10 Video Game Characters That Deserved To Die (But Didn't)

Nadine should've been toast.

Nadine Ross
Naughty Dog

As much as we all love intensely likeable video game heroes that we can't help but root for, there's something to be said for a character we absolutely relish despising, too.

And while the rules of storytelling typically dictate that the douchebag villain gets their comeuppance by game's end, that's not always the case.

And so, we have these 10 video game characters who clearly deserved an early appointment with the Grim Reaper, only to live and fight another day.

From corrupt cops who ruined the protagonist's life, to antagonists who escaped into the shadows never to be seen again, and even a psychopath of a player character who clearly deserved to die, these guys and gals all made it to the finish line surprisingly unscathed.

In some cases their survival was clearly the right dramatic call, but in others fans were left feeling empty and robbed of their chance to exact some well-earned revenge.

For better or worse, these characters are still out there, somewhere, doing their thing free of major repercussions...

10. Roy Earle - L.A. Noire

LA Noire Earle
Rockstar

In the tradition of the film noir genre, L.A. Noire is a video game where truly likeable characters are in desperately short supply, but there's one despicable character above all others who, for all his transgressions, still makes it to the end credits with his life in tact.

We're of course talking about Roy Earle, the partner of protagonist Cole Phelps and Chief Detective of the LAPD's Vice department.

He plays a major role in the climax of the game, using Cole's extra-marital affair with Elsa in order to distract the media from an impending corruption scandal in the Vice Squad he was deeply involved in.

Ultimately Earle manages to walk away scot-free, but not before delivering an infuriatingly disingenuous eulogy at Phelps' funeral, posing as his bereft partner and friend, causing a distraught Elsa to storm out in disgust.

That's not to forget his casual displays of racism and misogyny throughout the game, as well as his flippant use of violence when following up leads. Were he not so smug and savvy, his lack of punishment wouldn't be quite so infuriating.


9. Gabriel T. Rorke - Call Of Duty: Ghosts

Call Of Duty Ghosts Rorke
Activision

The formula of the Call of Duty franchise more or less dictates that the larger-than-life antagonist of each game is generally killed by the end, or at least returns to terrorise the world again in a sequel, right?

Well, there's one major exception, and that's the main villain of Call of Duty: Ghosts, Gabriel T. Rorke, the former leader of the Ghosts who was captured by the Federation and brainwashed into becoming their assassin.

He ends up killing his squad-mate Elias Walker, the father of the game's primarily player character Logan, and at the end of the game Logan seems set to exact violent revenge upon his father's slayer.

Though Logan and his brother Hesh do manage to wound Rorke, the game ends with Logan captured by Rorke and about to be subjected to the very same torture that caused Rorke's own brainwashing. Grim.

The middling critical and fan response to Ghosts ultimately led to no sequel ever being made, leaving the fates of both Rorke and Logan up in the air.

Given that Rorke was very much in control of the situation when we left him, it's pretty safe to assume that his comeuppance never came.


8. Natalya Simonova - GoldenEye 007

goldeneye 007
Rare

Though most of the characters on this list deserved to die because they were thoroughly contemptible degenerates if not outright villains, that's not quite the case with one entry on our list, and that's Natalya from the classic N64 FPS GoldenEye 007.

Natalya appears in several of the game's missions, infuriatingly serving as a VIP during the maddening escort romp "Control."

Escort missions don't have to be terrible - though they usually are - yet Control is a uniquely awful one because Natalya's A.I. is programmed to be as counter-intuitive as possible.

While the player attempts to fend off the fleet of goons trying to kill her, Natalya will freely run in front of bullets and basically demonstrate the absolutely opposite of anything approaching a basic survival instinct.

Though she of course can die at either your hand or the enemy's, resulting in a Game Over, canonically Natalya lives to fight another day, despite being one of the dopiest and most survival-averse NPCs in gaming history.


7. Donald Love - Grand Theft Auto III

Grand Theft Auto 3 Donald Love
Rockstar

Though the Grand Theft Auto franchise is full of murderous undesirables worthy of a dirt nap, there's one especially effed-up character who curiously never got their comeuppance.

We're talking of course about Rockstar's resident cannibal and necrophile Donald Love, a media mogul who appears in GTA III, Vice City, and Vice City Stories, but chronologically speaking, his final appearance was in GTA III.

Despite clearly being a ripe candidate for a grisly death, Love's final character mission, "Love's Disappearance," sees Love more or less disappearing into thin air along with his mysterious "Old Oriental Gentleman" sidekick.

Though it's possible Love was killed by one of the many enemies he's presumably made, the rules of media dictate that nobody's dead until you see the corpse. As a result, it's probably more likely that he simply fled Liberty City.

Rockstar received enough questions from fans about Love's disappearance that they actually offered up a rare official comment: "No one is quite sure what happened to Donald Love. He certainly crossed a few boundaries and was trying to find a way back to normality. Whether or not he managed this, and what happened to the elderly Asian gentleman are matters we cannot speculate on."


6. Carter Blake - Heavy Rain

Heavy Rain Carter Blake
Quantic Dream

The big appeal of Quantic Dream's interactive drama games is that there are no Game Overs, and players are in fact free to lead any of the playable characters to their eventual deaths.

Sadly that doesn't extend to the supporting cast, especially in the case of Heavy Rain's Lt. Carter Blake, the partner of player character Norman Jayden while they investigate the Origami Killer.

With a fondness for police brutality and a dogged determination to nail the innocent Ethan Mars as the killer - even getting Ethan killed in some of the game's endings - he's pretty much a walking, talking corrupt cop cliche.

While there are possible endings where Blake can be suspended from the force or even end up haunted by a digital manifestation of a dead Norman, there sadly aren't any endings where he pays the ultimate mortal price for his savagery.

Considering how much of a rageaholic malcontent he is throughout the game, he totally deserved to catch a bullet or twelve.


5. Postal Dude - Postal 2

Postal 2 Paradise Lost
Running with Scissors

It's pretty common for video games which cast players as reprehensible murderers to have that character die by the end of the game, but true to its tone, Postal 2 offers no such moral climax.

Postal 2 casts the player as the gun-totting maniac known simply as the "Postal Dude," and gives them free license to kill hundreds of innocent people, assault animals, steal, and even urinate on anyone unlucky enough to be in the vicinity (to the extent that it makes them puke).

The game is a ribald middle finger to political correctness, but at the same time, there's no way that a character as unbalanced and murderously psychopathic as the Postal Dude should be allowed to carry on unchecked, right?

Well, Postal 2 laughs at the idea of punishing the psychotic protagonist, and after blowing up his hometown of Paradise at the end of the game, the Paradise Lost DLC sees him leaving the town for good with his trusty canine Champ.

That's...a pretty sweet ending for a mass murderer, no?


4. Lan Di - Shenmue III

Shenmue 3 Lan Di
Ys Net

Lan Di is the primary antagonist of the Shenmue franchise, solidified at the start of the first game when he murders protagonist Ryo's father Iwao, beating him to death in front of his son's eyes.

Yet because the Shenmue saga was always intended to be four or five games long, some 20+ years after Iwao's death, players still haven't been given the opportunity to take Lan Di down.

A brief showdown at the end of last year's Shenmue III resulted in Ryo getting thoroughly schooled by Lan Di, and given that there's no guarantee a fourth game will ever even get made, it's possible the villain's misdeed will go unpunished forever more. Absolutely disgusting.


3. Kane - Command & Conquer

Command & Conquer Kane
EA

As much as fans love Kane, the shadowy yet deeply charismatic leader of the Brotherhood of Nod, there's no denying that Command and Conquer's recurring, seemingly immortal antagonist is a major piece of garbage.

Above all else, Kane is a megalomaniacal warmonger who has kickstarted each of the four Tiberium Wars, and despite losing most of them to the GDI, he's managed to live to fight another day every single time.

The last time we saw Kane in Command & Conquer 4: Tiberian Twilight, he escaped Earth through a portal, and given that the franchise has faded into the ether in recent years, it may very well be that Kane won't ever get permanently put down.


2. Nadine Ross - Uncharted 4: A Thief's End

Uncharted 4 Nadine
Naughty Dog

To be clear, Nadine Ross is one of the greatest characters in the Uncharted franchise, but she also can't be trusted any further than she can be thrown.

Nadine was introduced in Uncharted 4: A Thief's End as an utterly ruthless mercenery-turned-treasure hunter, hired by primary antagonist Rafe Adler to discover the mythical pirate colony of Libertalia.

Throughout the game Nadine is shown to be a substantial physical threat, holding her own against both Nate and Sam in a fight, and at the end of the game she leaves the brothers for dead along with Rafe before disappearing into the night with some treasure.

As much as the franchise might be embarrassed to admit just how much of a psychopath Nathan Drake himself is, Nadine's wafer-thin sense of loyalty to anyone but material goods probably should've led her to a brutal death by game's end.

Instead she survived and even co-starred in the spin-off title Uncharted: The Lost Legacy, where her edges were softened somewhat as she teamed up with franchise alum Chloe Frazer.

Though The Lost Legacy ends with Nadine going into business with Chloe and seemingly putting her mercenary ways behind her, that doesn't fully forgive her sordid past.


1. Viridi - Kid Icarus: Uprising

Kid Icarus Uprising Viridi
Project Sora

In Kid Icarus: Uprising, Viridi is the Goddess of Nature who, with her pathological hatred of humanity for destroying nature, actively relishes slaughtering armies with her immense abilities.

Though not always at odds with protagonist Pit throughout the game, and there's actually not even a direct confrontation with her, Viridi's single-minded, absolute hatred of humanity is never punished nor much addressed by game's end.

While Viridi's viewpoint is at least somewhat understandable, it's also a little too close to Thanos territory to be in any way comfortable, and if we're splitting hairs, he only wanted to kill half of humanity. That the game lets her off so lightly is really quite bizarre.

It's not so much that we wish she died, but that her flippant pleasure in causing human suffering made her absolutely deserving regardless.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Uncharted 4
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.