characters got there, and that's pretty much how Rocksteady came up with the narrative for City.
As mentioned in the same AMA, Sefton Hill explained that the image of Batman carrying the Joker's lifeless corpse (just like he carried Jason Todd in the comics) came right at the beginning, acting as a bolt of inspiration to build the rest of the story around.
Considering it was one of the first plot points thought up, it's no surprise that the moment is perfectly executed in the final game. All these years on, it's still such a ballsy move, and Hill explained why he thought that image was so important to the story:
"We wanted to show that even though Batman hates Joker, there's a part of him, which he wouldn't care to acknowledge, that is defined by Joker. Without Joker, Batman is not Batman. That image is Batman coming to terms with that loss."
1. Batman's "Shark Repellent" Gadget Was Originally Usable
When it comes to cut content for Arkham City, there doesn't seem to be too much information out there readily available. Fortunately, from what little we do know about the features and beats that ended up on the cutting room floor in the sequel, it's clear there were some major missed opportunities.
Case in point: the bat shark repellent. While this has only ever really been used during one particularly iconic moment where Adam West's batman fought a shark while hanging from a helicopter (literally the most badass scenario anyone has ever come up with), it's gone on to become something of a cultural joke that everyone understands.
Arkham City was originally going to pay homage to this very moment, during a sequence where Batman similarly comes face to face with a shark, this time called Tiny. Here, he was supposed to whip out "shark repellent" from his utility belt, which wouldn't be a spray, but actually a pair of brass knuckles.
For whatever reason, this great joke didn't end up making it.
Watch Next
How Well Do You Remember Batman: Arkham City?