10 Video Game Twists We Never Saw Coming

A selection of mind-benders that really twisted our melons.

video game twists
Nintendo/2K/SWERY

A lot of video games tend to be predictable by virtue of their design.

If you’re playing as the protagonist (which 99.99% of the time you are), you expect to be a somewhat benevolent hero who makes the world they inhabit a better place. If this wasn’t the case, you’d feel pretty rotten about all that horrible stuff you’d been doing to virtual people over the last five or more hours.

Unless you're playing GTA, of course, in which case literally anything goes.

As such, when video games unleash cruel twists of fate upon us and our avatars, they tend to be even more shocking than their cinematic or literary counterparts.

It’s always overwhelming to discover that a movie character has secretly been evil or unhinged, but when a character you have physically controlled for hours upon hours is the bad apple, when it's ultimately your fault, that can be even more devastating.

Perhaps the most observant of video game detectives were able to suss out some of the following rug-pulls beforehand, but the majority of players were completely blindsided by such unforgiving and memorable twists.

10. Final Fantasy VII

final fantasy 7 aerith
Square Enix

The death of a beloved secondary character can often give us something to fight for, but what’s rather less common, however, is for a playable protagonist to kick the bucket, and even less so for them to do it with so much of the game still left to play.

That’s what makes Aeris/Aerith’s death in Final Fantasy VII such a crushing blow; it doesn’t occur early on as a way to initially galvanise Cloud into action, nor does it happen at the end as part of a final dramatic coda.

It’s also a particularly jarring scene because it takes place within a game wherein Aerith had probably been killed and revived with a Phoenix Down several times prior to her canonical death.

But that dissonance aside, fans in 1997 were shocked when one of the game’s most beloved and benevolent characters was so mercilessly struck down. It’s arguably one of the main reasons why Sephiroth has lived on as one of gaming’s most iconic and sadistic villains.


9. Red Dead Redemption

red dead redemption john's death
Rockstar

Red Dead Redemption is a game that could theoretically end several times, and arguably etches out its ‘true’ ending through a series of extended prologues.

Throughout the game’s runtime, John Marston watches the world as he once knew it transform from one of bandits and outlaws to one of bankers and businessmen. In order to pay off his own criminal record, he is tasked with tracking down his former gang members and putting them down.

So, when Marston finally gets to retire with his wife and son, we’re led to believe all’s well. In fact, things start to get a little tedious, as all that’s left to do in the game is menial ranch chores.

That is, until the lawmen come a knocking. It turns out the Bureau of Investigation weren’t to be trusted; they betray Marston, surrounding his farm and opening fire.

Although it’s possible for John to take a few of them down with him, the lawmen ultimately leave him bloodied and riddled with holes. It’s a bold move, to render a player’s entire game time effectively fruitless for the sake of a dramatic punchline, but it works exceptionally well in Red Dead.


8. Metroid

Metroid Samus Underwear Ending
Nintendo

In 2017, it seems rather novel that a twist could amount to: "You were a girl all along".

Whereas most postmodern games tend to unleash the revelation that the player was actually the villain of the piece, the original Metroid created one of the industry’s most iconic characters, simply by revealing that Samus Aran had been packing the opposite set of genitals underneath her suit of armour.

The entire game was constructed to pull the wool over the player’s eyes. In Metroid’s English instruction manual (they still existed back in 1986), Samus was even referred to as a ‘he’, and Aran’s true gender identity was only revealed if the player completed Metroid in less than five hours.

Although she might have made a splash by stripping off and posing in her underwear, Samus will forever live on as one of the first and most memorable female video game characters in history, and her infamous ‘reveal’ serves as a reminder of just how far the industry has come in thirty years.


7. Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

Call Of Duty Modern Warfare 2 Shepherd
Activision

The original Modern Warfare gets an honourable mention here, for asking us to disarm a nuclear warhead that couldn’t be disarmed.

Having your chopper fall out of the sky while knowing a) you were about to die and b) there was nothing you could do, was a gutsy move on the part of Infinity Ward.

But it’s Modern Warfare 2 that takes the cake when it comes to Call of Duty twists.

After jumping through dozens of hoops and escaping death on countless occasions, the player discovers that General Shepherd, the very man who recruited them into Task Force 141, had knowingly sparked a war between Russia and the United States in order to spike enlistment and increase government spending on the military.

It’s a bonkers twist, but while Call of Duty often earns the ire of critics for its jingoism and apparent political conservatism, Modern Warfare 2’s climactic moments act in stark contrast to this. The real villain was never really Russia or Afghanistan, it was an American egomaniac who wanted to secure the future of the US military, and make his mark as a war hero.

Outside of totally upending the game’s story, the twist also saw the deaths of fan favourite characters like Ghost and Roach, in a moment that packed an emotional punch that no Call of Duty campaign since has managed to equal.


6. Heavy Rain

heavy rain shelby
Quantic Dream

In a game about catching the ‘Origami Killer’, it’s kind of a given that the plot’s major reveal will be the identity of said ‘Origami Killer’. But like a finely crafted origami swan, Heavy Rain’s twist is a shocking one, even if it doesn’t even make much sense to the naked eye.

The revelation that private investigator Scott Shelby was actually the Origami Killer all along contradicts earlier scenes in the game, and ultimately renders Heavy Rain somewhat riddled with plot holes (not many serial killers are stupid enough to call the cops on themselves).

It’s some real Scooby Doo chicanery, but it does serve its overall purpose in creating a dramatic twist. Shelby had been posing as an investigator in order to gain access to his victims’ houses and possessions, so he could then erase all evidence of his involvement in the crimes.

After rooting for and empathising with Shelby up until that point, it comes as a real shock that Heavy Rain’s resident PI was indeed the very killer he had claimed to be catching, even it doesn’t hold up to much scrutiny once the final credits have rolled.


5. Braid

Braid Game
Number None/Microsoft Game Studios

Jonathan Blow’s magnum opus often gets vilified for being pretentious or ‘too clever by half’, but it was a watershed moment for indie puzzles game.

People tend to remember it for two reasons, the first being its tendency to throw players under the bus with completely obtuse puzzles, and the second being its sly shock of an ending.

Set up as an archetypal ‘save the princess’ platformer, Braid is unashamedly a Mensa-level Mario pastiche.

As Tim, Braid’s besotted and besuited protagonist, the player stomps on enemies, jumps from platform to platform, and finds keys to new areas. Puzzles aside, it’s a pretty cut-and-dry platformer, that is, until the ugly truth behind Tim’s infatuation with the princess is revealed.

While all along we were under the impression that Tim was the heroic everyman destined to ‘get the girl’, and the armoured figure escorting her away was some sort of kidnapper, that couldn’t have been further from the truth.

In reality, Tim was the very monster he’d sworn to defeat, the princess had been setting him traps all along in order to halt his advances, and the armoured figure was a brave knight who was trying to rescue the princess from Tim.


4. Deadly Premonition

deadly premonition
SWERY

In a game that’s practically built upon twists, it’s hard to pin down which ones are more unpredictable than others.

Firstly, there’s the Raincoat Killer, the mysterious hooded figure who seems to have been terrorising the residents of Greenvale since the 1950s. Most think him a legend, but his true identity is revealed to be George Woodman, Greenvale’s sheriff, son of creepy gas mask-wearing Harry Stewart, grandson of the original Raincoat Killer from the 50s.

Then we have our protagonist, Francis York Morgan. Throughout Deadly Premonition, he’s seen talking to an alter ego called Zach, which the townsfolk tend to ignore, and players probably brush off as one of the game’s many references to Twin Peaks.

But York is actually Zach – York was Zach’s imaginary friend as a boy, but they ended up psychologically trading places when Zach’s mother was killed by the game’s true antagonist, Forrest Kaysen.

That’s right, the game’s dumpy, overweight tree salesman and comic relief character was behind the majority of killings; George Woodman had simply been a copycat with emotional trauma.

Kaysen was actually an emissary from an alternate dimension, who used his guise as a tree salesman to spread evil red seeds throughout Greenvale, seeds which drove the townspeople crazy.

Makes sense.


3. Spec Ops: The Line

Spec Ops The Line Martin Walker
2K Games

Set in post-sandstorm Dubai, The Line is a present day retelling of Hearts of Darkness, albeit one that uses video game tropes to get inside your head. At one point in the game, you’re tasked with bombing an enemy command post with an AC130-style weapon, the kind most people are used to using in modern shooters.

After picking off soldiers cleanly and efficiently with white phosphorous, Captain Walker and his team visit the site of their destruction, only to find that they had been bombing a civilian encampment.

Similarly, there comes a point when hundreds of rioters start approaching the player, throwing rocks and hurling abuse. In a moment of panic, most players tend to fire into the crowd, killing otherwise innocent civilians, when they could have simply fired off a warning shot into the air.

These moments all lead into The Line’s biggest twist, the reveal that Konrad, the game’s primary antagonist who had been conversing with Walker over his portable radio, had been dead all along.

The portable radio had been broken for some time, and Walker had been imagining Konrad’s voice on the other end, as a means of dealing with his own guilt and grief caused by his actions in the field.


2. Bioshock

BioShock Original
2K Games

When we think of video game twists, no phrase stings quite like ‘Would you kindly?’

Throughout Bioshock’s entire run time, we’d been led through a hellish underwater libertarian nightmare by the affable family man Atlas. His calming Irish brogue had been a comforting sound amidst all the murder and mayhem on Rapture, so when he revealed his identity as the ruthless and villainous Fontaine, it was tough news to take.

All this time, Jack (the player’s protagonist) had been Fontaine/Atlas’s illegitimate child, and had been sent away to the surface for later use in Fontaine’s war with Rapture’s mastermind Andrew Ryan. Whenever Atlas would request Jack carried out an action, he’d precede the command with a friendly ‘Would you kindly’, a hypnotic trigger that compelled Jack to obey without fail.

To learn that every action you had undertaken was at the behest of some cruel and distant father figure is a bitter pill to swallow, but it’s one of the many reasons why Bioshock has been canonised as one of the most potent pieces of interactive storytelling in modern memory.


1. Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic

Revan Reveal
BioWare

Star Wars and twist endings go together like lightsabers and Han Solo’s chest. Darth Vader’s infamous reveal at the end of Empire Strikes Back is one of the most Earth-shattering swerves in the history of cinema, but it was arguably outdone by BioWare.

Set during the Old Republic era, when both the Sith and the Republic command large military forces, Knights of the Old Republic puts you in the shoes of an amnesiac Jedi. The mysterious Darth Revan looms over events as an ominous yet absent figure; we know that he was once a Jedi knight, but he turned his back on the Order in favour of going to war. He helped to win the war, but his subsequent exile from the Jedi Order led him down a much darker path as ruler of the Sith.

So when it is revealed that you were actually Revan all along, your entire outlook on the game’s events is altered. It turns out Bastila – your close ally and confidante – had bested you in combat, before wiping your mind and turning you over to the Jedi Council.

From this point onwards, you can either chose to revert to your past life as Revan, or embrace a new existence as champion of the Jedi.

--

Which video game twist came out of nowhere and went down in history? Let us know in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Liam is a writer and cranberry juice drinker from Lincolnshire. When he's not wearing his eyes away in front of a computer, he plays the melodica for a semi wrestling-themed folk-punk band called School Trips.