10 Video Games MUCH Better Than We Thought They'd Be
Gotham Knights story is... pretty great??
There’s a decent chance if you roll the dice on a random new release game you have no prior knowledge of, you might end up realising it’s not for you. And there’s an equally good chance that the brand new AAA game from your favourite developer will impress you.
But what about those games that really seemed like they were going to miss the mark? The ones that, for whatever reason, didn’t leave much of an impression on you before release but ended up absolutely knocking it out of the park.
We can get lukewarm on games before they’ve hit shelves for a number of reasons. Maybe it’s because the developer isn’t well known, the game concept seems shaky, or a crappy trailer lands.
For whatever reason your expectations end up somewhere between middling and through the floor but these excellent games proved we couldn’t have been more wrong about them.
10. Tales From The Borderlands
A spin-off game that borrows IP from an existing game franchise is generally a small step above a movie-tie in game. Expectations for both are almost always low and they almost never even meet those let alone end up being really impressive.
Imagine our surprise then when Telltale’s Tales From The Borderlands arrived and it wasn’t just good, it was arguably their best outing yet, legitimately hilarious, and even capable of pulling your heartstrings.
Tales From The Borderlands managed to bottle the Borderlands chaos and magic without delivering something entirely predictable and strangely the Telltale gameplay formula worked like a charm. Combat didn’t completely disappear, though it was decidedly Telltale-ified, complete with a finger gun battle that will go down as one of the funnier scenes in video game history. The characters are almost all really well-rounded and sympathetic, the progression of the story is genuinely intriguing, and each chapter does a great job of weaving back and forth between humour, bombast, and earnest moments.
If you haven’t picked this one up because it’s a Telltale game or because it’s based on Borderlands, trust me and give it a go.
9. Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle
Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle is kind of a fever dream video game that shouldn’t exist. When it was announced that Ubisoft and Nintendo were smashing together the Mario and Rabbids IPs to create a brand new game whose gameplay is largely reminiscent of X-COM, few people really knew what to think, and even fewer thought there was any chance they’d actually be able to pull this off.
And yet, here we are in 2022 and not only was Kingdom Battle a smash hit, its sequel just launched to critical praise, too.
The key here is that somehow these two properties that could easily have spawned a pretty basic game largely targeted at younger audiences, instead offered up some genuinely nuanced and even challenging gameplay. The turn-based combat is satisfying, the tactical strategy elements work way better than anybody expected them to, and the quirky characters are oozing with charm.
Mario + Rabbids as an idea and a concept shouldn’t work, but it does, and you can’t argue with results.
8. Persona 5 Royal
For those wondering why Persona 5 Royal is on here, we of course knew this one was going to be good. Persona 5 vanilla is fantastic. But could it possibly be good enough to justify playing through a 100 hour game with largely the exact same content all over again?
Turns out, yes. Absolutely.
Royal may only technically include one extra semester of new content which totals around 15 to 20 hours, but almost every aspect of the game is updated in some way. The gameplay is levelled up with a variety of quality of life enhancements ranging from improvements to the turn-based combat system to more streamlined dungeon layouts. Additionally, the two new characters who come into full bloom in the game’s final dungeon are weaved through the rest of the story in a seamless and affecting way that ensures they never feel like an unnatural tack-on to an existing game.
In every way, Royal exceeds the successes of Persona 5 which is really saying something given the original was already a slam dunk.
Having said that, it’s a big ask for people to pay full price for a game they’ve mostly already played but if Atlus were going to go ahead and ask that of players then the game needed to be this good and, luckily, it is.
7. Gotham Knights

It's fair to say that Gotham Knights is far from the most polished game. It’s been justifiably raked over the coals for terrible optimisation on modern consoles, barely hitting 30fps at the best of times and for having various clashing game design philosophies that make it hard to say what the game is even going for.
HOW-EVER, where Gotham Knights might be scattered in its gameplay, the story, overall mystery behind how Batman died, cutscene direction, slow-burn reveal of the Court of Owls and by FAR the character writing, is some of the best in Batman video games, period.
The latter especially frames a series of proteges suddenly thrown into the limelight.
Each are shown trying their best in four separate ways to live up to the idea of “Batman”, in a Gotham immediately taking advantage of the power vacuum.
When you’re not visiting statues of Jim Gordon in the open world as Barbara, discussing his loss with Renee Montoya, you’re talking to Alfred as Robin about how he would essentially play “ghost chess” against Bruce, being given a series of instructions for Wayne’s next moves, while he was out on patrol.
WB Montreal “get” Batman mythology and what drives each member of the Bat Family. Gotham Knights is far from a perfect GAME, but everything else is pretty great.
6. To The Moon
It was easy for people to expect very little of the 2011 pixel-art adventure game, To The Moon.
For the uninitiated, it’s the first non-free game created by Freebird Games, a one-man studio with a particular talent for ripping your heart into a million pieces using only pixels.
To the Moon looks pretty unassuming from the outset with its telltale RPG Maker roots bleeding through and relatively rudimentary gameplay mechanics and systems. Don’t let that fool you, though, because this one has a brilliant story to tell and it is going to hurt. If you saw a screenshot from this game you’d be forgiven for letting it pass you by, but give it just an hour of time and it’ll have its claws in you and you’ll see why so many people claim it's in the top tier of video game storytelling. There’s a moderate dose of silliness and a couple of very basic puzzling elements in here but beyond that is an unforgettable narrative.
Not to mention a main theme so heart wrenching that it’s legitimately hard to go back and listen to without hurting. If you ignored this one because it seemed like a basic little indie game, it really does deserve your attention.
5. Call of Juarez: Gunslinger
Call of Juarez as a series has seen an extremely mixed reception. From the pretty shitty Call of Juarez: The Cartel to the pretty decent Call of Juarez: Bound in Blood, it was pretty hard for fans to know what to expect of the 2013 offering Call of Juarez: Gunslinger. Understandably, expectations were set pretty low but Techland absolutely pulled it out of the bag for their fourth entry which was universally agreed upon to be the best in the series yet.
Everything from the shooting mechanics to the charming narration, storytelling, and exciting setting just gels together perfectly.
Long-time fans of the series could breathe a sigh of relief when this one landed as it offered up everything they’d been looking for and more. With a refreshing sense of humour, tight gameplay, fun and varied environments, and some really clever plot points that keep you engaged with its story, Gunslinger proved that even the fourth entry in a series is entirely capable of reinventing the wheel in the best possible way.
4. Inscryption
Inscryption is an interesting one where you either knew all about its creator Daniel Mullins and the way his very unique brain works when it comes to video game development or you had no idea what you were in for and you were heading down the rabbit hole.
Inscryption is a game you shouldn’t let anyone describe to you, which is unfortunate because I’ve included it in an entry on a WhatCulture list where it’s kind of my job to do that.
Without giving the game away, pun partially intended, Daniel Mullins is the king of subversion, whatever you think you’re playing there’s a good chance it isn’t that at all and Inscryption is no exception. A combination of a clever but entirely breakable card game, horror aesthetics, psychological thriller elements, and even FMV elements make up the one-of-a-kind gaming experience that you won’t be able to find anywhere else.
And they also make it one that nobody could have seen coming, but when the surprise is this good it’s safe to say no one really minded.
3. The Swapper
The Swapper is a sleeper hit that plenty of people haven’t played because of its unusual gameplay mechanics, graphics, and structure. Which is a terrible shame because it’s a fascinating little puzzle game with genuinely interesting commentary on the human condition, and the implications of technology and cloning.
The game’s writer would go on to write The Talos Principle and Subnautica but in his early days the only work he’d done prior was the story for FTL: Faster than Light which would also be right at home on this list.
While most of those other works gained mainstream appeal, The Swapper slipped under the radar leading many to assume it might not be quite as impressive, but poorer timing absolutely doesn’t equal poorer quality. The unique challenges, impactful twists, and clever puzzles keep you engaged in the experience from start to finish and those who gave this one a shot could almost certainly attest to that.
2. Dirty Bomb
Dirty Bomb first came onto the scene in 2015 with a very funny trailer that landed on the side of legitimately hilarious or “what’s up, fellow kids”, depending on your sense of humor. For the large part, though, it seemed like there might be something special here. That said, in the oversaturated free-to-play first-person-shooter genre it’s hard not to go on with a healthy dose of scepticism.
Turns out, though, that in this case that scepticism would be entirely misplaced because Dirty Bomb is a damn blast. Yeah, I know what I just did. No I will not be rephrasing.
Fears that the 2015 Splash Damage release would simply be a Team Fortress 2 clone were quickly allayed as soon as players checked it out for themselves. It launched at a time where Steam was flooded with multiplayer shooters so, unfortunately, it struggled to gain traction at the time and now has a disappointingly low number of active players. That doesn’t take away from the sheer joy offered by the gameplay loop back when it launched, though. Movement is key, speed is encouraged, and matches are extremely well balanced. The combat is bombastic and immensely satisfying, maps are well designed, and the shooting feels fantastic.
The game has admittedly died in the seven years since it originally launched but it was far better than players expected it to be and plenty of diehard fans still remember it fondly.
1. A Plague Tale: Innocence
A Plague Tale: Innocence admittedly looked pretty great from its trailers but it was a weird one to get on board with because it’s made by Asobo Studio, who had at this point mostly helped out making content for games like Zoo Tycoon and The Crew 2.
Which, even if you know nothing about either of those games, clearly not a lot of overlap.
Beyond that, the game was published by Focus Home Interactive who admittedly do publish a handful of really great AA games and a handful of really average ones. As a result, it was hard to know what side of the fence A Plague Tale: Innocence would land on. Luckily it wasn’t just a fairly impressive outing for both studios, it was a smash hit success. Finding spots on almost every best of the year list, this game launched as a bit of a sleeper hit in the middle of the year in 2019 but once word spread of just how good it was, more and more people started getting on board.
Its endearing cast, enthralling setting, and engaging story made for a game that was incredibly difficult to put down.
The clever puzzling mechanics combined with the overwhelming sense of dread journeying through plague-rat-riddled France during the mid-1300s made for a gaming experience many people felt like they’d never had before. The world was frightening and oppressive, the stealth and action components balance well, and, to reference the Brooklyn 99 meme, we’ve only had our little brother Hugo for a day and a half but if anything ever happened to him we’d kill everyone in this game and then ourselves.