10 Video Game Sequels That Played Things Way Too Safe

The sequels too afraid to take any chances.

Call of Duty MW3
Activision

A sequel is supposed to be bigger and holder than the previous entry. Taking what was great in that title and expanding on it, while staying true to the core experience enough to satisfy fans.

Then there are those next chapters in a franchise that completely drop the ball by being too afraid of moving out of the comfort zone offered by that previous titles success.

Sales mean a lot in business so developers often want to broaden the appeal of a game in the market to maximise profit at the expense of innovation. They also might fear losing the wallets of those first gamers who bought into a series before due to that initial entries offerings.

Other titles merely don't have the confidence of trying something new and evolving, less they feel the wrath of fans who hate those changes.

These are ten games plagued with that mindset so much that they became footnotes in their own franchises - playing things way too safe so much that their release may as well not happened at all other than to fill a quota.

They aren't all bad games, but the disappointment of how forgettable they became due to the minimal risks they took still stings.

10. Crackdown 2/3

crackdown 3 iii
Microsoft

It is crazy to think that a franchise spread across so many years has all of its games so indistinguishable from each other despite being released years apart.

There are just zero opportunities to innovate taken as visuals look startlingly similar across all three games, and the gameplay is pretty much copy and pasted wholesale to the sequels from Crackdown, right down to the criticisms the gunplay got in the first instalment.

Crackdown 2 was released three years after the first, but you'd be forgiven for thinking it was released at the same time as it is by and large the exact same game. The entire development cycle appears to have been devoted to creating the lone zombie enemy type that was introduced.

The third game was even touted as having massive citywide destruction that would have injected the franchise with some much-needed freshness and given players something unique to look forward too. When the game was released, however, the feature was completely absent and it was back to the same drive, jump, shoot gameplay loop set in stone twelve years prior.

Both Crackdown sequels are quite literally the first game on repeat. They're the bare minimum of what you require for a sequel.


9. Bioshock 2

bioshock 2
2K Games

We get to go back to rapture, and absolutely nothing has changed.

When you see how daring Bioshock: Infinite was and how incredible that was received, it's a shame so much time was spent revisiting Rapture for the sophomore effort as it was a safe bet fans would embrace it.

The big selling point was being able to play as a big daddy, but all this really boiled down to was being able to wield a plasmid and weapon at the same time, and your view is obscured by a helmet. In nearly every other way this is the original Bioshock's gameplay through and through with nothing injected into the fold to excite players coming from the first game.

Part of the greatness of rapture was the brilliant atmosphere and unpredictability. You never knew what would come lurking out of the deep underbelly of the ocean, and the first game unraveled each new intriguing part of the underwater city beautifully. In the second, you're just exploring everything you already witnessed the first time around and it seriously lessens the impact with the law of diminishing returns.

The developers were too fearful of changing too much, and instead gave players more of what was well received beforehand. That's exactly the reason it's completely overlooked by the first and third instalments in the series that did their own thing beautifully.


8. Assassins Creed: Revelations

Assassins Creed Revelations
Ubisoft

Assassins Creed is a series that always felt like it was just about to crash and burn due to running out of ideas before it hit big with an entry that shocked it back to life.

Never has it been closer to this point than with 2011's near pointless instalment, Revelations, with the selling point being the protagonists Ezio and Altair were in it together, but beyond that, it feels like a tacked-on add-on than a full-fledged sequel.

The gameplay is Assassins Creed II with a hook-blade, and the multiplayer was looted wholesale from Brotherhood only a year prior. It doesn't help that Constantinople was a drab backdrop compared to the previous entries that made the franchise fatigue less bearable.

The series gameplay was just overly familiar by this point, and developers didn't seem willing to take the chances they would eventually do down the line to critical acclaim. People wanted to see Ezio in an open world and a third straight game with that mindset was shipped out to meet the demand.


7. Dead Space 3

Dead Space 3 Co Op
EA

Dead Space 3 is built from the ground up to appeal to as many people as possible. It took the survival horror gameplay focussed on atmosphere, item management, and tactically engaging enemies, and reversed them to avoid possibly alienating gamers put off by slower-paced horror.

Enemies and items are plentiful, can simply be pumped with ammo to kill and they can shoot back this time. Speaking of ammo, it's now universal and there's a ton of it, removing the final trace of the game's survival horror roots beyond the visuals.

Chuck in poorly implemented Co-op and one of the first iterations of microtransactions, and you have the cherry on top of the broad-appeal pie. To say the game played it safe would be a gross understatement.


6. EA UFC 4

EA UFC 4
EA Sports

EA's UFC series has stayed firmly stuck in the shadow of UFC Undisputed 3 now for six straight years, as the developers have completely struggled to match fan expectations set by that title.

After UFC 3 took a massive leap forward with the striking being the closest to real fighting in the cage yet, UFC 4 instead made such incremental changes it joined the list of EA's other bland annualised sports efforts.

Instead of learning from the past and adding the deep systems that THQ's series drew acclaim for, the developers adapted to the situation by using the motto 'Streamline everything to broaden appeal'.

There was no focus on improving the gameplay and putting in missing features that people have cried out for since the first entry. Gamers are instead given a bevy of wacky custom gear to kit out their fighter, hardly any of which would be allowed in a cage, and a slew of taunts and dances to choose for their created fighter.

Take two and a half years of development, and you get the exact same base game as EA UFC 3, but with worse visuals and streamlined mechanics. The developers almost seemed terrified of moving out of their comfort zone.


5. Far Cry 4

Far Cry 4 Pagan Min
Ubisoft

Far Cry 3's influence was felt across the video game industry after it dropped, and its gameplay loop became the template for 90% of open-world titles after it. Nowhere was that more painfully evident than in the direct sequel.

Far Cry 4 boasted a Himalayan setting and Troy Baker voicing the main villain, but beyond that, it is stunningly unambitious.

The weapons are all the same and the NPCs act and fight as they did before, resulting in battles playing out near-identical to Far Cry 3's. It all makes playing the game feel like having deja vu for anyone coming off the stellar third entry.

It was quite literally Far Cry 3 - just in a new setting.


4. Ghost Recon: Future Soldier

Ghost Recon Future Soldier
Ubisoft

The Ghost Recon series has been kicking around since 2001, and since GRAW hit the scene in 2006 it was the go-to shooter for gamers that wanted deep tactical combat scenarios. Its sequel was equally as praised, but sold less, only managing to shift around a million units.

When the next sequel in the franchise was finally birthed five years later, fans were understandably excited. However, the game they got was a much more streamlined experience that bundled it in with any other third-person cover-based shooter that was floating around at the time.

You spend more time watching your soldiers act like Spec-ops than actually performing as them with your squad syncing their shots at the flick of a button, multiple on-rails segments and the game was painfully easy to the point labelling it tactical produces a snigger amongst devoted Tom Clancy fans.

Ubisoft didn't want to gamble and see if the now heavily arcade-action focused gaming market would accept an old-fashioned tactical shooter, so they removed the majority of the mechanics that made the game deep and boosted their sales by 27.2% as a result.

The game ended the franchise's investment in realism, and the series has divested from tactical gameplay to something a lot more generic ever since.


3. Saints Row IV

saints row IV
Deep Silver

Saint's Row IV was originally meant to be DLC for the third entry in the franchise where you got superpowers, and boy does it feel like it.

The game uses an identical map to the previous game, the gunplay is unchanged and visually it improved next to nothing on a technical level. The superpower based gameplay was great, but it added little to the experience beyond making it near impossible to die due to how overpowered you were.

It even included systems from the previous entry that didn't make any sense, such as needing to buy ammo at a shop and there being no weather cycle. There's also somehow even less enemy variety, and they all can be blazed through with no effort.

The game feels hollow as a result, with less of a focus on the story and more of it just being a lifeless playground for you to be a bland superhero in. No risks were taken, no extra content made, and it was a safe bet the fans would like it because the third game was a success.

In the end, it all amounts to playing Saints Row: The Third on with god-mode enabled.


2. Star Wars Battlefront (2015)

Star Wars Battlefront
EA

The original Battlefront games are massive sweeping war simulators with an overly generous amount of content. From the vehicles you can pilot to the characters you can play as, there is almost nothing missing from those original titles from Pandemic Studios.

2015's reboot feels like a scrooge by comparison, with DICE merely dipping their toes into the water and feeling out what the reaction would be. It looked and sounded the part, but when it finally came time to actually play the thing fans were less than impressed.

Gone was the epic sense of scale - instead, the game focused on ground-based first-person shooting found in titles such as Battlefield, only without the strategy. Vehicles were now limited to power-ups you had to frantically rush towards to get a chance of using, and battles in space were relegated to DLC and severely limited.

DICE's long-awaited reboot was a fine and detailed Star Wars shooter, but was far too casual for its own good.


1. Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 3

call of duty modern warfare 3
Activision

Call of Duty used to rule the world back in 2011, and its yearly instalments always added more onto the franchise. But after six straight years of fast-paced shooting action, Modern Warfare 3 showed a genuinely deflating lack of innovation.

Modern Warfare 3 not only looked insanely similar to Modern Warfare 2, but it played like a carbon copy too. The campaign hit all the same beats as the previous two entries, the multiplayer was altered slightly rather than improved upon and the overall presentation from the menus to sound had not evolved at all from the first game five years prior.

While Treyarch was busy trying new ideas, time periods, and improving from game to game with their bi-yearly entries into the franchise, Infinity Ward was comfortable riding the wave of the original Modern Warfare's success until people ran out of patience.

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 is a fantastic shooter, but it played things way too safe, giving players exactly what was expected and, as a result, it ended up being one of the most divisive entries in the entire franchise.


Watch Next


You Won't Get 100% On This True Or False Call Of Duty Quiz!

Call Of Duty 1
Activision

1. The Call Of Duty Franchise Started Out In 2003.

Contributor

Crazy fan of MMA who also loves his films.