10 Underrated Video Games Nobody Appreciated In Their Time

How does something as original as L.A. Noire not get a sequel?!

LA Noire 001
Rockstar Games

As much as they say they want it, both video game fans as well as publishers really don't like change. Gravitating towards certain genres, trends and styles of games we're all used to, there's a reason why developers try to create experiences that players are familiar with. In 2007 it was modern first-person shooters and now it's open world games, with the industry leaning into a new craze every few years or so.

Consequently, while these trends obviously stagnate and require a revolutionary new release to move the industry in another direction, games that try to do something new too early are often ignored, criticised, and eventually forgotten about entirely.

Which is a shame, because some of the pioneering titles in the medium's history - your Grand Theft Autos, Resident Evils and Modern Warfares - would never have happened if others hadn't tried and failed to push new ideas beforehand.

Risking revolutionary gameplay styles that would later be picked up and subsequently perfected by other releases, if these ambitious titles came out in another time, they'd easily be considered some of the most significant releases in gaming history.

10. Turok Did Bow & Arrow Jungle Combat WAY Before Far Cry

Turok Game
Propaganda Games

Although it was derided as being uninspired at the time, 2008's reboot of the Turok series actually adopted some rather impressive gameplay mechanics that would go on to become hugely popular in the years following its release.

In particular, the game got in on the 'stalking-enemies-from-the-shadows-and-striking-with-a-silent-bow-and-arrow' trend long before the likes of Tomb Raider or Far Cry 3 were even in pre-production.

That gameplay loop was just as enjoyable in Turok though, made even better at the time by the title's impressive technical features like dynamic grass that actually reacted to your movements rather than disappearing once you passed through it.

It was far from perfect, but considering how much flack the reboot took when it launched for having no original ideas, it should be recognised for establishing a gameplay focus that would dominate the biggest releases in the following years.


9. Virtua Fighter Pioneered 3D Fighting Before Tekken

Virtua fighter
Sega

The very first fighting game to make use of 3D models, Virtua Fighter left the 2D space behind long before the likes of Tekken gained popularity for doing the same thing. Wanting to prove just how revolutionary it was, everything about the game was set up to distinguish its new focus and set it apart from other titles in the genre, right down to its future-focused name.

Unfortunately, despite its pioneering of inventive graphics at the time, the series didn't quite have the gameplay prowess or the personality to attract fans of the more popular fighting franchises.

Street Fighter was still dominating the arcades and was where self-proclaimed 'serious' fighting game fans were going, while Mortal Kombat was gaining traction for its sheer brutality and over-the-top gore.

Still, Virtua Fighter was an enjoyable fighting game in its own right, and offered players a taste of the future long before its competitors would follow suit.


8. Psi-Ops' Phenomenal Physics Sandbox Gameplay

psi ops the mindgate conspiracy
Midway Games

Developed by the criminally underrated Midway Games, on the surface Psi-Ops: The Mindgate Conspiracy looks like any other shooter from the early 2000s.

However, its early adoption of ragdoll physics and upgradable psychic powers that let you interact with enemies and the world in exciting ways marked it out as something special.

Releasing a few months before Half-Life 2, the game was actually first out the gate when it came to physics-based puzzles and combat. The wide array of abilities on display encouraged a sense of interaction with the world that few other games - especially shooters - encouraged at the time, but it might have been that forward thinking (as well Valve's immensely popular release) that killed the title before it had a chance to blossom.

Also, the name probably didn't help either.


7. Vampire: The Masquerade Should Be Up There With Half-Life 2

Vampire The Masquerade Bloodlines
Troika Games

One of the first games to use Valve's Source engine, Vampire: The Masquerade was a technical marvel when it released back in 2004.

Unlike other first-person shooters, Vampire put the focus on interacting with NPCs and enemies, requiring a system that far exceeded what other games in the genre were capable of. Where those releases would feature around 20 character models, this ambitious title had around 150, with an animation pool that reached 3000 individual assets.

Consequently, characters in the game looked better than ever, boasting lifelike animations and facial expressions, but unfortunately so much time was spent perfecting these systems that the game itself wasn't finished on time, and was eventually rushed out.

Suffering from a truncated development period, the title was already handicapped when it hit shelves, and it didn't help that its direct competition was Half-Life 2. It crashed and burned, but while players didn't miss out on not having any future instalments in the series, it should still be remembered for pushing the medium forward when it came to lifelike character models and emotional expressions.


6. Shenmue Pioneered Interactive Environments To The Wrong Generation

shenmue game
Sega

Originally an RPG set in, of all things, the Virtua Fighter world, the original Shenmue quickly sprawled into a much more ambitious project. By far one of the most expensive games of its time, the innovative title eschewed conventional gameplay mechanics and trends to offer something much more character focused and closer to adventure titles than regular open world affairs.

Featuring one of the first persistent worlds of its kind, the sandbox of Shenmue felt like a real lived-in place that would react to your progression throughout the title.

Instead of just being a backdrop, it was a place to explore, discover stories, and provide players with essential resources that would aid them on their quest to investigate the murder of the main character's father.

Unfortunately, because it lacked the set-pieces or the anarchy that everyone wanted from open world games at the time, Shenmue was a failure even in spite of its loyal cult following. These days, thanks to the likes of Persona and Yakuza, there's a big market for alternative experiences like this, but at the time the ambitious project couldn't find the audience it needed to survive.


5. Driver 2 Beat GTA III To The On-Foot Open-World Crime Game Idea

Driver 2
Ubisoft Reflections

While Grand Theft Auto was still a rudimentary top-down shooter, Driver was pioneering open world gameplay on the original Playstation. With the first game allowing players to drive around fully explorable mini open worlds in the shape of iconic American cities, the developers opted to push this vision one step further with the sequel.

Instead of only being able to drive around the city, in Driver 2 players were given the ability to get out of their vehicle and explore certain sections of the world on foot. Sure, it was a bit rudimentary looking back, but there was nothing else quite as advanced as this on PS1.

Of course, GTA III took this same concept and ran with it on the Playstation 2, but the second instalment in the Driver series should still be commended for showing what 3D rendering was capable of creating even on hardware as limited as Sony's first console.


4. Heavy Rain Was A "Narrative Heavy Game" Three Years Too Early

heavy rain shelby
Quantic Dream

A narrative-driven crime thriller, Quantic Dream's Heavy Rain today is considered one of the most interesting releases of the PS3 era. Back in 2010 though, many players wondered whether Heavy Rain could be considered a game at all.

Criticised for being an 'interactive movie' and taking too much control away from players, like Indio Prophecy before it, the choose-your-own-adventure title wasn't given a chance by audiences at the time. Sure, it found some love from the core Playstation fanbase, but not enough to spark a trend in this kind of gameplay.

Had it dropped now, in an era where 2013's The Walking Dead and Gone Home both proved that story-driven titles could be gigantic successes, Heavy Rain probably would have been a bigger deal.

As time has changed, audiences have warmed to narrative heavy games like this, and as a result the developer's upcoming Detroit: Become Human will probably be a much bigger hit than any of the studio's previous releases.


3. Alone In The Dark Invented Survival Horror, Not Resident Evil

Alone in the dark 1992
Infogrames Entertainment

While not the very first survival horror game, the classic tropes and features of the genre can be traced back to 1992's Alone in the Dark. A haunted house tale that made use of the very best 3D effects at the time (which is to say they look absolutely terrible now), the title pioneered things like pre-rendered backgrounds, static cameras and tank controls that the Resident Evil series would perfect a few years later.

Inspired by H.P Lovecraft more than George A. Romero, the title blended gothic horror with pure Lovecraftian terror. Well received at launch, the promising franchise quickly tanked when its two sequels (which released in the two years following the original) received a critical kicking.

Consequently, the series was effectively dead by the mid 1990s, with the final nail in its coffin being Resident Evil in 1996.

Although it tailed off though, survival horror as we know it wouldn't exist without Alone in the Dark, and classic entries in the genre probably wouldn't have been anywhere near as good as they were without it.


2. MGS 2 Was Incredibly Meta In A Generation That Didn't Understand It

Metal Gear Solid 2
Konami

Still considered one of the worst entries in the Metal Gear Solid franchise depending on who you ask, MGS 2 became instantly notorious for pulling off one of the greatest bait and switches in video game history.

Replacing series star Solid Snake with a rookie newcomer, the title constantly subverted fan expectations by essentially being a meta commentary on the first game. Adopting that title's structure, mimicking its villains and outright repeating certain lines of dialogue, the sequel attempted to deconstruct what virtual reality and simulations meant in the modern world.

However, that style of self-aware commentary was completely lost on players back in 2002, and it's taken until now for MGS 2 to finally be recognised as an intelligent and intriguing game that wasn't just a retread of prior glories.

With a whole sub-genre of games being released these days that happily acknowledge when you're playing a video game, MGS 2 set the bar for this self-aware style of storytelling almost a decade before it became popular.


1. Everything About L.A. Noire

LA Noire
Rockstar

Picked up by Rockstar after the game was languishing in development hell, the developers reworked the period-piece detective title into something more closely resembling their other popular franchises.

Consequently, the game made a splash when it released back in 2011, but a lot of players were put off by the lack of action and unique focus on classic adventure mechanics.

Instead of centring the game around shootouts and car chases, the bulk of the title was spent looking around crime scenes for clues, interrogating suspects and piecing together a criminal conspiracy that had infiltrated every level of 1940's Los Angeles.

While some loved L.A. Noire's brand of adventure gameplay, others weren't ready for a big blockbuster release that asked them to do more walking than shooting, and as a result the franchise has been dormant ever since.

Thankfully we've got a full remaster including all DLC coming in November, so perhaps if that makes anything of a splash, Rockstar might finally revisit such a promising IP.


Watch Next


In this post: 
LA Noire
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.