10 Video Game Betrayals Nobody Saw Coming

There's no honor amongst thieves... or Assassins.

Uncharted 4
Sony

There's something so inherently appealing about seeing someone you love being betrayed in a story. Maybe it's because a good twist like this fools you as much as it does the character, punishing you for trusting even the cuddliest sprites. At that point it becomes more than just you watching a story unfold: it's personal.

It doesn't have to be as big as someone you thought was on your side turning out to be the main villain the whole time or maybe a serial killer with a devilish origami fetish (though that does admittedly help), it could be a betrayal as small as a white lie which transforms into a whole web of deceit that leaves a virtual friendship shattered.

No matter the severity, it's essentially the equivalent of getting Catfished by the game developers - and boy, does it never get old.

--

10. Lance Vance - GTA Vice City

Gta Vice City Lance Vance
Rockstar

Rarely does a GTA game go by without one of the thugs that make up your in-game friends betraying you, be it Big Smoke in San Andreas or Dimitri in IV, so you should be expecting to be double crossed while playing Vice City, but it still comes as a huge surprise.

For one, Lance Vance is the coolest dude around, despite being one of the game's biggest liabilities from the beginning. He and protagonist Tommy team up to overthrow Ricardo Diaz, but then the white-suit wearing scoundrel starts to become irritated by his friend constantly berating him and calling out his reckless behaviour. Despite that, you never think a man who invented something as cool as the Lance Vance Dance could ever sink fully to the dark side.

That's exactly what he does though, and Vance eventually sells out his pal to his old crime boss, walking Tommy directly into a trap which ends in a Scarface-eseque shootout. As he says, it doesn't matter if they were once brothers; this is Vice City, and it's only business.


9. Pavel - Metro: Last Light

Metro: Last Light
Deep Silver

You first meet Pavel in the depths of the Reich in Metro: Last Light, coming across the prisoner and immediately watching as his friend gets executed before his very eyes. He promises to answer his tormentor's interrogation questions as long as your character, Artyom, isn't in the room. That's the first sign that he's probably hiding something, but you don't really question it at the time because, well, you've got a gun pointed to your head.

Either way, you both escape and seemingly set out with the same goals, and he even leads you through the dangers of the underground. After completing a few missions together you head for a celebratory drink. However, Pavel spikes your cup and knocks you unconscious, revealing himself to be a high-ranking undercover member of the Red Line the whole time.

You end up in the reverse situation of how you found him, with Artyom being held hostage by the man he thought was his friend. Fortunately it ends with the exact reverse of that first meeting as well, with Pavel being overpowered at knife point.


8. Darth Vader - The Force Unleashed

Star Wars Force Unleashed Darth Vader
EA

Look, I know it seems obvious that you probably shouldn't put your faith in frickin' Darth Vader of all people - especially when he stabs your character Starkiller through the chest at a moment's notice just to hide his own cover - but his plan to use his new secret apprentice to overthrow the Emperor in The Force Unleashed does initially seem watertight.

Unfortunately, it turns out that Starkiller's purpose was never to overthrow old Palpatine at all, but rather expose his enemies and wipe out any potential for a fully-formed resistance actually posing a threat in the future.

The plan was a bit of a mess in all honesty though, as it actually indirectly birthed the beginning of the resistance rather than stopping it completely. The Sith's arrogance was his downfall once again.


7. Lucy - Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood

Assassin's Creed
Ubisoft

Though the cast of Assassin's Creed found outside of the Animus is usually pretty throwaway, in the first few games there were a couple of compelling characters which kept this part of the story compelling. Perhaps the most important was Lucy, who essentially became Desmond (and the player's) right-hand partner in taking down the Templars. Which made it all the more shocking when she was killed off in Brotherhood.

However that game also teased that Lucy may have been an undercover agent the whole time, and actually working for the modern day Templars. Her death was still a shock, but this implied that at least she maybe had it coming.

The betrayal hit deep, but the worst part about it was how slowly it was revealed, with players not finding out until the next game's DLC just whose side Lucy was actually on. It ended up being similar to the "will they, won't they?" found in a sitcom like Friends, but with Templars and Assassin's swapped out for Ross and Rachel.


6. Alphys - Undertale

Undertale game
Toby Fox

Nothing is ever as it seems in Undertale, yet for some reason you leave your caution at the door when you bump into Alphys during a trip through the Hotlands.

Maybe it's the fact that they accidentally created an entertainment murder-bot obsessed with being the biggest celebrity in the underworld or their love of nerd tat that lulls you into thinking they're not capable of being just as devious as everyone else you've met, but they're immediately one of the most likeable characters in a game packed with lovable rogues.

However, while Alphys seems to be essential in getting you out of sticky situations, in particular handily putting the stop to insta-death lasers which block your progress, it's then revealed that she was the one who laid those traps for you in the first place.

It wasn't done in a malicious way to try and kill you or anything - you were never in any real danger - but after watching your journey and seeing your star rise, Alphys decided to selfishly insert themselves into your narrative to occupy a helper role, undoing challenges they were secretly responsible for.


5. Iron Bull - Dragon Age: Inquisition

Dragon Age Inquisition
EA

Okay, so this betrayal technically happens in Dragon Age: Inquisition's Trespasser DLC, but it was so surprising and such a major moment in the game's overall narrative that it absolutely deserved a spot on this list.

Throughout the main game Iron Bull is one of your strongest companions, with his romance option in particular being one of the best and most heartwarming in the whole cast. Unfortunately, when it comes to the DLC, unless you've completed Bull's personal quest (and even if you have and accidentally got his friends murdered), he'll turn on you in a heartbeat just before its climax.

Admittedly you have to be a little terror yourself a let the Chargers - essentially the only family he has left - get killed. However, even if you do save them and your approval rating is low he might still turn on you, meaning you can't entirely guarantee his allegiance, especially if you haven't read up on it beforehand.


4. Mark - Life Is Strange

Life Is Strange
Square Enix

Mark Jefferson initially appears to be one of the good guys in Life is Strange, being the stern-but-fair tutor who seemingly wants to help protagonist Max fulfil her potential at university. He was essentially the teacher you always wanted growing up: a caring, cool mentor who understood the plight of teenagers stuck in a rut.

That charming demeanour later gave way to his true nature as a cold, nihilistic killer, however. Though he gained success as a popular photographer, he became obsessed with capturing the "moment innocence turns into corruption" in his subjects, manipulating people to get what he wanted and murdering at least half a dozen victims in the process.

It turns out he was nothing like those cool teachers from school at all, but actually had more in common with the slimy ones who'd find any excuse to send someone straight to detention.


3. Eric - Tony Hawk's Underground

Tony Hawk's Underground
Activision

Tony Hawk games were never going to win any awards when it came to their narratives. After all, from Underground onwards they were pretty much just Jackass skits pasted in between skate competitions. That only makes it even more impressive, however, that they managed to create a genuinely loathsome nemesis in Eric Sparrow.

The player character's best friend in the first THUG release, the two of you rise the ranks together, breaking out of their s****y New Jersey suburb by impressing Jesse Peralta and going on to rub shoulders with the biggest and best skaters in the business.

Unfortunately, along the way your best pal gets a little jealous that you're getting all the attention doing McTwists over helicopters, and it turns out he's been sabotaging your success the whole time, even getting you dropped by your team and sponsor.

Admittedly, in hindsight one look at this guy should have told us all we needed to know about him.


2. Sam - Uncharted 4

Uncharted 4 Sam
Naughty Dog

Uncharted 4's entire reason to exist is Sam Drake, Nathan Drake's long lost brother who brings the adventurer out of retirement for one last treasure hunt. Naughty Dog needed a pretty good reason to ruin Nate's domestic bliss, so they had his sibling return from the dead, having broken out of jail with crime lord Hector Alcazar and forced to work for him, unless have his head on the chopping block.

However, halfway through it turns out there was no grand breakout at all, no debt needed to be repaid, and no Hector Alcazar.

The whole story was a way for Sam to get his brother back in the game and finish an adventure they started as kids. It's motivation which makes him far from a villain, but it's a certainly a dick move to put Nate's home life in jeopardy and lie to him after so much time away.


1. Vincent - A Way Out

A Way Out
EA

A Way Out unashamedly revels in prison and crime movie cliches, to the point where the majority of its narrative is familiar on paper, but is saved by the care and attention put into the execution. Of course, no game influenced so heavily by this genre would be complete without a last minute betrayal, but the beauty of EA's title is that the eventual twist still takes you by surprise.

Maybe it's because main characters Vincent and Leo seem so genuine all the way through, with their stories and motivations for helping each other creating a properly, brotherly bond between them. That affection does turn out to be real, but it can't save the breakdown of the relationship when it's revealed that Vince was actually a cop the whole time, using Leo to get revenge on his brother's killer.

From that moment, one is destined to die, and while everyone knows it has to happen, it doesn't make it any easier on either the player, or the character, to be the one who pulls the trigger.


Watch Next


Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.