10 Video Game Consoles The World Wasn't Ready For

Sometimes, a video game console doesn't sell despite being way ahead of its time...

Dreamcast console
Sega

Video game consoles have been a major player in the home entertainment industry since the very early days of gaming, but not every system makes it in the market. This can be due to a number of factors, and each console release has its ups and downs.

Most of the time, a system will fail due to competition within the market. In the early days, there were dozens of competitors, but even after the competition narrowed to 3-5 viable candidates (Nintendo, Sega, Sony, Microsoft, etc.), sometimes, a game system will falter because they're released ahead of their time.

Technological innovations in gaming are strange where the market is concerned, and it's often true that a platform with limited capabilities can still take the lead with an incredible game library. The Nintendo Game Boy is proof of that, seeing as its competition had color screens and better graphics.

Whatever the reason for a failure, there are some consoles the world simply wasn't ready for. Whether it was due to costs related to enhanced architecture, poor marketing, a crummy game library or all of the above, these video game consoles came to the market WAY sooner than they should have.

10. Sega Saturn

sega saturn
Sega

When it was released in 1994-95, the Sega Saturn was one of the most advanced video game systems ever made. It hit the market during the fifth-generation of home video game consoles, and when it compared to the competition, there was little doubt the console would succeed.

Sega already had a great deal of success from the Master System and Genesis, which meant there was a large group of people who would be early-adopters of any new hardware the company released. The competition from the 5th Gen hardware included the Nintendo 64, Atari Jaguar, 3DO, and PlayStation.

Sony was new to the console game, but the company managed to steal the generation from all other developers, including Sega and Nintendo. The Saturn was an incredibly innovative system, which featured 32-bit graphics, a CD-ROM, higher-resolution, better sound, and online access via a modem, which was something the competition lacked. Despite these features, the system flopped in the market and was the worst-selling of the bunch.

One of the main reasons the system failed was due to its lack of 3rd-party game support, which limited its library, making it weak compared to the competition. Add to that a $399 price tag ($689 in 2019), and the Sega Saturn was something few people were willing to buy.


9. OUYA

Ouya Console
Ouya, Inc.

The Ouya was developed via a Kickstarter campaign, and at the time is succeeded, its $8.5 million dollar haul was one of the highest-earning projects in the site's history. The system is an Android-based micro-console, which means it was made to play the games designed for the Android mobile market.

It was an innovative concept at the time as there wasn't a way to play phone games on a television, which was something a lot of people who supported the campaign wanted to be able to do. The console also featured a controller, which helped to transfer mobile gaming to a console.

The use of Android as the OS also meant that anyone who developed for that platform could then develop for the OUYA. People could sell their games on the free marketplace, and the OUYA would then become a new hub for entertainment, which was easy to use, inexpensive, and launched with a ton of content.

Unfortunately, while the campaign proved successful, the fruits of it did not. The OUYA didn't sell well outside the initial Kickstarter campaign, which forced the company to scale down considerably. This led to weaker development, and eventually, a commercial failure.


8. Atari Lynx

Atari Lynx 1
Wikipedia

The Atari Lynx was the most innovative handheld gaming systems ever made when it was released in 1990. It hit the market just two months after Nintendo dropped the Game Boy, and despite the competition, it looked like the Lynx would dominate the market.

This was the first handheld system to feature a color LCD display, and compared to the Game Boy, the graphics were years ahead in terms of advancement. It also featured an innovative ambidextrous layout, which enabled players to flip it around and play it with whichever dominant hand they preferred.

Unfortunately, despite being way ahead of its time, the Atari Lynx didn't sell well. Ultimately, it sold a paltry three million units. While that may sound like a lot, the Game Boy sold 118 million, which left the Lynx in the dustbin of console history simply in comparison to the competition.

The reason such a powerful handheld failed in comparison to the much less-powerful Nintendo offering has everything to do with content. The games for the Lynx were comparatively sub-par, and only about 30 were ever released. There wasn't enough developmental support to sustain the platform after launch, and the world was happy to play the monochrome offering from Nintendo, which also cost half as much as the Lynx.


7. Atari Jaguar

Atari Jaguar
Wikimedia Commons

When the Atari Jaguar was released, it was marketed as the first 62-bit console, and it was significantly more advanced than the Genesis and Super Nintendo's 16-bit, or the 3DO's impressive 32-bit architecture. This made it far more advanced than the competition, but it was released late in the 4th-generation of consoles.

This meant that it had to contend with the previously mentioned systems and well-established consoles that preceded it while simultaneously trying to match the competition of those that released soon after. That meant it had to compete with both the 4th and 5th-generations of consoles, which was a tall order, even for the advanced Jaguar.

The system featured impressive technology, but it also had a high price tag when compared to the other consoles. At $249 ($441 in 2019), the console was too expensive, but that wasn't the only problem.

The system featured a multi-chip architecture, had a number of hardware bugs and lacked tools for 3rd-party developers. These problems resulted in a limited number of games (50 in total), which paled in comparison to the competition. The company attempted to extend the lifespan of the Jaguar into the next generation with the Atari Jaguar CD add-on, but that also failed, and only managed an additional 13 games before being discontinued.


6. Nokia N-Gage

N Gage
Wiki

These days, hundreds of millions of people use their cellphones as their primary gaming device. Think about it--you probably play something while sitting on the toilet... most of us do, but it wasn't always like this. Years ago, the best a phone could do was a vigorous game of Snake, which is why the Nokia N-Gage seemed like such a good idea.

This was a phone, which was also a handheld video game system. It took cartridges like the other handhelds in the market and was released to take on the might of Nintendo's Game Boy Advance.

Not only could this thing play games, but it was also a phone! While that's normal now, it was pretty new back in 2003. Despite the innovative concept, the system completely bombed and was discontinued within a couple of years.

Many of the problems arose from its clunky design and the simple fact that the buttons, which were designed more for phone use than anything else, made it incredibly difficult to play any of the games. Add to that the need to nearly disassemble the taco-shaped phone to put in a cartridge, and you have a recipe for a failed game system. It was a great concept, but ultimately, a poorly executed design for a market, which would eventually catch up with phone-based gaming only a few years later.


5. Panasonic 3DO

Panasonic 3DO
Wiki

Panasonic jumped into the console market with a machine, which Time Magazine named the "1993 Product of the Year" due to its cutting-edge technologies and heavily marketed launch. This was a 32-bit system released among a sea of 16-bit competition, but despite having a lot going for it, the 3DO failed to win a market share.

This was largely due to the competition already having a foothold in the market. Panasonic was up against the early 90s juggernauts of Sega and Nintendo, which meant that even with a greatly advanced system, the 3DO had a tough hill to climb.

The system was launched in 1993-94, and when it came out, it was the most advanced console ever made. Unfortunately, it also cost a whopping $699 ($1,240 in 2019), and its claim to fame was lost when the Sony Play Station was released just two years later.

That system cost less than half that of the 3DO, and while it attempted to compete with the much better 5th-generation of video game consoles, the 3DO didn't have what it took. Panasonic discontinued it in 1996 having sold only two million systems.


4. NEC Turbo Express

Turbo Express
NEC

When the GameBoy, Game Gear, and Atari Lynx were launched, they had to completely rebuild their libraries with entirely new content. This was due to the fact that the cartridges they supported couldn't be used directly in one of their pre-established home consoles, or vise-versa.

The TurboExpress from NEC didn't have that problem, which was one of its biggest features, though not the only one. The TurboExpress could play every single game already released for the Turbo Grafx 16, which meant it had a library on launch that exceeded that of its rivals.

While this definitely was a good thing, it wasn't exactly a benefit seeing as hardly anyone in the United States or Europe had a Turbo Grafx 16. While it was one of the most advanced consoles in its generation, it was poorly marketed outside of Japan, and barely anyone owned one. This meant that the huge library advantage wasn't so huge after all.

Something else the TurboExpress had that the competition didn't was a color display, much better graphics and sound, a TV tuner, and a backlit screen. It only sold around 1.5 million units, and despite all it had going for it, the cost was the main feature in its demise. Innovation costs money, and even though it was incredibly advanced, at $249 ($488 in 2019), it was cheaper and easier to buy a Game Boy.


3. SNK Neo Geo Advanced Entertainment System

neo geo cd
SNK

Fans of old-style cabinet arcade systems are probably familiar with the SNK Neo Geo as it was incredibly popular throughout the 1990s. The system was innovative in that it was cartridge-based, which meant that arcade owners could swap out the games in their cabinets without replacing the entire system.

Additionally, they featured up to four games per cabinet and even had a memory card slot so players could save their games and take the cards to other arcades to continue playing them. To continue marketing their product, SNK created the Advanced Entertainment System, a home console version released in 1991.

The console was a beast, and it blew the competition out of the water in terms of specs and capabilities, but it had one major design flaw: it was the exact same thing as the arcade version, just repackaged in a home console form.

This meant that the home console cost just as much as the arcade system, and since its game cartridges were sold directly to arcades, the games were too costly for most people. The home system cost $649.99 ($1,220 in 2019) while each game cost $200 ($376 in 2019) and up to twice that. With those numbers, it's easy to see why the incredibly advanced system failed in the home video game console market.


2. Sega Dreamcast

Sega Dreamcast
SEGA

The Sega Dreamcast is one of those game systems that had everything going for it when it launched but never got enough traction to become the console it was designed and imagined to be. The system ended up being the final nail in the coffin of Sega's hardware development and would lead the company to become software-only.

The Dreamcast featured an incredibly powerful CPU with more memory and graphics capabilities than the competition. It also was the first console to feature a built-in modem, which gave it Internet and online play capabilities.

The system was vastly overpowered compared to its contemporaries, and it also featured a ton of well-developed games, but even with these things going for it, it didn't manage to sell well outside of Asia, and it ended up becoming a commercial failure with only 9.13 million consoles having been sold.

The biggest reason the Dreamcast failed was its competition. The Sony Playstation 2 ended up destroying Sega's console in the marketplace. Both systems were innovative, and even a bit ahead of their time, but only the PS2 won the console war. One of the reasons had to do with the PS2 buiilding off of the success of the Play Station while the Dreamcast had to build off of the failure of the Sega Saturn. Despite its impressive characteristics, that was a burden the Dreamcast couldn't overcome.


1. Nintendo Wii U

Wii U
Nintendo

When Nintendo launched the Wii, the console was one of the most successful the company ever launched, which is saying something. The innovative design of the controllers and the ability to really step into the gaming experience by using the whole body set the system apart from the competition.

In 2012, Nintendo followed up that success with the Wii U, and they piggybacked the Wii's hardware innovation by adding a new type of controller, which featured a 6.2 inch (15.7 cm) touchscreen. Players could use it as a screen separate from the television, or they could use it in conjunction with their TV.

It was an impressive addition to the console marketplace, but ultimately, the Wii U was a failure. While the Wii managed to separate itself from the competition by sticking to mostly family-friendly titles, the Wii U went another direction. The console featured support for Triple-A titles, which were normally outside the purview of Nintendo. This put the Wii U in direct competition with the Xbox One and Playstation 4.

When a company goes up against those platforms, it needs to really up its game, and the Wii U didn't even compare in terms of graphics and sound. While the touchscreen controller was an innovation clearly ahead of its time, it wasn't something the market demanded. Fortunately, that innovation was developed further into the Nintendo Switch, which renewed Nintendo's success in the console market.


In this post: 
Dreamcast
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jonathan is a graphic artist, illustrator, writer, and game designer. Jonathan retired from the U.S. Army in 2017 and enjoys researching and writing about history, science, theology, and many other subjects. He writes for ScreenRant, CBR, NerdBastards, Listverse, Ranker, WhatCulture, and many other sites online. You can check out his latest on Twitter: @TalkingBull or on his blog: jonathanhkantor.com