10 Video Game Plot Twists That Were OBVIOUS (If You Really Looked)

It was right in front of you the entire time!

Red Dead Redemption 2
Rockstar

Generally speaking, games aren't known for being subtle about their big plot twists. Pokemon villains are notorious for spouting out their evil plans right out of the gate, and the repetitive tropes of franchises such as the Legend of Zelda or Mario make it very easy to predict how each new story is going to pan out.

However, just because most games tend to go for the blatantly obvious approach to storytelling, that doesn't mean there aren't games that do it in a much more subtle and sophisticated way.

Some games are able to foreshadow their plot twists so cleverly that, even though they're staring you right in the face the entire time, you still don't realize what's happening until the big reveal. These are the best and most brilliant examples of storytelling in games that you tend to appreciate long after you finish your playthrough.

You may not have gotten these hints the first time you played, but once you read about them, it'll all become totally obvious. Here are some of the greatest plot twists in games that only the most observant players noticed (obviously, get ready for some spoilers ahead).

10. Arthur's Tuberculosis - Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead 2 Arthur Morgan
Rockstar Games

Red Dead Redemption 2 is a game full of amazing little details. From NPCs actually eating their food to certain body parts of your horse shrinking in cold weather, the developers clearly put a lot of thought into designing the game. This, of course, extends to the main story and how the game foreshadows Arthur getting diagnosed with tuberculosis.

Although the revelation came as a surprise to many during their first playthrough, there are actually a few subtle hints the game leaves to let you know of Arthur's sickness beforehand. The first and most direct one is Arthur getting coughed on by Thomas Downes when you try to collect money from him. You can see the sick man coughing up his spit and blood right into Arthur's face, sealing his fate.

This is not the only hint, however. The game also lets you know there's something wrong with Arhtur by making it more difficult for him to gain weight. Unlike John, who can get pretty big pretty fast, Arthur barely bulks up after becoming infected.

This kind of attention to detail is why Red Dead Redemption 2 is still considered a gaming marvel after all these years.


9. Nicole Is Dead - Dead Space

Dead Space Nicole Is Dead
EA

Nicole Brennan is one of the major driving forces behind Dead Space's storyline. She's Isaac's girlfriend, who helps him navigate through the Necromorph-infested Ishimura. She also serves as his motivation for delving deeper into the spaceship instead of hightailing it out of there like any sane person would.

The big plot twist here is that despite your frequent interactions with Nicole throughout the story, the woman has actually been dead the entire time, long before Isaac even arrived on Ishimura. The revelation is shocking the first time you play, although if you were paying attention to what's going on in the background, it's literally spelled out for you.

Combining the first letters of each chapter title in the game forms the sentence: "Nicole is dead." It's a pretty straightforward message for the player, but since most people don't spend their time looking for hidden messages in the naming conventions of chapters, only a few keen eyes can realistically catch it before the actual reveal.

To some, this method of foreshadowing is a clever metaphor for Isaac shortly regaining his clarity in between his hallucinations of Nicole. Others see it as a way for a bored story writer to have some fun naming chapters.


8. Ciri's Death - The Witcher 3

The Witcher 3 Ciri
CD Projekt RED

Pretty much all Witcher 3 players agree that the worst ending in the game is Ciri dying while trying to deal with the White Frost. It happens when you act overly protective of Ciri, which is why it can come off as a shock to most players, even though the game does foreshadow what consequences your actions will have.

During the mission "Blood on the Battlefield," there is an interaction between Geralt and Ciri after the girl grows frustrated with her magic training. The player can console her by saying she doesn't have to be perfect, or distract her with humor.

If the player chooses the first option, Ciri will feel less inclined to work on herself, resulting in her death in the final act. The game indicates this with the shot of a cat carrying a dead swallow in its mouth, which may seem unimportant at the moment, if you weren't paying attention.

The shot is clearly symbolic of Ciri's death. Her elven name translated is "swallow" and several characters use the word as a nickname for Ciri.

If you managed to pick up on this, you get a chance to reload and save Ciri. If you didn't, your obliviousness had just cost you your favorite protege.


7. Would You Kindly? - BioShock

BioShock Andrew Ryan
2K Games

BioShock is a game full of plot twists and shocking revelations. The most interesting one of them is the fact that the player's character, Jack, is a sleeper agent working for a criminal mastermind named Frank Fontaine.

The plot twist is revealed towards the end of the game, but the player can connect the dots way earlier, as BioShock's creators hint at this in a pretty clever manner.

Jack's activation phrase that makes him do Frank's bidding is "would you kindly." It appears at different points in the game, and at first you might think its use is all random, but in reality, there's a clear pattern. The phrase is only used during moments when you, as the player, have little to no choice about how you can proceed. The progression is linear because Jack's trigger doesn't allow him to do anything that isn't Frank Fontaine's command.

This is a really smart way of utilizing level design in storytelling. It foreshadows the plot twist with Jack's conditioning without ever having to mention it directly.

So game developers, would you kindly use this type of narration more often?


6. Solas Is The Dread Wolf - Dragon Age: Inquisition

DAI Solas Dread Wolf
BioWare

With the upcoming release of Dragon Age: Dreadwolf, the plot twist that Solas, one of your companions in the Inquisition, is the feared elven god Fen'Harel shouldn't surprise anyone. However, when Trespasser first came out, it was a pretty unexpected revelation.

Even though the game's writers were very generous about leaving hints...

It turns out that just by having friendly conversations with Solas, you can cause him to occasionally slip up and almost reveal his true identity. The most notable example of this is when you speak with him after attending the ball at the Winter Palace in Orlais.

Solas will state that he missed court intrigue, secretly referring to his feuds with the other ancient gods. However, because Solas the Companion is supposed to be a homeless mage with little to no possessions, his statement seems a bit off. If you confront him about this, he will act flustered and then come up with a half-hearted excuse about spirits and the Fade.

It's actually really funny because drilling him about his past is the only moment in the game when Solas disapproves of you asking questions instead of endorsing it.

He might like his Inquisitors curious—but not too curious, it seems.


5. Moon Ending - Portal 2

Portal 2 Chell
Valve

Portal games love their secrets and hints. Well, foreshadowy types of hints. You're still on your own, solving those puzzles.

The greatest twist in the sequel happens during the final stage, where the player needs to defeat Wheatley by creating a portal on the surface of the moon that sucks the lovingly maniacal core right into the empty void of space.

The moon's role in the final battle is foreshadowed earlier in the game, when Aperture Science's CEO, Cave Johnson, reveals that the white walls used in the portal gun testing are made out of moon rocks. However, there is also an even earlier reference to the moon that only the most observant players can find.

Inside the dens of Portal's mysterious Rattman, there are several drawings of the moon during its different stages. The full moon is always highlighted in some way, and although you could write this off as just another work of Rattman's insanity, its constant appearance clearly sends a message that it's going to play an important role.

Some have even theorized that Rattman purposefully made Chell wake up during a full moon to give her an upper hand when fighting GLaDOS.

Too bad his plan was wasted on Wheatley instead...


4. Humanity Is Gone - Nier: Automata

NieR Automata World
Square-Enix

The story of Nier revolves around androids helping humanity survive after a mysterious alien invasion destroys Earth and forces all humans to escape to a secret base on the moon. The twist here is that, in reality, all of humanity is gone, and all of the characters you play don't really serve any purpose.

The plot twist is actually really obvious if you take notice of some of the stuff happening in the background. One of the most glaring details that might grab your attention early on is the eerie silence inside the moon's base. There is no staff working there, aside from robots and androids, and you never interact with any humans while on board.

You do get to meet some humans throughout the game, but if you look into it close enough, you realize they're also just androids. The members of the Resistance you encounter early on might bleed like humans, but further down the line, the game shows you that older models of androids can "bleed" as well, by spilling crimson fluids from their malfunctioning body parts.

The twist is right there in front of you the entire time. Just like that self-destruct button, for some reason.


3. Samus Is A Girl - Metroid

Super Metroid Crystal Flash
Nintendo

The reveal of Samus's gender at the end of Metroid is one of the most famous moments in gaming. Despite being just a vague collection of pixels, Samus taking off her helmet shook the entire world and helped her solidify her status as a video game icon.

But all this said, Samus's reveal shouldn't have really been such a huge surprise. Her feminine features can be spotted way earlier in the game, though it does take some special knowledge regarding the game's mechanics.

The original Metroid featured a set of special moves that could only be activated by performing hidden combos. One of them, called the Crystal Flash, had the ability to heal massive amounts of damage, but more importantly, it gave the player an opportunity to peek inside Samus's metallic exterior.

The animation that played when the player activated the Crystal Flash showed a glowing orb encompassing Samus's body and then removing her armor. The silhouette inside the orb was clearly feminine, which is why those who knew about this secret mechanic probably weren't that surprised when Samus jumped out of her suit in the ending.

Talk about anticlimactic.


2. Ethan Is A Bio Weapon - Resident Evil Village

Resident Evil Village Lady Dimitrescu
Capcom

The big reveal of Resident Evil Village is that the real Ethan Winters has been dead since Resident Evil VII and that the character the player controls in Village is actually a Bio Weapon version of his body that was created after Ethan was exposed to the mold in Bakers' residence.

There are several moments in the game that hint at Ethan's true nature before it's revealed. In Castle Dimitrescu, the tall vampire lady herself first takes note of it when she drinks Ethan's blood and calls it "stale." Then, things get even more obvious when Lady Dimitrescu cuts off Ethan's hand, and the man barely reacts to it at all.

But if his weird resistance to fatal injuries was not convicting enough, you can actually examine Ethan's severed hand more closely in your inventory to find that there are small patches of black mold growing inside of it, confirming his mysterious endurance is the result of his death in BioHazard.

Ethan's condition is a plot twist known to everyone in the game, except Ethan himself and you, the player. However, you just have to be attentive enough to join the "We Know" club with the rest of Village's cooky cast.


1. You Are Revan - Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic

Revan Reveal
BioWare

The reveal in Knights of the Old Republic that your amnesiac character was the legendary Darth Revan the entire time is possibly one of the greatest plot twists in video game history. Partially, because it's so inspiring. And partially because it's actually really well set up, so long as you're able to notice certain things hidden within the dialogue.

The game makes plenty of references to your character's forgotten identity; you just need to make the connection. The first reference actually happens within the initial few cutscenes of the game, where your character learns how the Jedi use the Force to wipe people's memories after interrogating them. The first time you play, it sounds like nothing more than a little bit of lore or trivia, but given your own character's amnesia, it really makes the twist at the end quite obvious.

There are far too many similar moments in the game to list them all here; however, just this one quote should give an idea of how genuinely well-crafted the foreshadowing of Knights of the Old Republic is.

Now, if only the same could be said about that awful turret mini-game.


Watch Next


Contributor

Video games enthusiast with a love for bizarre facts about his favorite titles. Really into old-school strategies and RPGs of all shapes and sizes.