10 Video Game Plot Holes You Can't Ignore

Yeah, Deathloop makes NO sense.

deathloop game
Arkane Studios

Games in the old days used to just be a pie eating dots while running from ghosts, a pair of paddles swatting a ball back and forth, and your princess being in another castle. But nowadays, with the technological and societal improvements in game development, the narrative aspect of gaming has become more prominent.

There's still many issues with narrative development when it comes to making games, but things are a lot better than they used to be. That being said, even the greatest or most successful writers can forget some of their own lore and canon.

Now, imagine you're writing a book via council with three other people, while also including input from a graphical specialist, a mechanical specialist, and a marketing specialist telling you what to do. And all of them are telling you "No, we can't do that. Change it."

You're going to wind up with a few narrative mistakes, especially when the whole crew may change between entries in a series. So here's ten plotholes that are so blatant, you just can't ignore them.

Even if you didn't notice them before, you'll never be able to forget them now. You're welcome.

10. Resident Evil: Code Veronica - Claire Already Knows How To Find Chris

Resident Evil Code Veronica X
Capcom

Resident Evil: Code Veronica is many things - some reviewers called it the best RE game at the time of its release.

Many called it the best game to release on the Sega Dreamcast! And to a select more-than-few it is the game you had to start over at the halfway point because you couldn't survive the boss battle against the Tyrant on the plane.

The whole plot of the game is that Claire Redfield, three months after the events of Resident Evil 2, breaks into an Umbrella facility to find her missing brother, Chris. She is captured and imprisoned in a research facility in the Antarctic Ocean, owned by the Umbrella allies, the Ashford Family.

Before escaping the facility with fellow inmate Steve Burnside, Claire gets access to a computer and decides to send an e-mail. The message she sends goes out to her friend from RE 2, Leon S. Kennedy, whom she tells Steve, knows where her brother Chris is, and can therefore, forward the message to him.

I'm sorry, what? She has Leon's e-mail and knows that Leon is aware of where Chris is at? So why did she infiltrate the Umbrella facility, getting herself captured and not just call Leon to say, "Yo, Big L, little help??"


9. Hyrule Warriors - When Did You Transform?

Midna True Form
Nintendo

Koei-Tecmo has become the cranberry of the gaming world, mixing their Dynasty Warriors hack-and-slash and musou gameplay into other franchises. Gundam, Fire Emblem, and even the Legend of Zelda.

Said LoZ cran-apple concoction is known as Hyrule Warriors. It follows a similar format as the DW series, but - as you may have guessed - being filled with Link and pals.

One of those pals is Midna, the stone-crown wearing, tsundere, namesake royal imp of the 2006 release Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess.

In Hyrule Warriors, the first time you meet Midna, she whines that she hates another character in the game - Cia, because she turned Midna into the imp she appears as. Cia is a sorceress who joins with one of the villains from Midna’s game, Zant, and curses Midna to turn into the imp she’s mostly known as.

The issue with that plan being that Cia is also a playable character - and in Cia’s storyline, Midna is already an imp the first time they meet.

Now, game development is a tough gig and it does suck having to make an entire model for a single cutscene - but you’d think they would have just altered a bit of story to prevent the mistake. Especially since they wound up making her human form for later parts of the game, anyway.


8. Ni No Kuni - The Travel Gates Make No Sense

ni no kuni
Level-5

The plot behind the first Ni no Kuni game is kind of bleak when you think about it:

Kid nearly dies, his mother does die in the process of heroically rescuing him, and he goes on a quest to another realm in order to try to bring her back to life. Here's the thing, though - the creatures from another realm aren't visible to the folks of his realm.

Maybe we can ignore the fact that nobody calls BS when this kid just starts talking to, what to them, is just a doll - or even thin air. The kid just lost his mom, he's young, his world's crushed. But maybe somebody should say "Hey, this kid may have lost the plot - we need to get him to a counselor."

Now one we can't ignore, though, is that one of the early quests is to create a gigantic gate to travel between worlds. Part of the quest is finding a big enough open spot to summon the gate. And then, once you do it the first time - you can just do it anywhere. In the middle of the street if you want.

Which brings us back to the first point: This kid just disappears in front of people, in the middle of the street - and nobody bats an eye.


7. Tomb Raider Angel Of Darkness - Aren't You Happy To See Me?

tomb raider lara croft angel of darkness
CORE

The Tomb Raider series has certainly had its ups and downs, and Angel of Darkness is largely considered one of those downs. While the game was buggy, had a terrible camera, and control issues, many praised the plot. In this gothy re-imagining of Lara Croft she is framed for the murder of her old mentor, Werner von Croy.

The game opens to Lara confronting von Croy while he’s begging her to help him recover a series of paintings for a client. They don’t seem very friendly, what with Laura accusing him of leaving her behind - referring to him abandoning her in Egypt during the events of Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation.

Except...he didn’t leave her behind.

At the end of the game, she is hanging from a ledge and he offers her a hand to pull her up. In her defence, von Croy had recently been possessed by the real villain, Egyptian God, Set. But she refused to take his hand and he leaves before the whole place collapses.

In the following game, we see von Croy leading a search party in Egypt, excited to find signs that she is still alive. Sooo why is Lara so mad at him in Paris, and still willing to meet him at all?


6. The Walking Dead - How Did They Steal The Boat?

Walking dead episode 4
Telltale

Telltale put forth a champion steed when they put out the first season of their Walking Dead games. Sure, they beat that poor horse until it was dead, and then beat it all the way into bankruptcy.

But for a time, the Walking Dead episodes they were putting out were masterpieces that could do no wrong. Even when we learned our choices...really didn't matter as much as the game tried to make us think they did.

But there's a glaring issue in the first season - in Episode 4 the group finally finds a much sought-after boat, then meets up with and allies themselves to a group comprised of old folks, a few sick ones, and former cancer patients.

Then, in episode 5, those folks steal the boat from under the group's nose.

So... how did these folks get the boat out of the garage it was parked in? An earlier plot point is that there are no working vehicles in the whole city. Even if you had one, the roads are packed full of broken-down vehicles, so you couldn't drive out anyway.

In theory they'd have to drag it, but how did the aforementioned group of people carry a full-size speedboat through a zombie-infested city?


5. Space Quest 3 - A Lot Of Effort Over A Free Whistle

Space Quest IV
Sierra

Space Quest is a comedy graphic adventure series originally produced by the now-defunct Sierra Entertainment back in 1986. It was developed to compensate for the super-serious other productions by Sierra at the time such as the Kings’ Quest franchise and the film tie-in, The Black Cauldron.

In the second game in the series you are stranded on the planet Labion, after big bad, Vohaul, sends you there to become a slave worker in his mines. As punishment for playing the first game and ruining his plans, of course.

While you’re on Labion you find a mail box and send for a Labion Terror Beast Mating Whistle. This whistle becomes important to a puzzle later on - because of course it does in a classic adventure game.

Skip ahead to the third game in the series, literally because there’s time travel, and the main character, Roger Wilco, finds himself being hunted by a Terminator-like android out to kill him for having not paid for the whistle in Space Quest II, plus fees and interest.

The only problem with this hilarious event is that the whistle is advertised as free in the mail order form you submit in SQ2. How do you owe money for a free object?


4. Borderlands - Why Can't The Enemies Use New-U Stations?

Borderlands 2 new-u station
2K Games

Borderlands is a wonderfully chaotic loot-shooter known for its wild characters, tight gameplay, and a gun that yells 'pew pew' in Ashley Burch's voice.

With three games in the numbered franchise, a pre-sequel, Borderlands has also successfully survived several spin-offs, including a D&D-inspired stint and even an adventure game from Telltale Games - of Walking Dead and Batman fame.

One of the major aspects, especially if you die a lot, is the New-U stations. If the various whackjobs and wild monsters on Pandora kill you at some point, you will magically respawn at one of these New-U stations.

The question quickly becomes - why don't any enemies ever use them? We know they're canon because characters in the game talk about them - antagonist Handsome Jack even offers to pay you to kill yourself and try one.

The biggest conflicts are undoubtedly Handsome Jack, himself, and Roland. Handsome Jack dies and doesn't respawn at one - but he owns them. You'd think he'd have himself programmed in there, especially with all the people out there trying to kill him. And then Roland, who was a playable character in the first game, dies in a cutscene in 2. But the machines resurrected him all through the first game, so why not the second? I guess he didn't keep up on his insurance premiums.


3. Resident Evil 7 - The Happy Birthday Video

Resident Evil 7 Happy Birthday
Capcom

The fact that Resident Evil is on this list twice could suggest the whole series is filled with wild plotholes. I mean, it is, of course, but RE7: Biohazard was otherwise the pinnacle of fixing a franchise that had, honestly, fallen apart.

There was a section of the game where the protagonist, Ethan, winds up in what one of the antagonists, Lucas, refers to as his 'party room'.

This section is generally referred to as the Happy Birthday Puzzle. There, Ethan finds a video tape that details how to disable several of the traps and alerts him to the fact the cake explodes.

So... why does he just stand there in the cake's blast radius and appears to be totally surprised by its explosion? I'd like to think if I really found a video tape warning me something was going to explode, I wouldn't just stare at it and then go "Woah, an explosion! Who'd a thunk that was gonna happen?"

But Ethan, regardless of your actions as the player, does just that. Happy Birthday indeed, idiot.


2. Gears Of War - Are The Kryll Dangerous, Or Not?

Gears of war kryll
Epic

Gears of War did many things - push waist-high cover walls into the mainstream, make men with bigger shoulders than the pauldrons on a Warcraft character, and throw a terrifying enemy at you: The Kryll.

These flying creatures are like a strange mating of piranha and bat and will tear apart and eat anything in their path. And their path basically contains anything not bathed in light.

In the first game the Kryll are feared by both the humans and their locust enemies. They will eat the locusts just fast as they’ll eat your delicious human linebackers - and your chainsaw gun won’t stop them.

The only person on the planet immune to the Kryll is a locust general named Raam. Raam is basically surrounded by the things who do him no harm. His technique for doing so is never explained.

Which brings us to Raam’s Shadow, a DLC release for Gears of War 3 which canonically takes place before the events of the first game. But in Raam’s Shadow, the locust are able to walk through Kryll without issue - and several of Raam’s lieutenants can even command the aerial menaces.

So, when do the Kryll become dangerous to locusts - and why?


1. Deathloop - Juliana Has Infinite Time To Hack The Tunnels

Deathloop PS5
Arkane

Deathloop is a game about Colt, a security chief, turning on his former employers - and fellow conspirators - who have created a time loop. The death part of the titles comes from the fact that you’re trying to kill the aforementioned employers and also that dying resets the loop for Colt. There’s also another character named Juliana, who is really - and I mean really - out to get Colt.

A major aspect of the game is that you, as Colt, have access to a tunnel system that Juliana can’t get into.

It gives Colt a safe space and a way to travel undetected between the various locales of the island the loop takes place on, Blackreef. Juliana even laments to Colt at one point that she’s never been able to figure out the code to access Colt’s tunnels.

Except...it’s only a four-digit code and the digits are 0-7. There are only 4,096 possible combinations. Juliana and Colt have been in a daily cat-and-mouse game for a century by the time the game opens up.

If she tried a new code every day, she’d have figured it out after little more than a decade. And that’s assuming the randomizer at the start of the game didn’t make your code 0001.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Deathloop
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Author of Escort (Eternal Press, 2015), co-founder of Nic3Ntertainment, and developer behind The Sickle Upon Sekigahara (2020). Currently freelancing as a game developer and history consultant. Also tends to travel the eastern U.S. doing courses on History, Writing, and Japanese Poetry. You can find his portfolio at www.richardcshaffer.com.