10 Video Game Endings That Made No Sense

What if the entire game turned out to be a simulation designed by a dog?

A well-thought out ending can really cement a video game as a bonafide classic. After playing through something for anywhere between eight and eighty hours, of course, a solid ending is something that you come to expect; it's an aspect that you hope and pray that the developer has put time and effort into, not something they've come up with in 15 minutes so everyone can shoot off for an early lunch. And whilst there are tons of games out there with great, memorable endings that stay with you long after you're done playing them, there are other games that feature endings that leave you staring at the screen, scratching your head and wondering what the hell it is you just witnessed. Not because they're complex or confusing in a good way, though, but mind-boggling because they just don't make an inch of sense. At all. Here, then, are 10 video games endings that - all things considered - just don't make a lick of sense. These are the endings that left you feeling bewildered and disappointed; endings you thought might have been clever but turned out to be secretly shallow instead; endings that were pretentious, silly, or baffling - for all the wrong reasons...

10. Jason Must Decide Whether Or Not To Kill His Friends - Far Cry 3

Far Cry 3 is a great game; there's no doubting that. As Jason, a 25-year-old from Los Angeles, you find yourself stranded on a island in the pacific overrun by drug lords and militant groups, tasked with saving an ancient tribe from total destruction and rescuing your friends, who have been captured. And so Jason must go from punkass kid to badass warrior. The big problem comes at the end of the game, however, when Jason is suddenly given two options by a high priestess named Citra: become the ultimate warrior by killing his friends, or, you know, not doing that and leaving the island instead. And it's the fact that the game actually gives you this choice that makes no sense, because for the sum of the whole game Jason has been out to save his friends. That's what he cares about. At absolutely no point in the narrative is any other possibility hinted at, and it's completely illogical that the game would even present the player with this option because as a story beat, Jason betraying his companions without reason... well, it has no weight. The Jason of the game would never kill his friends - the whole point of Far Cry 3 is that he's out to rescue them! It's ridiculous that the game lets you do it if you want.

9. "It's An Ocean..." - Alan Wake

Alan Wake was a game designed with little focus on the story, but with absolutely everything poured into rendering the suspense factor. Which is pretty much a recipe for disappointment as far as a video game is concerned, because people like a coherent story. With Alan Wake, the developers clearly thought that they could get away with creating a mysterious but shallow game, throwing in all kinds of clues and weird twists and just not bothering to let it mean anything, which is why the ending of the game makes no sense. After traversing a mysterious island and fighting off the forces of darkness, Stephen King (uh, that is "Alan Wake") decides he must give himself over to the lake (whatever that means). From there, our hero appears back inside his cabin, and must... write himself out? At which point he enigmatically declares: "It's not a lake - it's an ocean." Huh? The worst thing about this ending is that tries to pretend that it makes sense, which is even more annoying than if just admitted that it didn't: it dares you to try and connect the dots and work it all out, when really it knows it's all bullsh*t. Sigh.

8. The Girl - Limbo

For the most part, Limbo is a pretty straight-forward video game; players control a small boy who must journey through a land on the brink of darkness - filled with violence and horror and images that will give you lots of nightmares - in order to save his sister. The ending - which purposely cements itself as a "Huh?" moment - occurs when players are flung through a glass window, only to find themselves at the beginning of the very first level all over again. Starting playing, however, and the game reveals a girl standing just ahead of you. There's a moment, and then... the game suddenly cuts to black. This was supposed to be ambiguous, of course; the kind of ending that people would discuss and debate. But it also makes little sense. There's not enough information here to warrant a conversation about "what happened." Why did the boy go all the way back to the beginning? For what reason? Who is the girl? Why was she there? Ultimately, Limbo's ending simply lacked clarity. It felt half-assed and was way too vague to be considered "clever."

7. The Patriots - Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty

There are probably a lot of people out there who will argue that the ending of Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty makes perfect sense - you just have to be intelligent enough to work it out. And whilst parts of it do make sense (though the game itself kind of doesn't in general), overall the ending to Hideo Kojima's otherwise fantastic title is a load of old tosh. So it turns out that the whole game has been a "simulation" - an attempt to recreate the Shadow Moses incident from the first game, which has been done to prove... well, nobody's quite sure. Then everything goes crazy (the game tells you to physically turn it off a few times), and then you're fighting Solidus Snake on top of Federal Hall in downtown Manhattan. Then comes the ending. Has there ever been an ending quite like this one? 17-minutes long, and absolutely packed to the brim with plot twists, plot revelations, plot clarifications, philosophical debate, meta-references and whatever else Kojima felt like writing into the game on that specific day. It's half hodgepodge, half acid trip, and no matter how you try to justify it - or explain it - it is entirely baffling in almost every way. There's simply no way that it can make sense.

6. Tokyo, Modern Day - Drakengard

Drakengard isn't a game you need to play, but you do need to hear about its ending, which - for all intents and purposes - is downright insane. The game, set in a fantasy world named Midgard, hinges on a fantasy hero named Caim and his quest to destroy a dragon that did him wrong. The whole game follows an otherwise generic story. That is, until the ending... The first sign that something isn't quite normal occurs when giant super babies hail from the sky, and Caim is forced to engage them in battle until he reaches the head honcho super baby (named "Mother"). It's important to mention here that these babies haven't been mentioned in the game beforehand, and they don't fit into the logic of the story in any way. But they pale in comparison to the next part of the ending, which sees Caim transported to modern day Tokyo (seriously) only to engage a monster in a rhythm game and ultimately end up being blown up by two fighter jets. There are actually five different endings to the game, but the Tokyo ending - for some reason - is considered to be the "definitive" ending.

5. Death Of The Planet - Killzone 3

The ending of otherwise pretty great first-person shooter Killzone 3 is somewhat notorious for the way in which it p*ssed a hell of a lot of people off, mainly because it changed how fans felt about certain characters in a moment of pure "WTF?" that also served as a still unresolved cliffhanger and made absolutely no sense. At the end of the game, then, heroes Sev, Hooper, Jammer and Narville destroy a giant cruiser with a nuke, which results in a huge explosion that - in turn - destroys the entire planet and probably everybody on Earth in the process. Not only did this make little sense from a story perspective, it felt a lot like the developers had no idea what to do and just opted to tie up the plot as quickly as possible, regardless of logic, with the death of the population. Why did the characters even do what they did? What was the point in trying to save the planet by, um, destroying the planet? Seriously rubbish.

4. Booker Is Comstock - BioShock Infinite

The ending of BioShock was acclaimed for being super trippy, unexpected and clever, and whilst it does nothing to ruin the wonderful game that came before it, you have to wonder whether - in its attempts to be shocking - it actually makes any sense. Here goes, then: at the end of the game, you find out that Booker DeWitt - the player character - is actually the father of his young and attractive sidekick, Elizabeth (glad they didn't kiss or anything; that could've been awkward). Then you learn that Booker sold Elizabeth in other dimensions (those exist), and that he also became Zachary Comstock - the antagonist of the game. Comstock also bought Elizabeth. Insane, yes? There's more... At this point, Elizabeth explains to her father that the only way to prevent him from becoming Comstock and being an evil tyrant is for them to go back to a time before he made the transition and for her to kill him. Which she does: she drowns him. But here's the bit that makes the least sense: the reason Booker choose to become Comstock in the first place was as an act of religious atonement for the part he played in a massacre. So why has he turned evil? It just doesn't ring true that Booker, attempting to atone for his sins as a man of faith, would become the racist ruler of a city in the sky. None of this is touched upon, leaving absolutely no explanation as to how such a transition was made - or why Booker choose that name.

3. Alma Rapes Becket - F.E.A.R. 2: Project Origin

The F.E.A.R. games see players battling a whole host of horrific visions and nightmares as a member of an armed paranormal investigation squad, the worst of which comes in the form of Alma - a young girl with a resemblance to that one from The Ring movies. Whilst F.E.A.R. 2 is a great game for the most part, though, the ending is nuts - it feels a lot like the developers wanted to do something "weird" for the sake of it, and it makes little sense. That's to say, F.E.A.R. 2 ends when Alma suddenly transforms herself into adult form, and then forcibly rapes the main protagonist - that is, Michael Becket - in order to impregnate herself, because... well, there is no real reason, aside from the fact that the makers of the game presumably wanted to end things on a controversial note. The very last scene then has the hero touching Alma's stomach whilst the word "Mommy" is faintly heard. There is no context for this, though, nor is this happening hinted at during any part of the story; it just occurs and the game ends, leaving players wondering what the heck they missed. The answer is nothing... you missed absolutely nothing.

2. Dog In The Control Room - Silent Hill 2

Granted, this ending is considered to be something of a "joke ending" and it isn't even supposed to make sense; quite the opposite, in fact. But given that it's an actual ending that anybody playing Silent Hill 2 could stumble upon given that they played the game a specific way, it only feels right to include it as an entry on this list. A lot of the Silent Hill games have joke endings as you may well know, but the Silent Hill 2 variant takes the prize for "most insane." That's to say, upon discovering a bone-shaped key during your second play-through of the game, protagonist James Sunderland might find himself coming face to face with... a dog in a control room? Yes, it turns out that the entire game has been a simulation designed entirely by a cute dog wearing a headset. "So it was all your work!" cries James Sunderland. Then the dog proceeds to lick his face, presumably as a treat for stumbling upon the proper ending. How very... Japanese?

1. Lost In Time (And Translation?) - Final Fantasy VIII

Final Fantasy VIII is a great game - for the first couple of discs. Once you reach the point in the narrative where Squall and friends discover that they were all at the same orphanage as children and don't remember because they've scrambled their memories using special summoning powers known as "Guardian Forces," it begins to lose its way. Then there's the ending, which is near impossible to make sense of. Basically, though, you learn that Ultimecia - an evil sorceress - has been trying to compress time to become all-powerful. Squall and his companions travel to the future to defeat her, but then Squall is lost in time, and Ultimecia then transfers her powers to another sorceress, who Squall is told to inform to create SeeD and therefore set an infinite time loop in motion and... You have to wonder whether the ending of the game was lost in translation, because no matter how you look at it it's plainly impossible to understand - a succession of explanations that only serve to make what was explained previously all the more confusing and/or convoluted (worst of all, it makes you feel dumb for not "getting it"). It doesn't necessarily take away from Final Fantasy VIII, because it's a wonderful game with stunning moments and some of the best game characters ever, but the ending is a bunch of nonsense, redeemed only by the lovely over-credits scene, and the bit with Squall and Rinoa coming together on the balcony for a kiss (or is he dead?). Like this article? Agree or disagree with these picks? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.