10 Video Game Boss Fights That Broke The Rules

A boss should be something the game controls... right??

Demons souls old monk
Sony

Boss fights are a cornerstone of most action-orientated video games, and it's not unfair to say that most of them stick to a pretty rigid formula - one way or another, hack away at a giant health bar until the big bad boss is dead.

And so, those boss battles which dare to stray from typicality are all the more alluring as a result, proving what brilliance can be produced when developers dare to do something different with a most basic aspect of the medium.

These 10 boss fights all ripped the rule book up and forged ahead on their own, bucking convention with their fiercely singular encounters which asked players to switch-up their styles and think a little differently about what a boss fight should be.

With just one unfortunate, near-game-breaking exception on this list, these boss fights all proved what great encounter design truly is, while also confirming just how tough it is to innovate in this well-trod area.

Boss fights that deviate from the norm this aggressively only come around every now and then, so when you experience them, make sure to savour them...

10. Famed Mimic Gogo - Final Fantasy V

Final Fantasy V
Square Enix

The Final Fantasy franchise has featured plenty of gimmicky boss fights over the years where players are encouraged to take a right-brained approach to defeat the enemy before them.

But even then, Final Fantasy V's Famed Mimic Gogo is a major outlier in that all the player has to do in order to progress through the fight is...a whole lotta nothing.

Those who immediately strike him will find that Gogo hits back with massive attacks which cause 9,999 damage - basically, traditional combat is a one-way trip to the grave for all but the most skilled players.

But Gogo does give players a cute little hint in the pre-battle banter when he says, "Could you imitate me, you'd certainly win."

And because Gogo is doing nothing but standing on the spot, that's all you need to do also. After about a minute of failing to select an option, Gogo will praise you for mimicking him before banishing himself and handing over the crystal shard for the Mime job.

It's completely antithetical to the ethos of Final Fantasy, RPGs, and video games in general, but for once the pacifist route truly is the easiest.


9. Mr. Freeze - Batman: Arkham City

Batman Arkham City Mr Freeze
Rocksteady

Though the Batman: Arkham series touts a disappointingly low number of truly creative boss fights, the Mr. Freeze battle from Arkham City is ingenious enough to basically compensate for that.

Widely regarded to be one of the best boss battles of the last decade, its brilliance lies in forcing the player to put so many of their well-honed skills to good use while also being unable to rely on just spamming their favourites.

Once the player has successfully used one of their tactics against Freeze, he will find a way to block that ability - most often by literally freezing it out, and if you're playing on Hard difficulty, you'll need to beat down Freeze eight different ways before the fight comes to an end.

By continually changing up Batman's combat options, it's a staggeringly diverse battle which effortlessly subverts boss fight cliches.

Unfortunately it's also an exceptional enough encounter that the final showdown against Clayface didn't have a hope in hell of living up to it.


8. Any Boss - Deus Ex: Human Revolution

Deus Ex Human Revolution Barrett
Eidos

Sadly not all rule-breaking boss fights are actually for the better, as anyone who has ever played the great Deus Ex: Human Revolution can surely testify.

Upon launch, countless players complained about the game's four boss fights, which with their mandatory combat effectively punished players who had focused on creating a stealth build character.

And so, many had to either try and cheese their way through the fight or actually put the game down entirely, because while the fights weren't mechanically complex in the slightest, they contradicted the previously established rule that stealth is always an option.

It was later revealed that these boss battles were outsourced to another developer due to time constraints, and it really shows.

The complaints were pervasive enough that Eidos eventually revamped the fights for the Director's Cut re-release, allowing players to defeat the bosses through stealth and hacking.

As much as creative rule-breaking can result in a boss fight quite unlike anything else, developers who contradict their own internal gameplay logic also risk alienating players en masse.


7. Valithria Dreamwalker - World Of Warcraft

World of Warcraft Valithria Dreamweaver
Blizzard

Even the most casual observer will be aware that World of Warcraft's more epic boss fights are typically defined by a raid of players organising themselves to take down a colossal behemoth that boasts a titanic amount of health.

But the fight against the Valithria Dreamwalker, a captured green dragon, bucks conventions because it flips the condition for victory.

Instead, you need to heal Valithria up to full health all while fending off the many mobs hell-bent on stopping you.

What's really great about the battle is that it's a rarest of boss fights to grant the focal role to healers, rather than simply having them support DPS and tank builds as per usual.

In a game so thoroughly concerned with bigger, badder bosses, this was a neat change of pace.


6. Saren - Mass Effect

Mass Effect Saren
BioWare

The first Mass Effect offers up a neat negation of the typical late-game boss fight by giving players the option to effectively forego the battle - well, one stage of it, anyway - by just talking their way out of it.

Near the end of the game, players with sufficiently high levels of Charm can actually skip the initial throwdown with Saren, instead convincing him he's in the wrong, after which he pulls his gun and shoots himself in the face.

It's a supremely shocking moment for anyone expecting a conventional fight, and though Saren is indeed brought back as a Sovereign-reanimated husk-thing afterwards, the initial fight against Saren's ordinary form can be circumvented entirely. How's that for different?

More than anything else, it's a testament to just how much weight BioWare placed on your character development and the power of words in the first game. Shame it didn't carry through to the third game, though...


5. King K. Rool - Donkey Kong Country

Donkey Kong Country King K Rool
Nintendo

Donkey Kong Country's final boss fight against King K. Rool seems pretty conventional for the most part - right until he falls down defeated, in fact.

After skirting clear of his attacks and leaping on his head a few times, K. Rool's day seems to be done, the end credits rolling as players get to sit back and toast themselves a job well done.

Except, those few who actually bother to read the end credits scroll might realise all is not well: most of the production credits are awarded to Donkey Kong's Kremling foes, and after about a half-minute, the credits will end and K. Roll will surge back to life for a second go-around.

Those who dealt with K. Rool easily enough the first time won't struggle too much here, though it's also highly likely you were caught off-guard when he woke back up.

The message here was simple - even when you're absolutely, positively sure you're safe, think again.


4. The Other Player - A Way Out

A Way Out
Hazelight

A Way Out was director Josef Fares' follow-up to Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons, a game which required the player to control two brothers simultaneously - one with each thumbstick.

A Way Out is an evolution of that concept, a two-player co-op experience where players each control a convicted criminal, with the stories unfolding in parallel both together and apart.

But the game's ingenious rug-pull comes in its final "boss" encounter, where after hours of working together to escape, protagonists Leo and Vincent are pitted against one another after it's revealed that Vincent is an undercover cop.

The climactic sequence is an epic showdown between the two players, ending with each man wounded and scrambling to pick up a gun first. Whoever gets the gun ends up shooting the other dead.

Forcing players who've been collaborating for the entire game to suddenly get combative with one another was a totally neat and unexpected twist on what players expected after playing through Fares' previous game.

Hopefully his upcoming co-op joint It Takes Two might find yet more creative ways to experiment with both co-op play and boss battle conventions.


3. Sans - Undertale

Undertale Sans
Toby Fox

To be completely fair to Undertale, the game as a whole is entirely concerned with breaking rules: you're conditioned from early on to expect the unexpected, with its meta tone continually recontextualising RPG tropes.

Players who decide to kill everything in sight and complete Undertale's ultra-challenging Genocide Route will end up facing off against Sans as the game's true final boss - and he sure is a "bad time," just as he promises players who continue their slaughtering ways.

The game's boss fights are largely defined by the rules of bullet hell games - that is, avoiding obstacles within a confined box.

But in the Sans fight this is all thrown out, with both the constantly adjusting size of the box and Sans' ability to attack you even while you're navigating the UI.

It is, in a word, completely ridiculous. To make matters even crazier, to finally defeat Sans you need to wait a few minutes for him to fall asleep and then push the combat box to the bottom-left corner of the screen over the "Fight" option.

Even for a game so thoroughly invested in inverting RPG formula, the Sans fight is like nothing else you've ever played.


2. Old Monk - Demon's Souls

Demon's Souls Old Monk
Bluepoint Games

FromSoftware are virtually unparalleled in their ability to craft unforgettable and intimidating foes who will strike players down time and time again, but Demon's Souls plays host to one especially off-kilter boss battle.

What's so brilliantly unique about your fight against the black phantom known as Old Monk is that it's highly likely he'll actually end up being controlled by a human, given that invading players are able to commandeer Old Monk.

Defeating a Dark Souls boss with a more predictable AI routine is tough enough, but a flesh-and-blood human whose moves can't so easily be telegraphed? That's something else.

Of course you're entirely able to simply play the game offline if you'd prefer a more dependable, learnable fight, but the addition of a human combatant absolutely helps Old Monk offer up a totally unique experience to everything else in the game.

With the recent release of the game's PS5 remake, Old Monk has naturally been given a major resurgence in popularity.


1. Psycho Mantis - Metal Gear Solid

Metal Gear Solid Psycho Mantis
Konami

The Metal Gear Solid franchise lays claim to many of the most inventive and singular boss fights in the history of the medium, courtesy of its genius creator Hideo Kojima.

But as brilliantly creative as so many of the battles have been over the years, Kojima has never quite topped the show-stopping, jaw-dropping insanity of the Psycho Mantis fight in the original Metal Gear Solid.

The fight is designed primarily around Mantis' extensive psychic abilities, with Kojima taking the opportunity to thoroughly screw with players' heads.

This includes Mantis making the player's controller vibrate, reading their memory card, commenting upon any Konami save files they might have, and trying to trick players into thinking the TV channel has changed.

But the pièce de résistance is unquestionably Mantis' ability to "read the player's mind," in that he can predict every combative move Snake makes against him and in turn evade every attack directed his way.

The solution? Unplug your controller and insert it in the second controller port instead, breaking the psychic link and making Mantis vulnerable once again.

It's such mind-bogglingly brilliant use of gaming tech, and laid the gauntlet down to other developers to try and match its devilish ingenuity - which, largely, they haven't. Over 20 years on, it remains one of the most intelligently constructed boss fights of all time.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Demon's Souls
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.