10 Video Game Cliffhangers That Will Never Be Resolved

Press X to continue... in your imagination.

The darkness 2
Digital Extremes

Who doesn't love a good cliffhanger?

Avengers: Infinity War's dusty mess of an ending, Modern Warfare 2's stab-a-thon final showdown, homeless Luke Skywalker in the closing scene of The Force Awakens... the list is near-endless.

Cliffhangers are great at keeping gamers and audience members buzzing long after they've finished the story, theorising and speculating about what the hell is going to happen next. But there is a downside to this: over time, these "to be continued" style endings can turn sour when it becomes clear that they will never be resolved.

Maybe the developers expected to make a sequel - only to have the first game flop - or maybe they just chucked in a cliffhanger for the hell of it, without outlining a real plan for wrapping the story up. This is particularly frustrating considering most games take over ten hours to complete, and spending so much time investing yourself in a set of characters, only to have their stories go unfinished... is annoying, to say the least.

So, just to annoy you all over again, let's take a look at some of these unlikely-to-be-resolved gaming cliffhangers, and cry salty tears all over our keyboards at the thought of where the followup games could have taken us.

10. Bulletstorm

Bulletstorm is one of those mid-tier FPS games that were oh-so prevalent during the PS3 era, and it's one of the most underrated of the lot. It also ends on a tantalising cliffhanger that teased a followup game, one that would have brought back characters who supposedly died during the main story.

In the final level you confront bad guy General Sarrano onboard his rescue ship, slaughtering your way through waves and waves of goons to get there. A short gunfight later, you whip Sarrano into the air and kick him onto a piece of metal sticking out of the wall, which seems like it should kill the guy... but nope. Sarrano ejects you from his ship, having you face off against more enemies before the credits finally roll.

Wait around after said credits and you'll be greeted by some extra dialogue that sheds a little more light on Sarrano's fate, while leaving a lot of questions unanswered. This extra scene reveals that Sarrano survived and is now a cyborg, and that Ishi - your former teammate - has also survived, implying that the two will be working together.

The reason Bulletstorm 2 is first on our list is because it has the highest chance of getting a sequel - albeit a small chance. The most recent update we had was that the developer has no plans to revisit the IP, even though they did remain hopeful.

Considering that this kind of non-committal, vaguely optimistic response is all we've had for the past eight years, it's hard to have faith that any movement will actually happen here. Maybe if the recently-released Switch port absolutely slays?


9. Advent Rising

The closing moments of 2005's third-person actioner Advent Rising are the very definition of sequel bait, which, considering that the game was intended to be the first part of a trilogy, was an inevitability.

The story follows protagonist Gideon Wyeth, a badass one-man-army type of guy, as he blasts his way through hordes of a sinister alien race called the Seekers. The Seekers are essentially galactic bullies, and have a desire to absolutely decimate the human race, so it's up to you to stop them.

Near the end of the game, it's revealed that the Seekers were only getting up to no good on the orders of someone else, a god-like being called a Koroem. Naturally, Gideon murders this thing as well, and for a moment, it looks like everything has been tied up in a neat little bow. But wait - there's more!

Out of nowhere, a portal opens and sucks Gideon inside, transporting him to a derelict ice planet where it looks like he's been stranded, left to die. After stumbling around aimlessly for a bit, Gideon collapses, but is soon approached by yet another random alien dude who tells Gideon "there is much to be done" before the game just... ends.

Publisher Majesco had big plans for the Advent Rising IP, including two more mainline games, a PSP spinoff, and even some novels. Sadly, the first game underperformed sales-wise, ending this potential franchise before it could really get going.


8. The Darkness II

Like Bulletstorm, The Darkness is one of those mid-tier last-gen games that doesn't seem like it made a big enough splash to be deserving of a sequel, and yet, it got one. The Darkness II launched in 2012, continuing the story of the first game while teeing up a third that never saw the light of day.

The series revolves around the relationship between Jackie - the hero of both games - and Jenny, his girlfriend. During the first game, Jenny is brutally murdered while Jackie watches, helpless to intervene. In the sequel, Jackie is haunted by visions of Jenny, which prompts him to kill himself in an attempt to rescue her from hell.

This leads to one of two endings: in the first, Jackie and Jenny are reunited in a hallucination, and the game ends with them slow dancing as the screen fades to black. Aww. The second, however, is a bit more grim: here, Jackie will fall into the underworld, where he manages to rescue Jenny for real. Everything looks great and it seems like it's over, right up until the moment it's revealed that Jenny has become the host for the Angelus, enemy of the titular Darkness.

Since Jackie is strongly affiliated with the Darkness, this plot development was not ideal for him. The game ends with Jackie screaming his head off as he's trapped in hell by the Angelus, and since The Darkness II was a financial disappointment, we're probably never going to find out what happened to him from here.


7. Sly Cooper: Thieves In Time

Sly Cooper is no Ratchet & Clank or Jak & Daxter, but his original trilogy of games on the PS2 (along with their high-definition remasters on the PS3) were popular enough that a fourth entry made its way to the PS3 and PS Vita in early 2013.

Thieves In Time follows Sly as he travels through time, attempting to repair his family history that is being tampered with by the villainous Cyrille Le Paradox. At the end of the game, Sly confronts his opponent atop an enormous blimp, where the two engage in a sword fight and Le Paradox falls into the ocean below.

Bad guy defeated - job's a good 'un, right?

Not exactly. Unfortunately for Sly, the blimp is on fire, so he can't just land it and clamber off. The game actually ends without revealing whether or not Sly survived, which would be a sequel-baiting ending unto itself, but devs Sanzaru Games just couldn't resist a final tease that directly hinted at the titular raccoon's next adventure.

If you collect all the game's trophies, you unlock a secret ending cutscene that lasts for roughly half a minute. Here, Sly wakes up in the desert, the golden sun beating down upon his face. The camera then reveals that he's ended up in Ancient Egypt, and with no way home, he's essentially stuck there.

Presumably, a sequel would've continued down this path and explored Sly's time in this new locale. However, with no solid word of a fifth game having materialised in the six years since Thieves In Time was released - and Sanzaru stating that they have no plans for a fifth game - Sly 5 looks unlikely.


6. Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance II

Both games in the Dark Alliance series end on a cliffhanger, and while the ending of the first game was addressed, the sequel wasn't so lucky.

Dark Alliance II is a fun yet formulaic fantasy adventure that isn't exactly remembered as one of the great RPGs of all time, but will certainly live in infamy if only for the messy behind-the-scenes issues that destroyed the future of the franchise.

Set within the city of Baldur's Gate, the game has its five playable characters facing off against the evil vampire Mordoc SeLanmere, who ends up causing chaos within the city when he turns its entire population into zombies. This leads to a final confrontation with Mordoc that sees the heroes kill him, restoring the citizens back to normal and saving the day. But it's not over yet.

The game then cuts to a room with a man talking to a sarcophagus (no kidding), with the two talking about how Mordoc has "failed", and that Baldur's Gate still stands. The sarcophagus then asserts that they'll get the job done themselves, raising an army and preparing a barge to (presumably) storm the city and mess it up.

But we never got to see this epic battle. Dark Alliance III was in the works even before Dark Alliance II came out, but when developer Black Isle Studios was closed down (after publisher Interplay fell into financial trouble), it was permanently shelved.


5. Half-Life 2: Episode 2

The non-existent sequel to Half-Life 2: Episode 2 has become a popular meme topic over the last ten years, almost like fans of the series are trying to turn their frustration into something more positive. They have every right to be frustrated too, because not only does Episode 2 end on a cliffhanger, but Episode 3 was explicitly promised to them on multiple occasions.

The haunting ending of the game shows the death of old Eli Vance, who is killed by a Combine Advisor that shoves its tongue into the back of his head. His daughter Alyx then cradles his lifeless body and begins to weep, before the screen fades to black and the credits roll.

So what happened to Alyx and Gordon Freeman from here? Valve probably knows, but the rest of us don't. Episode 3 was supposed to launch by Christmas of 2007, and even the developer commentary for Episode 2 stated that a sequel was coming. But, of course, it never did.

The most annoying thing about the absence of an Episode 3 (or even a Half-Life 3) is that Valve has never outright stated that it's cancelled. The only response fans ever seem to get is "we have nothing to say at this time", which is partly why the whole thing turned into a joke. It's almost like Valve is scared of the backlash they'd receive if they confirmed that the game is dead, which is odd, because they're getting a ton of backlash anyway.

Regardless, after a decade of increasingly declining fan optimism, it doesn't look like Episode 3 will ever see the light of day.


4. Star Wars: Republic Commando

With EA currently squandering the potential of its Star Wars license (fingers crossed for Fallen Order), the days when we used to get frequent, solid Star Wars games feel like they happened a million years in the past.

Along with the original Battlefront games, Knights of the Old Republic, and several others, Republic Commando was another fine addition to the galaxy far, far away's roster of gaming offerings, an FPS set during the Clone Wars that lets you play as an elite Clone trooper, who leads a unit called Delta Squad.

The climax of the game is set on Kashyyyk, and has you attempting to rid the skies of a huge enemy ship hovering up above. In order to progress, you will succeed, forcing you to evacuate with the remainder of your squad. The final scene of the game is set inside the evacuation ship, where the trio of troopers are told that their mission is not yet over, and that they must "lock and load" to prepare for the battle ahead.

Since you're told that Delta Squad was only the advance force for a full-scale invasion, the insinuation is that there's a lot more action for you to take part in. The game basically ends halfway through the Kashyyyk conflict, which is frustrating as hell.

A Republic Commando sequel was on the table at one point, but it was scrapped, and considering that there are far more popular Star Wars video game franchises out there, the chances of EA resurrecting this one are slim to none.


3. Too Human

The promise of its unresolved cliffhanger isn't the only time Too Human has failed to deliver the goods - released in 2008 exclusively on the Xbox 360, the game was originally meant to launch on the PS1 all the way back in 1999.

Its story revolves around Norse mythology, and includes characters like Loki, Tyr, Freya, Heimdall, and the mighty Thor himself. You play as Baldur, who, as the game progresses, discovers that he had previously been brought back to life by the other gods. In the final scene, he confronts the Norse council about this, has a hissy fit, and storms out of the room.

Elsewhere, the mischievous Loki is shown wandering through a wintry plain, set to a voiceover that basically says "let's stop this dude before he does more awful stuff". Loki then glances up at a massive titan towering over the land, with the insinuation being that he'll use it to devastate Asgard.

So not only is the extremely complicated dynamic between Baldur and the other gods left unexplored, but the prospect of Loki's next attack was just left dangling. Too Human was initially planned as a trilogy of games, but a messy lawsuit (in which developers Silicon Knights were sued into bankruptcy by Epic Games for using a stolen game engine) killed the series' future permanently.


2. Game Of Thrones: A Telltale Series

While the story itself is twisty-turny and enjoyable in that Game of Thrones sort of way, actually playing through Telltale's adaptation of the famous TV show is a miserable experience. Absolutely nothing goes your way, and by the end of the game, pretty much everyone you care about is dead, or in a horrible position.

Still, it's engaging stuff. The series has you playing as the Forrester clan, a family based in the fortress of Ironrath in the North of Westeros - and, as already mentioned, things do not go well for you. Young Ethan is killed at the end of episode one, Ironrath is invaded by the vile Whitehills, and it's revealed that one of your closest advisers has been a traitor all along. Not cool.

By the end of the game, things get even worse. Either Asher or Rodrik - the game's two primary heroes - will be killed (along with Lady Forrester), Ironrath becomes a crumbling warzone, and the few characters left standing are forced to flee the scene. Whoever doesn't die out of Asher or Rodrik is left wounded - but alive - riding off into the distance and reuniting with the few allies he has left.

But maybe things will look brighter in the sequel...? Actually, scratch that. While a followup was in development at one point, it's now dead as a result of the closure of Telltale Games roughly a year ago (the Telltale brand was recently resurrected, but the Game of Thrones license is no longer in play). It's a shame too, because along with Tales From the Borderlands, Game of Thrones is most in need of a sequel out of all the company's games.

Will Asher/Rodrik be able to exact revenge on the Whitehills? Will he even survive his injuries? Will House Forrester be able to make a comeback? The answers to all of these questions, and more, will remain mysteries.


1. Resistance: Retribution

Sony Bend has a habit of making great handheld versions of Sony's biggest console franchises, but years before they did it with Uncharted on the Vita, they did it with Resistance on the PSP. Resistance: Retribution is the best shooter available on the device, cramming Resistance's intriguing alternate history, creative array of weaponry and cool Chimera designs into a tidy portable package.

Taking place between the first two mainline PS3 games, this spinoff focused on Royal Marine James Grayson. After being forced to kill his own infected brother, Grayson is driven to breaking point and starts destroying Chimera conversion centres for sport. He gets so good at doing this that the game concludes with him and his allies wrecking the main Chimera tower in Paris, freeing Western Europe from the aliens. And while that's a happy ending overall, things don't end too well for Grayson himself.

One of the last scenes in the game shows Grayson standing in front of Saint Basil's Cathedral in Moscow, his back to the camera. When he eventually turns around, his eyes are glowing a bright yellow, a symptom of being infected with the Chimera virus. It's an awesome cliffhanger, but, annoyingly - considering the Resistance IP has been all-but abandoned by Sony - it isn't likely to be addressed anytime soon.

How did Grayson get infected? What will he do next? Will he turn into a full Chimera, or remain a human-Chimera hybrid? All questions that will never be answered. Sigh.

-

Any other games with frustratingly unresolved cliffhangers? Let us know in the comments section!


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Danny has been with WhatCulture for over ten years, and is currently Doctor Who Editor and WhoCulture Channel Manager, overseeing all of WhatCulture's Whoniverse coverage. In 2022, he took charge of WhoCulture and has grown it into the biggest Doctor Who channel on YouTube, and one of the biggest Doctor Who communities on the web full-stop. He has been writing and video editing since his early teens, and first got a taste for content creation after making his own Doctor Who trailers, off the back of a burning obsession with the Matt Smith era of the show. Like many his age, he first got into Doctor Who with the 2005 revival, but has since gone back and fallen in love with the classic years too. If you need someone to recite every Doctor Who episode in order, or to give you a random factoid about the making of Gridlock, Danny is the person to ask!