10 Video Game Bad Endings You Can Get By Pure Accident
No one likes to be punished for something they didn't know about.
Bad endings in games are a form of punishment for doing something wrong. You typically get them for failing an objective or neglecting it. However, bad endings can also happen by sheer accident.
Sometimes what ending you're going to get is not determined by your skills or knowledge of the game but by a streak of bad luck or the irrational whim of the developers.
These endings are the not-so-happy little accidents that fall upon unwary players for something that wasn't even their fault.
Sometimes it's the result of an arbitrary requirement that no one in their right mind would be able to figure out, sometimes it's caused by dumb chance that doesn't even give you a chance to defend yourself.
Whichever case it may be, the end result is a catastrophic cutscene that shows off your characters suffering the worst possible fates, as though the game wanted to punish you for something you had no control over.
Getting a bad ending stinks, but getting it due to an honest accident is even worse. For this reason, if you don't want to experience an unwanted surprise at the end of your playthrough, be sure to check the following list!
10. Don't Do What You're Told! - Dredge
Dredge is an interesting fishing game with an eldritch twist. Instead of a relaxing time in nature, it puts you in dark waters filled with Lovecraftian horrors, where you have to catch only slightly less Lovecraftian fish.
The game has a main story with two radically different endings that are determined by completing its main objectives.
Now, you’d think that this would mean finishing all of the main objectives would lead to a good ending, but no. It’s actually how you get the bad one!
Yes, if you unknowingly follow the main story without exploring the world, your character is devoured by a huge monster as they accidentally attempt to summon an old cosmic entity.
This is because the game reveals to you that the objectives were implanted into your head by the eldritch god in question, and the entire time you were unwittingly following their orders.
To avoid this fate, what you actually have to do is ignore the main quest completely and follow a chain of clues scattered across the entire world.
Considering a lot of new players don’t even know how to operate their boats, you can probably tell how many first playthroughs accidentally conclude with the bad ending.
9. The Slave To Bhaal - Baldur's Gate 3
Baldur’s Gate 3 features a variety of different endings, including some specifically related to the origin of your main character.
The Dark Urge origin comes with three such unique endings, determined by how you’ve dealt with your murderous calling throughout the game. You can reject your evil heritage and look for a better life; you can embrace it and become the murder lord of the world... or you can accidentally push yourself too far and become a mindless killing machine that pisses themselves at the thought of stabbing someone in the back.
The last ending is considered to be the worst of them all, not only because your character is reduced to a rabid beast, but also because in the end it’s implied you kill all of your companions.
This outcome is incredibly easy to get by accident, as in order to get it, you have to completely submit yourself to Bhaal’s influence for the entire game, but then decide to go against your unholy father’s wishes right at the end and destroy the Elder Brain instead of taking control of it.
You might think you're having a heroic change of heart, but in reality you're dooming yourself into becoming an even worse monster.
8. Do The Main Mission, And Fail - Fable III
The ending of Fable III is divided into two stages. After you ascend to the throne, the game informs you that the Crawler and his army of darkness are about to destroy Albion, and you have 121 days to build a force strong enough to stop them.
Normally, this part of the finale consists of you seizing each and every day to the best of your ability, gathering money for your cause, and keeping up the morale of your kingdom until you’re ready to face the Crawler.
However, there is a way to accidentally speed up the process and suddenly find yourself in the final fight without sufficient funds.
You see, although you have 121 days, if you decide to start the main mission quest on your strategy map at any point in that period, finishing it will immediately push you forward in time to the final day.
Without knowing how the mission works, it’s really easy to accidentally undermine all of your progress during the preparation period and set yourself on collision course with the game’s bad ending.
That quest must’ve been really tiring if it takes a hundred days to sleep it off.
7. Ciri Dies - The Witcher 3
In Witcher 3, most of the story is based on the decisions and actions Geralt makes. Each choice has the possibility of changing the course of game, however, you never really realize how great the scope of your decisions is.
Which is why some players probably get a nasty surprise when it turns out Ciri has died in their ending!
You see, the ending of the game is entirely dependent on how Geralt treats his protege throughout the story.
If you act supportive of Ciri and encourage her to pursue her own goals, the confidence she builds helps her save the world from the Wild Frost and walk away from her encounter with it alive.
On the other end, if you have been overly protective or too strict with her, Ciri will die in the process, saving the world but at the cost of her own life.
Since the game doesn't tell you the course of the final mission is completely in Ciri's hands, most players are shocked when it turns out none of the choices they make matter.
In reality, they matter a lot. It's just those choices that you made a few chapters ago.
6. Collect All Things, Lose The Game! - Blair Witch
The whole point of collectibles is to, well, collect them! It’s what games have been telling us to do ever since the first Mario Bros. and all of the shiny coins scattered across its levels.
However, this kind of logic does not apply to the Blair Witch game, because if you take the time to collect all of its dolls and carved figurines, you’ll be set on course to getting the worst ending in the game!
That’s right! Blair Witch is an incredibly manipulative game that sets you up for your own failure. Every time you follow your gaming instinct and fight monsters instead of avoiding them or pick up things that clearly look like collectibles, the game brings you closer to the bad ending where your character becomes possessed and takes the place of its main antagonist.
To get the good ending, you have to avoid all of the things you’re naturally drawn to. This is pretty difficult to do even when you’re already aware of the twist, because picking up even one figure can already doom you to losing, and you can probably tell how hard it is to dodge small collectible objects while navigating through a dark forest.
5. An Actual Suicide Mission - Mass Effect 2
Mass Effect 2’s ending is easily the most iconic one in the series, as it involves planning an entire suicide mission where the tiniest little mistake can cost you the lives of your squad members, or even Shepard themselves.
The choices that you make during the planning sequence are incredibly crucial to your success, but unknown to most players on their first playthrough are the many optional missions that you are supposed to complete before the finale.
Yes, whether you complete the mission or die trying is dependent on how much you’ve dabbled in side content. How well each member of the squad does during the operation depends on your relationship with them and whether you’ve completed their personal story missions. You also need to purchase a number of upgrades for your ship, or else you won’t be able to do certain actions during the mission.
If you’ve rushed through the game, thinking you can leave any side mission for another playthrough, your negligence will turn into a series of horrible accidents in the final mission, culminating in the death of the entire crew of Normandy.
It’s called a suicide mission for a reason.
4. Bad Kwarma - Oddworld: Soulstorm
Oddworld: Soulstrom is the new shiny entry in the cult classic Oddworld series. The game follows the mechanics of the original Abe’s Oddysee pretty closely. Your goal is to help Abe navigate his way to the end of the level without dying, and you can rescue some of his fellow Mudokons on the way.
Like in Abe’s Oddysee, how many Mudokons you save determines what ending you get. However, Soulstorm tallies up your number of rescues differently to Oddysee, which is why you can aim to get the good ending but still get the bad one on accident.
You see, whereas before Abe’s Oddysee counted the total number of rescues for your ending, Soulstorm counts the percentage of saved Mudokons in each level individually.
To get the good ending, you have to save 80% of Mudokons in at least 12 levels, meaning that even if you have the perfect score in a few levels and dozens of freaky aliens following you, it still may not be enough to save yourself from a catastrophe.
And oh boy, if the bad ending isn’t a catastrophe with a capital C! It punishes your neglect by blowing up Abe and everyone he’s saved in a terrifying and fiery explosion!
3. Mash The Button! But Not That One! - Resident Evil: Revelations 2
Nobody likes forced quick-time events, but you know what’s worse than an unnecessary button mash? An unnecessary button mash that punishes you for following its cues!
It may sound like a sick joke, but this is exactly what happens in Resident Evil: Revelations 2. In fact, the QTE in question is how the game judges if you deserve to get the bad ending!
In the third chapter of the game, when Claire and Moira fight mutated Neil, you get a quick-time event as soon as the monster pins the former to the floor.
The game asks you to mash the right button to have Claire pick up her gun and shoot Neil in the face, so you naturally do what you’re told... and then get the ending where Alex Wesker possesses Natalia.
What you’re actually supposed to do to get the good ending is use another button during the QTE to switch to Moira and shoot Neil with her instead. The game tells you how to do it, but in the heat of the moment, it’s easy to go straight for the quick-time event and ignore it on accident.
Especially since the decision doesn’t really have much to do with the finale.
2. Everyone Dies - Dragon Age: The Veilguard
The new Dragon Age: The Veilguard takes a lesson from Mass Effect 2’s school of final missions and gives you a chance to carefully organize your assault on Tearstone Island. You have to make good use of your companions and the different factions you’ve allied throughout the story, putting everyone in charge of different tasks.
And here is where another similarity to Mass Effect 2 strikes, because how effective everyone is in their task is largely dependent on how you’ve interacted with them before the final mission.
To get the good ending, you need to have completed the personal storylines of the companions you put in charge of different duties and made the correct choices during your dealings with the factions.
On top of that, you still have to assign the right people to their preferred stations, as even if the companion respects you, they may not have the skillset to finish the task.
It’s really easy to mess something up on accident without knowing how to prepare for the finale, and if you do, you get to see all of your companions die one by one, followed by the game’s gentle reminder that they weren’t the "best choice" for the job.
Judgmental much, game?
1. Don't Exit The Game - Banjo-Kazooie
Being able to take a break in the middle of your gaming session is really important, and in most single-player games, you're free to quit the game and start from where you left off at any point you'd like.
Most, because in Banjo-Kazooie it's the easiest way to earn the game's worst ending.
Yes, this classic Rareware platformer doesn't let you save and quit during the final level of the game. If you do, the game will not go to the main menu and instead bring up the final cutscene where the evil witch Gruntilda steals the cuteness of Banjo's sister Tooty, transforming the girl into a creepy monster and herself into a runway model with a very apparent green complexion.
It seems even Tooty's charms, which are supposedly the greatest in the world, can't wash off that iconic swamp tan.
Anyway, going back to the ending, the fact that the game doesn't let you know quitting would lead to this kind of outcome has obviously left plenty of children back in 1998 pretty upset, if not downright traumatized. The betrayal probably made them never want to pause for dinner ever again.
Not that they needed an excuse, of course.