10 Video Game Tragedies That Elevated Stories

The gaming moments that brought many of us to tears.

InFamous Cole and Trish
Sucker Punch Productions

Love hurts, so they say and throughout the decades entertainment has treated audiences to many a gut-wrenching tale. Video games were the last outlet to adopt this theme and was only made possible by gradual advancements in technology that gave developers the necessary freedom to take the next step.

As gaming has matured, deeper and more complex stories have lined new releases, taking narratives far beyond a plumber rescuing a princess or a hungry circle being chased by ghosts. Many a heart-wrenching moment has found its way into modern gaming stories, thus elevating them to the heights of other popular mediums.

We're talking about gaming tragedies, major events in the biggest titles that either moved or brought tears to the eyes of many a player. Conflict is often the biggest driving force behind many of the best cinematic tales and not every character makes it through alive.

Closing out the month of love, let's look at the other side of the coin. Which gaming romances ended in tears?

What are some of the most heartbreaking tragedies in modern gaming history?

--

Be warned as there are massive spoilers ahead for every entry.

10. Arthur Morgan And Mary Linton Can't Be Together - Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2 Arthur and Mary
Rockstar Games

First off, we have Red Dead Redemption 2 which offers arguably the finest story Rockstar has ever written. Despite its positioning as a prequel the game features a deep and involving story that details the fall of the Wild West.

RDR2 is filled with many emotional moments, but the life that could never exist between Arthur and Mary stands as one of its most tragic elements. Throughout the game, the former couple finds themselves crossing paths as Arthur assists with his former girlfriend's problems. Once the player has completed these side quests, things build to a day out in the town of Saint Denis. You head out to a feature to check out the latest onset of modern culture.

As opposed to all the shooting and robberies, Mary's last mission speaks to an ordinary life. As you play through, you'll find yourself wishing that Arthur could settle down with her.

There's a real connection between them, and the back and forth that unfolds shows they both have feelings for each other. Sadly, Arthur's close ties with the Van Der Linde gang and past choices keep that from happening.

This tragedy of a relationship that could never be really draws out the sympathy for Arthur, something which is only heightened at the game's conclusion.


9. Naked Snake Completing The Boss' Mission - Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater

metal gear solid 3
Konami

Regarded by many as the best game in the series, a lot of what Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater so successful stems from its engaging story. Set in the Cold War, the prequel tale of Big Boss's downfall is anchored by his relation to The Boss, the finest soldier who ever lived.

Throughout the game, we have no idea what she really stands for. Initially it seems like a huge betrayal; after defecting to the Soviets and reuniting with her comrades in the Cobra Unit, she lingers in the background, proving a near insurmountable obstacle for Naked Snake.

All of that changes in MGS3's final act; it is discovered that The Boss never defected at all. Instead, she infiltrated Colonel Volgin's ranks to retrieve the Philosopher's Legacy. When her usefulness was outlived, the United States cast her out, ordering her greatest student and protege to eliminate her.

Snake and The Boss's bond went deeper than being comrades. Killing her at the game's conclusion weighs massively on the protagonist for the rest of the series. Broken by her death and disillusioned with his country, Big Boss's descent into villainy begins. This final gut-wrenching twist solidified Snake Eater's story as the best in the series.


8. Vesemir's Sacrifice - The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

The Battle Of Kaer Morhen Witcher 3
CD Project Red

A title loved by many, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt featured many a likeable character in its encompassing narrative. Of the few mutated warriors that remain, Vesemir is the oldest and wisest Witcher of the School of the Wolf, having spent many years raising and training his fellow monster hunters.

He's with Geralt at the game's prologue which does a great job of laying out the strong companionship between the two of them. Later, once Geralt finds Ciri he partakes in the battle of Kaer Morhen; when the Wild Hunt launches a devastating blizzard that immobilises the group, Ciri is on the verge of capture.

Vesemir sacrifices himself to save his friends at Kaer Morhen, stabbing Imlerith to trigger a full outpouring of Ciri's powers. In a tearful funeral, the old Witcher is laid to rest on a pyre with Ciri declaring that she will no longer run from those who seek to obtain her power.

Many who played The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt were getting into the series for the first time. The way CD Projekt Red were able to draw so much emotion from players in a single game without background context is very impressive. This just pushes players even more towards avenging his death.


7. Sarah's Death - The Last Of Us

The Last Of Us Sarah
Naughty Dog

Widely regarded as Naughty Dog's magnum opus, 2013's The Last of Us was a smash hit that closed out the seventh generation of consoles with a powerful impact. Incredibly well-performed and intense in its gameplay, the PlayStation 3 couldn't have asked for a better exclusive.

We follow the aftermath of a cordyceps virus that has devastated the world. To set up its brutally emotional story, we start in the perspective of the young Sarah as the chaos erupts. After fleeing with her father Joel through the streets, it appears they've reached the safety of the military. The two are fatally mistaken as a lone soldier guns opens fire to make no exceptions for the virus spread.

The bullets catch Sarah in the process and she dies in Joel's arms. Moving from a romantic to a familial connection, Joel's heartbreaking loss opens The Last of Us with a gut-wrenching death. It's more than just a mortifying moment to open the game. Sarah's death sets Joel on his path to rugged survivor twenty years later.

The relationship formed between him and Ellie is heavily driven by happened two decades prior. As a result, the player cares deeply about them as characters and roots for them all the way through the game.


6. Ezio Auditore and Christina Vespucci - Assassin's Creed Brotherhood

Assassin's Creed Brotherhood
Ubisoft

For the long-running Assassin's Creed series, its popularity peaked between 2009 and 2011. In the opening of Assassin's Creed 2, we see leading man Ezio Auditore is a real womaniser, visiting the beautiful Cristina Vespucci for a "quick" visit.

Upon finishing one of the best entries in the series, we all assumed that Ezio's relationship with Cristina was a casual fling put aside after he became an assassin. Little did we know there was more to learn about this story thread in the next game.

It's revealed in AC: Brotherhood that Ezio's original love was killed during the Bonfire of the Vanities.

In a set of flashback missions we see what became of the romance between Ezio and Christina, starting with the burial of the protaganist's family and ending with a return to Florence. Sadly, in this period of violence, Cristina is attacked by a mob and despite Ezio's best efforts, passes away from her injuries.

This set of missions that may have been missed by several players are surprisingly emotional. Much of Brotherhood's story is heavily focused on the assassin's war with Cesare Borgia, yet this element adds a heavy dose of heart on the side. It's another example of why the community engaged with the main character so much.


5. Sephiroth Kills Aeris - Final Fantasy VII

Aeris Death
Square

The next entry is one that many an RPG fan will be aware of. Final Fantasy VII is by far the most popular and beloved entry in the franchise's extensive catalogue. It was also a major transition, shifting to a modern setting and leaving behind the cartridge format in favour of the PlayStation's CDs.

As Cloud Strife, you join up with freedom fighters Avalanche to tackle the corrupt Shinra corporation, bringing many memorable characters into your party along the way. Barret, Vincent Valentine and Tifa are just some of the cast members that made an impression with gamers, but it was Aeris Gainsborough that arguably formed the greatest connection.

Throughout the game, a close bond forms between Cloud and Aeris; both her and the protagonist discover secrets about themselves throughout the game. Things come to a head when Aeris prays to the planet for help, where the villainous Sephiroth attempts to manipulate Cloud into killing her.

It doesn't work and Sephiroth thrusts his sword through Aeris instead, bringing many fans to tears. The game makes full use of PlayStation 1 to make her passing as moving and detailed as possible. As Cloud lays her to rest in a lagoon, the determination to defeat the sadistic soldier at the end of the game only intensifies.


4. Everything That Happens With Sarah Kerrigan - Starcraft

Starcraft 2 Kerrigan
Blizzard

Blizzard's Starcraft may have wound down in terms of prominence, but it continues to maintain strong popularity. In addition to being an excellent strategy series, it also features a very involving story. A lot of it is focused on the leading human characters Jim Raynor and Sarah Kerrigan.

In their military service, Jim and Sarah developed strong feelings for each other, something that persists throughout the Terran Great War with the Zerg. The two fill in the roles of rugged soldier and stealth tactician respectively. In a critical narrative moment, Sarah is betrayed by General Arcturus Mengsk and left behind to be captured by the enemy.

Jim loses Sarah to the Zerg infestation and she later becomes something far more twisted. As the Queen of Blades, she is placed in full control of the Zerg invaders. Even with this painful transformation, Sarah's psychic link to Jim remained and their relationship gets much more complicated as the Starcraft 2 trilogy went on. Yet there's always a lingering acceptance that they can never go back to what they had before.

Despite her rescue at the end of Wings of Liberty, Kerrigan returns to her Queen of Blades persona in Heart of the Swarm and Legacy of the Void. The way she was moved to the centre stage in the overarching story made for a much more engaging outing throughout the campaigns.


3. Trish Dying No Matter What - InFamous

Infamous trish
Sucker Punch

Before they put out Ghost of Tsushima in 2020, Sucker Punch were known for the highly underrated InFamous franchise. This PlayStation superhero franchise put you in the shoes of Cole McGrath and asked to choose between good and evil pathways.

The original game is set in Empire City; ravaged by a blast that gave Cole his electrical powers. At first the protaganist looks to get out of the city with his friends Trish and Zeke at his side, but soon digs deeper to find who caused the explosion. At many points in the game, McGrath is tested by the antagonist Kessler, but the worst comes in the game's final act.

Kidnapped by Kessler, Trish dangled from a roof with her medical colleagues suspending from another. Cole is forced to make the brutal choice; the life of one or the lives of many?

Trish is killed no matter what the player chooses.

It's either a tearful or bitter farewell depending on which karma path the player has chosen but the ending reveals the truth behind her demise. It turns out that killing Cole's girlfriend was completely intentional on Kessler's path and this third act death makes the game's final twist even more shocking.


2. Finding Maria Santiago - Gears Of War 2

Gears Of War 2 Dom Finds Maria
Microsoft Game Studios

Across three games and a spin-off it thrilled many an Xbox 360 owner, becoming a franchise fully synonymous with the brand. Its story was no slouch either, telling of a brutal struggle for humanity on the planet of Sera.

Gears of War 2 took things a step further; it goes a lot darker with its story and the threat the locust pose to humanity is far greater. One of its more emotional moments comes from Marcus's best friend Dom Santiago. In the first game, Dom briefly mentioned he was looking for a missing woman, but this was mostly left to the background.

It turns out to be his wife Maria. In the latter half of Gears 2, Delta Squad is able to find her in a Locust prison cage on their way to the enemy's hollow. Dom is overjoyed when she steps out, but it turns out he's hallucinating. Maria has been tortured and malnourished to the point of catatonia. After months of searching, Dom is forced to tearfully kill his wife to end her suffering.

With this plot thread, Gears of War 2 successfully takes steps into more emotional territory, something that hammers home humanity's struggle for survival. This same tone would continue into Gears of War 3.


1. Max Payne and Mona Sax - Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne

Max Payne 2 Mona Sax
Remedy

Finally, we come to Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne. Developed by Remedy entertainment, it stands as the most underappreciated of the trilogy, selling well below expectations on its 2003 release.

Following the first game's straightforward tale of revenge, The Fall of Max Payne is heavily focused on a relationship that builds between the title character and femme fatale Mona Sax. They team up to track down Vladimir Lem and end up falling for each other.

This is on display through both the comic panels of the story and gameplay scenarios. One moment you'll be following Mona through an abandoned funhouse and the next you'll be covering Max from afar with a sniper rifle. It goes so far that Max kills his own superior officer to prevent Mona from being taken into custody.

In the final moments of Max Payne 2, fitting entitled "Love Hurts" Mona is killed in a gunfight, putting Max on his path of self-destruction. This comes after she refuses to kill Max based on her feelings for him.

In spite of its short length, the game is able to form a strong connection between these characters and closely tie it in with the protagonist's downward spiral.


In this post: 
Infamous
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

A tough but fair writer and critic broadly covering games, movies and just about every type of entertainment media. Spent a good part of the last seven years blogging and more recently, making amateur videos under "The Cainage Critique". You can follow my work on my website https://robc25.wixsite.com/thecainagecritique and my YouTube channel at https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCftJ6WcozDaECFfjvORDk3w