10 Video Game Objectives That Totally Trolled Players

Survive? Halo: Reach doesn't let you.

until dawn
Supermassive Games

Video games may have come a long way over the decades, but some of the tried-and-tested conventions of the medium are just too damn effective to get rid of.

Case in point: Mission objectives.

Any sufficiently linear, story-driven video game will give players a list of objectives to complete in order to progress through the game, whether written in the top-left corner of the screen at all times, spoken aloud by other characters, or merely implied by the gameplay loop itself.

And while players would do well to follow these instructions if they want to beat the game in a timely fashion, sometimes developers decide to subvert that gameplay formula for their own perverse amusement.

These 10 video game objectives all trolled players by messing with their expectations and deconstructing the very idea of how passively most of us just blindly follow instructions.

Whether ensuring players are doomed either way, presenting them with a tantalising optional objective which has inevitably dire consequences, or forcing them to dive headlong into a no-win scenario at game's end, these objectives left players questioning the very nature of gaming itself...

10. Deal Or Revenge? - Grand Theft Auto IV

Grand Theft Auto IV Kate Dead
Rockstar

Ahead of Grand Theft Auto IV's final mission, players are given the option to pursue one of two narrative avenues - take part in a heroin deal with the duplicitous Dimitri Rascalov for which you will be paid $250,000, or stick to your "principles" and take revenge against Dimitri for betraying you earlier in the game.

While players might assume the canon "happy" ending is achieved by seeking revenge against Dimitri and not being bought off, GTA IV's ending is most certainly a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation.

The "deal" ending results in Niko's cousin Roman being killed by Dimitri in a botched hit on Niko, while the "revenge" ending, where Dimitri is dead, culminates in Niko's girlfriend Kate being accidentally killed by Don Jimmy Pegorino when he attempts to murder Niko.

There's no good ending here - just misery and...misery. Thankfully the divisive fan response to these ending options prompted Rockstar to offer up a more definitively satisfying "everyone lives!" ending in Grand Theft Auto V.


9. Investigate The Voice - Until Dawn

Until Dawn
Supermassive Games

Until Dawn is a lovingly self-aware homage to the horror genre, and one which often toys with players' expectations to that effect.

However, those who believed they'd outsmarted the game while playing as Ashley sure ended up with a nasty - and fatal! - surprise.

In chapter nine while Ashley is exploring the underground passageway, players are given two options - investigate the faint voice of what sounds like a terrified woman in the distance, or rejoin her group.

The "smart" option, to rejoin the group, just seems too obvious to be true, like the game is setting players up for an easy death.

Hilariously, though, players who opt to investigate the voice and follow this line of inquiry to its conclusion will end up attacked by a Wendigo, which will leap out of a trap door and rip Ashley's head clean from her body.

In a way this is the beauty of Until Dawn - it's so wrapped up in horror tropes that you can't ever be 100% sure whether it's about to earnestly indulge a cliche or actually subvert it. If you thought you were being slick here, though, the game had your number.


8. Kill Yourself To Save The Human Race - Saints Row IV

Saints Row IV
Volition

The Saints Row games absolutely love trolling the player, and Saints Row IV relished doing so by presenting a pretty typical multi-coloured life-or-death choice in the mid-game mission "Zero Cool."

In the middle of your quest to retrieve Matt Miller, the game's extraterrestrial warlord antagonist Zinyak will offer two options - enter the blue door to rescue Matt and, according to Zinyak, doom the human race to extinction, or enter the red door and save humanity, albeit at the cost of your own life.

If you decide to take the red door and give humankind a chance, the game's end credits will immediately roll and an achievement will pop, knowingly named "You Chose... Poorly."

From there, you'll be able to reload from the last checkpoint and pick the option the game actually wants you to pick in order to continue onwards - the blue door.


7. Mix Medicine & Alcohol - The Curse Of Monkey Island

The Curse Of Monkey Island
LucasArts

Trust a Monkey Island game to troll players.

Despite your smarter instincts likely telling you it's a bad idea, roughly two-thirds of the way through The Curse of Monkey Island, players will realise the only way to progress forward is to mix a drink of grog with the Head-B-Clear medicine in their possession.

But upon doing so you might first assume you've simply met a narrative dead-end, as Guybrush immediately breaks the fourth wall to mention how foolish such an act is, before seemingly dropping dead on the spot.

The game keeps the gag going by having an undertaker collect Guybrush's "corpse" from the bar, and the end credits even roll over what appears to be Guybrush's final resting place in a crypt.

Just as players assume they've reached the most prolonged Game Over screen in video game history, however, the credits dissolve and the game continues, as you're now tasked with to finding a way to free Guybrush from his live burial.


6. Deliver The Mysterious Box - Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic

Star Wars Knights Of The Old Republic
LucasArts

In legendary RPG Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic, developers BioWare decided to mess with players' natural-yet-insatiable curiosity in one of the side quests on Korriban.

Those who complete a spice delivery for the Rodian Lurze Kesh will receive the offer of further employment, and upon accepting will receive a mysterious box to deliver to Motta the Hutt.

Lurze warns you not to open the box under any circumstances, albeit without ever explaining why not. Naturally for many players the temptation is simply too much, though if you're going to open the box you'll probably want to save your game first.

Opening the box results in the player's consciousness being transported to a white metaphysical prison, where a Rakatan prisoner is waiting.

You're then forced into a Hobbit-esque riddle game with the Rakatan, as only after answering a few riddles correctly will you be returned to your body.

Get any of them wrong, though, and you'll be trapped in the soul prison while the Rakatan makes off with your body, resulting in a Game Over. Nice.


5. Meld With Morinth - Mass Effect 2

Mass Effect 2 Morinth
BioWare

No video game franchise does romance quite like Mass Effect, and the second game in the series even allows you to forge a romance with a deadly mate, the asari known as Morinth.

Morinth makes the seductive sell that her melding partners experience much greater pleasure than in a typical melding, the only flipside being that she has a rare genetic disorder which also causes her to kill anyone she mates with.

Furthermore, because Morinth grows stronger, smarter, and more powerful with each deadly meld, she's effectively addicted to it and will do whatever it takes to lure mates in.

Players who sufficiently pursue Morinth will even hear her proclaim that Shepard may be strong-of-mind enough to survive the meld, and suggests they attempt it if they both survive the game's climactic suicide mission.

Those who hold Morinth to her word get a nasty - if hilarious - surprise, then, when finally melding with her.

The liaison quickly results in Shepard dying a seemingly agonising death as his nervous system is, as Morinth puts it, "overloaded with ecstasy."

Never change, Mass Effect.


4. Collect 50 Star Bottle Caps - Fallout: New Vegas

Fallout New Vegas Festus
Obsidian

Fallout: New Vegas' quest "The Legend of the Star" sees Sunset Sarsaparilla robot Festus instructing players to fetch 50 Sunset Sarsaparilla star bottle caps in order to receive a prize.

Now, collecting 50 star bottle caps takes forever in this game, so players are quite reasonable to expect a hefty reward at the end of it all.

But when you return to Festus, player rage is guaranteed when the "reward" is nothing more than him regaling you with the story of how Sunset Sarsaparilla came to be. And to rub salt in the wound, at the end of the story you'll get a "quest failed" message appear.

But wait, there's more. Cheesed-off players - that is, everyone - can talk to Festus again and register their dissatisfaction, and he'll then tell them to head around the corner and claim the real prize that Sunset Sarsaparilla decided to include after receiving so many complaints.

Though the "attendant" appointed to dispense the prize is now a mere skeletal corpse, you can loot him for a ton of bottlecaps and the Pew Pew, an extremely potent laser pistol. Talk about an emotional rollercoaster.


3. Screw Everyone - Dead Rising 3

Dead Rising 3
Capcom

You generally need to look out for yourself above all others in the middle of a zombie apocalypse, though Dead Rising 3 takes the opportunity to teach selfish players a lesson about the merits of teamwork - or, at least, not being a self-obsessed a**hole.

At the start of the game's seventh and final chapter, players are told to meet their friends at the karaoke bar, but you're actually free to instead head directly to the escape plane and attempt a speedy exit.

When you approach the plane, an objective prompt even appears which says, "Screw everyone. Time to leave?"

If you accept the prompt and continue your escape, player character Nick will be caught by his pals trying to flee Los Perdidos without them, at which point they'll knock him on his ass and fly out of dodge without him, while expressing disappointment at his selfishness.

To hammer home the fact you screwed up, an ending title card will then note that Los Perdidos was destroyed by a bomb with no evidence of survivors, and the United States is now a post-apocalyptic husk without hope of redemption.


2. Survive - Halo: Reach

Halo: Reach
Bungie

Halo: Reach's final mission is the definition of a troll-job. The mission, "Lone Wolf," takes place as protagonist Noble Six stages his desperate last stand against the Covenant.

The simple mission objective which flashes up on the screen? "Survive."

Except, there's actually no way at all to complete the mission in tact, as you're only meant to keep the Covenant distracted long enough for the Pillar of Autumn to make it safely out of dodge, in turn teeing up the events of the original Halo.

No matter how valiant your fight and the objective suggesting there is a way for players to make it out in one piece, you will eventually be overwhelmed by the Covenant forces and killed, albeit for the greater good.

It's kinda genius, really, as showing an objective on-screen makes players believe they can actually overcome and fight harder to do so as a result, rather than simply assuming they were always fated to die and just giving up.


1. Kill The Sadist - The Evil Within

The Evil Within Sadist
Bethesda

At the very beginning of The Evil Within, protagonist Sebastian Castellanos ends up plunged into a nightmarish world where he's strung upside down, requiring players to swing themselves around, grab a knife, and cut themselves down.

Upon getting to their feet, players will have to deal with their first combat engagement, as the towering recurring enemy known as the Sadist lurks nearby.

Between your recent acquisition of a knife and the game teaching you to sneak, it isn't immediately clear to all players whether they're supposed to take the Sadist on directly or go the stealth route.

But those who try to take the Sadist on with their knife will soon enough get their answer. Attempting to stab him will only result in the pissed off Sadist knocking Sebastian to the floor and swiftly decapitating him with one blow of his giant meat cleaver.

If nothing else, this made it abundantly clear to players that stealth would be a vital gameplay component without which they would be utterly screwed.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Until Dawn
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.