10 Video Game Enemies That Should've Been The Final Boss
Mortal Kombat fans never got their Dark Raiden.
There's a lot more to designing a final boss than making them tough-as-nails. Because there's so much emphasis on story and character development in modern titles, gamers expect the developers to put just as much effort into crafting a truly great antagonist.
The final battle is the last thing that players experience before the credits roll, and it's imperative these baddies leave a major impression.
That's why it's agonising when the last adversary stinks to high heaven. Anyone who's played Far Cry 3, Shadow of Mordor, or Gears of War 2 know all too well how a crappy climax can ruin an otherwise perfect game.
This is more frustrating when the player encounters evildoers throughout the main campaign who are far more interesting than the hero's nemesis. When a game spends hours fleshing out a villain's backstory and motivations, it's non-sensical to replace them with some nobody at the last minute. If an underling is ten times more memorable than the big bad, it's hard to understand why the showdown wasn't against them.
The final bosses on this list weren't just bad - none of them should've been the final boss to begin with.
10. Kuja - Final Fantasy IX
Within the first few hours of Final Fantasy IX, it's clear that Kuja poses a major threat to world. Being a genetically engineered entity hell-bent on Gaia's destruction, the feathered-haired foe has "main villain" written all over him. Since our hero, Zidane is Kuja's brother, their personal relationship makes their rivalry more engaging.
Now, because this is Final Fantasy, fans were expecting a bait-and-switch. Since Kuja's existence was orchestrated by the ancient mage, Garland, it looked like he would replace him as the final boss in the eleventh hour. However, Kuja kills Garland during the climax. With Garland out of the way, it looks like Kuja really is the true antagonist.
But after he's defeated, a mysterious being called Necron appears, revealing he was behind everything. Because Necron has never been mentioned until now, his appearance is totally out of left field. Since nothing is revealed about Necron's motivations or origins, his appearance is completely pointless.
If Necron was left on the cutting room floor, it wouldn't have any effect on the story, which makes players wonder why he was in FFIX in the first place.
9. Astor - Hyrule Warriors: Age Of Calamity
The Great King of Evil, Ganon is the overarching villain in The Legend of Zelda. Always has been, always will be.
And yet, it's refreshing when the Nintendo series introduces a new antagonist. Majora was a genuinely unsettling adversary. Ghirahim might be the most popular villains in the franchise, save for Ganon. Dark Link rarely appears, but still managed to become an icon.
So, when Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity introduced a dark wizard called Astor, it looked like Link has a new rival. Although Astor is Ganon's pawn, he displays tremendous power, proving he can hold his own against Hyrule's forces.
Astor can create energy clones in an instant, allowing the prophet of doom to summon soldiers of any shape, size, or appearance. Even though Link and his friends battle all sorts of monsters throughout their adventure, every run-in with the malevolent magician reminds the Hero of Time that he's not to be trifled with.
Sadly, Astor was replaced in the game's closing moments with, you guessed it, Ganon. Considering Ganon was the final boss of the previous LoZ instalment, Breath of the Wild, it would've been nice if Age of Calamity got the chance to mix up the formula a little.
8. Ra's Al Ghul - Batman: Arkham City
In Batman: Arkham City, Gotham's greatest detective finds himself caught in a maniacal scheme orchestrated by Hugo Strange. Since the devious doctor isn't much of a fighter, players were half-expecting another supervillain from Batman's rogue gallery to serve as the final boss.
So, when Ra's Al Ghul murders Hugo Strange during the climax, it looked like the immortal alchemist would be Batman's final challenger. Ra's seemed like the perfect adversary, since he's a prized fighter, a skilled swordsman, a genius tactician, and a master terrorist. Because his plans threaten the lives of billions, Arkham City couldn't have pitted Batman against a better opponent.
But for some reason, the developers pulled another switcharoo, having the cowled crimefighter squaring off against Clayface. Because this malicious mud-monster is a B-list villain at best, some gamers assumed this boss encounter was the preamble before the showdown.
In a manner of speaking, it is. When Bats defeats the shapeshifting monster, he fights the real final boss... which is Clayface again.
Even though Clayface is very dangerous, he's nothing more than a grunt. Clayface can take many shapes, but he doesn't fit the mold of a final boss.
7. Commandant Steele - Borderlands
Throughout Borderlands, the Vault Hunters learn Commandant Steele is preparing to open the fabled Vault, and use its power for her own nefarious schemes.
But when Steele activates the Vault, she releases a monster called The Destroyer, which abruptly kills her. Recognising the Destroyer will unleash untold destruction upon Pandora, the Vault Hunters band together to kill it.
Even though Borderlands is crammed with innovation, that's nowhere to be seen during this boss battle. Not only is this battle way too easy, it's boring as hell, since the Destroyer is a mega damage sponge.
To make the final fight have a more personal angle, it would've been better if the Vault's energy infused Commandant Steele with godlike power, allowing her to hold her own against our heroes.
Steele is nowhere near as entertaining as Borderland 2's Handsome Jack, but she's still a solid villain. Despite having minimal dialogue, the sinister Siren makes an impression, due to her authoritarian demeanour and her ruthless actions. She may be a bit generic, but there's no question Steele would've been a better final boss than what we got.
6. Anyone - South Park: The Fractured But Whole
South Park: The Fractured But Whole has some of the funniest bosses, not just in South Park games, but in gaming history. Foes like Spontaneous Bootay, Morgan Freeman, and the Crab People are so hilarious, it's difficult to concentrate while fighting them. South Park may not take itself seriously, but it gives 110% when it comes to making the boss battles imaginative, tough, and epic.
Sadly, the same can't be said about the final boss, Mitch Connor AKA Eric Cartman's hand. Considering all the zany characters South Park has introduced over the years, the developers could've picked a more epic antagonist, like Satan, Saddam Hussein, David Blaine, or Mecha-Streisand.
Even though the concept of Mitch Connor is funny and could work as a random boss, he doesn't have the grandiosity that gamers expect from a final fight. The previous instalment, Stick of Truth, had our heroes have a showdown with a zombified Chef and the death-defying Princess Kenny. It was dumb, but suitably histrionic.
Mitch Connor, on the other hand (literally) is so underwhelming, many players had no idea they were fighting the final boss until the credits rolled afterward!
5. Various - Tekken Tag Tournament
Because Tekken Tag Tournament is basically fan-fiction, Namco's two-on-two beat 'em up wasn't bogged down by continuity, meaning any character, living or dead, could show up. As such, there are plenty of imposing figures who could've served as the final boss in this PS2 launch title.
Although Ogre died in Tekken 3, there's no reason why he couldn't be TTT's overarching villain. Alternatively, the story mode could've concluded with a battle against the father-and-son duo, Kazuya and Jin, or an amped up Heihachi.
Instead, the final boss was a new combatant called Unknown. Unknown takes the form of a naked woman, shrouded in shadowy goo, with a ghostly wolf hovering behind her. Even though Unknown has a unique design, nothing is revealed about this dark figure, making her pretty forgettable. Although Tekken is renowned for its memorable villains, Unknown isn't one of them.
To be fair, Unknown could've been a serviceable boss if her identity was revealed. In Tekken Tag Tournament 2, it's revealed Unknown is Jin's mother, Jun Kazama. Although this is an interesting revelation, it's too little too late, since fans had to wait 12 years before Unknown was... known.
4. Salazar - Resident Evil 4
It seems blasphemous to criticise the universally beloved Resident Evil 4, especially after how well the remake turned out. But make no mistake, the primary villain, Osmund Saddler kind of sucks.
What makes the Los Illuminados leader more disappointing is how entertaining his subordinates are. Bitores Mendez scares the crap out of the player every time he appears. (Somehow, he's more terrifying in his boss form.) Jack Krauser has history with our hero, making their fight have more emotional weight. Ramon Salazar might be the most charismatic villain in the whole franchise. Not only are all these guys fascinating, their boss battles are absolutely fantastic.
And then, there's Saddler, who's just some boring, evil guy. Also, the boss battle with this cult leader is surprisingly anti-climactic. (Turning into a spider? That's the best you could do?)
Saddler is so uninteresting, it would've been better if one of his henchmen gave him the boot before taking over his entire operation. And if anybody deserved to replace the demented demagogue, it's gotta be Salazar. (Never get tired of the way he says, "Mr. Kennedy.") Since this dastardly dwarf's over-the-top nature perfectly coincides with RE4's campy charm, it's odd how he serves as a mere lackey.
3. Big Daddy - BioShock
BioShock's Frank Fontaine is a master con-man, capable of swapping personalities and accents at the drop of the hat, allowing him to exploit his victims with ease. Due to Frank's natural swagger and ingenuity, he seized control of Rapture, allowing him to manipulate our hero, Jack, for his own gain.
Even though Frank Fontaine has all the workings of a perfect nemesis, he makes a crap final boss. Not only is his design bafflingly uncreative, the fight itself is brief, generic, and insultingly easy.
In hindsight, it would've been better if BioShock culminated with Frank unleashing a beefed up version of the Big Daddy on Jack. Considering the lumbering brute is the game's mascot and was plastered on all the promos, having him serve as... well... the Big Daddy was logical.
Although Jack has no personal connection with the drill-handed creature, Big Daddy works perfectly as an adversary, since he symbolises everything Rapture stands for - a mechanical grotesquerie shaped by humanity's greed.
But instead of having epic showdown with one of gaming's most beloved villains, BioShock concludes with Jack fighting a Lawnmower Man rip-off.
Yay.
2. Haytham Kenway - Assassin's Creed III
Assassin's Creed III opens with the player taking control of Haytham Kenway. Although players initially assume Haytham is the main character and an Assassin, he's later revealed as the Grand Master of the Templar - the Assassins' sworn enemies.
The story then skips ahead, showcasing the game's true protagonist, Connor, who happens to be Haytham's bastard son. After his mother is killed by Haytham's second-in-command, Charles Lee, Connor vows to destroy the Templar.
Since Lee murdered Connor's mother in cold blood, it's understandable why he is the last villain that Connor faces. But there's no question Haytham is a superior foe by a large margin.
The main campaign spends hours fleshing out his character, allowing the player to understand where he's coming from. Being the hero's father, the riveting interactions between the pair are among the game's highlights. Adrian Hough's performance as Haytham is so compelling, it's hard not to be swayed by his words.
Even though Connor has more motivation to hate Lee, he's simply not that compelling. The fact that their final battle is a glorified chase sequence further highlights Lee was the wrong guy to serve as the antagonist.
1. Raiden - Mortal Kombat 11
In Mortal Kombat lore, Raiden was perceived as a benevolent hero for many years. But in Mortal Kombat: Deception, the thunder god started going down a dark path. After the noble warrior, Shujinko accidentally awakened the demonic Onaga, the realms were brought to the brink of collapse. Even though Shujinko defeated Onaga, Raiden believed he was beyond forgiveness and had him executed him.
Sadly, the deity's sinister streak continued in MK9. In this remake, Raiden shatters the rules of the Mortal Kombat tournament, tries to sell the souls of fallen heroes to Quan Chi, and murders Earthrealm's champion, Liu Kang. Because of his deplorable actions, Raiden had become the very evil he swore to destroy. And when he was corrupted by the Jinsei in MKX, all signs pointed to once-adored hero becoming the primary villain of the next instalment.
But in MK11, it's revealed that Kronika was behind Raiden's fall from grace, exonerating him from all his misdeeds.
Although fans were happy to see Raiden was a good guy again, it was annoying to see his entire story arc discarded, especially after his descent into madness was built up for 15 years.