10 Video Game Bombs That Made ONE Fatal Mistake
These games were all their own undoing.
Much as 2023 marked a banner year for quality video games of all shapes and sizes - even as the industry is seriously struggling at present - it is an undeniably unforgiving medium where developers can spend years working on a new game, only for it to flop at launch.
Sometimes the reasons for this aren't easy to ascertain, but there are also instances where a game's commercial failure was extremely obvious even to casual, outside observers. And so, you have to wonder what those in charge were thinking at all.
These video games all failed to sell as their publishers hoped on release, and yet, it's also clear that each of these games failed to attract players en masse for one very specific reason.
Sure, they may have been imperfect in a number of ways, but there's one particular, overpowering factor which kept every single one of these games from enjoying commercial success.
If nothing else, they should all serve as loud warnings for what developers and publishers positively shouldn't do when both making and releasing a game.
Things didn't have to be this way, but because someone was asleep at the wheel, they all landed with an epic thud...
10. Not Releasing Free-To-Play - Crash Team Rumble
Granted, you can argue that Crash Team Rumble's mere existence is one big mistake, given that Crash Bandicoot 4 developer Toys for Bob were forced to make the multiplayer party game instead of the fifth Crash game fans actually wanted.
All the same, on paper this wasn't exactly a terrible idea, especially considering the popularity of 2000's Crash-themed Mario Party knock-off Crash Bash. But Activision made one major miscalculation which demonstrated a fatal misunderstanding of the current gaming market.
Crash Team Rumble launched for a retail price of £25/$30, and while that certainly can't be dubbed a rip-off price point, many fans nevertheless felt that it should've been a free-to-play game, given the scant amount of content and relatively repetitive gameplay loop.
In an era where free-to-play games are commonplace - and typically funded, with varying degrees of success, by battle passes and cosmetic microtransactions - Crash Team Rumble seems like an optimistic relic, no matter that the core gameplay is completely fine, if certainly not remarkable.
It's unlikely that the game would've been a smash hit were it free-to-play, but at least it probably wouldn't have been beaten by a two-year old Peppa Pig game on launch.
9. Marketing Itself As Another Bland War Shooter - Spec Ops: The Line
The marketing for third-person shooter Spec Ops: The Line seemed hell-bent on selling it as the most generic war-themed cover shooter imaginable, but that approach apparently proved too dully cynical even for Call of Duty fans, who largely ignored this game when it launched in June 2012.
Once reviews were out in the wild, though, it became clear that Spec Ops wasn't just another chest-beating slice of military fetishism, but a more cerebral, thoughtful, and disturbing thriller about the psychological toll of war.
The trailers did basically nothing to highlight this facet of the game's story, focusing instead on adrenalised set-pieces and little else.
And so, in a genre already wildly oversaturated by empty spectacle, Spec Ops posted disappointing sales, in turn contributing to Take-Two's underwhelming financials in 2013.
Time has at least been kind to the game, which endures as a bonafide cult classic today, no matter that it was recently delisted from all online storefronts due to expiring license agreements.
8. The Toys-To-Life Business Model - Starlink: Battle For Atlas
At a cursory glance, 2018's action-adventure game Starlink: Battle for Atlas seemingly indicated yet another publisher attempting to hitch themselves to the toys-to-life gravy train, with players able to attach toy ships, pilots, and weapons to their controller in order to instantly load them into the game.
Yet by 2018 the toys-to-life genre was already well into its steady decline, and so Starlink basically felt a bit dated and desperate before it even actually released.
More to the point, Ubisoft didn't do a great job of clarifying that Starlink's toys-to-life elements were entirely optional, with many surely taking a single look at the plastic-strewn marketing and dismissing it as yet another clutter-fest money-sink.
Starlink could've been a modest success if it simply focused on filling the void left by the largely dormant Star Fox franchise - but more on that later - yet by encumbering itself with a risky, costly gimmick, it basically sealed its own fate.
Surprising few, Starlink underwhelmed commercially, prompting Ubisoft to stop producing physical toys for the game barely six months after release.
7. Not Releasing On PS2 & Xbox - Shenmue
There's no denying that the original Shenmue was a massive financial gamble, given that it was not only the most expensive game ever produced at the time - with an estimated budget of up to $70 million - but also released exclusively on Sega's Dreamcast.
Yet considering the Dreamcast's small install base, Shenmue would've needed to sell twice to every console owner in order to turn a profit, making it painfully clear that Sega should've also ported the game to the PS2 and Xbox in short order.
Their failure to do this had wider ramifications for the series, as though Shenmue II was released on the Xbox, players' inability to easily play the first game beforehand set it up to flop, which it did.
Things could've been so different for the franchise if Sega adopted a multi-platform strategy earlier on.
Ultimately it would be almost 20 years before the original game was finally released on PlayStation and Xbox consoles, by which point the ship had long since sailed and sunk.
6. Trying To Please Everyone (And Pleasing NO ONE) - Saints Row (2022)
Marketing 101 dictates that, above all else, you need to make the audience aware of exactly what your product is, and that was the critical failure of Volition's 2022 Saints Row reboot.
Sure, we all knew it was the latest entry into the developer's hit sandbox action franchise, but the marketing failed to clarify precisely who it was made for.
Trailers and previews painted a wildly mixed picture of what Saints Row was trying to be - at once tidying up the series' edgier past and trying to make the central characters more likeable, while still retaining some of the IP's signature silliness.
And yet, the result was a game that tried too hard to appeal to everyone and, consequently, left few satisfied.
Newcomers felt like they were being cynically pandered to while core fans of the series felt that its identity had shifted too far away from that of the more unhinged earlier games.
Even the fact that the gameplay is grossly unpolished couldn't have entirely doomed it if it had the charm and personality of the previous Saints Row games.
But instead it felt like a lamely corporate wax-work impersonation of the series that never once passed the sniff test, and so flopped epically.
5. Being Too Short For The Price - The Order: 1886
To be clear, games should be as long or as short as feels organic for the developers, but the price should also reflect that, as was the neon-signposted undoing of the PS4-exclusive third-person actioner The Order: 1886.
Though the marketing certainly did a solid job showing off the game's gorgeous graphics and intriguing steampunk London setting, there was much concern leading up to its release about its apparently short length for the full-fat AAA asking price.
Mere days before launch, developer Ready at Dawn estimated that first-time players would take 8-10 hours to beat the game, and given that "dev maths" is most definitely a thing, it was reasonable for players to knock at least a few hours off that ballpark figure.
And indeed, once The Order hit stores, players soon enough found themselves clearing it in less than six hours, even without making an especially hurried rush through the story.
Given that the game had little replay value, no multiplayer, and roughly half the play-time was comprised of cutscenes, many felt that it simply wasn't worth the price Sony was asking for.
Just a month after release, Sony responded by permanently slashing its price by one-third, though it's safe to say that the smarter option might've been delivering a beefier single-player experience upfront.
While we shouldn't undersell the enormous effort that goes into making any game, for a $60 price tag it was reasonable to expect more, and though artificial bloat is a bane of the industry, The Order's compelling world-building surely lent itself to a much larger canvas and more substantial campaign.
4. Releasing During A Crowded Month - Titanfall 2
EA had only themselves to blame when Titanfall 2 flopped upon release in 2016, because it certainly wasn't a result of the game's quality.
Respawn Entertainment's deliriously entertaining FPS sequel touted killer multiplayer and one of the genre's most memorable single-player campaigns of the last decade, so what went wrong?
It's almost embarrassingly simple, really - EA rather overconfidently released the game in late October, a mere week after Battlefield 1 hit stores and a week before Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare came out.
By sandwiching this decidedly more niche FPS franchise - the first iteration of which crucially never released on PS4 - between the two most popular FPS brands of the era, it was always going to be playing second or third fiddle.
And so, despite scoring rave reviews, Titanfall 2 flopped at retail, selling roughly 25% of what its predecessor did during its release week, even with the sequel additionally launching on PS4.
This could've been so easily avoided had EA simply nudged the game's release date back a few months. Instead, EA failed to let a potential future cash-cow grow, ensuring Titanfall has been left on ice ever since.
There is a small sliver of hope for Titanfall 3, though, given that the second game saw a resurgence in popularity when it finally launched on Steam in 2020, with thousands of players still playing online daily.
3. Oversaturating The Market - Guitar Hero Live
Once upon a time, the Guitar Hero franchise seemed absolutely bulletproof, with Guitar Hero III becoming the first video game in history to sell more than $1 billion at retail.
But in the years that followed, publisher Activision received vocal criticism for oversaturating the market with an increasing number of Guitar Hero titles, including band-centric spin-offs, yet doing little to sufficiently evolve the experience.
After the sixth main game, Guitar Hero: Warriors of Rock, underperformed in 2010, Activision put the franchise on hiatus until 2015, when they returned with reboot Guitar Hero Live.
While the nifty new guitar and GHTV music video mode were praised, it simply wasn't enough to move the needle with the many millions who had grown tired of the series, and so the game posted disappointing sales.
Guitar Hero was an undeniable cultural touchstone throughout the mid-to-late 2000s, but by flooding the market with so many middling releases, Activision practically invited fans to tune out permanently.
2. Going AAA Instead Of AA - Immortals Of Aveum
By most accounts, Ascendant Studios' recently released magic-themed FPS Immortals of Aveum is a decent enough game - if not one many rushed out to purchase.
With "Mostly Positive" user reviews on Steam and a fair 69 Metascore, it seems to be an acceptably mid-tier offering which, if budgeted responsibly, could've done just fine commercially.
Yet the game was far more of a dice roll for Ascendant than it seemed, given that production ended up costing an eye-watering total of $125 million.
That's a price tag similar to those of more recognisable titles like Destiny and Shadow of the Tomb Raider, and clearly far too high a cost for what the game actually is.
Though Immortals of Aveum's title, premise, and gameplay all felt categorically AA, the impressive visual fidelity was certainly AAA-caliber, suggesting that Ascendant mistook the broader appeal of what they were making.
Few are coming to a game like this for the pristine, world-class graphics, and so with a more modest presentation, Aveum could've cost drastically less and consequently launched for a AA price tag instead.
Reigning in the PC system requirements would've also made the game more accessible to a wider swath of players, given that many customers found themselves struggling to run the demanding title on even capable rigs.
Ascendant CEO Bret Robbins himself even admitted that Immortals of Aveum would've performed better at a lower price point, and in an era where game budgets seem to be spiralling out of control, there's a clear lesson to be learned from Aveum's ill-judged scope and resulting costs.
1. The AWFUL Control Scheme - Star Fox Zero
Even accepting the major commercial disadvantage that Star Fox Zero had by releasing on the doomed Wii U, it should've been a solid seller relatively speaking, especially as it was the beloved series' first mainline entry in an entire decade.
But immediately upon launch, the discourse was dominated by one thing and one thing only - those godawful controls.
The game's obtuse, arcane control scheme - complete with mandatory motion controls - felt unnatural from the jump and never seemed to grow on the player-base at large.
Critics and players alike were highly critical of them, which many felt ruined the entire experience and surely did its sales performance no favours at all.
Ultimately the game became the worst-selling Star Fox game in Japan and ended up shifting less than 500,000 copies globally. Considering that even Splatoon - an entirely new Nintendo IP - managed to sell almost 5 million units on the Wii U, that's an utterly shambolic showing.
And while Star Fox Zero wasn't exactly a great game even if you fix the controls, this was absolutely the reason that so many bounced off it in record time - if they even tried it at all.