10 Video Games That Messed With The Player
These games love playing mean tricks.
Here is a shocking statement for you: video game developers often create games with the player’s enjoyment in mind.
Whether that’s because they want you to stick around for a sequel, spend your hard-earned money on some sweet, sweet microtransactions or simply because they have made an excellent product that they want you to enjoy, a great player experience is at the forefront of a developers’ mind.
Some developers think enjoyment is not enough however, and want to take players outside of their comfort zone.
From games that convince you of your evil ways, make you think your console or PC has stopped working, or just send you on a wild goose chase; these titles are a bit more cheeky than your run of the mill experiences, and can’t wait to play a cruel trick on you before laughing at your expense.
10. Superliminal
Some games are made with the single intention of messing with you as much as possible. Superliminal is one such game, its often-obscure puzzles and perspective shifting mechanics making you question what is real.
The premise of the game is simple, with the player making their way through a dream-therapy programme, using forced perspective as a means of resizing objects to your advantage. The puzzles that resizing these objects helps you solve get increasingly more confusing though, and even the opening of the game tries its hardest to mislead the player, tricking you into signing the terms of service with a click of a button when normal games tell you that such a button press would pick the document up.
The signing of the terms of service sets the events of the game into motion, which the character, and indeed the player, mistakenly agree to. The game doesn’t stop there though, presenting you with tons more perspective changes, and giving you a headache with its many rooms of well-thought out and often elaborate scenarios.
You can make ramps out of cheese though, so there’s that.
9. Spec Ops: The Line
In a time where the video game industry was oversaturated with generic shooters, you would be forgiven for thinking that 2012’s Spec Ops: The Line was just another war game. Quite the surprise then, when not only was it excellent, it took players on an uncomfortable journey that they hadn’t been on with a shooter before.
Throughout the early part of the game, players kill enemies one after another, like they have done in so many games previously. Gradually though, it becomes clear that all is not well with protagonist Martin Walker, and by extension the player, who has killed scores of enemies without thinking twice. This comes to a head at around the mid-point, with Walker mistakenly killing a huge amount of innocent people with white phosphorus, leading to him losing control of his sanity, empathy and grasp of reality.
It also comes as a shock to the player, making them question their actions up to this point, and bringing the realisation that killing in video games and playing the hero of the story are not always compatible. Who says games can’t teach you things?
8. Control
A story usually has three distinct parts: a beginning, a middle, and an end. This is typically clear cut because the story never carries on after the end credits, does it? Well yes, actually. Granted, there are many examples of this in various forms of media, but Control does it particularly effectively.
You play as Jesse Faden, Director of the Federal Bureau of Control, tasked with, among other things, ridding the bureau of a supernatural entity known as the Hiss that has been possessing the staff. Towards the end of the game, Faden is infected with the Hiss, and before the player can even process this, the game cuts to credits, painting a bleak picture of her fate.
While this looks like a dark and depressing end, and certainly not what players expected, this is not the whole story. The credits warp and distort, while the words themselves change from the names of Remedy team members to nonsensical sentences. The game resumes shortly after this, with Faden able to rid herself of the Hiss through the actions of the player.
Post credit scenes, eh? They’ll never catch on.
7. Batman: Arkham Asylum
A Batman game is not one many would assume would contain a moment that messes with and indeed scares the player, but many would be wrong. Sure, Rocksteady’s Batman: Arkham Asylum is for the most part a straightforward yet brilliant action game but, for a few seconds, it becomes a terrifying experience.
Part way through the story, you encounter The Scarecrow who subjects you to his hallucinogenic agent known as Fear Toxin. This causes Batman to start hearing voices, and upon walking halfway down a corridor, the game freezes, the screen tears as if crashing and the voices become distorted. After a few seconds of this, the screen goes black, with many players convinced that their console or PC was breaking.
Not so though, as a few short moments later came a cutscene revealing that the “glitch” wasn’t real, with Batman imagining the Joker taking him to Arkham Asylum, his worst fear. And, calming down from the fright of a crashed system, the player realsies they had their worst fear shown to them as well.
6. Gone Home
Many of the entries on this list share a theme of expectation subversion and none convey that more clearly than 2013’s Gone Home. The expectation in question is that it’s a horror game, with many textbook horror tropes ticked off.
A lone woman, Katie, returns to her family home from overseas to find everyone missing, with a note telling Katie not to investigate. The game sees you explore the home, a classic dark and spooky mansion, in search of answers. The game is very atmospheric and you always expect a jump scare or outright horror visuals, but such things don’t happen.
The tension is felt throughout the entirety of Gone Home’s runtime, until you find the surprisingly tame answer... namely a vacation for Katie’s parents, and her sister Sam deciding to start a new life with her girlfriend after struggling with her parents about her sexuality. The game was praised for its well written story and LGBT representation, and was ultimately far less of a horror experience than it first appeared.
5. The Secret of Monkey Island
If there was ever a game whose developer had their heart set on messing with players, The Secret of Monkey Island is that game, and LucasArts is that developer. One of the most iconic point and click adventure games, the 1990 title is rife with obscure and ridiculous solutions to puzzles, tons of backtracking, and many 4th wall breaks.
This old school trolling largely gets a free pass due to its sheer charm and feelings of nostalgia, though one moment in particular tests the patience of many players. Protagonist Guybrush Threepwood finds himself atop a cliff at a certain point in the story, and if the player moves Threepwood towards the edge, the rock crumbles and he falls.
The player is immediately presented with a Sierra style game over screen, explaining that they would have to start over, and that hopefully the player has saved the game. Guybrush bounces back up to the cliff after a few more moments however, commenting on the fact that a rubber tree had saved him. Not enough to save the player from the panic they just endured though.
4. The Stanley Parable
One of the more interesting games on this list, The Stanley Parable is designed to confuse and frustrate its audience. Initially released in 2013, the game lets players control the titular character Stanley, as he explores what has happened to his colleagues who have mysteriously vanished.
The game gives absolute freedom to its players through the use of a narrator giving instructions to Stanley, which the player can obey or ignore. Doing either can lead to unexpected results, with the narrator commenting directly on actions taken through 4th wall breaks, and attempting to lead the player down certain paths.
Looping rooms and infinite corridors can make the player second guess themselves, and the short run time coupled with multiple endings can also confuse players, as they retrace their steps looking for one elusive alternate ending amongst the many. Staying inside your cubicle is also a valid choice, and might be a sensible one if you want to avoid the madness waiting for you when you step foot outside of it.
3. The Last of Us
How far should a person go to protect their loved ones? Like Spec Ops: The Line, 2013’s The Last of Us sought to tackle some darker subject matter. Throughout the game, protagonists Joel and Ellie fight multiple people infected with the Cordyceps virus as they attempt to get Ellie to the Fireflies, a militia group wanting to utilise her immunity to the infection in the search for a cure.
After the Fireflies get hold of Ellie and contain her within St Mary’s hospital, it becomes apparent that she will be killed in order for her to be used in the making of said cure, something that Joel is quite keen to avoid. Storming into the operating room at the end of the game, players have to kill the main surgeon, but can optionally kill the remaining unarmed surgeons in the room before carrying an unconscious Ellie away.
Regardless of your decision here, the bloodshed is made far worse by the revelation that Joel lies to Ellie later about the events that take place in the hospital, suggesting that the Fireflies weren’t able to make a cure and stopped trying. The lie reinforces the unease that the player is made to feel about the events leading up to that moment, some of which can be made worse by the player’s own freedom of choice.
2. Metal Gear Solid
It wouldn’t be a list about messing with players without mentioning a Kojima game. There are many instances in this PS1 masterpiece of the famous auteur having a bit of a laugh at your expense; from Psycho Mantis reading the contents of your memory card, to various other 4th wall breaking comments made by characters in the original Metal Gear Solid.
Arguably the most famous example was the solution to opening the cargo bay doors, whereby Campbell would ask Solid Snake to contact a number found on the back of the CD case. Many players at the time didn’t realise that he meant the actual physical case that the game came in, and were frantically searching items in their inventory to no avail.
Turns out the physical case had a screenshot of the digits on the back, and it remains one of the most ingenious examples of a game giving its audience the run around. It probably caused some problems for those that were pirating the game as well, another bonus troll from Kojima.
1. BioShock
Yes, the game that is featured in lists far and wide couldn’t be left out of this one. You probably know the story by now, but for those that don’t: Bioshock follows protagonist Jack as he attempts to escape Rapture, an underwater utopia that has seen rapid decline due to ADAM, a genetic substance that grants supernatural powers.
As Jack, the player fights various enemies with the help of Atlas, a revolutionary who needs help to stop Ryan, the brains behind Rapture, from killing his family. It is ultimately revealed that you are in fact Ryan’s son, and that Atlas is the true enemy, directing your behaviour, and that of the player, through repeated use of a hypnotic trigger phrase: “would you kindly.”
The realisation that this phrase has been spoken multiple times throughout the game and that you have been mind controlled represents one of the biggest and most famous twists in gaming, and makes you question every decision you think you made during the game. It’s one that stays with you long after it’s finished, and may well give you trust issues long into the future.