10 Video Game Remakes Fans Won’t Allow
Leave these alone, or we riot.
Why bother making a new game when you can simply take an old one and remake it? There's been a startling upturn in the amount of remade games being released and it's pretty obvious why - few things empty wallets faster than nostalgia. Don't be too cynical though; most remakes, when done with care, are actually worthwhile.
There are some games that developers should be afraid to revisit though. Video game fans are a passionate bunch at the best of times; but when things displease them, it can get very ugly, very quickly. Remaking a classic game and not doing an exceptional job of it is a surefire way to draw hatred from fans, yet those same fans constantly demand updates to certain games... would you want to be a developer?
In a similar fashion to films, games can draw cult audiences as well; these are the fanbases you really want to avoid upsetting. Not every game on this list would classify as a cult title but there are a few; developers beware, your reputations could be on the line if you don't follow this article's advice. For various reasons the ten games on this list are best left alone as the fans would go insane if the remade versions didn't live up to their insanely high standards. Some games on this list might actually benefit from a revision but the risk just wouldn't be worth it; it's better to play it safe sometimes and leave things as they are.
As always, if you want to add your opinion, feel free to leave it in the comments below.
10. Psychonauts

It must be amazing to live inside the mind of Tim Schafer. His bonkers (yet brilliant) approach to game design has created some of the most unique experiences in all of the medium and he's a pretty funny guy to boot; after all, he did co-create the Monkey Island series. As such, pretty much any Double Fine game could appear on this list; they're all unique, entertaining games which still to this day are highly playable.
The demand for a follow-up to Psychonauts is impressive though. The game is all about entering people's minds and exploring their imaginations; it's pretty crazy (in a good way) as a result. There's also no conclusive end to the game, leaving it wide open for a sequel, yet a follow-up doesn't seem to be a priority for Double Fine.
Could the game be remade for next gen consoles with a new look? Absolutely, but what most people would prefer to see is a brand new game. After all, Psychonauts' PC release was already upgraded to high-definition standards; anybody interested in playing the game with better graphics should really be looking there. Most fans will want to see a continuation to the game, not a revisit to the original.
9. Shadow Of The Colossus

Can video games be referred to as art? It's a debate that's raged for years and one game in particular is frequently used as an example of an 'arty game' - Shadow Of The Colossus. A real sleeper hit for the PlayStation 2, Shadow Of The Colossus' minimalist design and emotional journey have struck a chord with the vast majority of people to play it; to say it has a cult fanbase is an understatement.
The game has undergone a HD upgrade for it's PlayStation 3 port but a full remake could potentially happen one day, especially given the fact that a movie based on the game was recently announced. Even turning the game into a movie sounds a bit bizarre; will the game's journey be as powerful if there's no physical input or connection between the narrative and the audience? Will Wander defeating the hulking, giant Colossi mean as much if there's no playable risk of failure? It seems like an odd move.
Above all else, if we're willing to decide that Shadow Of The Colossus should be considered as a form of art, does it need changing? After all, it's not as if people are constantly debating about upgrading or remaking the Mona Lisa; we seem fairly content to leave artworks the way they are, so why change arty games?
8. Devil May Cry

From the very first teaser, people absolutely hated Capcom's 2013 reboot of the Devil May Cry series. There was some real venom being thrown around about the game and all because Capcom dared to change the series up a little bit. In particular Dante - the demonic hero - went under a huge overhaul; almost every stylish detail was stripped away in favour of a younger, more rough 'n tumble look.
A second game in the new reboot series is almost inevitable but can you imagine Capcom announcing that they plan to remake the first game in the new style? Fans would go mental. It's not entirely inconceivable either; the reboot didn't sell too well and a remake would be an easy way for Capcom to turn the series profitable again, at the small, tiny cost of upsetting a large majority of the fanbase.
It's a shame because the rebooted game was actually great fun; if people would simply look beyond the change in style, they would find a game that's still loaded with great gameplay. A remake of the original Devil May Cry with the new combat systems and an updated, re-imagined version of Mallet Island would actually be well worth a play... It'll never happen though as a series of furious, new-Dante hating fans would tear Capcom down first.
7. The Legend Of Zelda: A Link To The Past

If you were to ask people to name their favourite Zelda game, the vast majority would say Ocarina Of Time. You might also hear a few people vote for Wind Waker or Majora's Mask but A Link To The Past would probably follow closely behind. Regardless, it's easily the best of the pre-3D Zelda games and it's up there as one of the finest titles on the entire SNES. Even more importantly though, it absolutely never needs a remake.
While it's uniqueness has been compromised somewhat by the Zelda titles that came after, A Link To The Past is still an intriguing and challenging game. It was the first Zelda to introduce two parallel worlds - a Light and a Dark world - which the player had to travel between to solve certain puzzles and it was also the first Zelda title to feature key items like the Ocarina, the Master Sword and the Hookshot. It's legacy speaks for itself.
As a result, A Link To The Past is one of those games that simply doesn't need changing at all. Sure, you could make it shinier but it still looks great today; what would be the point? The game actually had a successor released last year on the 3DS - A Link Between Worlds - hopefully indicating that, while acknowledging just how important the game is, Nintendo are only interested in using it for inspiration. Some people might like to see a complete 3D remake of A Link To The Past but it's simply unnecessary; let it lie in peace in the Gaming Hall Of Fame.
6. Earthbound

If you played Super Smash Bros and wondered just who exactly Ness is, don't worry, you weren't alone. After all, Earthbound only received a global release in 2013 when it was re-released on the Nintendo Wii U; up until then, the only way to play the game in Europe was to emulate it.
Whether you played it legally or not, Earthbound is a timeless classic. It's remarkably off-the-wall but it has some great RPG gameplay and the visuals are beautifully cartoony. What really sets Earthbound apart is the writing though; it's funny, original and it's always entertaining.
Some fans would probably love to see a 3D remake of Earthbound but most fans are probably willing to accept it for the classic that it is. Besides, it would take an enormous effort to recreate the game and there's a huge possibility that certain moments or events could be drastically changed. The game features a lot of pop culture references and many of these prevented the game's release on the Virtual Console; while nothing was completely cut, a full remake might be a different story. Plus, do you really want to see Gigyas remade in 3D? How terrifying would that be!
5. Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty

Hideo Kojima has never been afraid of utilising the nostalgia factor of his flagship franchise; after all, nostalgia was pretty much a constant feature of Metal Gear Solid 4. Hideo's also incredibly willing to revisit his past games and give them a current gen makeover, as shown with Metal Gear Solid's remake for the Gamecube, entitled The Twin Snakes. Did you know Metal Gear Solid 3 also got the makeover treatment with a Nintendo 3DS release though? (Alright, it was more of a port, but it did add new features).
The answer is probably not, as it wasn't that great of an idea. Yes, it's still a great game on a portable device (hence the mostly high review scores) but the newly created features for the 3DS were pretty forcibly implemented (not to mention that technically, the game ran pretty horribly at times). Even The Twin Snakes is a massively divisive title; the wacky changes to the game's cut-scenes (like Snake dropkicking Metal Gear REX) were a real love or hate thing.
Previous mistakes aren't the only reason to not remake Metal Gear Solid 2 though; it's pretty widely available (thanks to the HD ports to the Xbox 360 and PS3) and even today, it holds up pretty well. Change in lead character aside (that alone could be another reason why people would want to avoid revisiting MGS2), Metal Gear Solid 2 should be very favorably remembered for being a great game; it doesn't really need altering or fixing.
4. Banjo-Kazooie

You have to feel sorry for Banjo and Kazooie. Their Nintendo 64 debut was just as exciting as Super Mario 64 in places and it's drawn a cult fanbase as a result, but recently, they've been left by the wayside somewhat. Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts was a pretty bad idea all round, and aside from the XBLA ports of the two Nintendo 64 games we haven't seen anything from the twosome since.
A Banjo-Kazooie remake would be great, it really would. Rare can clearly make beautiful games (Viva Pinata, Nuts & Bolts) and their new found style would really suit the original game... But wouldn't you much rather see a brand new game? Banjo-Threeie (the name comes from a reference in Banjo-Tooie) has long been discussed and clamored for; undoubtedly the majority of the fanbase would much rather see a brand new game being developed than a remake.
Is either option likely? It's hard to judge. Rare are now owned by Microsoft and their last title was Kinect Sports Rivals; it's possible that Microsoft may be interested in cashing in on the company's history but it's so hard to tell. Would Rare even be able to do the title justice anymore? Maybe it's best that they just leave it be.
3. Streets Of Rage

Back before they became best friends with Nintendo, Sega had their own console and released some amazing games to support it. While Sonic is still alive and kicking, most of the Mega Drive's (or Genesis, if you're that way inclined) greatest hits are dead in a ditch somewhere, including the phenomenal beat-em-up Streets Of Rage.
The premise of Streets Of Rage is remarkably simple; scroll from left-to-right, beat up everybody in sight and finish the level. Yet a combination of great visuals, addictive gameplay and catchy tunes elevated the game from simple beat-em-up we've seen before to cult classic. The series has since been ported to modern day consoles but thankfully, it was left untouched. Messing around with Streets Of Rage is a big no-no.
Just one look at a similar Sega franchise will tell you that. Golden Axe, which bares a lot of similarities to Streets Of Rage, was given a 3D sequel in 2008 but the game was slaughtered for ruining the series' reputation. Do you really want the same thing to happen to Streets Of Rage? There was actually a fan-made re-imagining that was shut down by Sega back in 2012 but reception to the leaked footage was mixed to say the least. Most fans agree that the series is simply best left alone; beat-em-up's haven't transitioned into 3D that well and trying to force Streets Of Rage down a similar path is probably going to end in disaster.
2. Final Fantasy VIII (Or Any Final Fantasy That Isn't VII)

When did people start demanding a remake of Final Fantasy VII? Probably about a week after the game originally came out. People have been getting unbelievably excited about the prospect of seeing a Final Fantasy VII remake for years now, no matter how likely it may actually be. One tiny mention of the game from Square Enix or Sony and it sets the internet ablaze with rumours and speculation; it's fair to say that a Final Fantasy VII remake is in demand.
So can you imagine what would happen if Square turned around and picked a different Final Fantasy game to remake? There would be riots, especially if Square were to opt for one of their more divisive titles, like Final Fantasy VIII. It's not beyond the realms of belief; after all, Final Fantasy XIII was a massively unpopular game and we've since seen two sequels to it!
Why would a remake of Final Fantasy VIII be so opposed? Many fans take great delight in picking holes in it, criticising everything from the storyline to the gameplay, when really the game's main crime is that it just isn't as good as VII. While that may seem unfair, that's just how passionate the Final Fantasy fanbase is. Seeing one of the less acclaimed titles receive a remake before VII might just be the final nail in the coffin for the series in some people's eyes.
1. Chrono Trigger

Some games don't need remakes because they're already as good as they can be. Some are best left alone to prevent ruining them. Others might benefit from a remake but the developer has moved on and can no longer be trusted to do a great job - remarkably, Chrono Trigger probably falls into all of these categories.
Chrono Trigger is one of the best games of all time; a quick Google search will tell you that. It's beautifully designed; the story is exciting and unique; the characters are memorable; and the gameplay is massively addictive. It's also available in several places; originally released on the SNES, the game has since been ported to the PlayStation, the Wii's Virtual Console and the Nintendo DS. It's also available on mobile devices, so it's not as if it's hard to come across.
Plus, it's a game that doesn't need remaking at all. The character designs may look familiar to you; that's because they were created by Akira Toriyama who was also responsible for the Dragon Ball series. As a result, the game has a wonderfully unique look that still looks great today; it's bright, it's colourful and it has aged gracefully. Rest assured, Chrono Trigger is every bit as playable as it was back in 1995.
Also, and this might sound harsh, it's hard to trust Square Enix to develop a remake worthy of the original. As a company, they've made a noticeable shift towards action-orientated games and even their premiere series, Final Fantasy, has become a mixed bag. That's not to say that a Chrono Trigger remake is guaranteed to be awful... but let's just play it safe and leave it alone, yeah?
Can you think of any other games which fans would rather see left alone? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.