10 Video Games Cancelled Before Their Time
Sleeping Dogs, we hardly knew ye.
While there are plenty of fantastic video games that do see the light of day, there are a few wildly promising looking titles that slip through the cracks. Those cracks being financial issues, studio acquisitions, executives believing the audience just isn’t interested and everything in between.
Whatever the case, it’s gamers, and those dedicated developers and creators who hoped to see their dream realised, who end up paying the price when for whatever reason an anticipated game doesn’t eventuate.
Even though the world never gave these games the chance to hit shelves, we’re giving them a moment in the spotlight now. Obviously there are way more games that deserve to be here which we couldn’t fit on this list so please do use that comment section to mention other games that were unceremoniously cancelled that none of us can quite can over.
--
10. Silent Hills
If we’re discussing wildly disappointing teasers that never eventuated into a full game we’d be remiss not to include one of the most fantastic horror experiences ever made, 2014’s P.T., which was initially intended to become Hideo Kojima’s survival horror Silent Hills.
Not only was iconic ex-Konami employee Hideo Kojima on board, the game was set to be the ninth main entry into the celebrated Silent Hill series starring Norman Reedus and co-directed by award-winning director Guillermo Del Toro. Entertainingly, Kojima described himself as a bit of a scaredy-cat when it comes to horror games but given his pedigree, and the popularity of the franchise, it generated a lot of understandable hype. The game began production in 2012 and was ultimately cancelled in 2015 due to the breakdown between Kojima and Konami.
A small happy ending was that come 2019, Kojima, del Toro, and Reedus reunited for the fantastic albeit divisive action adventure, Death Stranding.
At the initial time of its cancellation, del Toro was not delicate in his response to Konami’s decision, saying “it was not a gentle and ambiguous collaboration”, claiming the studio had taken the game down with a, quote, “scorched earth approach”. In the years since there have been plenty of rumours suggesting Silent Hills might not be dead after all for what is completely reasonable wishful thinking, but unfortunately nothing concrete has eventuated in the years since.
9. World Of Darkness
If you haven’t heard of World of Darkness it may be because you’re not too across tabletop RPGs but for those in the know, it’s an incredible lore-rich and deep roleplaying universe that lends itself perfectly to the video game medium.
While we have a handful of excellent vampy video games at our disposal including Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines, Vapyr, V Rising, but this is one that could have easily risen to the top of the blood-sucking pack but was instead left in the dust like a vamp in the sun.
The developers of EVE Online, CCP, were all set to launch heavily into the, well, world of darkness, a supernatural-riddled alternate modern reality where creatures like vampires and werewolves occupy the same spaces as humans. Renowned for its deep writing, complex lore, and various cults with wildly unique characteristics, it seemed primed for a fantastic gaming experience.
Despite releasing a compelling concept art trailer that dazzled fans of the franchise, a huge round of layoffs at CCP Atlanta in addition to the merging of CCP and White Wolf quickly lead to development crises, staff upheaval and restructuring, general disorganisation, and a lack of focus. Even after a decade so little of the core game was established and the gameplay fell closer to Assassin’s Creed than a compelling roleplaying game.
An absence of clear vision and game direction unfortunately shot the project in the foot before it even had the chance to get off the ground.
8. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic 3
Almost certainly the cancelled game on this list that hurts my feelings the most is Knights of the Old Republic 3. Spawning out of BioWare’s heyday as they were creating some of the greatest RPGs the genre had ever and perhaps will ever see, Knights of the Old Republic 2 came out in 2004 and naturally we expected the celebrated series would only get bigger and better. Not to mention that the series was always intended to be a trilogy, leaving the second game feeling unfinished and half-baked.
Unfortunately, for a number of reasons including the extreme instability of LucasArts at the time, the buck stopped there.
According to Chris Avellone, the game was set to have you continue in the footsteps of Revan, ultimately encountering the ancient Sith lords whose power exceeds anything the player would have experienced before in the two games prior. You would also have been able to delve into the psyches of the game’s antagonists, their place in the lore of the galaxy, and their impact on the planets within it.
Much like other entries on this list, there have been a Half Life 3 grade of murmurings about whether KOTOR 3 is coming to fruition or not but at this stage one seems about as likely as the other.
7. Star Wars 1313
Since we’re on the topic of Star Wars and painful cancellations we may as well move to the next entry I’m sure you’d expect to feature on this list and that is, of course, Star Wars 1313.
The game seemed like an absolute slam dunk. A LucasArts open-world, action-adventure that abandoned the Jedi-focussed Star Wars trap in favour of a grittier world starring the infamous fan favourite bounty hunter Boba Fett. Despite a compelling demo that generated a wild amount of hype, Disney’s acquisition effectively killed off LucasArts and its existing Star Wars projects.
In trading lightsabers and force powers for guns and practical abilities, it was a fascinating prospect at finding a new lens through which to experience an extraordinary well-trodden property. It was also the first Star Wars game designed to be mature rated, allowing for a different set of themes. In addition, it was suggested that 1313 would have let you embody a young Boba Fett as he explored the seedy underbelly of Coruscant.
Sadly, come 2013, Lucasfilm eliminated LucasArts entirely and in 2014 the Star Wars 1313 trademark was abandoned entirely.
6. TimeSplitters 4
TimeSplitters is an iconic FPS from Free Radical Design that ran from 2000 to 2006. Just a year later it was rumoured that TimeSplitters 4 was in the works, a rumour confirmed by a scriptwriter from the previous title.
That said, it was said that the game was in very early concept stages and was yet to find a publisher. Early logos and teaser trailers suggested TimeSplitters 4 would have been fairly satirical in nature. Unfortunately, Free Radical went into administration and was bought out by Crytek and in combination with the middling reception to the studio’s previous game, Haze, things were looking dire for production on the sequel. While crowdfunding, new and improved game engines, and a petition were all options that were considered or put in motion the hopes of getting the game off the ground, it was conceded that there wasn’t enough demand for a sequel.
When Crytek also shut down in 2014, the majority of the staff was shifted onto Deep Silver’s Dambuster Studios whose latest release was Dead Island 2.
5. Titanfall 3
To call Titanfall a sleeper hit wouldn’t be quite correct but given how fantastic the series was shaping up to be and what a fast and dedicated fanbase it accrued, it’s a wonder the third game never came to fruition.
Ultimately, though, developer Respawn Entertainment were just too occupied with Apex Legends and its consistent stream of content to dedicate the needed time and resources to bring justice to a third instalment in the cult favourite FPS.
There were actually a total of three Titanfall related games cancelled between the years of 2017 and 2023, the first being a collective card game, the second an online version aimed specifically at an Asian market, and a third game which would combine the worlds of Titanfall and Apex Legends in a single-player adventure. While a number of these had potential none stung quite as much as the disappearance of Titanfall 3 which was apparently in development for ten months before it was canned. Allegedly part of the decision to not proceed with a third game was due to the disappointing sales of its predecessor but in retrospect opting to release it in the same window as Battlefield 1 and Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare certainly didn’t do it any favours.
While devotees are still hoping for a miracle that this one might make it out of the woodwork after all, we’re yet to receive anything concrete to go on.
4. StarCraft: Ghost
StarCraft is the strategy series that keeps on giving but according to the fans who were hotly anticipating the release of StarCraft: Ghost it still didn’t give quite enough.
Announced in 2002, StarCraft Ghost was being created for the Xbox, PlayStation 2, and GameCube by Nihilistic Software. The stealth-focussed, third-person shooter popped you in the shoes of a psychic spy by the name of Nova. A sea of delays continued to push back the game’s release date and the studio responsible for the development of Ghost even changed to Swingin’ Ape Studios in 2004.
Then the seventh generation of consoles hit pushing back development on the game yet again as Blizzard reassessed how the project would fit in with the new ecosystem.
Though the game was still not officially cancelled in 2008, Blizzard’s preoccupation with World of Warcraft and StarCraft 2 took a toll on the development of Ghost. Eventually the major reason the game was shelved was due to the development pressure required to shift the resources from the PS2 and Xbox generation to that of the PS3.
Then things took a turn for the worst as 12 years after the initial announcement, Blizzard CEO Michael Morhaime confirmed the game had been completely abandoned.
While sadly the game itself never hit shelves, would-be protagonist Nova is a playable character in Heroes of the Storm and also makes an appearance in the sequel, not to mention she even got her own backstory in novel form. It’s not the game we were hoping for but better than nothing. If for some reason you want to feel even worse, though, a handful of years later some gameplay allegedly released online so you can check that out if you like.
3. Star Wars: Battlefront III
Unfortunately for them, this is the second time studio Free Radical Design appears on this list but perhaps it at least speaks to the impressive potential of the games they had in the works.
Published by LucasArts, the shooter was in development since 2006 and was set to let players travel between grand space battles and ground conflicts without any load screens. Plenty of hype was generated over the game’s potential, so much so that in 2007 not only was development of Battlefront III well underway, but a new game called Battlefront IV was greenlit as well. Battlefront III’s deadline was pushed a year later to 2009 with LucasArts agreeing to foot the bill for another seven months of work but ultimately a huge staffing restructure, mass redundancies, and change of leadership at the publisher left LucasArts with little choice but to do their best to pick up the pieces.
Despite their best efforts trying to adapt to a new generation of consoles, design overhauls, and the demand for more staff proved to be too overwhelming.
The game was officially cancelled in 2008. In short, the relationship between Free Radical and LucasArts became incredibly strained with finger-pointing from both sides. Free Radical co-founder Steve Ellis would go on to say that the game was 99% finished to which a LucasArts employee retorted, quote “there was 75% of a mediocre game”.
While EA got their hands on Battlefront a decade later and didn’t do a half bad job of it by any means, to this day modders are still doing their best to recreate the dream that was Battlefront III.
2. Sleeping Dogs 2
Yet another case of a slam dunk cult favourite game bizarrely not leading to a sequel when the interest was clearly rife is Sleeping Dogs.
Like so many other games on this list, it was rumoured that Sleeping Dogs 2 was already in development when it got the axe. Given the original game had a rich open world, a compelling story, stellar combat, and truly memorable characters, it seemed like a sequel was a sure thing. All that said, part of the reason for this was due to the sales of the first game falling short of the publisher’s expectations. According to SVG, Square Enix believed that greenlighting Sleeping Dogs 2 wasn’t financially viable due to their position in 2013. Even though Hitman: Absolution and the Tomb Raider reboot were a hit, the company was still losing money.
Like, a lot of money. Specifically $61.08 million dollars. An amount that led to the resignation of its CEO.
As a result the publisher leant back into its more reliable properties, Tomb Raider and Hitman. There was an effort to revive Sleeping Dogs 2 in the form of the free-to-play mobile game Triad Wars, the game wasn’t terribly well received and was shut down just a year after its beta launched in 2015.
1. Prey 2
When we’re talking about Prey 2 we first need to be clear that this isn’t the fantastic and underrated 2017 FPS by Arkane that was published by Bethesda.
This was the sequel to the original Prey, a game that launched in 2006 headed up by Human Head Studios. Really didn’t mean to phrase it that way but here we are.
While Arkane’s take incorporated some elements of the originals such as the broad themes, it’s otherwise almost entirely unrelated. Sci-fi shooter Prey plopped you in an alien spaceship in the shoes of a Cherokee man called Domasi “Tommy” Tawodi who possessed the unique ability to revive himself and also separate his spirit from his body for short periods all in service of trying to fight the big bad, The Sphere.
The game allowed you to accumulate alien weapons, utilise portals to transport oneself to different areas, and solve environmental puzzles.
It should be noted that regardless of its various successes, Prey itself sat in development hell for 11 years as a result of technical problems, various key staffers leaving the project, and even an indefinite hold. Eventually the game was pulled together with a tiny 30 person team. Despite receiving overwhelming praise for its graphics and gameplay, not to mention proving to be a wild commercial success, the development of its planned sequel took an unfortunate turn.
Quickly after the game was determined to be a hit, development parent company 3D Realms confirmed Prey 2 was in development with an epic E3 2011 trailer to-boot.
The studio’s Scott Miller created a brand management group that was to oversee the sequel while Human Head still held the responsibility of its development. In 2009, however, Bethesda acquired the rights to Prey 2 and cancelled the project with Bethesda’s Pete Hines claiming the game was not up to their standard.
To add insult to injury, studio Human Head was also disbanded with much of the team migrating to another of Bethesda’s in-house studios.
Curiously, there may be more to the story as Bethesda had shafted Prey 2 off to both Obsidian and Arkane Austin before abandoning it entirely. Additionally, a Human Head employee later said that the game’s cancellation was “political” and “petty” and that it would have been a blast. So, big shame for us.