10 Unfair Dark Souls Enemies

Which enemies and bosses in the Souls series felt like they were playing dirty?

You Died 3
Bandai Namco Games

While the Souls series prides itself on being difficult but fair, there are definitely moments when it seems like it is falling a little short and moving towards being decidedly unfair.

These moments can be brought to you by specific enemies, bosses, and even by particular areas. It is testament to how well-made and enjoyable the series is that these events and encounters stick out so prominently in the memories (and nightmares) of players, even if they stick out because they drive you insane.

Everyone has their own bugbears and specific enemies that bother them more or less than the average player, but there are some enemies that most would agree make you feel like the deck is stacked against you. The ones that you dread dealing with on new playthroughs or decide ahead of time to avoid and run past.

Looking at the current trilogy of Dark Souls games, what are these small blights on an otherwise tough but enjoyable experience? And what is it about them specifically that makes players feel that way? Here are some suggestions.

10. Bonewheels - All Three Games 

Dark Souls Bonewheel Skeleton
FromSoftware

Skeleton enemies that are attached to a wooden spiked wheel (hence the name), the Bonewheel Skeletons made their first appearance in the original Dark Souls and Remaster. Located mainly in the Catacombs and Painted World, they could prove especially difficult to deal with.

Their main attack was to roll towards the player at high speed, stopping only when they hit a wall or were deflected by a shield.

Manageable one on one or in small numbers, the trouble really started when they were in groups and in open spaces where it was very easy to get hit. Once you were hit, you'd be stunlocked by a party of attacking wheels, leading to your death or losing a chunk of health.

They did reappear in Dark Souls 2, being summoned by the Skeleton Lords boss and hanging around in the basement of the Majula mansion. They were also found in the Catacombs of Carthus in Dark Souls 3, but either through redesign or player improvement, they never seemed to pose the same controller-snapping threat that the original version did.

That is to say they were just hugely irritating, instead of downright unfair.


9. Jailers - Dark Souls 3

dark souls jailers
FromSoftware

These floating harbingers of doom were found in the Irithyll Dungeon, holding a lantern in one hand and a branding iron in the other, which was named a “Soldering Iron” in game for reasons that are never made clear.

They had a line-of-sight attack where the lantern would turn red and your life would start draining. Until you got out from their view, your health would keep ticking down and once the effect was gone, you would need to heal all the HP that had stolen.

The main issue is with the enemy placement. They feel as though they are placed in long corridors and locations where it is nearly impossible to not get most of your health stolen by this attack and if you got close too them, being hit with the soldering iron meant that you couldn’t use your estus flask to heal.

It also increased your equip load which could mean players ended up fat-rolling their way to an untimely death.

One room in particular housed many of them patrolling in a loop and the only way to pass was to snipe them one at a time with a bow or run past. Not fun or fair.


8. Basilisks - All Three Games

Dark Souls Basilisk
FromSoftware

A mainstay of the series and making an appearance in all three games, these frog-like creatures didn’t pose a threat because of any direct attack they had. They didn’t hit hard, they took few hits to kill and you had to get supremely unlucky to die to them directly.

What they are more infamous for is an attack that built up the player’s curse status. Although this mechanic existed in Dark Souls 2 too, the effect was a lot less brutal – you lost some health and became more hollow.

In the first and third games, once that curse bar filled up, you died. Instantly. Leaving behind a petrified statue and a great sense of remorse. In the original game, once you were cursed, even after dying, harsh penalties remained. Your health was halved and a skull replaced the humanity counter on your bar.

While there were no lasting penalties in Dark Souls 3, there were a few more locations where these enemies were bunched together and it became fairly easy to get overwhelmed and surrounded with no way to avoid the curse-clouds being spat all around you.


7. Any Swamp Or Water Level - All Three Games

Dark Souls Blighttown
FromSoftware

If a game is released in this series and doesn’t have a hugely frustrating poison swamp or water-based level, is it even a Souls game? The fascination that the games developers seem to have with this concept is clear because they seem hell-bent on including some form of it in every iteration.

The original game had Blighttown. A much-loved and definitely not infuriating level where enemies tried to toxic you, falling to your death was far too easy and best of all, standing in the swamp itself built up poison and drained your health slowly.

Harvest Valley in Dark Souls 2 was the box ticked for that game. Pools filled with poisonous gas, enemies and loot to entice you in. Nothing makes a game more enjoyable than forgetting you’ve been poisoned, running out of moss and dying because you got distracted.

And Farron Swamp in Dark Souls 3. Most notable location of the Basilisks, they were more dangerous than ever here since your movement was slowed by the swamp. And it poisoned you as well, because of course it did. Using any dagger's weapon art let you quickstep even in the water and is highly recommended.


6. Royal Rat Authority - Dark Souls 2

Royal Rat Authority
FromSoftware

Found at the Ordeal’s End bonfire in the Doors of Pharros, this boss was at least optional, so no one was forced to fight it if they didn’t want to. The problem wasn’t the rat itself, or even the fact that it looked an awful lot more like a dog than a rat. The problem was the four smaller rats that spawned at the start of the fight.

The way the fight was going to go was decided by how this first part went. If you killed them all, then beating the main boss would be a piece of cake. Stay under the body and swing at the legs. If the smaller rats managed to inflict a status-effect like toxic on you, you’re as well just giving up then and there because it isn’t going to end well.

There doesn’t seem to be any rhyme or reason to when this did and didn’t happen so it felt a lot like RNG. A bit of luck in a Dark Souls boss fight is not something that you ever want to rely on.

Casting lingering flame and luring them into it is cowardly, shameful and worth doing.


5. Dogs - All Three Games

dark souls Undead Burg
FromSoftware

The classic annoying enemy that never seems to get any easier to handle. The humble dog has been harassing players throughout the series and doesn’t seem to want to quit.

The best strategy tends to be either hide behind your shield and attack once they’ve bounced off you, or just run past. They seem to be found in groups and their lunging and biting is always timed so that there is never a good moment to get your retaliation in.

On top of all of that, they are low to the ground and some attacks can whiff clean over them, leaving you vulnerable and open again for another bite. In the third game especially, they had a huge aggro range, chasing you seemingly forever. And don’t worry, if you have high stamina and should be able to outrun them, the game will literally teleport them right behind you. Because of course it does.

Best advice is to either lure one at a time with a bow, use a shield and a low-profiling weapon with a wide swing, or just hit the legs and leave them for dust.


4. Poison Statues - Dark Souls 2

dark souls 2 gutter
FromSoftware

Poison was highly effective in the second Dark Souls game, which worked both in your favour and against you. A highly upgraded bow with poison arrows let you trivialise some of the largest and most hard-hitting enemies in the game from a safe distance.

Almost as though the game had realised you were cheesing too many enemies, it decided to let Black Gulch and The Gutter even the score a little. Statues were scattered all over these two levels and some of them spat at you as you passed, which occasionally had knockback and built up poison.

Sure, you could painstakingly smash them all one by one, but it was easier to just run past, accept you’re going to get tagged a bunch, and hope you remember to heal.

The element of luck and RNG was what made these things unfair. Sometimes you could sprint and roll past without being hit. Other times, you’d get caught once, stunned, hit another five times and then smashed over the head by an NPC red invader. No logic to it at all.

Better make sure that every time you visit Gavlan for these game-breaking poison arrows, you buy some of his moss as well.


3. Exploding Mummies - Dark Souls 2

Dark Souls
FromSoftware

Dark Souls 2, much more than the other two games, seemed to think that equipment breaking was a fun mechanic. They must have, when you look at all the various ways it could be accomplished. Corrosive urns, acid pools and the pyromancy Acid Surge were all capable of breaking rings and equipment in pretty short order.

The worst offenders by far were the suicide-hollow mummies. There are a couple of variations on the theme but their general attack was to run towards you, fling themselves on the ground and then explode for some beefy damage.

The ones in Dragon Aerie were particularly annoying, as they had an acid explosion and seemed to be hidden around every corner in places you wouldn’t expect. Often, the first warning you would get was an explosion, the sound of your Third Dragon Ring breaking, and then you were heading back to the bonfire to go get your stuff repaired.

Not enjoyable to sit through multiple loading screens to get everything repaired, only to warp back and get surprised by another mob that you hadn’t noticed and have to repeat the exercise over again.

Best handled with a bow, patience and plenty of repair powder.


2. The Rampart Hedgehog And Reindeer Combo - Dark Souls 2

Dark Souls 2 Frigid Outskirts
Bandai Namco Games/FromSoftware

Frozen Elyum Loyce was the main location in the Crown of the Ivory King DLC for Dark Souls 2 and housed two of the cheapest and most unfair enemies in the game. The “Rampart Hedgehog” to give it its real name had all the issues of the bonewheel skeletons had, and then some more.

Did they do insanely high damage if you were caught in their rolling attack? Check. Were they usually found in groups? Yup. Could you be damaged just by standing near them? Yeah, that too.

The Frozen Reindeer were found in the Frigid Outskirts on the path to Lud and Zallen. A blizzard blows across this level, leaving you small windows where you can see your destination in between snow blindness. These would appear out of the whiteness and trample you for a big chunk of your health.

Best of all, the game just spawned them near you at certain points, no matter which route you took.

The area became hated for this run to a boss and got a pretty vulgar nickname that I won’t say here. They were the definition of unfair.

Best advice is to summon NPC phantoms, sprint to the gate and hope they pull aggro.


1. Bed Of Chaos

Bed Of Chaos
FromSoftware

In a game like Dark Souls, at the very core of the gameplay is the idea that you can learn. Even through dying repeatedly, enemies and bosses will do the same attacks in the same way and with time, anyone can learn how to react and avoid enough of it to succeed.

This is why the Bed of Chaos in Dark Souls 1 is the very definition of unfair. One of the most frustrating boss fights in the series and for all the wrong reasons. There are many elements of chance to this encounter and it flies against everything that the game has been teaching you up to this point.

The floor underneath you breaks away leaving pits and insta-kill drops. The boss has sweeping limb attacks that always seem to throw you down to your doom. You need to perform a running jump between these attacks to reach the centre of the Bed of Chaos to kill it.

You take everything that the game has taught you so far about managing bosses and throw it out the window because this boss feels like it was dropped here out of another game. The original unfair Dark Souls enemy and probably the worst offender.


Watch Next


The IMPOSSIBLE Dark Souls Quiz: How Far Will You Get?

Dark Souls Boss
FromSoftware

1. Easy: In The First Dark Souls Game What Is The Name Of The First Boss?

In this post: 
Dark Souls
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Matthew is a Marine Engineer to trade who writes sub-standard Scottish crime fiction in his spare time that can be found here:- https://mmacleodwriting.uk/ Originally brought up in the Western Isles of Scotland, he lived in Edinburgh for 18 years but now stay in Aberdeenshire with his partner, sons and dog.