10 Underhyped Video Games That Blew Everyone Away
These masterpieces came totally outta nowhere.
Given that video games often end up releasing years and years after their first trailer drops, it's fair to say that the industry as a whole is incredibly reliant on the hype machine.
Nothing parts people with their money quite like the promise that an upcoming game will be bigger and better than what came before, even if this often results in tremendous disappointment when a title doesn't meet expectations.
Conversely, it's always a pleasant surprise when a game is actually underhyped on its way to market, most often because the publisher themselves has no idea quite what kind of solid gold masterpiece they'd been sitting on.
These 10 games were all released with average expectations at best - and in some cases, much lower than that - but each ultimately received rave reviews, Game of the Year plaudits, and perhaps even commercial success beyond the wildest predictions.
They all stand as proof perfect that mediocre marketing and a lack of industry buzz aren't always indicators that a game is in trouble or the publisher is embarrassed of it...
10. Batman: Arkham Asylum
The Non-Hype
As much as a Batman video game was always going to stir up some level of interest among gamers, there wasn't much reason to believe that Batman: Arkham Asylum would be anything more than an also-ran addition to the Dark Knight's video game canon.
After all, back in 2009, how many great - or, hell, genuinely good - Batman video games could anyone name?
When you factor in that Arkham Asylum was being developed by Rocksteady Studios, who at the time had only the mediocre FPS Urban Chaos: Riot Response to their name, there wasn't much reason to expect a quality product.
The Big Reaction
But as soon as the reviews landed, it was clear that a surprise hit had arrived.
Arkham Asylum received rave reviews for its fluid combat, strong voice acting, and unexpectedly involved story, causing many prominent outlets - including the famously harsh Edge Magazine - to call it the greatest superhero video game of all time.
Were it not for the fact that Rocksteady thoroughly one-upped the game with its sequel, the excellent Arkham City, Arkham Asylum would probably still be the king of the genre.
Despite most fans expecting another bland licensed superhero game, it ultimately won numerous Game of the Year awards and posted gangbusters sales to boot.
9. GoldenEye 007
The Non-Hype
Much like Arkham Asylum, GoldenEye 007 had the stink of a licensed video game lingering around it, given how terrible the overwhelming majority of video games based on movies were - and basically continue to be.
And that's without even considering the generally low standard of console FPS games at the time.
As a result, GoldenEye released to minimal hype, exacerbated by general skepticism from the games media, who typically gave it unremarkable preview coverage and expressed concern about the project's numerous delays.
A poor showing at E3 1997, just two months before the game hit shelves, didn't help at all.
The Big Reaction
Despite expectations that Star Fox 64 would be the N64's big summer release in 1997, GoldenEye went on to receive near-universal critical acclaim for its uncommonly reverent campaign and especially its ludicrously deep multiplayer suite.
GoldenEye quickly became a system seller and went on to shift 8 million units, making it the third best-selling N64 game of all time, in large part due to the absurd appeal of its four-player split-screen multiplayer.
Better still, it was festooned with countless Game of the Year awards and, despite how dated it is today, continues to be regarded as one of the greatest and most influential games of all time.
Without it, the console FPS never would've flourished in the way that it did.
8. Rocket League
The Non-Hype
Rocket League is a textbook example of a game that came totally out of nowhere and set the world on fire.
Indie outfit Psyonix's previous game Supersonic Acrobatic Rocket-Powered Battle-Cars received wildly mixed reviews from critics, and as a sequel of-sorts to that, Rocket League just wasn't on anyone's radar.
Even though the game's beta phase was well received by players and the game began to pick up some traction thanks to streamers, it still hadn't made a dent with the mainstream.
The Big Reaction
Then Psyonix made the game-changing deal to release Rocket League day one as part of Sony's "Instant Game Collection" on PlayStation Plus.
Though many players understandably have low expectations for games dumped straight to a PS+, the deal immediately got millions upon millions of eyes on Rocket League, with even skeptical players able to give it a quick try at no extra cost.
But most players didn't merely play a match or two and move on: Rocket League quickly became a viral phenomenon with PS4 owners, while also quickly becoming a best-seller on Steam.
Its "easy to pick up, difficult to master" core gameplay loop allowed it to find a huge audience across a wide spectrum of gamers, aided by its subsequent release on Xbox One and, most ingeniously, Nintendo Switch.
For a game that Psyonix expected to be a modest success at best - not to mention everyone else - it's nothing short of staggering that it sold 10.5 million copies within two years of its release, and just recently racked up 75 million lifetime players.
That's without even getting into the continued support Psyonix has provided to players, as well as the various cross-promotions with major sponsors and the fact that Rocket League is now a popular Esport.
7. The Witcher
The Non-Hype
When the original Witcher was released back in 2007, it had all the makings of a niche title which wouldn't break outside of its core fanbase.
Released exclusively on PC by little-known Polish developer CD Projekt Red, The Witcher further walled off the mainstream by being adapted from a series of acclaimed Polish fantasy novels which few in the English-speaking world had ever heard of.
As a result the game was released to a totally muted air of excitement, and few expected it to move the needle much at all.
The Big Reaction
Driven by strong reviews which praised the RPG's high level of immersion, The Witcher overperformed and sold over 1 million copies in its first year, prompting CD Projekt Red to release an Enhanced Edition the very next year, which similarly sold well.
This unexpected critical and commercial success not only saw the release of two highly acclaimed sequels in the years that followed, but also ignited worldwide interest in the source novels, and more recently led to the creation of a Netflix live-action series.
Though the original Witcher might seem a tad clunky by contemporary standards, it was so far and above what anyone expected, and paved the way for the developer to thoroughly outdo themselves with the third game, which is often cited as one of the greatest video games of all time.
6. Deus Ex
The Non-Hype
There was no reason at all to expect much good from Deus Ex pre-release, given that it was the third title released by Ion Storm, the troubled outfit co-founded by hubris-riddled industry legend John Romero.
After the company's first game, Dominion: Storm Over Gift 3, received mediocre reviews, they released Romero's long-awaited, much-delayed FPS Daikatana, which was summarily pummelled by critics and remains one of the most disappointing video games of all time.
Why, then, would anyone expect anything from their third game, a sci-fi-themed action-RPG bearing the esoteric moniker Deus Ex?
The Big Reaction
Deus Ex's secret weapon was veteran video game designer Warren Spector (Wing Commander, System Shock), who was invited by Romero to make any game he wanted at Ion Storm with full creative control and a large marketing budget.
The result was one of the most critically acclaimed video games of the last 20 years, a dense, challenging, and highly innovative project which offered players a near-unprecedented level of freedom.
Deus Ex ultimately scored numerous Game of the Year awards and sold more than a million copies, resulting in three sequels having been released to date.
5. Life Is Strange
The Non-Hype
Episodic adventure game Life Is Strange was released throughout 2015, just as the resurgence of the episodic video game was beginning to reach market saturation, courtesy of Telltale Games flooding the market with an excess of bite-sized stories varying wildly in quality.
On paper Life Is Strange seemed like a pretty basic attempt to cash-in on that formula, to say nothing of its hipster-baiting setting and central characters, which suggested a game perhaps trying a little too hard to be down with the kids.
The Big Reaction
The game ultimately received warmly enthusiastic responses from critics and players alike, who praised the uncommonly strong visual presentation for the episodic genre, the emotional plausibility of the characters, and the generally affecting nature of the story.
Fans became intimately attached to Max and Chloe's story, resulting in the game selling over 3 million copies and receiving more than 75 Game of the Year commendations.
And so a franchise was born, which has since continued with both the prequel series Before the Storm and a largely standalone sequel, Life Is Strange 2.
4. Titanfall 2
The Non-Hype
Titanfall 2 is an especially interesting example because, despite being a sequel to an acclaimed multiplayer FPS, many simply felt that it looked like more of the same - a sequel quickly thrown together two years later to print some more money.
Though developers Respawn Entertainment assured fans that Titanfall 2's campaign would be a major improvement over the original's much-criticised excuse for a story mode, fans were skeptical that they had much new to offer.
It also didn't help that the game was released in an extremely crowded window, hitting stores within spitting distance of Gears of War 4, Battlefield 1, Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare, Dishonored 2, and Watch Dogs 2. Oof.
The Big Reaction
While Titanfall 2's multiplayer suite was predictably well reviewed, what truly caused players to take notice was the shockingly polished quality of its single-player campaign.
Given that truly unique and creative FPS campaigns were few-and-far-between by 2016, Titanfall 2's stole headlines and resonated deeply with those who actually bothered to play it.
Despite its brevity, Titanfall 2's campaign remains one of the genre's best this decade, and the game received a slew of Game of the Year awards off the back of it.
Sadly its ill-advised release date ensured it fell massively short of EA's projected 10 million sales, ultimately selling "only" 4 million copies.
Thankfully the game has remained a cult fave over the years, and its recent Steam release resulted in a considerable surge in popularity. Though it didn't set the world alight sales-wise, it's a game beloved by practically everyone who gave it a chance. Titanfall 3 when?
3. Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice
The Non-Hype
Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice was released in the summer of 2017 to precious little buzz, with many evidently writing it off as just another generic "AA" action game.
It didn't help that the game was developed by Ninja Theory, the team responsible for the fun-yet-divisive Devil May Cry reboot DmC.
With its decidedly smaller budget than that project, Senua's Sacrifice just didn't have the marketing presence or gamer mind-share to make much of an impact.
The Big Reaction
Everything changed once the reviews hit, which confirmed the game to be far more than a self-consciously grim mid-brow action game.
Even critics who weren't too enamoured with the combat or puzzles couldn't deny its unexpected emotional complexity with regard to its protagonist's fractured mental state.
Considering how few video games have dealt with mental illness in a mature and compelling way, Hellblade was a major breath of fresh air, to say nothing of its spectacular, artful presentation.
In addition to selling well enough to break even in just three months - rather than the company's projected 6-9 month window - it scooped numerous prestigious year-end awards, including Best Audio Design, Best Performance (Melina Juergens), and Games for Impact at the 2017 Game Awards.
Better still a sequel, Senua's Saga: Hellblade II, is currently in development for next-gen platforms.
2. Doom (2016)
The Non-Hype
It cannot be understated just how pessimistic fans were about Bethesda's 2016 Doom reboot ahead of release.
From the mediocre marketing to its much-loathed multiplayer beta and the fact that the publisher held back review codes until the day before release, it seemed like the perfect storm for a critical dud.
The Big Reaction
To the surprise of most everyone, Doom ended up scoring rave reviews from many outlets, who praised its frenetic, ultra-violent gameplay, slick presentation, and self-aware tone.
With the dearth of quality, lengthy FPS campaigns by 2016, Doom felt like a jolt of adrenaline to the genre's heart, offering up pleasantly old-school thrills with just enough of a contemporary gloss.
In addition to strong sales, it also landed on countless 2016 best-of lists, leading to the recent release of the sequel Doom Eternal, which ultimately doubled the weekend sales of its predecessor. Who could've seen all this coming four years ago?
1. PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds
The Non-Hype
Back when PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds was released into early access in March 2017, there wasn't much expectation for it to be anything more than another me-too multiplayer shooter to add to the long list - and one that would probably never actually slink out of early access.
The Big Reaction
Shortly after hitting early access, however, PUBG became a stonking hit, with a soaring concurrent player count on Steam which eventually outpaced even the phenomenally popular Dota 2.
PUBG surpassed 3 million concurrent players by the end of 2017, at which point it exited early access. By March 2018, the game has sold an astonishing 40 million copies worldwide in addition to scoring strong critical acclaim.
PUBG's true legacy, however, lies in popularising the Battle Royale genre, which has seen a slew of inferior imitators - and a few worthy successors - attempt to cash-in on the trend.
For a game that basically came out of nowhere to the casual observer, its influence on the industry over the last three years is nothing short of staggering.
Watch Next
How Well Do You Remember Batman: Arkham Asylum?