10 Video Game NPCs You Should NEVER Kill

If you're harvesting in BioShock, you're playing yourself.

Bioshock Little Sister
2K

NPCs are an important part of many games. They offer us insight into their fictional world, sometimes supply duties to fulfil or perhaps even join us along our quest. For the most part this means that, because they serve a purpose, most games make their cast of key characters unkillable. Try all you might, as much as you might hate them, some characters are just here to stay.

But that's not always the case. Some games embrace a player's total control of their electronic entertainment, allowing them to make their own choices whether it comes to back haunt them or not. We, as players, need to make our decisions and live with them. Is your thirst for electronic blood as important as taking a moment to consider the consequences?

Whether offered the choice in story or just genuinely given a health-bar, the following characters are all killable. But should you see them off? Well, quite simply, no.

Whether robbing you of great rewards or breaking the story, the NPCs on this list should be kept alive at all costs.

10. White Mask Varré - Elden Ring

Elden Ring White Mask varre
FromSoftware

Elden Ring's core identity is it's vast open world and the unfolding enigma of it all. As part of keeping the air of mystery and isolation alive, there aren't a lot of friendly NPCs in the game to interact with. So, that being said, why on Earth would you want to hurt any of them?

To be fair, the first NPC you meet - White Mask Varré - will give you good reason right away. He's rude, insulting and Elden Ring players all felt the sting of the remark that they did, indeed, had "no maidens". Look, we're just going through a dry patch okay?

However, if you hold off on your desire to test out your broadsword on him, you'll ultimately be rewarded despite the fact that originally he just seems like a nuisance. White Mask Varré? More like Varré the Gaslighter...

His questline isn't all that good in the grand scheme but fulfilling it up to a certain point gains you early access to Mohgwyn's Palace. This is a darn sight easier than using the late-game (and hard to find) portal. This area is particularly good for levelling up, especially for those with ranged weapons, making the daunting adventure of Elden Ring a little more palatable.


9. The Merchant - Resident Evil 4 (2005)

Resident Evil 4 Merchant
Capcom

One of the most memorable starring roles of Resident Evil 4 is the cockney-accented salesman who buys your junk and sells you new guns with a warm chuckle.

There's a lot of theories surrounding The Merchant in Resident Evil 4? Is he infected? After all, he seems to be safe from the angry villagers and monsters. Additionally, he makes the sound of screaming Ganado when killed.

Isn't it Leon's duty to kill all the infected on his way saving the president's daughter?

In easier difficulties, taking out the Merchant isn't so bad since he'll respawn after a short time. In Professional Mode however, this isn't the case. The Merchant you killed is gone for good. This actually kicked off a theory that there's more than just one of the robed, rocket-launcher-selling salesmen since he does appear later even if you kill him and it would explain his ability to teleport about the place so fast.

Whatever the case, it's generally advised that you don't take this route. Just because you can doesn't men you should!

In certain areas it might not be so bad but in rooms that you might return to or where you need to make a quick sale of spinels to buy some First Aid Sprays before a boss fight, taking out the Merchant is a quick way to screwing yourself over.


8. Faendal - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

skyrim faendal
Bethesda

Skyrim, like many games, marks a lot of key characters as "essential". This mostly means that mainline quest figures are indestructible. However, it doesn't mean that regular townsfolk who held questlines couldn't be killed. One of the first memorable NPCs players interact with in Skyrim is Faendal, a wood elf with a code of honour.

Faendal has a plethora of worthwhile interactions beginning with a quest about his love triangle with Sven and Camilla. He can become a follower for the Dragonborn and, in the Hearthfire DLC, a steward at one of their homes. He can even join the Blades. On top of this, he's able to train the player in archery.

Also, if the player likes taking advantage of the system, since he's a follower he'll be more than happy to trade with you. So you can pay for archery lessons and then just take your money back and poor Faendel will just stand there, shut up and like it.

So not only is Faendel worth keeping around for the exploits, he's also a really good character on a roleplaying level. A man of morals and devoted to his love interest Camilla, he can be randomly found visiting her wherever the player may be in the world. It's a real testament to the Skyrim's world which you can ruin by casually killing Faendel off without a second thought. Fiendish.


7. Nil - Horizon Zero Dawn

Horizon Zero Dawn Nil
Sony Interactive Entertainment

Across Horizon Zero Dawn, Aloy comes into contact with many great characters. One of these is Nil who is, ostensibly, a psychopath.

Despite how conerning his love of murder is, he's a useful ally to Aloy when clearing out the bandit camps across post-apocalyptic Utah and Colorado. When Nil's questline comes to end, he feels as though he has nothing left to do and asks Aloy to fight him - a choice left in the player's hands. Know however that if you choose yes, Nil intends to fight to the death.

There's an trophy in Horizon Zero Dawn called "All My Allies" which is exactly what it sounds like. When Aloy gears up for the endgame, if you've completed the right side-quests, you'll unlock this as you discover your compatriots banding together with you for the greater good. Considering several of Horizon's tribes are wary of each other or outright isolationist, it's an awesome moment.

Nil doesn't actually contribute to this trophy but can join them. In fact, if he doesn't show something feels quite frankly missing. Considering the conversations he and Aloy have are the deepest and most philosophical, he adds a unique element to the world. Quite simply, whilst you'll still get the trophy, Nil deserves to be here.

You get nothing for killing Nil yourself, whereas refusing to fight him allows him to take part in the huge Battle of the Alight.


6. The Rachni Queen - Mass Effect

Mass Effect 3 Rachni Queen
BioWare

In the original Mass Effect, the player comes across a giant alien spider called the Rachni Queen. A feared species yes, but this particular creature is alone and afraid and it's up to Commander Shepherd to decide to kill or spare it.

Because of the ability to carry your save and thus your choices along from game-to-game, the Rachni Queen was able to make appearances in both ME2 and 3, provided you didn't drown her in acid. In fact, she remembers the fact you saved her life very well. When encountering her in Mass Effect 3, you have the choice to again free her from Reaper control (who have been using her body to create soldiers) or abandon her to her death.

Simply, if you save her here then she and her children will be added to the war effort at the end of the game.

If you don't save the Rachni Queen in the original Mass Effect, in her place in the threequel is a Reaper-created clone. Saving this cross-species monster not only doesn't add to your war assets but actively hurts it as a future report details it attacking the Alliance Engineering Corps.

And so, it all comes back to this one decision you made two games ago. Do not kill the space-spider, no matter how bad your space-arachnophobia.


5. Zevran - Dragon Age Origins

dragon age Zevran Arainai
BioWare

Some games, especially RPGs, tend to offer a lot of player choice so that each gamer's journey can take it's own shape. Some of these choices can indeed include which NPCs to kill or spare as well as which allies to recruit to your cause. Dragon Age Origins combines both of these choices into one mega question which some players come to regret.

Zevran is introduced as one of the many side-quest specific villains of the franchise as part of the chapter The Long Road. Here, he's been tasked with ambushing and assassinating the Warden. Upon being defeated, Zevran is knocked unconscious and a particular choice is presented. Either the player can wake Zevran and talk to him or kill him whilst he's no longer a threat.

If you choose the latter in vengeance, then that's the end of matters and you'll go through the rest of the game without realising that you've actually just killed off a potential member of your party. Oops?

Zevran is a valuable companion for a few reasons. Beyond just being a capable rogue, he's a rare character in fantasy. Most elves tend to be hoighty-toighty but Zevran has a certain amount of snark and street-smarts, which make him very memorable... if you didn't unknowingly kill him, that is.


4. Little Sister - BioShock

Little Sister Bioshock
2K Games

One of the selling points of BioShock at the time was it's over-arching choice about the Big Daddies and the Little Sisters. After taking out the protective diving-suit monstrosities, players can decide the fate of the ADAM-riddled children. The words specifically used are "rescue" or the much more sinister "harvest".

In reality however, one of these choices is greater than the other in absolutely every way.

The so-called advantage of immediately harvesting a Little Sister is an instantaneous pay-out of ADAM which can be used to gain more abilities and make your character stronger. However, if you just wait things out, Dr Tenenbaum, who cares deeply for the children, will supply with a greater share later. In fact, it's only in this way that you can get certain plasmid upgrades.

Moreover, the game has three different endings depending on how you tackled this conundrum. If you harvested more than one of the girls, the story concludes with darker undertones that see the player turn into a villain with an army of mind-controlled Little Sisters. Only the good ending is considered canon, which instead allows the girls to live out their lives in peace and take care of the player on their death bed.

It's a moral victory as well as a utilitarian one, which is a rare combination.


3. Michael, Trevor And Franklin - Grand Theft Auto V

Grand Theft Auto V Ending
Rockstar

The GTA series has crime in it's veins and killing in it's blood. So generally speaking, the NPCs caught in the cross-fire of your rampages tend to be inconsequential. Really, all you need to worry about is yourself.

Grand Theft Auto V did a wonderful thing compared to its predecessors by letting gamers take control of (and switch between) three playable characters. It changed everything, allowing players to choose different ways to tackle many missions. When not working through the main story though, it's possible to come across your two allies in the mean streets of Los Santos.

GTA is all about two things: free-roaming player choice and the potential for mayhem. Yes, you could hang out with yourself at a bar or go play golf... or you could fill your fellow protagonist full of lead to see what happens.

For main characters in GTA, death isn't permanent and players will be familiar with getting "wasted" (as the game calls it) and waking up outside the hospital with a cut of their cash gone. This actually isn't any different here. Your compatriot will even text you to say they've footed you the bill.

Thankfully, you've not suddenly cut out a third of the game... but was it worth spending the ammo just to be charged for it?


2. Yagrum Bagarn - Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind

Yagrum Morrowind
Bethesda

Before Skyrim made characters indestructible, Morrowind decided to let players eat their cake and suffer with the consequences. That is to say, every NPC in the Elder Scrolls III is technically killable. You will, with a great many of the most important ones, receive a prompt that warns you that what you did has had a profound effect and "severed the thread of prophecy", recommending reloading a save.

But you don't technically have to and, in all fairness, it's still possible to complete the game no matter what you do or who you kill... with the exception of one character.

Yagrum Bagran is the last living Dwemer and a key figure in the game's story with how it relates to defeating Dagoth Ur. He's the only person in Morrowind with the knowledge and skill to restore the power of the Wraithguard, which is a necessary tool in taking down the immortal final boss of the game. The gauntlet itself is a gift from Vivec but, thanks to a sneaky and exceptionally hidden "back path" route, it's possible to get Wraithguard by killing the NPC.

In fact, the back path method is a totally viable option if you want to roleplay as a sociopath on a killing spree... you just can't murder Yagrum and expect to finish the game. Lucky him.


1. Oswald Of Carim - Dark Souls

Oswald Of Carim Dark Souls
FromSoftware

In Demon's Souls, the sort-of blueprint of the Soulsbourne series, players could very easily ruin their campaign if they aggravated friendly NPCs. Whether you started the fight intentionally or not, any character you've lumped over the head won't stop fighting back until you put them down for good. There's no way to make peace with them and if they were key to the main questline then that's a really rather awful way for your game to end.

So, for all of its own brutality, Dark Souls included Oswald of Carim to fix this.

By ringing the Bell of Awakening at the Undead Parish, the player can speak to and use the services of Oswald providing they can afford it. As a pardoner, Oswald is able to basically calm down any upset NPCs. This is obviously a solution to this issue... unless you decide that Oswald's creepy laughs are reason enough to take an axe to his skull.

Yes, as is the way in this franchise, it's absolutely possible to kill Oswald - and turn Dark Souls back into Demon's Souls. If the pardoner is angry at you he won't offer his power and thus this solution is gone for good, just like that.

Forget looking a gift horse in the mouth, you just punched it and now you'll suffer for it.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Bioshock
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite