10 Video Game Achievements That REALLY Needed More Thought
These achievements betrayed the very idea of video games.
Whether you love them, hate them, or just don't care about them, achievements and trophies are a cornerstone of modern video games.
At their best, they can provide a meaningful incentive for players to remain glued to a game, and at their worst, they can exploit players' most primal, obsessive compulsive tendencies.
And then there are those 'cheevs which have clearly been implemented without the developers actually employing anything close to critical thought.
These 10 achievements, whether making absurdly unfair demands of the player, failing to consider key technical aspects, or forcing players to betray the actual design of the game itself, were all totally misguided in both intent and execution.
As such, it won't surprise anyone to learn that most of these achievements have been unlocked by only a small fraction of players committed or bored enough to put in the leg-work.
In extreme cases, the backlash was even severe enough that the achievement was actually changed by the developers themselves.
For most players, though, these unhinged achievements elicit nothing more than an eyeroll as they consider the many other things they could do with their time instead...
10. Grab Bag - Turok (2008)
The Achievement
Kill at least 1 creature, 1 enemy, 1 teammate, and yourself in the same round of a public match.
Why It Needed More Thought
Achievements were still in their conceptual infancy back in 2008, and developers often didn't think much about how achievements needed to reflect the design philosophy of the game itself.
Case in point, 2008's Turok reboot, which encouraged 'cheev hunters to literally kill their own teammates and then themselves during online matches in pursuit of a measly 10 Gamerscore.
Because the game's achievement list was revealed many months prior to release, players were able to express their outrage ahead of time, raking developer Propaganda Games over the coals for effectively incentivising griefing and anti-social play.
The backlash was significant enough that Propaganda ended up releasing a day-one patch to modify the 'cheev, removing the team-kill requirement entirely.
If nothing else, Turok makes a solid argument for achievements being published far in advance of a game's release if possible, giving players ample opportunity to call out any achievements created in bad faith or without sufficient thought.
9. Hail To The King - Final Fantasy IX
The Achievement
Jump rope 1000 times without tripping and obtain King of Jump Rope.
Why It Needed More Thought
For starters, Final Fantasy IX's infamous jump rope mini-game can literally take players longer to master than the game's linear 40-hour campaign.
Pulling off 1000 flawless consecutive jumps requires players to exhibit frankly superhuman reflexes for seven-and-a-half minutes, jumping in time with a rope which periodically changes its speed and pattern.
If the sheer difficulty isn't bad enough, Square Enix clearly didn't consider how much more difficult it is to complete on a modern HDTV with a wireless controller, both of which introduce more lag compared to the CRT TVs and wired controllers generally used when the game was released back in 2000.
This is the achievement most likely to prevent you from getting the game's Platinum trophy, and some players got desperate enough that they literally coded a script to run through the PS4's Remote Play app and automate the jumping. Madness.
8. The Gold Spender - SSX (2012)
The Achievement
Collect all Gold Global Events Badges.
Why It Needed More Thought
On paper this sounds simple enough - collect the various event-specific badges by simply playing the game, except that one of them is contingent on the number of players online.
One of the badges requires players to "compete in an event with 50,000+ players," per the game's massive multiplayer Global Event system.
It's a neat idea in theory, though like many ambitious multiplayer-centric trophies wasn't implemented with much consideration for the future.
Somewhat hilariously, EA optimistically assumed that 50,000 people would be regularly playing Global Events at the same time, but per the game's softer-than-expected sales, this was far from the case.
Within days of SSX's release, the online player count had dipped irreversibly below 50,000, and so many players were effectively blocked from getting an otherwise relatively easy Platinum trophy.
EA at least had the good sense to make things right, as a few months later they patched the badge to automatically unlock for all players. Even so, it's a rare achievement that threw a developer's hubris right back at them.
7. Et Tu, Brute? - Battlefield: Bad Company 2
The Achievement
Online: Knife 5 friends.
Why It Needed More Thought
This is another achievement that just didn't consider the realities of online play. The 'cheev requires players to be in an online match with at least one person from their friend list who also happens to be on the opposite team, and then stab them to death five times.
For starters, not everyone plays video games with their friends - we've all got busy lives, after all - and even if you do have a friend to play with, ensuring you end up on opposite teams is basically a roll of the dice.
If there are two slots available on the same team, the game will automatically team you together, so you need to hope you join the match with one open slot per team.
And even if you get this far, the achievement basically encourages you to boost, by communicating over party chat, meeting up with your friend at a secluded spot, and then taking turns stabbing each other so you can both pop the 'cheev.
Doing it for real, against a friend who is playing competitively while avoiding all the other players, is nigh-on impossible.
6. Lightning Emissary - The Last Guardian
The Achievement
Reach the end of the game in 5 hours or less.
Why It Needed More Thought
This speedrun achievement isn't that challenging if you're willing to put in the work and get to grips with the game's cumbersome AI, but on a philosophical level it feels entirely at odds with The Last Guardian's core ethos.
This is a game that begs the player to stop and smell the roses at every possible moment, and to savour the growing relationship between the boy protagonist and his giant pet creature Trico.
Considering that a playthrough can easily take upwards of 12 hours, encouraging players to sprint through the artful experience in record time just feels like an achievement added because the developers had a list they needed to fill.
5. The Bladder Of Steel Award - Rock Band 2
The Achievement
Complete the Endless Setlist 2 without pausing or failing.
Why It Needed More Thought
This achievement is a cruel exercise in punishing the player and, in particular, their bladder. It requires players to complete the Endless Setlist 2 - which is a marathon of all 84 songs in the game, totalling over six hours in length - without failing a single song or pausing even once.
What this means is that players aren't able to hit pause to head to the toilet, and in the event their controller battery dies late in the game or they accidentally hit the pause button while strumming, they've wasted a huge chunk of their day.
There are obvious strategies to improve the experience - make sure you've got brand new batteries or use a wired controller, and tag-team the setlist with a friend - but for many players popping the achievement requires not eating, drinking, or going to the toilet for six hours, which sucks to say the least.
Given that holding your pee for hours at a time can literally kill you, it's probably not something the game should be encouraging so brazenly.
4. And They'll Tell Two Friends - Borderlands
The Achievement
Play in a co-op game with either an employee of Gearbox or someone who has this achievement.
Why It Needed More Thought
If you played Borderlands upon launch, this achievement wasn't too bad. Even if you never teamed up with a Gearbox employee, it wasn't that hard to stumble across someone who had, allowing you to pop the 'cheev by proxy.
But the further away from launch we got, the harder it became to unlock due to both the lesser presence of Gearbox employees online and those who got the achievement early.
Years later, you'd have to keep cycling through random co-op match-ups in the faint hope that one of them had the achievement and could pass it on to you.
Gearbox eventually realised how poorly thought-out it was, though, as 2019's Enhanced Edition revised the achievement to be far simpler - you just needed to play co-op with at least two other players for it to pop right away.
3. Power Of Two & Dynamic Duo - Ninja Gaiden Sigma 2 Plus
The Achievements
Successfully complete all missions on Normal difficulty.
Successfully complete all missions on Turbo difficulty.
Why They Needed More Thought
The PS Vita port of Ninja Gaiden Sigma 2 takes ill-conceived achievements to a whole new level.
Team Ninja effectively just transferred the 'cheevs from the PS3 version of the game over to the Vita version without considering the differences between the two platforms.
The big problem stems from the fact that the Vita version doesn't have online co-op play unlike its console counterparts.
As a result, the co-op missions - which needed to be beaten to unlock these two trophies - paired players with a hugely inferior AI teammate. On top of this, the game's performance on the handheld is atrocious.
Without a skilled human comrade, beating the co-op missions even on Normal difficulty is literally impossible, meaning the two trophies have only ever been unlocked by a small handful of players who took advantage of a Vita exploit.
This also means that most all players have been prevented from unlocking the game's Platinum trophy. As baffling as all the achievements on this list are, this one really takes the cake.
2. More Heist Less Speed - Thief (2014)
The Achievement
Finish the game in 15 hours or more.
Why It Needed More Thought
Though achievements can present a fun and creative way for players to experience a game, in the case of 2014's Thief reboot this achievement simply prolonged a thoroughly underwhelming time for most players.
The game's main campaign can be comfortably beaten inside of eight-or-so hours, but to pop this' cheev you needed to hang around for almost double that time.
A 'cheev that encourages you to soak in the game world sounds fair enough in theory, except that Thief doesn't really have much on offer for curious players, and is basically just a waste of their precious time.
It's certainly not a hard achievement - you can just idle on a roof or a safe spot within The City to add time on the clock - but one that just ties up your platform of choice unnecessarily without much in the way of actual entertainment value. It is as perfunctory and pointless as achievements come.
1. World Champion - Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter
The Achievement
Climb to the top of the universal leaderboard.
Why It Needed More Thought
Many online-centric achievements are a pain in the ass, but most of them seem completely trivial compared to the "World Champion" 'cheev in Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter.
The 'cheev can only be unlocked by claiming the #1 spot on the game's worldwide multiplayer ladder, an ask so absurd that many players have begged Ubisoft to remove the achievement over the years to no avail.
Today, it can only realistically be unlocked by leaving numerous Xboxes running in tandem for literally months on end, the latest time estimate coming in at an outrageous 4000 hours.
Even then, there are enough players still trying to get the achievement now that you're unlikely to hold onto #1 for very long. This is surely the achievement most likely to drive a human being insane - an abomination that shouldn't exist.