10 Video Games That Fans And Critics Will Never Agree On

Mass Effect 3 is NOT a 9/10 game. It's that simple.

Mass effect 3 metacritic
Bioware/Metacritic

Since the first day a writer decided to use a number between 1 and 10 to describe their overall impressions of something like Pong, there have been disagreements between gamers and critics.

It might not be entirely accurate to say that the two side are in a constant state of debate over every last game - we'll always share different opinions through subjectivity alone - but as a general rule, reviews are often treated as an indication of quality, as opposed to the final word. 

Every once in a while, though, a game comes along that doesn't just cause a few scuffles between gamers and critics; it serves as the catalyst to a full-blown war. Years later, the mere mention of the following titles can re-open old wounds and start the debate once more. 

The only real question is: When it comes to these games, which side are you on? 

10. Fallout 4

fallout 4 noodle stand
Bethesda Softworks

Metacritic Score: 87

User Score: 6.4

Why The Difference?

Given that Fallout fans had become rabid with anticipation leading up to its release, Fallout 4 should have been a surefire hit for developer Bethesda. At the end of the day, all they really had to do was give everyone more of the same formula they love and reap the considerable fan praise that would follow.

Naturally, then, they did the exact opposite.

Initial reviews of Fallout 4 suggested that it may indeed be the greatest in the series so far, but some gamers disagreed with this assessment, simply on the basis that it skewed far more towards wider appeal, and felt less like a Fallout game.

The basic argument revolved around accusations that Bethesda removed many role-playing aspects - the less said about the dialogue system, the better - in an effort to broaden its appeal and simplify the experience. However, when you're in possession of one of the most highly-regarded RPG experiences of all time, chances are your fans really aren't going to appreciate any change.

It’s easy to see why critics fawned over Fallout 4 as it is - objectively speaking – a pretty well-made game. However, some gamers were not so easily amused.


9. Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 3

CoD Modern Warfare 3
Activision

Metacritic Score: 88

User Score: 3.4

Why The Difference?

On the opposite end of the fan backlash Fallout received for changing its formula too much, is a game that received an equal amount for not doing so at all.

Modern Warfare 3 was heralded as a fitting conclusion to the trilogy, which is true in the sense that it contains nearly every great thing that came before, before simply giving you more of it. The problem was that the game made few efforts to advance the franchise forward in a meaningful way, or really even address some of the more glaring technical issues of the previous titles.

Many within the gaming community saw Modern Warfare 3 as a lazy cash-in on one of the most profitable game franchises in recent memory.


8. Halo: Master Chief Collection

halo master chief collection series franchise
Microsoft/Bungie/343 Industries

Metacritic Score: 85

User Score: 7.3

Why The Difference?

Do you know the old gag in cartoons when someone claims to be a bad chef and the animators illustrate the point by having them burn cereal?

Halo: Master Chief Collection is the gaming equivalent of that burnt cereal.

Based on the concept alone, this should have been a gimme for Microsoft and the Xbox One. Early reviews suggested the anthology was everything gamers hoped it would be, with some publications referring to it as the best collection of all time. Once the game hit the general population, however, a host of issues emerged that revealed how broken it truly was. Crashes happened regularly, achievements barely worked and the online servers were simply busted.

Though some later reviews pointed out these technical flaws, those who went off of the pre-release reviews had to have wondered if critics received an entirely different game.


7. Dragon Age II

Dragon Age 2
BioWare

Metacritic Score: 82

User Score: 4.4

Why The Difference?

Whenever a game comes along that garners favorable reviews from critics but is greeted with a hostile reaction by the gaming community, there are always going to be some accusations regarding illicit matters such as payoffs and favoritism.

One of the most overwhelming instances of this came shortly after the release of Bioware’s Dragon Age II. Critics praised the game as a brilliant follow-up to the jaw-dropping Dragon Age Origins, but many gamers couldn’t help but notice its best qualities were lifted note for note from the previous title.

In fact, aside from the introduction of some wonderful new bugs, Dragon Age II was seen as more of a reimagining of Origins than an entirely new experience.

Opinions varied on how just how derivative this truly was, but it wasn’t long before the most passionate of the game’s detractors began to hurl a volley of accusations at critics regarding their supposed fear of speaking out against beloved developer Bioware.


6. DmC: Devil May Cry

DMC: Devil May Cry
Ninja Theory

Metacritic Score: 85

User Score: 6.7

Why The Difference?

Never underestimate the blowback that an adamant group of franchise fans can generate. No matter how good of a job a developer thinks they may have done crafting the new entrant to a series, it is ultimately the most hardcore members of the fanbase that will have the final word.

That’s certainly the case with the 2013 reboot of Devil May Cry. Though not universally beloved among critics, many still praised this game for its original sense of style and interesting characters. Devil May Cry fans in the gaming community, however, were not so impressed.

Aside from a few technical issues, most of the complaints centred around the game’s radical departures in difficulty, combat system and general tone. The word "casual" was tossed about quite liberally to degrade the game's attempt to broaden the appeal of Devil May Cry by making certain elements more accessible.

Hey, you can’t please everyone.


5. Diablo III (PC)

diablo 3
Blizzard

Metacritic Score: 88

User Score: 4.0

Why The Difference?

If you play Diablo III on PC in its current state, you’ll probably have a hard time understanding just why there is such a great divide between its critic and gamer scores. What’s not to love about a beautiful, addictive and faithful return to form for one of gaming’s greatest franchises?

Well, initially, quite a lot. Much of the scorn Diablo III attracted shortly after its release can be traced back to Blizzard's decision to make its single-player mode require an online connection. In and of itself, this was already a controversial policy, but things got particularly heated when fans soon discovered that nobody could actually maintain a connection long enough to play the game. Critics, meanwhile, were able to play their early builds free of this issue.

Even then, there was quite a bit of backlash concerning Diablo III’s removed features and perceived change in tone. Thankfully, Blizzard was ultimately able to please most Diablo fans on both sides through subsequent releases and updates.


4. Gone Home

gone home
The Fullbright Company

Metacritic Score: 86

User Score: 5.4

Why The Difference?

Gaming can be an expensive hobby if you're not judicial with your purchases. It’s why so many gamers rely on reviews to some degree in order to make sure the game they intend to buy isn’t a complete bust. Sometimes, the fact that many game reviewers receive games for free means that this particular purchasing element doesn't always get factored in.

At least, that was the accusation critics suffered in the wake of Gone Home. This minimalistic adventure game was praised for its brilliant social commentary and clever design, but none of those elements translated to a game that really offered much to do. Many gamers were upset that a highly touted game could be beaten after just a couple of hours where 'gameplay' amounted to picking up items and... putting them back down.

Though games of this type remain a point of dissension between gamers and critics, no title has caught the same amount of flack as Gone Home since.


3. Grand Theft Auto IV

Grand Theft Auto IV Darko
Rockstar

Metacritic Score: 98

User Score: 7.9

Why The Difference?

Sometimes, gamer backlash doesn’t come right after something is released. A little more time with a title can reveal flaws that may have not been apparent during the initial impressions stage, which is why some critics have taken to revising their reviews a few months down the line.

Enter Grand Theft Auto IV. The initial reviews of this game painted it as not just the best Grand Theft Auto game ever, but in some cases the greatest game ever made. What gamers found, though, is that a little more time with the highly touted title revealed a disturbing lack of content in comparison to San Andreas.

The debate rages on to this day regarding GTA IV’s place in the franchise hierarchy, but it’s clear that the hype of this came cast a hyperbole spell on its most adamant early critics.


2. Mass Effect 3

mass effect 3
Bioware

Metacritic Score: 93

User Score: 5.5

Why The Difference?

If you took on a complicated task and did 95% of it incredibly well, that would have to be considered a pretty good job wouldn’t it? I mean, is it reasonable to expect someone to do something 100% all of the time?

Perhaps not, but sometimes the final result is a matter of that 5% still being incredibly important. Although most of Mass Effect 3 is every bit the brilliant game that the early reviews suggested it was, gamers everywhere were soon only talking about its mismanaged ending.

Essentially negating many of the decisions in the game that came before by having the franchise’s ending boil down to a simplistic series of final choices, gamers took this as a slap in the face to everything they'd been promised.

To this day ME3 is a sticking point for a lot of gamers, as they were simply not as willing to focus on what came before as other critics were.


1. Deadly Premonition

deadly premonition
SWERY

Metacritic Score: 6.8

User Score: 8.3

Why The Difference?

Every other game on this list is an example of a title that was largely beloved by critics and largely ridiculed by general gamers. Most of the time, if there is a divide between the two parties, that is how the relationship works. Deadly Premonition though, is a fascinating exception to that rule.

The reviews of this game painted it as nothing short of a travesty. The most infamous came from IGN who described it as “awful in every way.”

Gamers, however, soon realised that past the game’s many technical flaws was a horror adventure too weird and wonderful not to love. There was nothing else one the market quite like Deadly Premonition, and many players loved it because of that.

A true anomaly in every way, this cult hit proves that sometimes you just need to take the fiscal risk and form your own impressions on a poorly received game that looks interesting to you.


Contributor
Contributor

An entertainment enthusiast living in Brooklyn, trying to make his way by slinging words at blank pages.