10 Video Game Bad Endings BETTER Better Than Good Ones
Cyberpunk 2077's secret cutscenes.
Generally speaking, video games like to divide their endings between the good and the bad ones. The good endings tend to require more effort to attain but promise greater payoffs, while the bad endings are mostly treated as punishments for failure or finishing the game the easy way.
However, sometimes this golden rule of gaming can be broken, and the bad ending can feel more right than the supposedly good one. Despite the developers leading you to believe that you’re getting punished for not playing the right way, the "terrible punishment" of your character turns out to be far more satisfying than whatever the alternative has to offer.
It’s almost as though the developers wanted you to play their game the wrong way.
Let’s examine some of the best and worst endings the video game world has to offer. Although everyone wants you to believe they’re there to punish you, in reality, they’re likely the most satisfying endings you can get.
10. Going Back For The Money - Red Dead Redemption 2
Although the main cast of Red Dead Redemption 2 are all hardened criminals, most players tend to keep Arthur's honor levels relatively high. The man is just too loveable to turn into a scoundrel or to make him turn on his friend during the final act of the game.
The last Arthur mission in Red Dead Redemption 2 has the player decide between helping John Marston escape from the Pinkertons gang or leaving John to his fate and going back for the robbery money you've left behind in Dutch's camp.
Naturally, ditching John is considered a bad choice, but on the other hand, no one can deny that Arthur turning back and taking revenge on all the people who betrayed him is easily one of the most badass moments in the game.
From Arthur's rage-filled taunts to the epic soundtrack playing in the background, the scene makes you feel like a total menace. To top it off, you get to have a proper knife fight with Micah and leave him some scars to remember Arthur by.
It may not be right to leave John behind, but at the same time, this choice is the right way to say goodbye to Arthur.
9. Take The Treasure - Rayman 2: The Great Escape
Some games enjoy giving the player a fake moment of choice where one of the options usually leads them straight to a game over. These moments tend to act as jokey punishments for trying to choose the easy way out of a situation.
However, in Rayman 2, there is no punishment for acting lazy. In fact, the game lets you enjoy your laziness in a tropical paradise.
In the level called "The Cave of Bad Dreams," Rayman comes across a floating one-eyed monster named Jano. Aside from his dapper top hat and cool skull-decorated cane, Jano is also in possession of a huge pile of treasure, which he uses to tempt Rayman into giving up the fight with him.
The player can choose to take the bait or reject Jano's offer and fight him. Normally, you'd assume that the game would want to punish you for acting greedy; however, if you accept to take the treasure, Rayman actually gets what he wants. He's instantly teleported to a remote tropical island, where he gets to retire and enjoy his riches in peace.
Considering the "good" ending is just more of the usual fighting and getting into danger, the wrong choice has never felt so right.
8. Teaming Up With Father Elijah - Fallout: New Vegas
While it's certainly fun to play the lone hero in New Vegas, the kind that always carries a big iron on their hip, the game also lets you play as the villain of your story. Typically, this means joining the Legion or killing every unfortunate NPC that crosses your path.
This said, there is another, secret way to finish New Vegas as the ultimate monster, and even though it's considered a bad ending, it is still the best ending any diabolical player can hope for.
New Vegas' DLC, Dead Money, is centered around the location of Sierra Madre, where a mysterious red mist either kills or horribly mutates anyone who enters it. The DLC's main villain, Father Elijah, seeks to weaponize the mist and unleash it upon the Mojave so that he may "wipe the slate clean."
You're obviously meant to oppose Elijah, but you can also secretly team up with him if you want to. This prompts a special cutscene in which you and Elijah kill everyone by unleashing the Cloud and become the Mojave's enigmatic overlords.
The cutscene does cause the game to end, but then again, you've already conquered the land, so you don't really have a reason to keep playing.
7. Easy Ending - Earthworm Jim: Special Edition
Earthworm Jim is one of those games that likes to laugh at people for playing on lower difficulty settings. It does so with a special punishment ending for beating the game on easy mode; however, the joke is so elaborate and unique that when compared to the regular ending, it ironically feels far more rewarding.
Normally, when you beat Earthworm Jim, the only thing you get is a simple game-over screen congratulating you on your victory. It's just a still image with a couple of words and then a quick fade to black.
However, if you're playing the game's special edition and you beat it on the lowest difficulty setting, the boring game over screen is replaced with one of the developers "punishing" you by calling you out and then delivering a long and convoluted lecture about the life cycle of real-life worms.
Ah, yes. Everyone must feel so humiliated, getting this special treatment and learning something interesting in the meantime. That will definitely show them not to chicken out and play your game on easy mode!
6. Sacrifice Yourself - Dragon Age: Origins
No one really likes to see their favorite character die. It's even worse when it's your own player character, not to mention one that you spent a considerable amount of time creating and leveling up.
For this reason, out of all the endings in Dragon Age: Origins, the one in which your Grey Warden sacrifices themselves in order to destroy the Archdemon and save Ferelden (without doing the ritual with Morrigan) is considered the worst ending in the game. It's painful to see your character go after you gave them so much of your time.
However, at the same time, letting your character die does come with a unique opportunity: seeing what your companions, as well as other characters, think of you. After you die, the game's epilogue plays out from the perspective of your fellow Grey Warden, and you get to see what legacy your character has left behind.
The sacrifice ending includes some fun and touching moments, like Allistair rebuilding the Mage's Circle in your name if you're a mage or the city elfs gaining independence due to your elf's sacrifice.
The ending does such a great job of commemorating your hero that it's almost a shame if they stay alive.
5. Staying With The Song - Furi
The hack-and-slash bullet hell Furi is a game where you play as a mysterious prisoner trying to escape his elaborate confinement. You spend the whole game fighting and killing your jailers, only to, spoiler alert, discover that your character was an alien invader all along and that you were sent to the jailers' planet to determine if it was worthy of destroying.
In the "good" ending of the game, your character betrays the aliens and destroys their mothership in order to save the planet. But let's be real: dooming your own species while also having to kill nine innocent people beforehand hardly sounds like a victory.
Luckily, the game's "bad" ending offers a much more satisfying solution.
The ending is a secret game-over screen that you can activate before fighting the Song, the sixth jailer, who promises to be your friend if you abandon your fight.
If you wait in front of the battle arena long enough, the game will actually let you comply with the Song's plea. This will prompt a cutscene in which your character sits down with the Song and the jailer tells him she'll take care of him forever.
Now you have a friend, you didn't have to kill all nine jailers, and you're not a traitor to your own species. It feels nice to lose, doesn't it?
4. Siding With O'Dimm - The Witcher 3
When it comes to The Witcher 3's Heart Of Stone DLC, most people agree that siding with Gaunter O'Dimm is not right. Gaunter is a soul-stealing demon, after all, and his deal with Olgierd was clearly twisted to ensure Olgierd would suffer and lose everything in his life.
However, while it is true that O'Dimm is the villain of the story, siding with him and letting him consume Olgierd's soul is actually the lesser of two evils.
You see, even before Olgierd was cursed with becoming an unfeeling monster, his life was centered around raiding and pillaging. He was always a thrill-seeking and selfish person who was not above sacrificing his own brother's life just so he could marry the love of his life.
When Geralt saves Olgierd, the man has nothing to live for. His brother and wife are dead, and his family's fortune is all but gone. Combine this with Olgierd's past and personality, and it's very likely that as soon as the curse is broken, Olgierd will return to drowning his sorrows in reckless fights and terrorizing local villages.
The choice here is really between punishing one guilty man or letting the world suffer the whims of a depressed maniac.
3. (Don't Fear) The Reaper - Cyberpunk 2077
In the finale of Cyberpunk 2077, your character V needs to storm Arasaka Tower with Johnny Silverhand and their closest companions in order to determine the fate of the megacorporation.
There is a slight problem, however. If you never bothered to help out your friends, it's very likely they won't be willing to go on a suicide mission with you...
"(Don't Fear) The Reaper" is a secret bad ending in which V needs to take down Arasaka solo as no one answers their call. It only triggers when the player waits long enough during the final conversation with Johnny, and interestingly enough, it is the only ending that doesn't allow you to save or reload your game.
When you die, the screen simply fades to black, and the credits roll.
Now, although the concept of an actual suicide mission sounds pretty bad in theory, this ending is easily the most badass thing you'll ever experience in Cyberpunk. The finality of everything, combined with the fact that your V becomes a one-person army, killing everyone in their path, makes this the only ending that solidifies your status as a Night City Legend.
After all, a good samurai is a lone samurai.
2. Escaping With Otacon - Metal Gear Solid
Usually, when the game kills off your character's romantic interest, it does so in a really dramatic and gut-wrenching fashion. It's supposed to be the lowest moment in the character's life that makes you realize you've probably led them down the wrong path.
Well, except when you're playing Metal Gear Solid. Here, the death of your sweetheart is just another excuse to hang out with your favorite buddy.
The original Metal Gear Solid game features two distinct endings. One in which you escape the compound in the final mission with Meryl, Snake's potential love interest, and one in which you let Meryl die and you end up leaving with everyone's favorite geek, Otacon.
Since the latter ending is a direct result of Meryl's death, it's technically considered a bad ending. However, in reality, escaping with Otacon is just as good, if not better, than it is with Meryl.
Sure, Snake is initially distraught by his partner's death, but Otacon is quick to cheer him up, and afterward, the two of them share a heartfelt moment talking about each other's aspirations and making awkward movie references.
It's a gloriously campy ending that's so good, you'll completely forget you had to let Meryl die to get it.
1. Usurpation Of Fire - Dark Souls 3
When it comes to lore, there are two types of Dark Souls players: those who spend hours meticulously analyzing every piece of information, and those who look at the funny onion-shaped knight, laugh, and then go on with their lives.
If you're part of the latter, you probably view the three Dark Souls 3 endings as just the same boring bossfight followed by slightly different cutscenes talking about ashes, cinders, and other fire-related things. However, lore-wise, the three endings are actually about deciding the fate of the world. And it just so happens that the basic "good" ending is the worst fate you can subject it to.
The primary story of Dark Souls is almost entirely focused on the world's Cycle of Rebirth. The world keeps resetting, preventing everyone from dying and making everyone go insane. Your character's goal in Dark Souls 3 is to rekindle the Flame that keeps the world going, prolonging its suffering.
However, if you manage to corrupt your character throughout the story and make them abandon their mission to usurp the Flame for themselves, the world can finally break out of its maddening cycle, ushering in a new curse-free age.
See? This is why you read up on lore.