10 Video Games Even Worse Than Everyone Expected

Lord of the Rings: Gollum surpassed even the lowest expectations.

The Lord Of The Rings Gollum
Daedalic Entertainment/Nacon

Try though video game publishers might to disguise an incoming turkey in their marketing, we as players can usually sniff out a game that's been through the developmental wringer.

Yet sometimes a game ends up plummeting far beneath even our already-low expectations, delivering an experience that's best described as an abject disaster worth neither your time nor money.

And that's absolutely the case with these 10 games, each of which came to market amid little hope from players, only to end up being received even worse than everybody feared.

It's certainly a testament to just how damn difficult it is to produce a quality game, and also the near-impossibility of turning around a sinking ship - especially once players en masse have caught wind of what's going on.

None of these 10 video games left players optimistic for the end product, yet what ultimately released was somehow more disastrous than we all braced ourselves for, in some cases even ranking comfortably among the very worst games of all time.

So here's to games that weren't content to be merely mediocre or bad - they went the whole terrible, barely playable hog...

10. Fast & Furious Crossroads

Fast & Furious Crossroads
Slightly Mad Studios

While a Fast and Furious game theoretically had a ton of potential, the track record of video games based on movies being what it is, most were simply expecting Fast & Furious Crossroads to be a bog-standard Need for Speed clone with some franchise branding slapped on it.

Even with Vin Diesel, Michelle Rodriguez, and Tyrese Gibson lending their voices and likenesses to the title, Crossroads looks more like a fake game you'd see in a movie than something that was actually released worldwide.

Given the film series' penchant for hilariously gravity-defying action, it's baffling just how unimaginative and forgettable the "cinematic" gameplay is throughout.

But worse than that, it's saddled with atrocious handling, an awful camera, and woefully dated graphics which feel a whole generation behind.

This all evidently turned players off enough that the multiplayer suite became an arid, unpopulated wasteland within days of the game's release.

The ultimate vote of no confidence came from publisher Bandai Namco themselves though, who delisted Crossroads barely 18 months after release, presumably because they didn't want to renew their licensing agreement with Universal for a certified dud of a game nobody was buying.


9. The Quiet Man

The Quiet Man
Square Enix

Expectations were already borderline-subterranean for The Quiet Man prior to release, given that Square Enix scarcely discussed the action-adventure game at all after giving it a surprisingly fanfare-filled unveiling at E3 2018.

In the very least its fusion of traditional beat 'em up gameplay and lengthy live-action video sequences, alongside minimalistic sound design to convey its deaf protagonist's perspective, would make it a bold swing-and-a-miss, right?

Well, The Quiet Man was quietly dumped on digital storefronts in late 2018 and failed at basically every single thing it attempted to do.

The fighting gameplay was clunky and awkward, the live-action elements turned out more confusing than entertaining, and the muted sound design did less to build empathy with the game's lead character than leave players tuning out of the story in record time.

With the right approach The Quiet Man could've absolutely been a fascinating step forward for representation in video games, but this bungled throughline unfortunately rendered it a pure laughing stock.


8. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5

tony hawk's pro skater 5
Activision

With the Tony Hawk's Pro Skater franchise categorically being on the skids by the early 2010s, there wasn't a ton of hope that developer Robomodo - responsible for some of the series' worst entries - could get it back on track with 2015's Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5.

All the same, it was sold as a back-to-basics entry for the franchise, ditching the goofy plastic skateboard peripherals and getting back to the purity of traditional skateboarding gameplay.

With fans vocally complaining about the game's dated graphics mere months from release, few were expecting great things from THPS5, but passable entertainment that reminded them of the series' better days? That, at least, was a realistic goal.

But THPS5 was very rightly panned upon release by critics and fans alike, for its clunky skating mechanics, lackluster visuals - which Robomodo tried to conceal by shifting to a cel-shaded style shortly before release - abundance of glitches, poorly designed levels, and overall lack of charm.

When it later emerged that the game was developed in just a few short months before the licensing agreement between Tony Hawk and Activision expired, not a single solitary soul was surprised.

Its failure well and truly killed any remaining goodwill the series had - that is, until 2020's remaster of the first two games finally won fans back.


7. Redfall

Redfall 2023
Arkane

Oh, we all wanted so desperately to believe that Arkane Austin's new squad-based FPS Redfall would be a pleasant surprise, even though the pre-release materials suggested it'd simply be another generic, flavourless entry into the overcrowded genre.

After all, as long as the gameplay was basically functional, it could be a fun time with three friends on Xbox Game Pass, right?

Yet Redfall was an even emptier, shallower experience than anyone could've seen coming.

From the embarrassingly braindead AI to the boring, repetitive mission objectives and progression, a nothingburger of a story, empty world, and unsatisfying gunplay; it failed in every way that a game of this type possibly could.

Playing with friends proved only slightly less miserable than going solo, if only because you could bond over your collective bemusement at what Arkane served up - or rather, didn't.

While most were expecting a game that would at least be basic dumb fun with pals, Redfall ended up feeling fundamentally unfinished, enough that Xbox boss Phil Spencer even apologised for it just two days after release. Yikes.


6. Superman 64

Superman 64
Titus Interactive

The pre-release hubbub around Superman 64 wasn't exactly optimistic at the best of times. Its official gameplay reveals at three consecutive E3s failed to move the needle much with fans or critics, unaided by numerous delays which saw it release roughly 18 months later than planned.

But a Superman game on the N64's then-beefy hardware? It surely couldn't miss entirely, could it?

Ultimately Superman 64 was a historic train wreck unlike anybody could've ever seen coming.

From the tedious, confusing, and frustrating gameplay to the underwhelming visuals, repetitive soundtrack, and excess of garish Kryptonite fog to paper over the game's short draw distance, it's a title that categorically failed to deliver the expected wish fulfilment of playing as the Man of Steel.

Despite selling well out of the gate, Superman 64 was near-universally panned by the press, prompting Titus Interactive to develop a reworked version for the PlayStation, yet their licensing agreement with Warner Bros. ultimately expired before they could finish it.

Almost a quarter-century (!) later, Superman 64 lives on as one of the worst games of all time - and with damn good reason.


5. Umbrella Corps

Umbrella Corps
Capcom

While few were expecting greatness from Resident Evil's tactical shooter spin-off Umbrella Corps, the general pre-release feeling was that it'd be a firmly "mid" offering in the vein of Resident Evil: Operation Raccoon City a few years earlier.

Yet Operation Raccoon City ultimately looks positively good compared to Umbrella Corps, which couldn't even reach the basic competence of being a formulaic squad-based shooter with the Resident Evil branding clumsily plastered over it.

But the fact that Umbrella Corps doesn't even have "Resident Evil" in its title could suggest that Capcom themselves was basically embarrassed of its existence, and frankly who could blame them?

Movement and gunplay feel bad, it does absolutely nothing interesting with its franchise identity across both its single-player and multiplayer modes, rocks a dead-generic aesthetic and resolutely feels like a game brought to market with all the grace and enthusiasm of somebody passing a kidney stone.

Moreover, its concurrent players on PC peaked at a pathetic 428 people during release week, before promptly falling off a cliff and never recovering.


4. The Simpsons Wrestling

The Simpsons Wrestling
The Big Ape Productions

The idea of a Simpsons-themed wrestling game was certainly unhinged enough to get people's attention, but nobody had much in the way of hope for it, especially with gameplay footage making it clear just how hideously low-fi the visuals looked.

But no matter how bad you expected the game as a whole to be, The Simpsons Wrestling was oh-so-much worse.

Whether you're a Simpsons fan or a wrestling fan - or, if you're interested in this game, probably both - it's got desperately little worthwhile to offer beyond impressively featuring voice work from The Simpsons' actual voice cast.

Even if you can somehow forgive the persistent eyesore that is the game's aesthetic, the gameplay is embarrassingly rough - it simply doesn't feel good to play, with stiff, clunky animations and crap controls which incentivise players to mindlessly button-mash their way to victory.

In the right hands The Simpsons Wrestling could've been a fun, bonkers romp, but with such a barebones, visually repellent treatment, it's instead destined to live on as a mere point-and-stare curio on lists like this.


3. Fallout 76

Fallout 76 Costumes
Bethesda

As awesome as the concept of an online Fallout game sounded on paper, any reasonable fan of the series was acutely aware of Bethesda's tendency to deliver jank-filled experiences, and how that would surely only multiply exponentially with a multiplayer framework involved.

It was still reasonable to expect a fundamentally enjoyable experience in spite of this, yet upon launch Fallout 76 was everything but that.

Where to begin? Even for a Bethesda game it launched packed to the gills with infuriating, potentially game-breaking bugs, the available quests were dull and repetitive, the lack of human NPCs made the world feel barren, and even the online functionality felt held together with loose duct tape.

Though Bethesda did modestly improve the game with subsequent updates, for many players it was simply too little, too late, as they'd already moved onto other games that actually respected their time and money from the jump.


2. The Lord Of The Rings: Gollum

The Lord Of The Rings: Gollum
Daedalic Entertainment

Expectations were certainly middling-at-best for Daedalic Entertainment's The Lord Of The Rings: Gollum, which finally released recently after over 18 months of delays.

Between a series of underwhelming trailers and gameplay clips showing off its mediocre visuals and generic stealth-action gameplay, this felt like a modest AA cash-in on the Rings IP that'd receive mixed reviews and then be quietly forgotten.

Yet the situation was sadly so much worse than that.

Yes, Gollum's gameplay is as soulless and blandly formulaic as it looked from the marketing, but the final visuals actually look markedly worse than in trailers, with Gollum in particular appearing considerably less-detailed than customers had been led to believe.

This is without even bringing up the glut of launch day glitches and horrible user interface, ensuring that few have even bothered playing to the end of the over-egged 10-hour campaign.

Few were expecting Gollum to be a pleasant surprise, but for it to not only be 2023's consensus-worst game so far, but arguably one of the worst games of the last decade, is truly dispiriting.


1. Postal III

Postal 3
Running with Scissors

Look, none of the Postal games are genuinely good, but in the very least Postal 2 was a moderately amusing time-waster where you could creatively raise hell and, er, hang out with Gary Coleman.

In theory, Postal III should've basically just delivered more of the trashy, deranged same albeit with shinier graphics, yet developers Running with Scissors made the ill-advised decision to outsource development to a Russian publisher, Akella, who hired the aptly-named Trashmasters to make the game.

Unsurprisingly this resulted in development straying from Running with Scissors' original vision for the sequel, in turn delivering an atrocious end product that was far more linear than the second game while packed with bugs and charmlessly edgy "humour."

Evidently Postal III even turned out far worse than Running with Scissors themselves could've ever anticipated, causing them to remove the game from their own store, with company head Vince Desi bluntly calling it a "s**tfest."

An expansion to Postal 2, Paradise Lost, was released by Running With Scissors a few years later to a considerably more positive response, and to draw a firm line under Postal III, it even retconned that game's events into a dream sequence that never actually happened.

The recently released Postal 4: No Regerts may have been an abject disaster, but it still wasn't as soul-destroyingly terrible as the third game.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.