10 Video Game Classics That Desperately Deserve Remakes

Forget the Uncharted Collection and Gears of War... these would be welcome with open arms.

Remake, remaster, re-release: the games industry is so quick to throw around similar-sounding buzzwords without care that gamers have started to lose track of which ones mean what. It certainly doesn't help when developers mislabel their games as total remakes or remasters only for us to discover that the end product barely even fits the definition. Annoyingly, such descriptors are all-too-often used purely to generate sales or renewed interest in a game who's original release date has long-since faded into distant memory. The terms aren't mutually exclusive either. Take Ocarina Of Time for example - the critically-acclaimed Nintendo title was originally released for the Nintendo 64, but has since been squeezed onto the Nintendo 3DS as a re-release with remastered textures. But can one count it as a true remake? Hell no. All of the games present here are worthy of more than just a quick spit and polish and a punt out the door - they deserve better than that. A good idea is always good, and a video game classic will always be just that. Everything gets old though, and these games deserve to be rebuilt for a whole new generation to enjoy.

10. Panzer Dragoon Saga

Remember that really obscure wave of games back in the 90s and early 2000s that had what, at first, seemed like really obtuse control schemes? Yeah, I'm talking about the on-rails shooter. The genre is pretty much dead in the water today, but over a decade ago, it was the go-to mechanic if you wanted to sell your product as a unique alternative. The original Star Fox games, cult-classic Killer7 and of course, Panzer Dragoon Saga are all famous proponents of the system where directing your character, vehicle or dragon was left entirely up to the computer to decide while you were tasked with shooting and killing any living thing that dared to cross your path. Now, you're probably going to bring up the poorly-received Xbox One release title - Crimson Dragon - as an argument against remaking a game such as this, but that catastrophe was a result of the game originally being a Kinect-controlled title. It's best we just forget about its existence entirely, to be honest. Panzer Dragon Saga, though? You can bet your sweet behind that it deserves a total remake, if only to remind the current generation that such games can actually be good.

9. Metroid Prime

Well fancy that, Nintendo actually did know how to take the traditional 2D Metroid experience and graft it onto a 3D frame. What's that, I'm thirteen years late to the party? Oh, I just assumed Metroid Prime had only just been released - it still looks that damn good today that I sometimes forget how old the GameCube title is. If it still holds up today, why has it plonked itself down at number nine on this list? Well, look at it this way; if Nintendo were able to make Metroid Prime look so fantastic back at the turn of the century and play equally well, then just imagine what they could do with a total remake. The purple lunch-box-sized GameCube wasn't exactly the most powerful machine of its generation (the Xbox gets that title, ironically), but it still managed to make Metroid Prime look like a top-end tour de force, regardless. Imagine updating the original with some modern visuals and textures and an overhauled control system and you're looking at a very tantalising prospect indeed. Please Nintendo, make it so. It's this or a reboot. Either is fine, and a far better alternative to Metroid Prime: Federation Force.

8. Shenmue

Could there honestly be a better time for this to become a reality? Shenmue III has finally left the realms of being an impossible dream to an actual reality thanks to an equal showing of passion from both fans and series creator Yu Suzuki. While Sega seemingly didn't care enough about a third game to fund it themselves, they can certainly put things right (and stop making bad Sonic games) by throwing some money behind a Shenmue remake to initiate those who are unaware of its legacy. Hell, if the current news and eBay listings are anything to by, the announcement of the long-awaited third game has actually re-ignited interest in the Sega Dreamcast as a whole, and if that's not a clear sign that a Shenmue remake would bring in the big bucks, then what is? Part of what made the original so mesmerising was its realistic depiction of a 1980s Japan undergoing a drastic process of Americanisation against the backdrop of traditional Japanese culture. Imagine that stark visual image but in a fully re-written graphics engine. Oh, and streamline those controls while you're at it, Sega. Anyone who thinks the original Resident Evil games had tanky controls obviously never played Shenmue.

7. Legacy Of Kain: Soul Reaver

Sadly, Legacy Of Kain: Soul Reaver is probably the least likely member of this list to ever be remade. We've had sequels, spiritual successors and even MMOs over the years since the original games, but none have even come close to topping the original tale of revenge and vampiric conspiracy. Despite being known as an action-adventure series at its - very black - heart, the series' legacy (no pun intended) is its story. The Gothic-themed tale of betrayal, redemption and revenge revolving around anti-heroes Kain and Raziel and their role as pawns in a grander scheme of biblical proportions is what keeps it memorable to this day. It deserves to be remade purely so fans can experience its curious narrative all over again but backed up with an overhauled game engine. Crystal Dynamics currently have their work cut out for them with this year's Tomb Raider sequel, but they've got to start work on something once that's out the door. Here's to hoping it'll be this.

6. Resident Evil 3: Nemesis

Well done everyone, mission accomplished. Capcom have finally sat up and taken notice of all the calls for them to do a Resident Evil 2 remake, now we just need to do the same thing for Resident Evil 3: Nemesis. We may be jumping the gun just a tad, considering the Resi 2 Remake has only just been announced as being a reality (it could turn out to be terrible, after all), but both games are traditionally seen as a package deal due to the close proximity in which they were released. Out of all the entries you've seen and are going to see on this list, this one is not only the most likely to happen, but there's already a precedent set for what we can expect thanks to the excellent work Capcom did with the Resident Evil Remake and next year's Resident Evil 0 HD Remake. If you think Nemesis has an ugly mug now, just imagine what some new tech could do for that smile. If Capcom were feeling really experimental, they could even expand upon the unique chase mechanic and enable the Tyrant to smash through walls doors and save rooms to up the ante.

5. Fallout 1 & 2

The two original Fallout games are pretty ancient relics by today's standards. In fact, if you were to take a trip down memory lane and play them now, you'd find yourself wondering how in the hell Fallout 3 and New Vegas are even a part of the same series in the way they're played and presented. The top-down, isometric-like gameplay of the originals are a far cry from the first-person sandbox worlds of the newer entries in the series. There's obviously running themes throughout the entire franchise like the post-apocalyptic America setting and large helpings of oddball humour, but simply remaking Fallout 1 & 2 in the style of Bethesda's interpretation would probably just piss off more people than it pleased. There's still hope though! There's already a modern equivalent of Black Isle Studios' original formula in the form of the rather excellent XCOM: Enemy Unknown, or to a lesser extent, Massive Chalice. How about you give 2K a call, Bethesda? Let them work on some remakes of the original while you focus on getting Fallout 4 out the door. That way, we can have the best of both worlds.

4. Sonic The Hedgehog 3 & Knuckles

Its almost become customary to rag on every new Sonic game that Sega pushes out the doors these days. The magic has quite clearly left Sonic and his friends; having buggered off to hide in some dark corner somewhere out of shame. Sonic Team have only put out two works since the Mega Drive days that have ever really shown a glimpse of that lost sparkle, the first being Sonic Colors, the other being Sonic Generations. There's always the fear that a company will totally annihilate the original game when the term remake is pegged on the end of a name, but remaking a classic such as this wouldn't require changing anything to do with the mechanics. The gameplay formula is so perfect and ageless that it's perfect the way it is. But just imagine if every single stage were to be recreated using the Sonic Generations engine and every stage track (which is fantastic) was remastered or re-recorded to follow suit. It would look and sound glorious. End of discussion.

3. Super Mario 64

Have you revisited Super Mario 64 recently? If your answer is no, then what the hell is wrong with you? If yes, then you know exactly what I'm talking about when I say it's as good today as it was 18 years ago. You'd think remaking a game that essentially set the precedent for how a 3D platformer should be made would be a no-brainer decision for Nintendo higher-ups to consider, so why hasn't it happened yet? I mean, remaking one of the greatest games of all time for a modern audience would essentially be giving Nintendo a licence to print free money to the same extent that the Final Fantasy VII Remake is surely going to do for Square Enix. Perhaps it's nostalgia that's preventing such a thing from happening, or the Big N are simply apprehensive about potentially ruining a remake of the original that's become a fond childhood memory for over eleven million people across the globe. Just imagine taking those first few steps into Princess Peach's castle in the Super Mario Galaxy engine. Now wouldn't that be a sight to behold?

2. The Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time & Majora's Mask

No, the 3DS versions of both games - as wonderful as they are - don't count. Those aren't remakes, but updates. It's a feat in itself that Nintendo were able to cram both games onto a puny little SD card for a handheld console as opposed to the brick-like cartridges of the N64, but it's also a reminder of just how far technology has come in fifteen years. Termina, Hyrule, the hypnotising tunes of Link's Ocarina - even Ganondorf (but not Navi, she can do one); all of it deserves to be rebuilt, brick-by-brick, pixel-by-pixel. Who knows, the 3DS versions could very well be Nintendo secretly testing the waters for potential interest in complete remakes. But that's unlikely, given that the Wii U is still waiting for its own Legend Of Zelda game to début after various worrying delays. Honestly, we'll probably have to wait until Ninty are on the brink of bankruptcy before they'll consider remaking either title as a means to recoup their losses - such is the lasting popularity of them both.

1. Metal Gear Solid

Nobody said games that have already been remade are exempt from this list. You don't make the rules! Besides, the 2004 GameCube remake is eleven years old itself as of 2015. Now that the intricately-plotted Big Boss saga has come full circle with Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain, what better time has there been to tie it off neatly by recreating Solid Snake's first 3D outing? God knows, the child of Big Boss himself deserves a little TLC - its now been seven years since he last headlined his own gig in Guns Of The Patriots. Nobody in their right mind would pass up the chance to take another whistle-stop tour of Shadow Moses Island. So memorable is its design and kooky inhabitants that recreating it with Phantom Pain's graphics engine would surely make you expel a tiny little wee in anticipation. It would be like revisiting your childhood home. All of your old FOXHOUND 'friends' are still living in the place you grew up in, and they're as eager as ever to kill you at the behest of Liquid Snake. Okay, that's an awfully haphazard metaphor, but you get the point - Metal Gear Solid has one of the best casts of characters and self-contained worlds of any entry in the series so please, Kojima, try and convince Konami to do it. We'll love you forever. What game would you throw up as genuinely deserving the remake treatment? Let us know in the comments!

In this post: 
Mario 64
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Joe is a freelance games journalist who, while not spending every waking minute selling himself to websites around the world, spends his free time writing. Most of it makes no sense, but when it does, he treats each article as if it were his Magnum Opus - with varying results.