10 Video Games Studios Were IDIOTS To Cancel
We're still not over most of these.
While the video game industry is responsible for so many untold hours of joy in all of our lives, there's a completely other side to it too. For every game that sees the light of day, there's another still waiting in the dark, hoping for its moment to shine.
Over the years, countless video games have been either pitched or started development before being completely cancelled. Whether it was done publicly or behind closed doors, there's plenty of fantastic-sounding titles that for one reason or another just weren't allowed to get to the full release stage.
The reasons for this happening vary greatly depending on the title. Developers might fall out with publishers. Companies may repurpose what they've already done for another game. Or perhaps an entire studio might get shut down mid-cycle.
Regardless of what happened, there's certain games that we just can't get over the developers cancelling. They really were idiots to cancel all of these, as each of them could have been spectacular if handled by the right team.
Hopefully one day somebody at these developers sees sense and brings these titles back to life somehow.
10. Batman: Project Sabbath
It's hard to believe that the last time we got a really good dose of Batman in gaming was over six years ago in 2015's Batman: Arkham Knight.
In the years that followed, speculation has been rife about what was going to happen to the Batman gaming IP. Would Rocksteady keep going and make something new, or would Batman: Arkham Origins developer Warner Bros. Montreal continue on Rocksteady's legacy?
As we now know, Rocksteady is developing Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League, while Montreal is working on co-op Batman universe adventure Gotham Knights. However, it's recently came to light that that wasn't the original plan.
Codenamed Batman: Project Sabbath, Montreal's original vision for a new Batman game would have an older, more grizzled Bruce Wayne (complete with Kratos-like big bushy beard) and also include a playable Damian Wayne as he takes up the mantle of Batman.
Several pieces of concept art from the cancelled title have trickled out over the last few years, including looks at Gorilla Grodd, Two-Face, what appears to be a female version of Black Mask, renders of Bruce and Damian in the Batsuit (including a Batman Beyond-esque red and black number for Damian) and two versions of Bat Cycles.
Here's hoping that Gotham Knights will be as good as this could have been, as it sounds like a real shame that this one was cancelled.
9. Silent Hills
In what has to be one of the biggest travesties in gaming survival horror history, Silent Hills came out of nowhere hitting us like a train with excitement and hype, and then was almost immediately killed off as publisher Konami pulled the plug.
Silent Hills is perhaps one of the most infamous cancelled games in history, and one that players everywhere still hope will be released at some point. The hype around this game was unreal; after Konami pushed out P.T, a short, playable teaser for an unknown survival horror game, people soon cracked it apart and were greeted with a trailer for Silent Hills, fronted by none other than legendary game designer and Metal Gear creator Hideo Kojima himself.
The project was to star Norman Reedus of The Walking Dead fame, and looked to build upon the terrifying foundations established in the P.T demo.
Then Metal Gear Solid V happened, Kojima and Konami had a big bust up, and Konami decided to cancel the project and make Pachinko machines and a terrible Metal Gear Solid spinoff. Kojima then went on to create Death Stranding, which was we all know finally allowed Kojima to create a project with Norman Reedus.
Is there still any hope that Konami might see sense and actually make Silent Hills at some point? We honestly don't know right now, but that won't stop us from pushing out relentless thoughts in their direction trying to subtly influence them to do it.
8. Star Wars 1313
Star Wars and video games seem destined to be together. The universe of Star Wars is just so inherently game-y; there's space wizards with awesome laser swords, huge spaceship battles, amazing characters and so, so many stories just waiting to be told.
That said, despite a huge amount of Star Wars games being released over the years, there's been quite a few which have had their proverbial heads cut off before they ever saw the full light of day.
The first of these, and one of the hardest-hitting, was Star Wars 1313. First revealed via a bombastic trailer at E3 2012, 1313 was to put you in the shoes of none other than old favourite bounty hunter Boba Fett in a third person, fast-paced shooter.
It looked brilliant, full of excellent environments and slick combat. It really could have been something special.
Unfortunately Star Wars 1313 was cut just a year after its initial reveal, after Disney shut down the developers, LucasArts, and subsequently fired all of the staff who worked there.
7. Bully 2
In November 2021, rumours began to circulate that Rockstar, behind closed doors, had quietly cancelled a project that had already cost them over $50 million.
With Grand Theft Auto 6 no doubt already in the works and there being absolutely no chance of that being cancelled, and it being very unlikely Rockstar would cancel Red Dead Redemption 3, a lot of people thought it might be the sequel to a classic Rockstar game from yesteryear: Bully 2.
In a recent call with investors, Take-Two CEO Strauss Zelnick noted that "a lot of time and resources went into to the property," but ultimately, the project wasn't reaching the "level of excellence" Rockstar normally aspires to in their games (with the GTA Definitive edition being the exception to this rule!).
"When we talked about our robust pipeline, over a multi-year period, we did say that certain titles would not make it. And this was one of them," said Zelnick. "There's not much else to say, ultimately. We devoted a lot of time and resources to the property. Our standards are incredibly high. We're trying to build tentpole franchises. And in certain instances, we don't have the confidence that something will reach that level of excellence, and therefore we can't proceed."
Bully 2 has been rumoured to be in development at Rockstar for years, and if this is true, it's a real shame as it could easily be a very popular IP if done right.
6. Days Gone 2
Days Gone is like a dog that hasn't been brushed for a while - scruffy, rough round the edges, but still, underneath, inherently lovable if you give it the time of day.
When it first released, Days Gone was met with casual indifference and got a bit of a drubbing from the critics. As such, it didn't really set the world on fire; instead, Days Gone sold reasonably well, has its fans, but in the eyes of Sony, it wasn't considered a massive success.
The end of Days Gone leaves it wide open for a sequel, and developers Sony Bend were definitely planning to make one. Unfortunately it wasn't greenlit, and instead Sony Bend was tasked with helping Naughty Dog on their projects, and is heavily rumoured to be working on a new IP.
This is a real shame as a sequel could easily iron out a few of the problems of the original, and deliver a more streamlined, memorable and overall more enjoyable game than the first one was. That's not to say the first one wasn't enjoyable at all! In fact, despite being a bit lengthy, it's got a lot to see and do, some cool mechanics, and when you're strong enough to take on a Freaker horde, it's one of the tensest moments you'll find in gaming.
We aren't the only ones clamouring for a sequel to Days Gone either; as of writing, a Change.org petition asking Sony to reconsider on their decision to not make Days Gone 2 has over 138,000 signatures on it!
5. Gotham By Gaslight
Steampunk and Batman together in one glorious project? Sign. Us. Up!
Based on the 1989 Batman comic of the same name, Gotham By Gaslight imagines what it would be like if Batman was alive in the 1800s, rather than in the present day like we're used to.
Gotham By Gaslight never got very far off the ground and was actually only at the pitch level before it was cancelled. That said, it looked like with the right team and amount of effort, it could have been fantastic.
A very early prototype of the game has been released in recent years, showcasing a steampunk-style aesthetic for Batman, a foggy, 1800s Gotham environment and some seriously-impressive-looking cape physics.
It's obviously super-rough around the edges as Batman can leap as high as building roofs, but the actual environment looks great, and the verticality involved with Batman being able to traverse rooftops looks quite reminiscent of Rocksteady's Arkham City and Knight.
We won't lose hope that this one won't be created one day.
4. Hanger-13's $50 Million Superhero Game
While Hanger-13 aren't as well known as some of the developers on this list, they have quite the pedigree of making good games.
They're the people behind Mafia 3 and the Mafia Definitive Edition, and they're led by Haden Blackman, who was the former creative director at LucasArts, responsible for all kinds of Star Wars games.
Recent rumours point to the fact that Hanger 13 was working on a sci-fi superhero game, but it has since been canned by parent company Take-Two.
That's a real shame; the planned project - codenamed Volt - has been described as 'Saints Row meets Cthulhu' and a planned emphasis on multiplayer gameplay implies it would be some kind of large-scale, open-world game where you could run amok with your friends as superheroes.
According to well-renowned game journalist Jason Schreier, the game cost over $50 million to make so far and the project has been far from smooth. The development of the game has been rebooted several times, there's problems with the game on a technical level and COVID 19 certainly hasn't helped development along either.
Ultimately Take Two has decided to pull the plug before it ever saw the light of day, but it could have been something special.
3. Rockstar's Agent
Although there's never been any official cancellation of Rockstar's Agent, the planned stealth adventure is all but completely dead.
First announced in June 2009, Agent was set to be Rockstar's take on a spy adventure in the 1970s during the Cold War. It was to immerse players in the "world of counter-intelligence, espionage and political assassinations".
At the time, Sam Houser of Rockstar was all-in on the project, believing it could be as successful as Grand Theft Auto, and that players might get to play it exclusively on PS3 as early as 2010.
In the years that followed, complete radio silence happened. Agent was never mentioned by anyone, apart from those who remembered its initial reveal and wondered what had happened to it.
When the PS4 released, Rockstar renewed their IP rights to the trademark of Agent, and there was some belief it would launch on PS4. Now, several years later, it's still nowhere to be seen.
As we mentioned previously, there's been no formal cancellation announcement, but Rockstar quietely let their IP registration expire in 2018, meaning they've likely completely moved on from the Agent project in favour of games such as Grand Theft Auto 6, Red Dead Redemption 3 and probably Table Tennis: The Next Generation with laser balls. Ok, maybe not the last one.
2. StarCraft: Ghost
While the StarCraft franchise has its fans, developers Blizzard really missed out on an excellent opportunity to expand it even further when they cancelled their planned StarCraft: Ghost title.
Originally announced in March of 2006, StarCraft: Ghost moved away from the franchises' roots of real-time strategy and instead which was set to be a third person shooter. It was to have a heavy emphasis on stealth and gunplay, with weapons and guns ranging from an EMP device to assault rifles, flamethrowers and sniper rifles.
Blizzard envisioned that the main character, Nova, would be incredibly agile. Able to easily climb ledges, move quickly and navigate via ziplines, Nova could also access 'psionic' powers which would gave her almost superhuman abilities.
The title was also to include a multiplayer element which would put a greater emphasis on allowing the player to see a different view of classic battles from the real-time strategy series.
Following 2006's initial reveal, information on Ghost was increasingly sporadic. It was one of the titles deemed to be vapourware; it was only in 2014 that Blizzard's president, Mike Morhaime actually admitted that Ghost was no more.
1. Super Mario RPG 2
When Squaresoft and Nintendo collaborated together to create an RPG based on the Super Mario property, it was easy to think it sounded absolutely crazy.
At the point of the original Super Mario RPG's release, Mario's backstory was almost non-existent. He was just the plumber off to save the princess from Bowser, and he didn't really have a whole lot of depth.
But when it came out, somehow, Super Mario RPG just worked. It was a great take on the adventures of Mario, and remains to this day one of the best games released on the SNES.
With that in mind, surely it was due for a sequel?
Well, it turns out that was originally the plan. Super Mario RPG 2 was to be released for the Nintendo 64 DD, and was planned to be a direct continuation of the original game.
It's not known how or why this changed, but at some point during development the developers switched tack, and used what they'd already built to start up a new Mario IP: Paper Mario.
Which is all well and good as Paper Mario is generally quite excellent, but we'd still really like a direct sequel to Super Mario RPG please Nintendo.
Would be perfect for the Switch. Just sayin'.